DEBATE
alley
In our last issue (S.O. 11), in 'Tigers the Indian Army Cannot Tame. Finn Jensen argued that as the leading force - politically and military - in the fight for a liberated Tamil Eelam, the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) should be supported by socialists internationally, irrespective of differences over their tactics. M. MANICKAM and LAL SILVA take issue with him below.
Jensen's analysis contains inaccuracies and fails to deal with the ethnic conflict in Sri Lanka and the role of different political and military groups from a class perspective. His article reproduces uncritically the selective 'facts' and interpretations which the LTTE use, and so jensen unwittingly abandons a marxist approach.
Tamils and the Tamil nation
Tamils make up about 21.5 per cent of the population of Sri Lanka. But there are sig- nificant caste, class, political and economic dif- ferences between the Tamils in the northern and caster provinces of Sri Lanka, and the Tamil plantation workers who live mainly in the Central and Uva provinces. Jensen lumps them together.
And by stating that 'A plantation conomy was introduced in Sri Lanka which forced hundreds of thousands of Tamil labourers to migrate to the Sinhalese south",Jensen gives the impression that a significant proportion of these Tamil plantation workers came from the north and east of Sri Lanka, or Ceylon, as it was then called. This was not the case. All the plantation workers came from South India and they were regarded as low caste 'untouchables by Ceylon Tamils, who were used as middle management and as supervisory personnel by the British plantation Raj. In 1948 when the first post-in- dependence goverment formed by the conser- vative United National Party (UNP) dis- enfranchised the Tamil plantation workers, the overwhelming majority of Ceylon Tamil MPs voted in favour of that draconian act. The marx- ist and liberal MPs (mainly Sinhalese) voted and campaigned against it. Furthermore, up until 1965, Ceylon Tamil politicians regularly fored coalition governments with the UNP
This accounts not only for the traditional an- tagonism between the plantation Tamils and
Ceylon Tamils, but also for the total lack of sup-
port amongst plantation Tamils for the demand
for a separate Tamil state, despite the super-ex-
ploitation they have suffered for many decades.
These are not just historical issues. Even today, the LTTE has no programme for the tea
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 12 February 1989
plantation workers. and have consistent- ly failed to support their struggles. In fact any attempt to campaign on the specific demands of the plantation workers has been opposed by the LTTE as a diver- sion. Nol surprising- ly in the recent presidential elec- tions held last December, the vast majority of the plan Lation workers voted for the UNP candidate.
For the very same reason it is methodologi- cally incorrect - if we still accept Lenin's method - to lump together these iwn separate and distinct communities as one nation. Quite apart from cultural, caste, and class differences between these two groups, they live in different geographical areas and have different 'national" aspirations. For Jensen "nation" is an ahistorical concept: he speaks of "wo nations" unified by the British, thereby using the term "nation' in- terchangeably with the term "kingdom" (Ironi- cally, immediately prior to the British conquest, the so-called Sinhala Kingdom in Kandy was ruled by Tamil kings and its official language wax Tamil.)
In our opinion, the development of the Tamil nation in Sri Lanka is a post-imperialist and post-capitalist phenomenon, with its roots in the inability of the post-independence sin Lankan ruling class to fulfill basic tasks of the democratic revolution. It is theoretically and politically incorrect to refer to pre-capitalist political formations as "nations'. Jensen falls into this trap
The development of a Tamil "nation" was by no means a foregone conclusion. In fact there
was a far greater degree of class solidarity
across Sri Lanka as a whole - both in the ruling
class as well as in the working class - than on a linguistic or ethnic basis, in the first decade after
o again:
1965 UNP government
independence. The Sinhala and Tamil bour- geoisie ganged up against the Tamil plantation workers in 1948 precisely because these workers had voted for marxist and working
class representativex to parliament that ycar. If • were not ir the Ceylon Tamil repre- sentatives, the first government of Sri Lanka: would have been a coalition of working class and elinic minority representatives led hy the Trotskyist LSSP (literally translated, the 'Equal Society Party').
Tamil resistance
Jensen's potted history of Tamil resistance
leaves nut one very important feature of nimost all Tamil political formations including the LTTE. That is their consistent subordination of
the interests of the Tamil people to bourgeois and/ot imperialist interests.
Jensen states that in 1976 the Tamil United
«depen maici.
