Is Thatcherism' a completely new political phenomenon, or just a handy smokescreen to mask the capitulation of sections of the Labour, trade union and Communist Party leaderships? Or is the truth somewhere between the two?
In the last issue of Socialist Outlook Phil Hearse in a controversial article suggested Thatcherism
represented a decisive move towards a 'strong state', and embodied elements of 'semi-bonapartism'.
Here, JOHN LISTER, opposing the notion of 'semi-bonapartism', widens the debate by looking in
more depth at the origins of Thatcherism and its dependence upon the weakness of leadership in the labour movement.
Future articles continuing this debate will also include a political assessment of the 'Charter 88' campaign around democratic rights.
'Charter 88'
THATCHERISM has in the past few years become the measuring stick for political ideology and metbod not only in western Europe, Australia and New Zealand but also - especially since Thatcher's Polish visit - in the Stalinist states as well.
Recent articles in two important Soviet publications show that
of the Iron Lauy - sc. Pravda Was compart- the economv: 3o world trade, arraner at* positively eulogistic.
The British no Lev Makarevich.ap out of its depr petent nureaucrats.
Both waiter
perestroika-«fu* next election ar Makarevice ship was no
Sover publications show that run a owing appreciation of the politics
• Finuncial Times, While an artice un
stressing ner success in turning around
t. and stabiling the British share of
alisucheskava Industreva was
writi..
2e. R
desperation to Thatcher. wniles Mr in- years she had "lifted the country
ane industries and sacked incom-
a growth «* share ownershup and
regard the Thatcher refors as a unified * agren that Labour is unlikely to win the -amninous of the trade unions, of which
•* them proved easy, since the leader-
aid tear of the scientific technical
iw1k n^ *.2 Februar 1989
revolution
This approach is not only illuminating for our understanding of the politics of today's Soviet bureaucracy and the implications of perestroika. but also a reminder that the Thatcherite package of policies has been de- pendent for its implementation upon a certain relationship of class forces that has been established since 1979.
In this sense it is useful to look again at the question of de frition of the Thatcher government and its ever-increasing powers.
In the December-January issue of Socialist Outlook, Phil Hearse stressed the sinister strengthening of the state machinery and its use by the Thatcher government, as well as her dominant personal role in the cabinet, and warned of the possibility that the govemment is becoming a "semi bonapartist combination herween parliamentary democracy and forms of dictatorship.
In posing the question this starkly, Phil' sarticle has unleashed a num- ber of heated responsex (see Letters page). Many feel that the heavy qualifications needed in using the term "semi- bonapartist" to characterise Thatcherism are so far-reaching as to question the value of the label. In. deed the questions arising from it flow thick and fast:
• Would a 'semi-bonapartist" regime, in the sense that Trotsky talked of bonapartist dictatorships in the 1930s, really remain subject to regular cloctions in which it could be simply voted out of office?
• Has the Tory Party been refashioned behind the scenes into the power-base of a new dictatorial regime?
«ur understanding of the - de unplications of perestroika i package of policies has been de- (certain relationship of class forces
samn a the question on detaution or
asing powers
alist Outtook. Inu Hearse
the state macrunery and its use by
i domunus personat role in the
Mowery that the covemment is becoming a wnati(n.hetwee sarhamentary democracy and
Page 23
DEP
rue mat ine ..
ass forces the Britie neasures in on
• Are That net - me and heathtaking those prevalu Germany, he LISA.
Ther are or honapartism. sy im
exaggerating ti
Betor
Thatcherism, we must be-...
the old terms and exi. anations.
toncal understanar. • now
eyes of a handfu.
of me more bru...
working cians n
Insofar as Thar
personified by
authority of Thatcher
ing her cabinet in the uw
grip on the state machi"**
guard rote by the par.
powers already open men
ly since Kinnack's takeover
most total collapse of Labour:
Socialist Outlook has pres
Kinnock and Co jettisoned the word "nicialism" from Labour's vocabulary.
