Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Political urban cowboy

· Socialist Outlook no. 13, March 1989 · p 32 · 1,122 words

Latin America

urban

For Queen and Country Fllm, starring Denzil Washington Reviewed by Barbara Green

THE FILM tells the story of a young black man from South London who has had a "mis-spent' youth and joins the British Army. He serves in the North of Ireland and the Falklands.

After eight years service he leaves because he is consistently refused promotion. The rest of the film concentrates on the problems he has when he retums to his run down council estate.

The film's message is clear: the British imperialist state is quite happy to use black and working class people as cannon fodder hut deserts them after they ve served their purpose. Not such a new theme, but what makes this film slightly different is that it trys to deal with this in the context of urban unrest. It brings in a Broadwater Fam type situation which all the main

characters are eventually involved in.

It is difficult for me to review this film because although I had assumed that I would enjoy it, I did not. My complaint is not about the message, but about the technique. The film is quite long. it is very short on dialogue.! suspect this is because the main character who is supposed to be from South London is in fact an American actor called Denzel Washington of Biko and St Elsewhere fame, and his acccat is appalling. Unfortunately these things matter, particularly if you

come from South London - contrary to the image in the film not everyone fmom these parts greets each other with quaint little ditties like I'm ducking and diving — fucking and skiving"!

The director and co-writer, Martin Stellman says he thinks the film is an urban westem, dwelling on men with violent asts trying to hang up their guns ind settle down and ther renlising that this is not possible

asts trying to hang up their guns

and ending up even more violent.

ancy seeing an urban westem with politics this is the film for you — otherwise I'm not sure it's worth the effort.

So if you urban we

Sorry!

Page

POWER IN THE ISTHMUS: Political History of Modern Central America James Dunkerley, Verso 1988

Reviewed by

Maria Astorga

JAMES DUNKERLEY'S book is undoubtedly the milestone that its cover promises, It could become essential reading for anyone interested in the politics of the region were it not for its unpopular price of E29.95 which puts it beyood reach ifor the many

The first part looks at the whole of Central America — its history since the 1821 independence trom Spain and the formation of a riberal regime to the present crisis and intervention of US imperialism.

It shows that the ideal of a united single nation was never achived, as there wete no

changes in the distribution of

wealth and therefore no struggle

for a nation. A cluster of city

states calling themselves

republics, in the shadow of

Guatemalan hegemony and an

increasing subordination to the

"demands of production for an intemational market organised

on the logic of capitalism'

shaped the future.

The capitalisation of

agriculture was not paralleled by

any industrialisation which would have formed a unified and large proletariat: leading to

uneven and combined development' as Dunkerley recognises. Capitalist agriculture tarted with coffee in Costa Rica

in the 1830 and was to produce

similar one crop economies in

all countries, leading them later

Unity and diversity

to be nicknamed banana republics.

Each country has its spocificities that explain the particular formation of the mling elites, the role of the military and the emergence of revolutionary movemenis. Dunkerley uses the dual theme of unity and diversity to encapsulate this process. He also introduces the theme of rupture and continuity, insisting on two periods of ruptures that influenced the present situation: the mid-40s and 1979-82. This Latter period saw the triumph of the Nicaraguan revolution, changes in the governments of otber countries, the "final offensive" and defeat of the FMLN in El Salvador, the wave of repression in Guatemala, that is reactions by ruling classes and revolutionaries to the impact of the successful Sandinismo.

This book was completed in 1987 and so does not cover the most recent developments with their increasingly rapid pace which might indicate a new period of rupture in Central America. Nicaragua is totally suffocated cconomically (the Intest inflation figure reactice 36,000%), El Salvador is on the verge of cloctions in which the polarisation betwoen the FMIN and the extreme-right wing party ARENA will come to a head There in a similar polarisation in Guatemala between thin mantr right-wing faction of the army and the popular movement on the rise. Even Honduras does not remain immune to the conflict having inherited a forign army

of uncontrolled mcrcenaries with the military defeat of the contras.

The sccond part of Power in the Isthmus analyses cach of the five countries (Nicaragun, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras and Costa Ricar ap to 1487. A short review cannot do justice to the abundance of material and Ideas detailed in the book.

On Nicaragua for example, there in a long analysis of the

political and economic complexities of the country leading the author to state that "Nicaragua is not a worken" state since a considerable portion of the cconomy remains in the hands of large capitaliet enterprise and to proceed with a long analysis of the varioux clements of this position. It makes compulsive reading but does not attempt to provide any characterisation of the Nicaraguan state, using the unciarified team of Sandinismo. This position is close to that of Carlos Vilas, from whow many statistics are taken, but might not heip to clarily the dehate among the left. In the very valuable description of the economic factors, the role played by the wiltra war in sonichow underestimated. This is regrettable because the economic impact of the war is one of the key elements in understanding Nicaragua's present situation and the US policy. To downplay it can give

support to those who tend to blame Sandinists mismanagement an the main cause for this disastrous state of

affairs.

The same in-depth analysis of

the political components and

evolution of the ather countries

provides the readers with a wealth of information and a verve reminiscent of the author's previous books on El Salvador

(The Long War) and on Bolivia ‹nunerlion in the Varrisi

Given the density of the information, the myriad of cross

relerences demonstrating an extraordinary mastery of the

subject, the academic but elegant style, there is no sense of repetition in the 661 pages that include fascinating footnotes. Power in the Isthmus is not an easy read and presupposes a contain familiarity with the situation to be able to be fully

political synthesis.

← A green crop of slogans · Heavy on Stalinism, light on answers →

Something wrong on this page?