• 1970 the Tamu Umted
Liberation Front (TULF) called forthe "restora-
Lion and reconstitution of the free, sovereign.
secular, socialist (1) state of Tamil Eclam' and
that "the 1977 general election gave a majority
in Parliament to the right-wing United Nation-
al Party, with the TULF as the leading opposi-
tion party." What has been omitted here is that despite their chetoric, the TULF was an oppor- tunist bourgeois formation and that in 1977 the TULF made a socret pact with the UNP. In
retum for certain concessions and possible af-
heratie
in Pie.
Page 21
mauseras inhe the TULF denvered a killed by the LTTE. (A further 260 or so WeR
LTTE members who took cyanide pills when substantial portion of the Tamil vote outside the north and east in the INP Tensen article aler captured by the army, and the remainder were
militants killed by their own organisations.) fails to mention the fact that many of the lead-
Organisations such as the Belam People's ing cadres of the LTTE itself were the strong
Liberation Front (EPRLE), which aims to com- em then of the TULP
bat caste oppression and has set up grassroots
When UNP repression compelled Tamil
committees of the masses, have been the chief youths to take up arms, the leaderships of most
targets for LTTE liquidation campaigns. Like armed groups switched their allegiance from
the Sri Lankan government, which set up spe- the Sri Lank an bourgeoisie to other ruling clas
cial detention camps (the most notorious being sex - including the Indian bourgeoisie. These
at Boosa, near Galle), the LTTE also set up their
own version of Boosa. After a bomb wasthrown
al Kittu, an LTTE militant, all these detainees
were summarily executed.
And in January of this year, Annamalai, the
Jalina leader of the Trotskyist NSSP, was shot
and killed by LTTE forces.
In the Tamil community itself - both nation-
ally and internationally - the LTTE draws its
support largely from the upperlayers of society.
Internationally their main financial support has
comc from the late Chief Minister of Tamil
Nadu - M.G. Ramachandran and the American
Tamil Association. Many Tamil socialists are
suspicious of the amount of American Tami.
money going to the LTTE. One of LT TE x most
vociferous supporters (at present campaigning
for them in Britain) is N. Satyendra, the former
Chair of Union Carbide in Sni Lanka. He was a
vicious anti-working class record co-operating
with the Sri Lankan government an 1978 to
smash a number of workers' struggles. He is
one amongst many in the LTTE pack. The
LTTE claim to be advancing the class struggle,
even in the north and cast, is, to say the least,
absurd.
Relations with the Indian
ruling class
1 10 Ae)
other rume clae-
leaderships consciously and deliberately prevented the development of solidarity he-
wudarity he
tween Tamil masses in the north and east and Espens Tamu the oppressed Sinhala workers and peasants, or the super-exploited Tamil plantation workers. They would seck the assistance of plantation youth only as foot soldiers in their "Belani" suicide squads.
Prettifying the LTTE
Marx often said that if appearance and reality were the same there would he no need for science. We need to look further, beyond the rhetoric and behind the superticial appearance of LTTE's class character (where Jensen seems to stop), to the reality of their politics.
The LTTE (with, to a lesser extent, the stu- dent organisation EROS), more than any other Belam group, have treated not just the Sai Lankan ruling classes and the Sinhala dominated army, but also ordinary Sinhala workers and peasants, as their enemies. They have carried out innumerable attacks - mas- sacres - of Sinhala civilians. Small children too. have died at their hands. Just like the Sinhala soldiers who indiscriminately attacked Tamil villagers, LTTE cadres have repeatedly attack- ad Sinnala civilians. Before the arryval of the los dian peace keeping force in 1987, this policy of the LTTE strengthened the hand of the govern- ment and Sinhala chauvinists, It also substan- tially weakened the efforts of progressive for- ces in the Sinhala south that supported the right of self-determination of the Tamil nation and
opposed the militarist and chauvinist policies of
the govemment.
Whilst every subjugated nation has a right to determine the tactics and strategy it should adopt in the struggle to free itself, those within that nation must adopt strategies to unify
workers and all the oppressed forces against the
ruling class. Socialists have an additional responsibility: to assist workers to develop a
socialist consciousness, It is not enough mere- ly to tail-end bourgeois and petty-bourgeois
currents in the nationalist movement. Through their programme and their actions, socialists
must consistently seek to break the bourgeois
and petty-bourgeois stranglehold.