A second prblem with the insistence upon the term semi- bonapatism" is that
Thatcherism it can - in the manner of d
Marxism Today's fixation with and capimlation to the apparent strength of Thatcherism - npen the door to defeatist
Police powers have increased: but key is political
One such solution that hax bea raised
paralysis of labour movement - though not by anyone writing in
Socialist Outlook - could be the search for desperate laxt-gasp
"democratic alliances" on the model of the Stalinists" ill fated 1930s
Popular Fronte', aiming to appeal to "Jemocratic", anti-authoritarian ele
ments of the middie class and bourgeoisic, precisely those elements who
have done so limle to fight any aspect of Thatcher's policies up to now.
This would he particulady pernicious if (unlike Phil Hearse's
proposals, but as with Marxism Today and its fellow travellers in the
labour movemeat) such alliances are seen as a substitute for working class
politicalaction, or as a step towards calitionist anti-Thatcher" clectoral
mary strength of the working nisic to contemplate such extraordinary
class rule
ani-democratic measure: sweep m. they ne - Queuitativeiy more dracoan than
ad houroenis democratic countries (West
There are other problems with the use of the term
bonapartism". By implicitly (through the analogy with actual dictator-
ships) exaggerating the extent to which Thatcher' sauthoritarian approach
rests upon extra-parliamentary support, it runs the serious risk of foster-
ing illusions that a 'real" bourgeois parliamentary government could not
act in the increasingly savage fashion we have seen since 1979. Yet in fact Thatcher is simply taking advantage of the British parliamentary sys- ten, which has always boen wide open to the ahitrary abuse of a large
majority by a right wing party - provided only that it is able to maintain majority by a nght wag sant sufficient discipline over its MP's.
ship: rests nnon r ine illnes
et in 1l
majority by a right wing party - provided only that it is able to maintain
- MPs.
The same options have never been open to a majority goverment of the left.
since the full use of these parliamentary powers depends upon the connivance of both the media and the establishment - the judiciary, police, military. Lords, monar-
chy and the like - which would certainly
intervene to disrupt any progressive
measures from the very outsel. This is of
measures IT" nurse why
• No.
MIC ENLY *
course why the notion of a 'parliamentary mad to socialism", whether in the Mar- xism Today or Militant ("Enahling Act") verinn. was a pipedream long before Neil
1aIc" "solutions".
- if sho
e done so une to mut ay astery This would he particulary pem
roposals, but as win 1- abour movement such u.. politicara..on. fronts.
Ware on, a diec .. Hearse unal - rary democ"
an ne
sugh campaigns involving the to which this can be scen as a
• the middle ~ alvet in fighties.
. mulld wagree with Phi
-ust be defended against Torv attack
i widest possible united fronts, the ex-
•nt-Line response to Thatchensm is
ux ule extent in which more than a handful zone wet Toric», are prepared to hecome in- emment ‹except perhaps on rare, emotive 1s
evagn. for instance, of substantial layen
setting angry over the immigration law..
she- anti-democratic Housing. Act
ur chaneel to force even more
1r tute per meag..
whatever succeer we have in doir major struggles remain the role
council houses into private hands.
win* * throw the rampaigning net. and
.. on, the decisive tactor in each of these
and the mass organisations of the work
.. at readerahip is absolutely central. Indeed. *warneskaya Inaustriya point out, but many oh? is mar Thatcher's successes to date can only be
untam of analysing the unresolved and ap
confronted the workers' movement in
what Pirene British analy:*. .nrg properiv unarrstood .. ae palling cosıs of leg archp that nac ihe 1980kc
Page 24
Before resorting to new definitions and labels to characterise. Thatcherism, we must be certain that the present situation has outgrown the old terms and explanations. Yet there seems no reason to alter our his
torical understanding of how Thatcherism developed from a glint in the
cin
char tense
won has or 2rown
in aitar nuit his su trọm a gies in the Dar-mom daydicams
eyes of a handful of right wing ideologuce and the bar-room daydreams of the more brutal employers into the present rampant offensive against
working class rights and living standards.
