(the Pamella Bordes revelations), in- competence (Paul Channon's catalogue of fiascos and cover- ups at the Transport department), and authoritarianism (repeated efforts to gag the press and media through new Of- ficial Secrets laws, censorship and back-room pressure - so strikingly rebuffed over Death on the Rock). Thatcher has been forced to intervene in contravention of 'market' pres- sures to impose a more expensive route on the Channel Tun- nel rail link, and the government has lost its aura of invin- cibility along with its predominant lead in the polls. For the first time in years it is suffering the threat of humiliating by- election defeats.
Under such conditions, a coherent counter-offensive from the labour movement around a frontal challenge to the in- creasingly discredited notion of the free market, arguing for a planned, socialist answer to the huge social problems and yawning class divide consciously widened by Thatcherite policies, could be making real inroads into sections of the newly shaken middle class.
Instead, the Labour leadership has emerged clutching the meagre fruits of its sweaty labours in 'policy review' workshops: a defeatist economic policy aimed not at a planned - let alone socialist - economy, but at making the market work'. Neil Kinnock's keynote speech in Nottingham unveil- ing the new policies revealed a confused and pathetic package
Thatcher off the hook?
of half-measures designed to manage capitalism better than the Tories. Abandoning not only nationalisation but even the watered-down concept of social ownership, he advocated moves to shore up nationalist and protectionist prejudices by safeguarding 'our' industries (and employers) against "foreign' takeovers. He proposed a nationwide network of 'one stop' advice and resource centres for small businesspeople, bringing grim reminders of Harold Wilson's failed National Enterprise Board and the equally useless Greater London Enterprise Board nurturing feeble herds of white elephants.
While Labour adopts a policy little more radical than the old Liberals, David Owen's Social Democrats (SDP) and Paddy Ashdown's Democrats (SLD) have raised the issue of electoral pacts. In the aftermath of the Richmond by-election, where the combined votes for the SDP-SLD candidates out- numbered the Tory vote, the idea of anti-Thatcher parties joining forces to defeat Tory candidates may appear superfi- cially attractive to the non-political.
However we must not forget that what the SDP and SLD have in mind is a specifically non-socialist opposition to Thatcher (in view of Kinnock's latest political shift, it might be more accurate to say a non-Labour opposition). The failure of Ashdown and Owen to negotiate a deal for a common can- didate in the forthcoming Vale of Glamorgan by-election should not blind us to the fact that their common goal was to smash Labour's chances of challenging the Tories.
For these second-rate 'centre ground' forces, their flimsy political programmes are largely academic and wholly subor- dinate to the hunt for votes. But they are not the only advo- cates of broad 'never mind the politics, feel the width' elec- toral pacts. The closet liberals of Marxism Today and the Communist Party are making the running in renewed proposals for a broad cross-class anti-Thatcher alliance, while reserving their main hostility for class struggle politics in the labour movement.
Bitter experience has shown that the most fatal error is for the workers' movement to set aside or subordinate its own political programme in the hunt for 'unity" with bourgenis parties around a shapeless political programme which aims to be all things to all people.
However it would also be an error to miss out on new op- portunities to draw some of the new forces opposing aspects of Thatcherism into the labour movement fightback against the government, which should aim at building the widest pos- sible support. Health workers and campaigners combatting the new NHS White Paper, for example, should be looking on this issue to collaborate with individuals and local branches of the BMA and any other professional body prepared to fight. Trade unions and civil liberties groupings opposing attacks on freedom of the press should enlist wherever possible the support of top journalists and newspaper editors - who have shown they do not like being publicly shown to be less than free in what they report and how.
In each case the key issue is that the workers' movement must campaign in its own right, in its own name, and on its own demands, seeking on that basis the maximum collaboration with other forces. The growing pool of actual and potential opposition to the Thatcher government can only be trans- formed into active mobilisation through leadership from the labour movement. Though national Labour and trade union chiefs continue to duck this responsibility, the chances to build local and national campaigns on a range of issues that can in- flict defeats on the Tories have not been so favourable for many years.
Don't let Kinnock let Thatcher off the hook!
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 14 April 1989
Pare 1
450 at Women for Socialism conference
At last a positive answer!
A NETWORK of socialist women must be set up, which will say 'no" to the *bureaucrats and yellow-bel- lied men' who are imposing local government cuts upon the very people they claimed not so long ago to be supporting.
