Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Heavy on Stalinism, light on answers

· Socialist Outlook no. 13, March 1989 · pp 32-36 · 2,992 words

Stalinism Russia and the USSR Trotsky Marxism

Perestroika Annual Ent Abel Aganbegvan 'Futura. E9.ag. 346 pages)

Reviewed by FINN JENSEN

ROBERT MAXWELL has taken the initiative in puhlishing yearbooks charting the progress of perestroika in the Soviet (Inion. They will be edited

alinism, light on answers

by Professor Abel

describes 16 outstanding men.

hut not one woman! Indeed only Aganbegyan, a close ally of

une of the twelve contributor to Soviet President Mikhail

the volume is a woman; not Gorbachev:

surprisingly the lilveration of

The first Perestroika Anal

Soviet women is not mentioned was published at the end of 1988 in the book ax a special task for and contains 12 cesays by

perextroika, though there is much journalists, econumisty, artists.

about the liberation of the people sociologists, sposts personalities

as a whole, Also omitled is the and church leaders. Although all

issue of gay and lesbian rights. of them hilly support

while the vexed issue of the Gorbachev s relorm programme.

national question and the the twelve authors do not have a

conflicts between nationalities unifom view of events.

within the USSR is mentioned

The opening chapter, a

anly in pissing, with an 'Who's Who of Perestmika".

sulutions proposed other tran

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 12 February 19B9

Weapon of

War

Mapantsula A film by Oliver Schmitz and Thomas Mogotlane

Review by David Grant

There is something deliciously seductive about enjoying the fruits of a secretive, subversive labour,

When the resulting product is both challenging and compelling the experience is pleasurahle indeed. Such is the appeal of Mapantsula, shot directly under the ever-watchful, although in this case seemingly not very alert, eyes of the South African police state. The film makers pretended to the authorities that they were making an ordinary gangster movie. In reality, the film is a critique of, and an attack, on apartheid.

Refreshingly, its subject matter is the inter relationship between the black working class and lumpen proletanat, highlighting the use the apartheid state makes of the latter to contain the power

the pres of the former.

The focus here is most

definately black. And high time too! Cry Freedom left a distinctly liberal taste in the mouth. Were we really supposed to take seriously the transformation of Steve Biko into a latterday Christ figure. wandering through gardens, relating the teachings of (peaceful, what else 17) black

conciousness, sermon-like. to an open-mouthed, white liberal ? Still, what can we expect from a film director prepared to kneel before the monarchy?

Our hero is Panic, a small time petty criminal from Soweto. Through a circuitous route. which ends in his incarceration. he comes into contact with the township comrades" and the

R EV

Shooting

will never

44. /71

never

stop our

Scruggle

sple of Soweto as themselves in Map film, to asserting the centrality of the hlack working class to the struggle against apartheid. It wrests the imagery of this struggle away fron the news organisations and the mainstream film industry whose liberal, su called balanced ideological viewpoint has, up until now, gone unchallenged. Mapantsula states that there is another way of seeing these same pictures. The film's

Reality as fiction - the peop trade unions. A well structured use of flash back takes us through Panic's journey towards understanding. His isolated,

marginal and subjective rehellion is contrasted to that of

his politicised cell mates, They enjoy a profound solidarity that

empowers them even in the face of imprisonment and torture.

The gaols may be full, but they

are also filled with singing and

defiance, One of the 'contrades"

observes that life in a prison cell

is not that much different to life

at a warden.

in the Soweran township. least we don't have to worry

indeed, it has advantages! At

worry

about being arrested, be shouts

Mapantsula shares common ground with Pontecorvo's The Battle for Algiers, the politicisation and heroic transformation of the petty

ne rile

pantsula. militant stance invests images we are used to seeing with a new

content, giving them a suhversive, dangerous twist

The fact that it was filmed in such an audacious manner, in the very heart of the beast, adds much to the pleasure of this. excellent film which, in the best

traditions of oppositional film

making, is both work of at and

weapon of war.

akinu

thief/central character; the refusal to simplify and stercotype so that even the white policeman/tortures is a character

with some complexity; the

images of the masses moving

into action as a politicised force

rather than a mob. Director

Oliver Schmitz and lead actor

(also co-writer) Thomas

Mogotiane, however, deliver their film in a more restrained, less epic manner. Mapantsula is a major contribution, through

ts only Thomas Mogotlane as the wide boy of the 'ille checking his weage

going back to tu L conception of at...