authority of Thatcher herself, ruthlessly selecting, purging and remodel!-
ing her cabinet in her own image - it derives not from a new dictatorial
sly new nolllica lorce
isive perengality and
w..pureing and remodell-
tor from a new dictatonial
IS:ous adontion of a van-
as energeticallo using tim
-ngth af nurpose has
... been mintorced by.the al- anu -on opposuon. riodsey sed un gormer Tory chair
Norman Tebbit's definition of the role of political leadership - moving from
analysis to define necessary tasks, and then through determined action to imple- ment the policy decided and if possile convince the electorate (or in any case change the status guo). We have pointed
out that Tehhit's approacli- here echoing
Thatcher herself - is much closer to the
"Leninist' notion of the vanguard role of
the party than that of the current Labour
the
timid ask the MORI pollsters" view of
how policies should he tailored to avoid
offending the existing prejudices of the electorate - ensuring no commitment to
Troll's methos ~ the Tabour teader
211511 dup 10 a.
radical change.
Thatcher and the strongest elements of her team grasped the role of generals
leading the counter-attack of British capi-
tal against a workers movement which
despite-or partially because of - the con-
cessions and reforms it had won since the
war, was saddled with a hureaucralised.
passive, complacent trade union and political leadership. Even the more
militant shop stewards movement and rank and file forces lacked any
developed class conscious socialist cadership capable of withstanding a
full- scale onslaught from the employers. The traditional power-base of
the shop stewards movement, in manufacturing industry, had altendy
come under attack during the Labour goverment, and was the linst 1o.
suffer the squeeze of recession under the Tones.
The Thatcher years have been marked hy a relentless drive to exploit
every opportunity opened up for the bosses by this lendership criss
Leaming the lessons from Edward Heath's half hearted cfforts at anti-
union laws and his inclegant retreats, culminating in the electoral defcat
of February 1974, and utilising the new police anti-picket squads set up
by the Labour goverment to smash strikes at Grunwick and other firms
in the late 1970s, Thatcher resolved to prepare the ground more thorough-
ly for cach confrontation. The Tory strategy relied upon the salami
tactics" of picking off one section at a time - and took for granted the
refusal of TUC and Labour leaders to fight for unted mass action.
Thatcher was allowed to pick the best time to provoke cach fight, and
then able to utilise the full forces of the state to hold the line, as unions
It was therefore no accident that the Thatcherite prioritien were - in order - monetarist policies to squeeze inflation through mass memploy
weakened by the recession; and wave after wave of privatisation to
merals
Passis «impiacer. militant shon stewar** eveloped class con full-scale onstag.. ...
-Ollue under attack me suffer the squeeze
The Thatcher yew>.. every opportunity openca Leamine the lexiras fon. union tux and nes.- ot Febnim. _974. -
in the ema. ly for car tactic refusar of Tx Thatner was *
come under attack during the Labour goverment, and was the linst 1o.
The Thatcher years have been marked hy a relentless drive to exploit
sor Ihe: bosse
award Hein.
retreats, cul...
il utilising the new poli ament to smash strikes: tcher resolved to predan
M SUN Hat
were confronted one hy one
It w. order- monrust pur mere. anti-union lav weakened by " race! liberate reccurone..of to inversible hiow again.