So said Haringey councillor and black activist Martha Osamor in a key specch from the platfomm of the Women for Socialism con ference in London. 'We now have to pay for the unholy alliances formed in the past when the women's movement was at its height", she added. "As a result of good local authority manifestos, women's units, race units and re- search units were set up: but now the same councils are taking them away again."
Also from the platform in an
opening session chaired by Betty Heathfield, Mairead Keane from Sinn Fein told the conference that
women had gone through too much in the "laboratory' of the six counties. They have spent much of their energy trying to achieve women's reproductive rights, and in other battles there have been few gains. Women have been trapped at home; and the partition of Ireland has hindered effective trade union organisation and weakened the forces of the left.
The fight for national liberation and equal citizenship includes achieving hasic civil liberties and overcoming the stereotypes of women as only wives and mothers. In Sinn Fein they now have a women's policy, and a quota sys- tem ensures that at least a quarter of the executive must be women.
From the women's movement in Palestine Jamilha Akmed ex- plained how their committee had been set up in 1978. Women in Palestine faced the occupation every day. The number of women prisoners had increased 50% since
1987; the number of miscarriages was up 200% from exposure to lear-gas. Palestinian women are active on women's and other political issues, fighting both for national liberation and for women's liberation.
The conference was a welcome tonic, a women's organisation in favour of socialism and not simp ly campaigning against something (though of course we are all against violence, pil closures. racism, imperialism, and soon...) Ideas were welcomed, and in sharp contrast to many conferences in- cluding the Socialist Conference there were no arguments over whether the fight is best fought in- side or outside the Labour Party or elsewhere. We seemed unani- mous. Here were women wanting to get on now with any and all im- mediate, practical work against our common oppressors, and will- ing to work in all the organisations we are already in.
We want to make links with all women in struggle, using our skills to build wider support and take the fight forward. There were a num- ber of black women at part of the conference and several disabled women were present - though more needs to be done to ensure they feel welcome, and we had to Icave committee positions open for represcalation of black women and differently-abled women, be- cause there were no. candidates available.
However 22 women did volun- teer for a whole range of tasks in- cluding production of a four page newspaper and investigating the prospects for an anti-imperialist women's solidarity conference.
Women for Socialism will be organising at national Labour Women's Conference and the next Socialist Conference. Member- ship is £5 waged, t2.50 unwaged. Look out for ux.
Judith Parsons
As 26,000 face deportation...
Migrant workers organise
ON MONDAY February 27, 38 Kurdish and Turkish workers were arrested in raids on factories in Hackney. By the next day seven had been deported and a further four- teen were under threat. This action came in the wake of a wave of raids across North and Bast London.
The Kurdish and Turkish trade union, community and political groups organised immediate protest action: a mass picket of Daiston police station on March 4, a 3000 atrong march the next day and an International Women's Day march through Hackney under the slogans "No worker is illegal", Right to settle, right to work!', 'No more deportations", No to police raids", "Long live our struggle"
The fierce attacks by the police and immigration authorities take place both in the context of the in- tensifying racism of the British state, and against a background of a struggle by migrant workers against employers in the factories
Page 2
themseives.
The 1988 Immigration Act made 'overstaying' a criminal of fence (see Socialist Owlook 6). The implications of this were heralded in last November's an- bouncement by the Home Office that it was to double the number of officers investigating "overstayers" and migrants, with the aim of resolving 26,000 cases -that is, deporting 26,000 pcople.
In the run-up to 1992 the European govemments are plan- ning to ensure migrant workers and black people in general de not have 'equal rights' to freedom of travel and citizenship within Europe. They are not to get the benefits from the relaxation of border controis given to European Community (EC) citizens. Non- EC people, including refugees, particularly from the third world, will be unwelcome in 'Fortress Europe. The British state's violent deportation of Viraj Men- dis clearly marks this intention.
Migrant workers in Britain are to face even more severe restric- tions and harassment under a comprehensive syster of internal
controls. This is likely to include a compulsory identity card for migrant workers as already in- stituted in some other countries. The state already holds an exten- sive base of information on black people here, and an undefeated Poll Tax would complete the structural base to enable an iden tity card system to be imple- mented.
The state has moved steadily under this government to relin quish responsibility for the social cost of migrant labour. The 1985 definition of recourse to public funds' and the 1988 Social Security Act are two among a tightening net of rules and regula- tions that discriminate against black and migrant workers in ac- cess to health, housing, benefits, education and so on. At the same time the monitoring and question- ing by public agencies and their linking to the Home Office. alongside direct harassment by police and immigration officials. creates fear and uncertainty. They constitute a concerted attempt to destabilize the lives of black people in Britain.
