F E A T UR
against
JANE KELLY looks at some of the issues raised
by the Rushdie affair and censorship in the light
of de-regulated TV.
Within the space of a few months we've seen the Government ban on Sinn Fein's right to free speech and support for Sal- man Rushdie's freedom of expression; the setting up of a new TV watchdog the Broadcasting Standards Council (BSC), under the watchful eye of Lord Rees- Mogg, and much discussion on the like- ly filling of deregulated TV with soft
porn: remember the ad Italian
housewives do it on TV'? The Tories (and in some cases people who should know better) are supremely pragmatic when it comes to censorship. The left however, cannot afford to be.
Although Howe and Thatcher have since hacked down from total support for Rushdie. the Tories' immediate response was to defend him to the hilt, in complete contrast to their im- position of a ban on the right of Gerry Adams and others to express their point of view on the North of Ireland. Perhaps the proximity of Ireland compared to iran had something to do with it; or maybe the racist attitude of the British Government led them to abhor the Ayatollah's death threat to an (albeit Pakistani) British writer, while conveniently forgetting their own use of censorship.
The Rushdie affair has also produced some unexpected divisions amongst the left intellec- tuals, resuscitating the debate about the Jim Allen play Perdition. Some who favoured cen-
sorship (bocause of accusations of historical in- accuracy!) in that case, now present themselves
as being opposed in principle to any form of
censorship. Others whose past record might have led one to expect something better, have
come down in favour of a kind of self-censor- ship-John Berger and Dilip Hiro for example.
Religion and race
Some of the confusion arises from a misplaced anti-racism. Feeling. quite rightly. that the Moslem community in Britain suffers racism, such intellectuals respond in an am- bivalent way to the Islamic attack on The Satanic Verses. There has been similar con- fusion in response to Moslem demands for religious and single-sex schools. Religion is not the same thing as race. The left has to determine its support or otherwise for demands of black or other oppressed groups on the basis of politics. of which anti-racism is only one component. Thus, for example, we should argue that we are
Page 8
apposed to all religious schools includ- ing Moslem ones, and we are also ap- posed to the oppression of all women, in- cluding within the Islamic community-
Amongst Labour politicians 100 the divisions have been unexpected - and confused. Some, with more than half an eye to their con- stituency, have echoed the Iranian denuncia tions of Rushdie's book. Other Labour MP's on the left have called for the Blasphemy Law 1o be extended to all religions, with only a hand- ful correctly demanding its total abolition. For this law is not just a quaint, anachronistic left- over from feudalism. It was used as recently as the mid 1970 against a homosexual poem about Christ in Gay News.
Images of women
folio Etchort Roller
Soft porn from the Sky?
The confusion over censorship is not con- fined to the Rushdie affair. Claire Short's bill against Page 3 nudes, ridiculed for the worst of reasons by most Tory and many other MPs in Parliament, received more than 5000 letters of support from women who favoured censorship. Out of that support, both financial and moral. the Campaign against Pomography was set up. The campaign claims that there are direct links between violence against women, sexual abuse of children and pomography. But it has no clear theoretical framework, and while not directly calling for censorship is ambivalent about what action should he taken.
Atthe same time we have the new Broadcast- ing Standards Council (BSC) expressing con cem about the stereotyped portrayal of women on TV, using arguments developed by feminists when analysing sexist imagery and preparing to decide for us what we can watch on the new de- regulated airwaves. Market forces and in- dividual freedom reign - but not when it comes to sex. Evoking a mythical public disgust, sex and violence, irrevocably conjoined by Mary
Whitehouse and the censors, are to be banned from nur screens for our own good. However. the statistics do not support this view of public opinion. Far from being the first reason for com- plaint, the representation of sex on TV is rather
top and bran vi
-612800
urust. with rescheduling at the
vendence hon language and sex
in- order And when Channel 4 .. mamous mol triangle to desig zht filmir - a lot of sex in them
Annhica
No, it's not a question of public disquiet, but rather what is thought to be gond for us. And
despite the evocation of feminist concems: despite the "The BSC intends to crack down on commer- cials which reinforce sexual stereotypes and en- force a laste and decency requirement on adyarisements the trik ix that such stereotyping is not the real concem. Material dealing with controversial issues, inclurling sexual issues, hut not limited to these, will be banned. We know from the Soction 28 debate that open images of lesbians and gay men are Liable to be censored.
How should socialists and feminists respond to all this? Although much interesting and im- portant analysis has been undertaken in relation to the representation of women in the mediatin- cluding film, TV and advertising), the question of what should he done about it is a vexed nne. And when it comes to pornography proper then the debate becomes very heated, as the session at the Women for Socialism conference proved, with the question of censurship at the heart of the debate.
Pornography
The parameters of the pornography debate are represented by Andrea Dworkin, an American radical feminist on the one hand and Angela Carter, British novelist and feminist on the other. Dworkin argues that pornogmphy is an 'institution of male supremacy' "propagan- da for and a tool of sexual suppression of women inbelievably powerful in its effects It was Andrea Dworkm with Catherine MacKinnon who introduced the anti- pomography ordinance in the US, at present
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 14 April 1989
T U R ES law
Taw only 1. Besingham. Washington. The ordinance allows an individual's complaints against the display or use of pornographic material to be taken up as a matter of Civil Rights.
Carter, at the opposite end of the spectrum, argues in her book The Sadeian Woman: sexual relations between men and women always render explicit the nature of social relations in the society in which they take place and, if described explicit- ly, will form a critique of those relations * Further the pornog- rapher "may not think of himself as a friend of women; that may be the last thing on his mind. But he will always be our unconscious ally be- cause he begins to approach some kind of emblematic truth, whereas the lackey pomog- rapher, like the devious fellows who wrile love
stories for women's magazines, that softest all forms of pornography, can only do hame of
Carter is explicitly opposed to any form of censorship. She pointer. that hard pom ex- poses the ugly reality that underpins sexual rels- tions in a capitalist society and as such is ex- plicity political. Soft pom on the other hand, is both more pervasive and more dangeroux: far from exposing