This the LTTE will not do. It is the most
right-wing of all the Felam groups. Instead of
promoting political debate and dialogue with
other Tamil liberation groups it has attempted
to anniliate them - particularly those who raise
the awkward issues of caste, class and women's
oppression Since it is hacked by powerful
bourgeois interests, it undoubtedly has the fire.
poser to outgun its democratic and left-wing
opponents. Between 1983 and 1987, an es-
timated 3,000 Eelam militants have died. 1,500
were killed by the Sri Lankan army or police.
Another 1,000 were militants of other groups
murgeore These
and delorratelv
The Indians, as Jensen correctly states, cer- tainly trained and armed the L'TTE better than other groups. In particular the Indians made sure that left wing groups such as the EPRLF were not well armed.
The Indians had constant consultations with LTTE leaders. They were the only group con- sulted by the Indian govemment immediately before signing the Indian-Sri Lankan accord To all the others it was presented as a fait ac- compli.
The LTTE did not always oppose the peace accord. Initially they accepted it and tried to put pressure on the Indian government to impic ment it in a manner that would allow the LTTE to dominate the Provincial Councils. In fact to date, the LTTE hasnot called for the withdrawal of the Indian peace keeping force from Sri Lanka.
The Revolutionary Marxist Party of Sri Lanku accurately characterised the accord as horse-trading between the Indian and Sri Lankan bourgenixies, over the heads of the Tamil and Sri Lankan masses. The LTTE iv a part of this robber gang and is in no way a revolutionary force. Its quarrel with the Indians is not about transferring social and economic power to the masses. For their part, the Indians want to ensure that the US and other westem in- terests do not establish military bases in Sri Lanka
Jensen scems to have ignored the fact that the
Page 22
LTTE itself wants to do a diplomatic deal with the Indians. And the Indians do not want to eliminate the LTTE at the risk of weakening their hargaining power with the Sinhala bour-
geoisie: so they are smugly uxing all the politi-
cal groups to achieve their ends. To this extent
Jensen is right - the Indians want to "lame" the Tigers - but not eliminate them. Contrary to LTTE propaganda, the Indian peace keeping
force has succeeded in limiting the effective- ness of the LTTE, largely because many people
in the north and cast have become war weary.
The LTTE'S blind alley
The LTTE policy of alienating all other sec. tions of the oppressed manses in Sri Lanka has driven them more and more into the arms of the Indian and other bourgooisies. They have fought tooth and nail against any form of democratic grassroots organisation of the mas ses, apposed moves to challenge class and caste oppression, and sought to maintain their grip by sheer armed might and the physical elimination of all other political currents. They have alienated not only Sinhala toilers and plantation workers, but also a substantial section of the Tamil masses loo. In the recent Provincial Council clections a majority of Tamils in the eastern province defied LTTE threats and their
call to boycott the elections. The LTTE are not "the leading political and military force' in the fight for Tamil Belam, as Jensen claims.
The Leninst thesis
Often petty bourgoois nationalists will bran- dish Lenin's thesis on the national question but empharise one aspect of his thesis and happily abandon another. They draw our attention to Lenin's insistence that socialists should recog nise the right of oppressed nations to decide their own destiny; the right of self determina tion, including the right to secede from the op pressor nation.
However, in the very same thesis, Lenin also emphasised that on no condition should workers" organisations be divided on national or ethnic lines. Furthermore the whole thrust of Lenin's orientation was to assist workers of the oppressed nation, whose socialist conscious- ness had been blocked by national oppression.
By intervening in the struggle for full democracy, socialists enable these workersto overcome this obstacle and create conditions for a unificd struggle to overthrow capitalist rule. This involves a dual fight - against chauvinist consciousness of the workers and toilers in the oppressor nation, and for a class programme and against bourgeois and petty- bourgeois currents within the oppressed nation. Socialists must implement this approach in its totality and struggle against petty-bourgeois
charlatans seeking to steal some of their clothes to serve their own class needs.
The LTTE, like many other petty-bourgeois nationalists, have been quick to adopt those axpects of Lenin's thesis on the national ques tion that suit their class interests, whilst discard- ing and suppressing those that don't. Viewed from this standpoint it looks like the Tigers have taken Jensen for a ride.
M. Manickam and Lal Siha
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 12 February 1989
lullo Etchart/Reflex