The factory bosses have used this background to intensify ox- ploitation. They have been met by increasing struggles over the right i to organise in trade unions, over wages and conditions and in op position to the arbitrary deduction of "tax" from take home pay - al levy that is not surprisingly un known to tax officers.
These struggles have led to the formation in North and Bast Lon- don of a TGWU textile branch No. 1/1312 by 550 Kurdish and Turkish workers. This represents a real step forward but will require committed support from the TGWU against the attacks it will face, including trade unionists being shopped to immigration authorities by employers, and in the battles that lie ahead over recognition.
The formation of this branch could provide an example lo migrant workers across London in demanding that the trade union movement join them in resisting the ever-more vicious attacks off the employers and the state.
Simon LynnI
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 14 April 1989
UPDAT E Troops out: self determination for the Irish people
Time to Go!
TEN YEARS AGO, on the 10th anniversary of British troops going on to the streets in the north of Ireland, to prop up the tottering Orange State, a demonstration for withdrawal, called by a broad alliance of forces including the Com- munist Party, the Troops Out Movement, the Socialist Workers Party, the Young Liberals and a lew Lahour MPs, attracted less than 10,000 people. This August, on the 20th anniversary there is to be a march followed by a carnival.
Called by the Time to Go Cam- paign around the slogan of: "For British Withdrawal from Ireland, Time to Go', the organisers hope to attract a much larger tumout for both events than the "traditional withdrawal movement'. Their belief is that those forces who would not now support troops out and self determination will be mobilised by the slogan "Time to Go'.
The AGM of the Labour Com- mitfee on ireland (LCI) endorsed the Time To Go initiative by a small majority and after much criticism. The LCI also committed itself to building the largest pos- sible withdrawal contingent on the August demonstration on the basis of 'troops out and "self-deter. mination for the irish People and to co-ordinate this with the Troops Our Movement and the Irish in Britain Representation Group:
Many of the problems in the relationship between the Time to Go initiative and other elements of the Year of Action flow from the conception of how to extend the influence of the traditional withdrawal movement put for- ward by the leadership of Time To Go.
There is agreement on the need
to hroaden support and the Time To Go could have been the basis for a broad alliance of those in favour of withdrawal, including those who do not support self determination. The main problem has been the insistence by Time To Go that it must, in the words of one of its leaders, "hegemonise' the Year of Action. In Scotland, sup port for the much discredited Chatter was made the precondition of participation in the Time To Go Committee.
It is this, together with the bureaucratic methods of the Time To Go leadership which has done much to divide and, in some cases hold back, the process of building
movement for British withdrawal.
It is ironic that most of the ac- tivities on the ground have been organised by people who, while not giving political support to Time To Go because it puts preconditions on British withdrawal, are prepared to work with any other forces towards that end
The same problems are emerg- ing in relation to the demonstration on August 12. The first organising committee for the demonstration did not take place until March 9 and then only after an emergency resolution to the LCI AGM and sustained pressure on LCI mem- hers of the Time To Go National Council. The late start in setting up an organising committee and the laid-back attitude of Time To Go Council members to such urgent matters as the preparation of publicity material, has fuelled the suspicion in the L.Cl and elsewhere that the demonstration is very much secondary to the camival in the minds of the Time To Go or- ganisers. Matters were not helped by the announcement that there was to be no rally at the end of the
Uprising in Kashmir
EVENTS IN INDIA often go unnoticed in the west: however the past few months have brought struggles which are of immense importance for the region. In particular there have been increased calls for an independent Kashmir, the norther state bordering Pakistan and the now troubled Tibet
Demonstrations and riots have broken out in the Kashmir's two major cities, Jammu and Shrinigar, causing Indian Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi the same problems as thone he faces in the i neighbouring Punjab.
Jammu-Kashmir and the Pun- jab are both areas of vital impor lance to Indian politics and economics. The predominance of sikhs in the Punjab and muslims in Kashmir makes the majority in both states hostile to hindu India. There have been repeated calls for an independent Punjab, resulting in fighting especially around the Punjab capital and sikh holy city of Amritsar. Last year alone thousands of people were killed, forcing the govern ment to declare the arca a restricted zone.