The Annua' scene.

discum many tundar

AfTarenI по

Soviet society. All twelve

authors see perestroika as a

in the Brash the "period of stagnation". Throughout the book the criticism of this period of poliucal seas. cultur econollar sponatio and on ine aestro nearly as harsh as critique.

However wras any understand: stagnation and Stour.

otten the explanation is reduced lo blaming bad leaders or the cult of personality. Noue of the

•ex reduced

on the vone of thie nentions the

fight waged against Stalinism by

Trotsky and the Left Opposition

in the 1920c and 1930s, though

Aganbegyan at least has certainly

acad Trotsky, World politics, toe.

are treated very superficially.

arguing vaguely thut political

systems will have to leam so live

logether if mankind is to

of the coonomic systems whuch underlie the political systems, or the class struggle

The supporters of perestroika will have to challenge its

AIMEnT DU

14 OUT

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 12 February 1989

opponents inside the USSK. One of the essays is entitled Friends or Fees? Social forces working

for and agdinst perestroika. atyana L. Zaslavskaya, a sociologist, openly admits that "executives of the apparatus are

probably the staunchest agents of the ideology of the stagnation

Conservatives still

is an influential and dangens mafia oforganised crime" order to deleat these forces a "radical democratic revolution" is

"Is any revolutionary Iransformation of society

social struggle? Certainly not.

It is obvious that even the

present early moves towards

revolution are giving rise to

extensive social struggle*.

was perestr

a "revolution", since it does not

aim to abolish the political

power of the ruling bureatcracy

and replace it with a pluralist

socialist democracy. But the real

question is whether Gorbachev's

supporters will he able to control

the 'extensive social struggles"

that are yet to come?

Page 31

What sort of history? I read Jane Kelly's review of Chiff and Gluckstein's book in SO 12 with some amusement. If the book had avoided drawing poltical conclusions appropriate to the SWP's practice, it would have been criticised instead for being too abstract. But the review also raises the more serious question of what sort of history revolutionaries should write.

No doubt we could all agree that revolutionaries should produce history books that have as their "starting point the interests of the working class'. But in fact, the drift of Kelly's review is that we should not make specific suggestions as to what should be done. Yet, I would argue, most of the best Marxist histories do in fact do this.

Trotsky's History of the Rusian Revolution' in certainly a general history, but its purpose, directly political, was to reassert the revolutionary process in a period where Stalin and social democracy had almost obliterated its memory. E.P. Thompson's "The Making of the English Working Class is not just a general history, but has the concrete effect of furthering his.own socialist humanist political position.

Finally, John Foster's •Class Struggle and the Industrial Revolution" deals with the history of class politics in Oldham in the first half of the nineteenth century. But the methodoingy and analytical categories used are clearly drawn from. and designed to reinforce, Stalinist politics.

Should we find this. surprising? I would suggest not. It is, after all, the ruling class who think it is possible to write neutral history. albeit "naturally" from their world view. Marxist

Page 32

LE T T E R

history, on the other

hand, examines the past in order to suggest ways of changing the present. Chiff and Gluckstein's book more than passes this test, even if the reviewer is unhappy about the specfic changes suggested.

Keith Flett Tottenham.

Thatcher's active base The debates which have opened in the last few issues of SO are not about whether the way forward is Marxism

Today-style defcatism:

nor are they really about

how one is to characterise Thatcherism. They are ahout the

halance of class forces and the tasks facing those

who claim to be

revolutionary marxiste

Phil Hearse's sober assesment of Thatcher's progress towards the strong state (SO 11) was

a refreshing departure from the tendency of

some on the left to focus on the xupposed weakness of her government 'if only the

• Il onlv the working class had a decent leadership'-

The Thatcherites have always sought to build up an active popular base for their strategy, setting in motion the nouveau riche, enterprise-oriented elements who have found seats on the gravy train and increasingly populate the pivotal jobs in our society - the management levels in manutactuning and

service industries,

education, health, social

services, and so on. The

destruction of the public

sector is helping to build

this profit-socking, ruling

class supporting cadre.

