Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

El Salvador: the end is in sight

· Socialist Outlook no. 12, February 1989 · pp 21-22 · 2,206 words

Latin America Trade unions

Salvador. In the view of the FMLN armed liberation front, after nine years of civil war, 'the end is at last in sight?. This view is an optimistic one, but not un- realistic. The FMLN paint three scenarios for 1989: a negotiated political settlement to the war, a popular insurrection, or an es- calation of the war.

So what has changed in El Sal- vador? How can you tell when a vol- cano is about to erupt? It is important to understand the degrce of social in- justice, poverty and oppression that are the roots of the present civil war. The human rights abuses, the total ab- sence of national sovereignty and the large scale cconomic crisis then follow from the government's insistence. on continuing the war.

The FMLN has been referred to by US observers as having the largest guerrilla army ever in Latin America. They are vastly more powerful than the Nicaraguan or Cuban insurgents on the eve of their revolutions. However they have to be. They are fighting an army that has been rebuilt from top to bottom with massive train ing and aid from the LIS. At $2 million a day, US aid is equivalent to 105% of the Salvadoran budget. El Salvador has reached the record dependence of South Vietnam during the height of the Vietnam war.

The Salvadoran army simply can- not handle any more hardware or aid. They cannot expand the numher of combatants as much as they wish even by pulling youth out of cinema queues. Their methods of forced recruitment produce an unreliable, discontented and demoralised army. The FMIN will rely on a level of disintegration and defection from the armed forces to carry through an insurrection.

Even against this highly trained army, the FMLN constantly takes the initiative. Their list of military actions is impressive. They can take almost any lown temporarily and make regular attacks on fortified army bar- racks including recently in San Sal-

can they defeat

the armed forces and a possible US intervention on a purely military level. If the Salvadoran wi people choose to rise up against a US puppet state they have an extremely capable army to lead them.

The mass movement has grown sig- nificantly over the last three years. Militant trade unions have been built through strikes and demonstrations. These unions formed the National Unity of Salvadoran Workers (UNTS) which has further sparked the development of other mass organisa- tions. The UNTS has become some- thing more than a trade union or- ganisation, and includes peasants, the universities, human rights groups. women's and youth groups.

The UNTS takes a different ap proach from the trade union move ment in the late 1970's. People are facing varies problems that have a common link, falling living standards, fewer jobs, rising prices, higher taxes and a reduction in welfare, health and education provision. All of these can be indentified with the government's special economic package which demanded austerity as a military re- quirement to fight the FMLN.

Salvadorans are being asked to make these sacrifices fora warthey do not suppon. They want peace, and they have been won to the demands of the FMILN and the 'political" wing, the Revolutionary Democratic Front (FDR), the UNTS and the catholic church for a negotiated political settle- ment to the conflict. Human and civil right are massively abused with government complicity. The people are becoming increasingly aware that the war is being carried out under in structions from Washington, as well as

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 12 February 1989

kers launch UNTS noting the high levels of US inter- ference at other levels, notably within the trade union movement itself.

The UNTS has brought together the issues of national sovereignty. human and civil rights, living stand- ards and peace. There are all issues connected 10 the war an Washington, so the solution is a na- tional political one. The UNTS works to pose a common solution and way of fighting. Unity, self organisation, col- lective resources for the use of all, na- tional sovereignty and democracy.

Top of the list is a negotiated politi- cal settlement to the war. By this they do not mean a deal negotiated be- tween the EMLN/FDR and the government, but a national debate and agreement which involves all the mass organisations. This process has already begun as the Catholic church. the universities and the UNTS have met in forums and conferences to put forward their analysis of the country and potential solutions for discussion.

This creates a very powerful situs- tion. These forums are not soviets, or forms of dual power, for they have no power. However these forms of mass organisation have enormous poten- tial, for they exist in the midst of a revolutionary civil war, despite every attempt by the govemment and US to demobilise them.

The anti-insurgency programme of the US has failed most clearly in its at- tempt to produce a stable and respect- able government. The Christian Democratic party, the PDC has failed in its mission. Its leader President Napoleon Duarte is dying of political

"Militant

trade

unions

have been

built

through strikes and

demos"

Page 19

Nicaragua Solidarity Campaign, 23 Bevenden Street, London N1 6BH Affiliations: €12.50, €5 unwaged.

ELSSOC, 20 Compton Terrace, London N1 Affiliations:

E6 individuals, £2.50 students /unwaged, £10 trade unions, LP wards, €20 CLPs. trades councils.

Page 20

U P PL E E N

cancer as well as of the meal thing. The party has been exposed as corrupt and has broken down into factions squab- bling about who is to take over from Duarte. Their base has gone over either to UNTS or to the far right ARENA party, breeding ground of the death squads.

The ruling class does not know how to deal with the economic, political and military crisis. A growing faction within the ARENA party is in favour of the total war solution. They figure that killing 50-100,000 peopie in one go would stop the mass movement and revolutionary potential in its tracks. At present the death squads have been told to keep the death toll to tens rather than hundreds per month. The figures for 1987 were a dozen dead bodies dumped per month, increasing four- fold for 1988.

With the collapse of the political centre, the US has had to improve rela- tions with ARENA, and with its new leader Christiani who has replaced the notarious d'Aubisson. It is trying to paint ARENA as a reasonable party committed to human rights. But this does not remove the reality of the polarisation taking place.