Now in Jammu and Kashmir, the two states directly to the north, there has been a resurgence in the struggle for independence which began in 1947 when the British cynically backtracked on their promise of a Kashmir state, and rode roughshod over Kashmiris" distinctive language, culture and religion by making them a part of India.
Kashmir's capital, the pice ture sque city of Shrinigar, sitting on the shores of Lake Dal at the
demonstration and that there would be no political input to the camival other than the music and what the bands might say.
Worst of all, plans have been laid for the march which make or- ganising a rally impossible. When pressed, they conceded that it was essential to have speakers at the camival, though who these will be is, at the moment, a matter for spoculation.
A combination of a small demonstration and low key speakers at the camival would be a setback to building a withdrawal movement and it throws away the opportunity to speak to new for- ces, which was the rationale for
foot of the Himalayas, has made the headlines recently for its violent demonstrations. Apart from muslim reaction against Salman Rushdie, there have been far more important clashes be- tween supporters of Pakistan, India, and independence,
Despite its reputation for poverty. India in a strong regional economic power, which acts in an imperialistic manner towards na- tional minorities and dissenting states. India could almost be described as practising "capitalism in one country, with most of its consumer goods being home made and very little in the way of exports. It is difficult to spot a westem car on the roads and refreshingly impossible to buy Coca Cola.
Gandhi's determination to hold on to the Punjab and Kash- mir has an economic basis these two areas include some of the richest and most prosperous farming land on the subcontinent. The loss of such wealth could help put the skids under Gandhi's regime, which is already losing some of its political grip on the rest of india.
Such a blow struck at the centralised authority of the Delhi government would strengthen the hand of the masses elsewhere in India. It is for this reason that socialists should support the right of the Kashmiris and Punjabis to self-determination, while look. ing for the future not towards a patchwork of isolated capitalist statelets on the sub-continent but a socialist united states of India, based on free association of sovereign peoples.
Jonathan Jones
Time to Go in the first place. If, as is likely, the biggest tumout is for. the music rather than the march, having no rally and no one calling for Brits Out will make the event indistinguishable from a Christy Moore gig at the National, and surely less political.
While continuing to press for a proper rally and to ensure that there is some political input to the camival, the I.CI must make a big effort to ensure that on August 12 there is a massive demonstration for Troops Out and Self Deter- mination.
Even at this late stage, there is still time to ensure that happens.
David Coen
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 14 April 1989
PaRe 3
Beleagured
Benazir stands
firm
THE MASS mobilisations by fundamentalist muslims in Pakistan over the Salman Rushdie issue are simply the latest aspect of a fightback by supporters of the old regime of General Zia against the goverment of Benazir Bbut- 10.
Fundamentalist forces in par- ticular had done well under Zia, and seen their dream of islamisa- tion nearly come true: they now fear a possible reversal of their 'achievements". Some rushed at once to army chiefs as soon as the election results were declared last November, begging them to take over again.
The somewhat chastened of ficers refused; they had nothing to gain and everything to lose if they took power at that stage. Even Zia had promised elections in 1988 before the August air crash killed him and most of his top army generals. And the officers also knew as well as Bhutto that whoever came to power in November would not be able to in- terfere with the interests of the army or its American masters.
A massive 41% of Pakistan's budget is eaten up by the armed forces: all in all the country spends 87% of its money on defence, ad- ministration and servicing the $17 billion foreign debt. In com- parison it spends 0,57% on health and 1.7% on education - in a country where 40% of all deaths are caused by water-bome dis- eases and the literacy rate is only
True enough, Benazir Bhutto publicly declared on taking office that she cannot cut military expen diture - for the simple reason that the powerful armed forces "won't allow it". This point was made bru- tally obvious to her in the period between winning the election and taking office.
Army chief of staff General Mirza Asiam Beg joined with the figurehead President of Pakistan Ghulam Ishaq Khan (Formerly a minister in Bhutto's father's government, but kept on as a close advisor by his murderor General Zia) and 'unexpected" guests-the USA's deputy Secretary of
Page 4
Defence, the deputy Secretary of State and the US ambassador, to spell out terms.
The US repre- sentatives came with a strong bar- gaining hand: as a result of recent decisions by the US Congress.
Pakistan has the third highest al- location of US economic aid - after Isracl and Egypt - as well as massive military aid.