These people represent a mass base of a sort and in a real sense are part of a mobilisation - against

the left conservative. Liberal and social democratic forces who used to dominate at least

in the public sector. In

their new portions of power they are let loose on all aspects of working class interests.

With reactionary ideology also finding support in sections of the traditional working class, there is significant social weight behind the attack on our basic rights. The Conservative Party has been transformed by these layers, the pretensions of social democracy severely punctured, and the stalinist bureaucracies given much food for thought. Whatever it is, it is not "business as usual.

As Phil says, this is not a fascist mobilisation; but it would be wrong in dismiss the fascist threat. There is a growing underclass of the dispossessed and despairing. Grinding poverty and disillusion cannot breed to no effect indefinitely. On the wastelands of big city estates, the fascists can move with an ease the Thatcherite yuppie cannot. If we on the socialist left do not seck and find a road to the dispossessed, then the "left" fascists will, and therefore can play a useful supplementary role in the ruling class. offensive.

Phil is right on the need to develop the widest possible support for democratic rights. In the past we have shied away from alliances with non-working class forces, but we have also avoided taking responsibility for fighting abuses of democratic rights ourselves, such as the Birmingham Six and Guildford Four campaigns, where Chris Mullin, Robert Kce and church leaders have taken the lead. Shouldn't we be making a priority of the Broadwater Farm Three case?

Clearly we must vigorusly fight to defend every inch of democratic rights, and our only criterion for alliances must be

agreement on the issue in hand - "Free the Guildford Four' *Maintain the right to silence, and so on.

What is more, on

issues which arise within the labour movement we must be interested enough to have developed a view in advance of the Labour right's initiatives. We were left unprepared and wrong-footed over one person one vote; we are only now beginning te tackle the block vote: and we must urgentiy discuss pruportional representation.

No doubt some sectanans will be busily misinterpreting Phil's formulas as incipient "popular frontism'. This is not how read tus proposals at all, but I do feel his views would have been less open to misunderstanding if be wad llesbed them cur somewhat. He does of course emphasise the

political independence of the workerr movemene Creany he- use of the term "semi-bonapatism" has confused the issue put the real point must not be lost: real steps are being taken agsinst our democratic liberties, thus weakening our ability to resist the general onslaught.

What Phil fate to do... address the relationship between the fight to defend democratic rights and the socialist programme. Such a programme needs to be developed urgently if we are to challenge the successes of the Thatcherites. Dave Packer's article in SO 10 on "The Transitional Programme - a programme for our times" should mark the start of such a process.

Let'smake 1989 the

year in wish we D seriously to develop a

workers inter pran Io save ll Keith White, Coventry

Fighting 'state capitalist' theory There was a typing error in my letter in last month's SO (No 12). Instead of reading that a number of us fought as

an opposition for a

"deformist" position in the international Socialists/S WP against Tony Chiff, it should have read "defencint".

This means "defencist" of the gains of the October 1917 Revolution. We saw a basic contradiction in the IS/SWP's 'state capitalist' view. Whereas unarchists and others who hold a state capitalist" view of the USSR deny that the Russian Revolution was a workers' revolution, the Chiffites do support

1917.

The question then arises: if the working

class took power in 1917.

when precisely did the

counter-revolution take place, since the

capitalists (or bureaucrats, if you wee them as a class) would need to take power at

some obvious point in history. The altemative,

an Trotsky points out, would be a gradual reformist return trom working class power to

capitalism - a type of Fabianism in reverse which is contrary to marxism.

Our argument was then that "defencism" was the key issue, since the Russian Revolution was a step forward for the intemational working class, it must be defended against imperialism - whether you call it a degenerated workers" state, "state capitalist'. "bureaucratic collectivist" or whatever.