The state seems incapable of meet- ing the demand for a negotiated set- tlement. Meanwhile it is propped up

hu massive financial subsidies from the US. While much of this goes in

corruption, it is much harder for the 11S tr maintain this aid (second in size only to that give to Israel) if the government is too openly fascist.

In this context the presidential elec

tions in March are quite important.

They will be tradulent and only a

minority will participate, but they

might be decisive in deciding the balance of forces within the bour-

geoisic and influencing their sub-

sequent strategy. ARENA are likely to

win, although probably not with an

nutright majority, so it might have to

go to a second round.

It is very interesting that the FDR

have decided to participate and stand

candidates as part of the newly estab

lished Democratic Convergence

(CDi. Thus has resulted in an open but

apparently friendly split between the

two revolutionary fronts FMLN and

FDR. The FMLN will not call for a

vote for CD, but for abstention. Both

fronts stress the tactical nature of the

disagreement because they agree that

the clections are fradulent and that

power cannot come form winning

votes through them.

Guillermo Ungo of the Socialist in-

terational affiliated MNR is standing

for president, and Reni Roldan of the

Social Democratic party, which is not

part of the FDR, is standing for vice-

president.

CD say they are not competing for votes, but in order to put forward their politics, in particular a negotiated political settlement to the conflict. If they hold a balance of votes between the two parties, they will not recom mend that their supporters votes for either of the other parties.

The international context is critical. The most difficult issue is that a popular insurrection and military vic- tory by the FMIN would undoubted- ly be met by an invasion of US troops. The FMLN/FDR is very aware of this and ix preparing the ground to make it as difficult as possible for any US in tervention.

The US policy is to contain the situation, given that its plans to defeat the FMLN and set up a pliant democracy have miserably failed. There is no reason to believe that the Bush administration will differ from Reagan's. The US is particularly cager to get the international trade union movement to aid it in its attempts to set up parallel unions in El Salvador in order to undermine the mass moment. The CIA continues this work with

British trade unions, but the TUC it-

self has taken a stand in favour of

promoting the UNTS, which is a boost

for the Salvadoran labour movement.

Latin American govemments take

the Salvadoran revolutionary situation

seriously and are probably more aware

than the US government of the effect

of a US invasion on the whole sub-

continent. Arguably they would prefer

a lame revolution to a violent counter-

revnlution imposed by the US. This is

also the view of the Socialist Interna-

tional.

Guillermo Ungo of the FDR is also the vice president of the Socialist In-

ternational and was invited to speak to

the European parliament in Novem-

ber, a sure sign of the differences that

the European capitalists have with the

US counter-insurgency approach.

What are the essential fcatures of

the Salvadoran revolution? Firstly the

size of the US intervention prior to an

insurrection means that the

revolutionaries face a task far more

difficult both militarily and politically

than that faced by Nicaragua or Cuha.

Given this the revolutionaries have

achieved a great deal, something not

to be underestimated.

The project of the revolutinnaries

has been to win hegemony. They have

gone a long way towards this with

their demand for a negotiated political

solution: A large social political

novement has developed which is

much broader than the FMIN fighters.

If the movement continues to grow

and the government refuses to recog-

nise it, repressing it instead, the condi-

tions will be set for an insurrection.

one of the FMEN's scenanos.

But what would a negotiated politi

cal solution mean? Could it be a Lan-

caster House type solution? Quite pos

sibly, hut the best way to look at is is

as a framework for a political battie

thai could go various ways, not as a

solution in itself. However, this is not

how it is presented by the FMIN.

It is a strategy that is undoubtedly working in the revolutionaries' favour, whatever the risks involved with it are. Most importantly it is a policy that allows or anticipates mass participation in the proces of decid ing the future of the country, in a way far more advanced than any bourgcois election process.

The problem is that it is posed as a solution within itself. It is difficult to see from here if peuple are being misled into believing that peace could be achieved through compromises on both sides. Altematively the unfold- ing of the struggle will teach people the need to replace the entire state structures, and replace them with a new one hased on new valnes and a different social and economic order.

Trotsky put forward an idea in his writings on Britsin, that the people will try everything clse hefore revolu- tion. This could be a giant practical lesson that the bourgeois state cannot in any of its various forms meet the

tomands the peopie. Thic choice facing the people would then be the FMIN slogan "revolution or death".

In Britain our starting point must be

solidarity: support for the tight of the

Salvadoran people to self-determina-

tion, support for the trade unions and the mass movements in their just

struggles. The way to do this is through the El Salvador Solidarity

Campaign (ELSSOC).

Get your trade union, trades conn-

cil, Labour Party or whatever to af-

filiate locally, regionally and national-

Iv in ELSSUL. If you cannot do it

yourself, get someone you know to

take a regular active role in solidarity

work through their local branch of the

campaign. The starting point is allia-

tion and donations.

ELSSOC is vastly under resourced

because people have lost interest over the eight years of the civil war. Now. when El Salvador is nearer popular in- surrection than any other country in the world, the campaign will he un-

able to meet the new demands being put on it unless the left gives it more

suppon. The rewards are not only

giving concrete support but being in

the best position to lear from the un-

folding revolutionary process and its

strength and weaknesses.

Gareth Mostyn

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 12 February 1989

← A Very Guatemalan Coup · Riding a Tiger into a blind alley →

Something wrong on this page?