Through mone" press-gunged into up almost act.. during the per stewards aise
JaCk wave. of
oritics wett
nass wemploy
wuous almady
nivatisation io :her expectsio be an
liberate resources for tax cuts and effect what Thatcher expects to be an
Through monetarist discipline in the first phase, employers were
press-ganged into imposing massive closures, redundancies and specu-
up almost across the board in manufacturing industry. As had heen seen
during the period of Labour government, trade union leaders and stop
stewards accustomel to negotiating on wages and conditions in times of
impr
trane
stewards accustomel to negotiating on wages and conditions in times of
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 12 February 1989
relative expansion, had never questioned the
"right of the employerto a profit, and there-
INALES
SACED
-FAT WAPPINE
WAPPING -
¡ELATED NUS STOP HAPPY NEW
DIPY MURDOC
YEAR
ON THE
DOLE
Wapping dispute: landmark in Tory anti-union
fore to make firms "viable" in capitalist terms at a price of massive redundancies and closures. This inability to challenge the logic of capitalism (transformed into an argument that only through collaboration with employers at every level to prevent strikes could jobs be saved) has hocome the bedrock of today's politics of 'new realism' that dominate hoth TUC and Labour Party.
The xame period brought the relaxation
The xame period brought the relaxation
The drive to privatise the major state in
dustries - shortly to reach a new peak with
the sale of vast electricity and water industry
assets - began in part from the monetarist
squeeze on "ines-making" dustries (nicel, shipbuilding. .... Britis ,...
ways, BL cars). It also stemmed from the lust
to Liberate vast profits generated in natural
monopolies such as British Telecom and
British Gas; and it later developed through
mass share issues as a sophisticated bribe to more prosperous soctions of the middle class
ansvatise the n le da foo
of exchange controls, which enabled the big
employers and the finance soctor to maxi-
mise their profits despite the recession by channelling vast sums of North Sea oil
revenues into investment portfolios over-
and employed working class.
Though she has been egged on at each
stage to go further by visionary prophets of
the ultra-right, it is still not proven that
Thatcher has all along simply been carrying
through sages of a pre-formulated overall
strategy. One of her former policy advisors,
Patrick Minford, in a rocent essay brands the
early exercises in council house privatisation
as "initially a sideshow" (in Thatcherism, ed
Mobilising the short-
lemm self-interest of existing enants to break
up the public sector in housing proved suc
cessful in many ways: it won extra Tory
voles, it undermined another area of local
government; and it boosted the long term
profits and prospects of estate agents, private
developers, huilders and landlords.
Minford then describes the subsequent
moves towards mass share issues in the
privatisation of the big nationalised in-
pectedly popular success of the housing "sale of the century". Of course the goal of privatisation could as easily have been carried out by selling shuex primarily to big city institutions. An it is, the whole myth of
HAMMOND'S
HYENAS
PUT 6,000
Despite the political weaknesses of the labour movement, this first phase could only
link up the early struggles whice yuckly Cognoni/Report
have succeeded under conditions where the trade union leaders refused to strengthen and
broke out against a still new and incs-
Toke no perienced Thatcher government. TUC leaders in February 1980 ganged up not to
support but to isolate the marathon 4-month g national steel strike (squashing calls for
general strike action and potential support
from miners and rail workers) and simul-
tancously sold out the BL carworkers, other
sections too were held back from struggle until after the steelworkers had been forced Wapping back to work with a hollow victory' on pay offensive and the certainty of plant closures to follow.
rainty
is to follow
motless clbow mom by
ned the annou
dustry, and quickly threw over 2 million additional workers onto the dole queues. This in tum halted the progress of unionisation in the private sec-
dine pro
- workerkonte the dole
on us the private se
tor, and also - alongside cut after cut in unemployment and social security benefits - began to open up what hus been a deliberate and ever- widen-
The lesson for today, however is that it need not have happened. In
ing gap between the employed and unemployed working class. 1980 it was not the 'bonapartist" use of dictatorial powers which kept
we fuse happened in
Thatcher in office so much as the timidity and treachery of the union
The Tories next tumed their attention to a frontal attack on the trade
unions themselves, in the form of two major Acts piloted through by Nor-
man Tebbit. Once again the TUC showed itself to be all mouth and
trousers: ax soon as the NGA print workers ran up against the new laws
and the courts in fighting Eddie Shah's Messenger Group in Warrington.
und the NGA faced threats of sequestration, the TUC collapsed and ahan-
doned its pledges to give industrial support.
traches of the thin
had Dece seyuestrated, months into their * a-munle ew the presence .... it wound defy espig the ner ust uld hardly ar Scarg. and the NUM wour be deteated. The
aid the No
Seanca s retreat ..