That is why the question of defencism is

a key one to put to Sacialist Organiser today. Dave Spencer Coventry

SOCIALISI «SUTLOOK nu 12 Fetiruary

URGENT SOLIDARITY N

DEFEND HUGO BLANCO

AN INTERNATIONAL CAMPAIGN is under

way to defend one of the world's best-known Trotskyists, Hugo Blanco, who

was kidnapped on February 9 by

Peruvian police during a mass demonstration, and has not been seen

since.

Blanco was selzed by machine

gun-toting cops while sharing a

communal meal with 200 peasants af

the headquarters of the Peruvian

Peasant Confederation (CCP) in the Jungle town of Pucalpa, after leading an

8,000-strong demonstration of small farmers. Also arrested was CCP general secretary Luls Tuesta de la Torte. Police

shaved Blanco's head on the spot

before leading him away. This escalation in the repression came in the midst of a strike by Pucalpa peasants demanding the payment of debts owed to them from the state, better prices for

their produce and bank loans af affordabi rates. 28 peasants have been killed in clashes with violent police, and

over 200 imprisoned in the local

barracks. The Peruvian Ministry of the

Interior has announced that Bianco is

being held in Pucalpa prison, and that he could face serious charges of inciting

armed rebellion and carrying arms. Blanco came to prominence in the late

1960s as the principal organiser of the

Peruvian peasants' movement. He

became the leader of thousands of

Quechus Indians in their fight to take

back the lands stolen from them. As a

consequence of these armed

occupations of the land he was

sentenced to 25 years in prison. While

there he wrote his account of the

peasant movement, entitled Land or

Death.

Two days after his relecise In 1970, Bianco

was adderssing a raily of 10,000 people. and he has subsequently been active In

all the major struggles of the oppressed and explolted in Peru. He has served as a

deputy to the Constituent Assembly. elected on a revolutionary platform, and

Hugo Blanco

is currently, along with Luls Tuesta, a leading figure of the Peruvian Partido

Untficado Marlateguista (PUM).

The campaign for the release of Blanco

and Tuesta has been promptly taken up with public statements, demonstrations

and appeals in many countries.

Including Mexico, Sweden, Spain. France. Belglum, Italy and Switzerland.

The seriousness of the charges raised against them underlines the urgency of

mobilising In their support.

Letters, resolutions, petitions and

telegrams from individuals and organisations should be sent at once to the Peruvian embassy in Britain and to

Peruvian President Alan Garcia:

Peruvian Embassy.

52, Sloan Street.

London SW1

Telephone 01-235-1917

Alan Garcia

Presidente de la Repubblica. Palacio de la Goblerno

Plaza de Armas

Lima

PERU

«EFDED!

José Ramón García

José Ramón García

still missing

IN MEXICO, the campaign continues to

demand the retum of a leader of the Trotskyist Revolutionary Workers' Party

(PRT), Jose Ramon Garcia, who

disappeared over two months ago PRI leaders have blamed the police for

this attack, and point to the fact that Garcia was a prominent member of the Committees to Defend the Vote, almed

at combatting precisely the kind of

electoral fraud which secured the

election of new Mexican President

Salinas. His disappearance follows a number of attacks on PRT premises, and

has been followed by police

Interrogation of PRI activists. Telegrams of protest at the abduction of Garcia, and demands that the Mexican state retum him, alive and unharmed,

should be sent to:

Carlos Salinas de Gortiari.

Presiciente Constitucional.

Estados Unidos Mexicanos,

Palocio Nacional Mexico D.F..

Mexico

and to

Antonio Riva Palacio Lopez

Gobernador Constitucional

Estado de Morelos.

Palacio de Goblerno.

Cuernavaca,

Morelos,

Mexico

READ SOCIALIST OUTLOOK EVERY MONTH -

the magazine for the serious left

Special rates for regular individual subscribers:

1 year's subscription (ten issues) for

£7.50 (inland); £10 (Europe); £15 (outside Europe)

(multi-reader institutions E17 inland, E30 overseas

Name.

Address.

Subscription to start from issue number.

(Return to Socialist Outlook, PO Box 705, London SW19 1HA, England

← Political urban cowboy · Not such a strong state? →

Something wrong on this page?