Ecology and Socialism Martin Ryle (Radius, £5.95) The Coming of the Greens Jonathan Porrit and David Winner (Fontana, £4.95)
Reviewed by JOHN MULLINGS
The Coming of the Greens is not a religious reference or a special Hite report on the sexuality of the Green Party but a mine of information on the influence of the green movement throughout British
society.
Some of this claimed influence is rather exaggerated (such us the inclusion of the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds and the National Trust!): but this is linked to another weakness -the a-political nature of the book. It ix strange, for cxample, that the Green Party's opposition to NATO is not mentioned in the
book.
In most cases this is the result of the influence of the German greens, which in tum reflects the alienation of German youth from traditional party politics (which
in Germany has little to do with radical movements of any kind). Luckily, despite different strands of thought in the green movement. Winner and Porrit are not at all hostile to open debate. They are however. quite hopeless on the question of class, presenting completely unserious sociological rubbish in place of any real analysix.
The picture presented of the ercens 1s one of a movement committed to 'small is beautiful". However they were obviously pleased by a joint demonstration held between CND and Friends of the Earth against nuclear power and nuclear weapons on the first anniversary of the Chemobyl disaster in April 1987. This was not so small: it mobilised 50,000 people. Initiatives such as this are the sort of thing the left should propose and support.
The main obstacle to more
such joint initiatives is the
opposition among some Green
Party memhers to organisation.
One wonders how the Green
uty ever got set up in the teeth
•the-opposition. Whether thev like it or not, there has to be some organisation if any form of eco-socialist project ix ever to be
carried out and in any way
democratic.
In a book entitled Ecology
and Socialism, one would expect
to find an explanation of the
programme of the Groen Party
ul an expla
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 12 February 1989
and the strands of political thought on the issue in the Labour Party, if not a discussion
an the ideology of marxism and
the socialist thinking of the green movement.
Instead this book offers an appalling example of
loganising. Martin Ryle frequently uses phrases such as "anti-capitalist alte mative" and parochial and regressive localism without really explaining what he means. This makes the book extremely difficult to read, leaving the reader exasperated at the use of terminology.
Other aspects of the book are not much better. Ryle sees workers owning cars, videos and washing machines as a problem for those seeking to win them to a brand of radical socialiste which must take into account the preservation of the countryside.
He does not answer which
class is going to have to implement a radical eco-socialist programme, which would have to include the nationalisation of industry and the financial institutions. Only this can make possible the re-structuring of the economy to chable workers to make socially usclul products (such as kidney machines) and reopen closed pits to produce power for consumer use.
The reason for Ryle's sloganising is that he is stuck in the bourgenis democratic
tradition. He raises issucs but
does not develop them, apparently failing to understand that it is the profit motive which makes big companies move into areas that have not been developed and destroy the environment.
The closest Ryle gets to a entique of the problem of the
state is not where we might expect it (in the section on the state) but in refcrences to what he calls the "formal cconomy" (for which read finance capital'. He ends up saying that people will be willing to pay more through taxes to develop
cological programmes such as the retro-fitting of coal burning power stations to cut acid emissions. So what need is there for socialist solutions if the
bourgeois state, through the rule of law and the goverment, can
enforce ecology programmes? Never mind the class issues, all
that would be needed are ligh
enough taxes, and laws to
combat environmental damage.
Ecology and Socialism is an
annaying book because some
pans raise issues that should be
exlended - for example on
management - and then
stops on precisely how and
through what agency socialist
whi re it
policies are going to be
presses
Page 29