It was agreed that Benazir would follow Zia's economic foreign and defence policies - so much so that she has retained Zia's foreign minister Sahabzada Yaqoob Khan. There is to be no nationalisation of any sort, and foreign investment will be en- couraged. This has angered not only the left but also many of Bhutto's own supporters, who believe that after cleven years of suffering and torture they have been asked to compromise with the torturers and work with their enemies.
Bhutto has inherited a bankrupt economy. Just before the election the interim regime hastily signed
an agreement with the Internation-
al Monetary Fund for a ES55 mil- lion loan, in exchange for a promise to impose austerity measures.
However most of the left op position groups realise that any or- ganised campaign against her Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) goverment would now play right into the hands of the right wing cut throats who hate any sort of democracy, and would love to see another fundamentalist dictator- ship imposed on the country. Much to the dismay of these for- ces, Bhutto's first speech as Prime Minister announced some very radical reforms, many of which are (thankfully) 'unislamic' in the eyes of the mullahs and their right
Bhutto: fa
wing allies.
Among other proposals, Bhut- to:
• lifted the previous ban on trade union activities:
• permitted student unions to frinction:
Bhutto: far-reaching reforms have angered mullahs
• commuted thousands of death sentences to life imprison- ment;
• promised that all laws which specifically discriminate against women will be abolished.
The last two pronouncements in particular were very hurtful to the mullahs who believe in 'eye for an eye punishments and had worked with Zia to subject Pakis- tani women to barbaric oppres sion.
Bhutto has also promised to release all political prisoners. withdraw cases pending against opponents of the previous regime, set aside the sentences passed against oppositionists in their ab- sence, and made immediate arran- gements for political exiles to retum home. Women will be given equal treatment on wages and working conditions, she says.
These measures, though not yet completely fulfilled, have changed the climate in a country suffocated by social, political and religious oppression. Within months of only the second election in the country's 41-year history, Pakistan is enjoying more freedom than ever before.
This " breath of fresh air" is quite unacceptable to the mullahs, who believe that liberal, modern. secular ideas lead to godlessness. In the last week of February = united convention of ulamas (religious scholars) was held in Rawalpindi, linking three of the largest muslim sects. It declared that the installation of a woman as head of state is 'unislamic', and decided to start a campaign to get rid of 'woman's rule.
Socialists should fight this counter-attack by the mullahs and, while preserving their own politi- cal independence, side with Bhut- to in ridding the country of in-
human, degrading and oppressive laws imposed under Zia's martial law. In doing so they can take ad- vantage themselves of the new democratic rights to organise politically and in the new trade unions that will spring up.
This does not mean uncritical support for anything Bhutto says or does: but socialist demands and tactics should make use of and maximise the present process of democracy and not axmist the ultra- night efforts to topple the govern- ment
A strengthened mass move. ment of workers and peasants will be necessary to combat the threat of a right wing/military come- back. There is much basic reor- ganisation and political prepara- tion to be done, and no advantage in a premature showdown which will see the workers and op- pressed once more the losers.
No existing mass leadership of- fers any more radical economic, military or foreign policy than Bhutto. While it works to ensure that this alternative is built, the left should continue to fight for even fuller democracy, and raise slogans including:
• The army back to the bar- racks, the mullahs back to the mosques!
• No US bases in Pakistan!
• No help to the mujahedin in Afghanistan!
• Full rights to national minorities and minority provin- ces!
• No discrimination against women in jobs!
Ir would not be too surprising if Bhutto herself and the bulk of her PPP supporters were to welcome left campaigns on such demands as a counterweight to right wing and LIS pressure.
Ahmad Shuja
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 14 April 1989
UP D T
Wealth tax not Poll tax
THE POLL TAX is one of the most swingeing attacks on the working class and on local government that Thatcher has introduced. The response of the leadership of the labour movement has been pathetic on this issue as on the many other attacks facing the work- ing class. They have refused to countenance any action that goes outside the law: whether it be non-implementation by councils or trade unionists or the building of a mass non- payment campaigo.
Nevertheless, the campaign against this iniquitous tax con- tinues to grow apace. In England and Wales new groups are being formed every week. In Scotland
the ...
pain nas w
strength and direction following the successful 'unity conference" held in Glasgow on March 4.
In response to this groundswell, the Labour Party in making the weekend of April 8 one of "local activity' against the poll tax and the TUC have agreed to call a national demonstration, but not until July 1 in Manchester.
This hardly matches up to the
national demandr for demonstration at the beginning of April (when collection started in Scotland) for which many ac- tivists have lobbied consistently. By July registration will be well under way in England and Walcs. ax will be collection in Sontland, an the moment when local cam- paigns most need the boost of cof lective mass action will have passed However, it is vital that the lahour movement responds to both these calls, that we attemptto make them as successful as pos sible, and give the leadership ax little excuse as possible to argue that they have tried to give a lead, but no-one is interested.
The shallow response of 'new realism is not only apparent thrugh their failure lo give direc- tion lo the mass movement, hut
also through their altemative to
the tax itself. The document Local
nieren
"ur Par
April
mad
48a88
services, localchoices localtaxes produced by the labour Party for last yearx annual conference proposes two local taxes - a local income tax and a new property fax. Apart from the obvious draw- hack of seeming to propose twice
TAX
ohn Hans/IF
as many taxes as at present, their arguments do nothing to deal with the fact that taxation under the
present system is deliberately
designed to shift resources from poor to rich. Their two taxes will merely perpetuate this fact.
It is not possible to deal with the crisis in local goverment merely by addressing the question of finances at the level of the local state. We need rather to look at taxation in a much more com- prehensive sense; to attack the fact that both local and national taxatinn are regressive, or only slightly progressive, to point out that taxes on profits and uneamed income are pathetic, while work- ing class people face unemploy- ment and low wages. Socialists argue for a steeply rising Wealth tax as an alternative to the present system of taxabion.
Any comprehensive solution to the issue of local authority fund- ing has to take into account such issues as the proportion of local authority spending that goes lo pay debt charges - much of which had been incurred long before the imposition of rate-capping. In tenns of property taxes, it is non- sense to claim as the Association of London Authorities document An Alternative to the Poll Tax does that rates have proved to be *a good local tax over hundreds of years'. As a tax on the value of a property, rates do not necessarily
SUPPORT
TENANTS
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 14 April 1989
PO
HERE
bear the slightest relation to the
A radical overhaul of the way wealth of the people living in the Rate Support Grants are axenned property.
needs to be a key plank of any
In the period before the intro- proposals. The government's duction of ratecapping, the fight moveto Necds Assessment' sup- against rate rises was correctiv posedly simplities the current sys seen by many socialists as an im tem, but in practice makes it easier portant part of the battle to protect to deny support to Labour working class living standards; authorities. The Labour Party op- we fought under the banner of No poses this and talks of more ac cuts, no rent increases and no rate curately reflecting need in Rate increases. Councils which Support Grant assessment, hut in funded improvements to services practice the control that local through massive rate increases authorities require is over how such as Walthamstow and Ealing they spend their income. not
in London did so on the backs of working class peopic. The issue has not ceased to be relevant. Fur- ther, in the last year before the im- position of the poil tax in England and Wales, the debate shout going for high rate increases is being used in the Labour Party and trade unions as a supposed alternative to making cuts or confronting the government; a supposed third way which is in fact only another cut in living standards.
Before new taxes can he intro duced a first demand must be made that local authority debts are written off so that the financial manoeuvres used by councils do not now impose too high a burden. We are already secing the effectof this in boroughs such as Brent and Haringey being forced to make cuts and put up rates in order to pay for their refusal to fight in previous ycars,
where it comes from, and there in no particular reason why all taxa- tion should not he collected na tionally, as long as local people had the ability to determine how local needs were addressed.
Of course there will not be agreement on these issues amongst activists campaigning against the polltax. The key issuex within these campaigns will be fighting for non-cooperation with the tax by councils and trade unions, building opporition to the register and developing massnon- payment campaigns. Bur socialists should uxe the debate around the poll tax to develop dis- cussion not only around local goverment financing but around the whole question of taxation more generally.
Terrv C
Page 5
U P DATE
Pletro GIgI/IR
'Democracy under the gun: army in a Salvadoran refugee camp
El Salvador Elections
ARENA wins'
while masses
stay away
THE QUESTION as to whether the elections in El Sal- vador represent a qualitative turning point in the political situation is still an open one. However, despite the short period that has elapsed since, it is possible to register a number of important political points.
The first thing to note is the tum out for the election. According to reports from San Salvador, this ap pears to have been lower (how much lower is open to question) than the 30% for the town council elections in carly 1988. There are 2.8 million eligible voters in El Salvador, but only 1.8m are registered to vote. Even if the recent tum out was equal to the council elections, ARENA can only have won 12% of 2.8m poten- tial voters (based on the 55% that ARENA appears to have won) and the figure is more likely to be below 10%. In effect, the party of the oligarchy was voted for by the oligarchy and the legitimacy of the ARENA goverment within El Salvador is non-existent.
There were several reasons for such a low tum out. The FMLN proposal for a postponement to enable them to take part received overwhelming support from the people of El Salvador. This offer had the effect winning the leader- ship of the radical trade union
movement, the UNTS, to call a
boycott. The refusal of ARENA and the Christian Democrats to respond to this offer significantly increased support for the FMLN position when the elections went ahcad.
In addition, the position of the ballot boxes, within the wealthier arcas of San Salvador, for in- stance, as well as near to army bar- racks, meant that it was both physi- cally difficult for the poor to vote. and intimidating given the social tenvion that existed in El Salvador during the clection period.
Finally, two other key factors were a product of the FMIN's politico-military strength. Bet- ween one third and one quarter of the country is under the control of
the guerillas and the population
within it obviously played no piut.
Secondly, the FMLN's transport
strike was a total success and
demonstrated yet again that there
are two armed powers within El
Salvador capable of enforcing policy on a nationwide scale.
But none of these factors will
stop ARENA claiming that the
elections were legitimate and the
US winning international respect-
ability for the new government in
the short term. From the moment
that ARENA appeared to be the
'Democracy ur
only party that could win the clec- tion outright it became inevitable that the United States would switch horses and begin to present ARENA as an acceptable altema- tive. In the next period the US has to hold the hardliners back until, at least, international attention is focussed elsewhere. The best pos- sible result for US imperialism would be the construction of a new centre right alliance based on the Christiani wing of ARENA and the fragments of the Christian Democrats which would opcrateto hold back the 'total war porition on the far right of Salvadorean politics.
Despite all the publicity given to the now president Freddi Chris- tiani, it is common knowledge that the real power still lies with
D' Aubuisson and the right wing of
ARENA. They are committed to completely destroying the labour
movement and popular organisa. tions, and to a reenactment of the
1932 massacre, only this time on a grander scale. This type of
scenario, although not on the cards
in an immediate sense, is
a real possibility if the
army leadership feels a
life and death struggle is
imminent and attempts lo
strike the first blow. This
is not the perspective of a
crated minority but a
coherent alternative for
the El Salvadorian
International
Advert
VIEWPOINT
A fortnightly review of news and analysis
published under the auspices of the United
Secretariat of the Fourth International
nited
Subscribe now!
Payment: French francs preferred. Cheques to PEC, CCP No 2 322 42T Paris. Bank transfers to PEC, BNP Robesplerre, Account 230179/90. Important: All bank or postal transfers must also be notified by letter. Subscription and correspondence to:
International Viewpoint, 2 rue Richard Lenoir, 93108 Montreuil, France Subscription rates:
Surface Mail: 1 year 200F FIE18; 6 months 120FF/£9.50
Air Mail: 1 vear 245FF/£21; 6 months 135F F/E13
Paris. nt: All
tive comes to appear as the only serious one will depen apo° the development of the mass
movement and the guenil-
la struggle. The discus- nion around the clections created = pop majority for the FMIN's position and developed a united front between the
oligarchy
How tar
How far this perspec-
mas to appear »
labour movement (principally the UNTS) and the guerrilla forces on the immediate tactical question. Ar the same time the FMLN has been demonstrating a capacity to operate in urban areas which at one paint led to a rocket attack on the presidential palace and other buildings representative of state power. There has been the development of the MPTI. (The Movement for Peace, Work and Land) which is a movement in working class areas that is laying the basis for insurrection at a street level via both the development of street level organisation and the at- tempt to respond act for act to the repressive activities of the army and the police.
Thus the elements clearly exist for an insurrection at some point.
The issue is whether the FMIN is able to translate its majority on the
question of the elections into a majority on the question of how to
overthrow the present system ie. whether or not it can take the
political leadership of the whole
opposition to the ARENA govem-
ment, its war against the people.
and the US aid to the Salvadorean
regime. The FMLN's stated belief
is that an insurrection is possible in
the next twelve months and that it
is a question of binding together
the popular organisations for a
final offensive and producing the
catalyst that will set the process in
motion.
Whalever the result of these
political developments it is clear that the left must step up its
vivity and build links the FMIN and the amar task ix to build a ..all for the end of all # Salvador. Affiliate to vador Solidarity Cam- in Compton Terrace.
Will McMahon
Page 6