•y rubbeu in the fact
vultually avery nabsonal
..TYw: itself increas
ingly an irrelevance.
It is on this new balance of class forces- hacked up and budgeoned home hy new peaks of police thuggery on the picket lines during and since the miners" strike — that Thatcher's authority and authoritarianism rest
By their tacit suppon for the governent, or refusal to combat
Thatcher's offensive on the NUM, and their insistence upon drawing
sea un ana nurgeonca
a palt = consoli
ombat
au Henne drawing
ince 1980, the The
"g her political anp
and Torv Party. Even
m. euner monetanst ie goods in the for or
an more liave been red up by privatisation.
Tals leadere har
~mpioyers.w policies mav= AT Cuts alc mas 31 ma deliented by me cha
within important sections of the capitalist class and Tory Party. Even
employers who suffered squeezed profits from the earlier monetarist
policies have been placated since she delivered the goods in the form of
delighted by the short-lem profits bonanza opened up by privatisation.
1 pita
strategy. One of her former policy advisors,
taste
Robert Skideisky).
tered in mars
sere-
lemm self-interest of existing enants to break
government; and it boosted the long term
he suhnequent
ssues in th
the gon
dustries as a logical "follow-up' to the unex-
- Of coure
it by sellin-
se myth ot - where a fow more prosperous share owning
opens
manneu sutmula
2888475
* THE
workers labour under the deluxion that they, too, are capitalists -appents to have Inken shape empirically rather than to a pre planned formula. However the chicf long tem advantage for the Tores of dispersing mil- lions of shares to large numbers of individuals is that it makes the task of reversing these measures even more daunting for any suhsequent Labour
Throughout the Thatcher years there has been a consistent patlem of forcing through measures without undue regard for their short- team
popularity, in such a way as to pull up the ladder behind them, making it
almost impossible for a reformist Lahour govemment to relum to the old
Money freed by cuts in social socurity, the housing hudget
and other sectors of state spending has been immediately redistributed to
the wealthy and to the employed in tax cuts - forcing Labour to con
template tax increases to restore previous levels. Similarly Tory restric-
tions on local govemment, including ratecapping and soon the Poll Tax.
have reduced or restricted rates, or thrust the burden from rich to poor.
forcing ay Labour reform to contemplate major increases. Privatisation
of British Acrospace and the planned kale of the water authorities seem
certain to be followed by huge once-and-for-all asset-stripping land sales
- as has happened with desperate health suthorities selling property to
There are still many Tory projects to complete, not least the full ex- ploitation of the current halance of forces to drive still lower the basic rates of pay. The significance of the slave labour" youth opportunities,
"populur capitalism"
sha. malista
wex the task.. mcquent Labour
(or socialist) govemment.
maris quo. Mone, meu ... and other sectore of car the wealty and Icmpiate his incre tions on Itm. porn. have reduced or rer
and other sectors of state spending has been immediately redistributed to
made en
Tax wan
-in tions on local govemment, including ratecapping and soon the Poll Tax.
the forcing ay Labour reform to contemplate major increases. Privatisation
un Enlish Aer...
main to be tollowr
balance their books.
Hien are sur ploitation of the rates of pav. The youth tnunu.. en up bv new. prutal ing such scheme. n lowerune waze nere will orI..
icast the lull ex- shi lower the bass
outli opportunuties, -.-Iic= (now backed real unal youth refus-
everall abiective of ne Tones believe this
youth truning, employment training and "Restant" schemes (now backed up by new, brutal cuts in social socurity and the threat that youth refus- ing such schemes will be denied state benefit) is the overall objective of lowering wage expectations and actual pay levels. The Tories believe this
will bring in its train the destruction of what remains of trade union. or-
ganisation, beginning in the lower paid jobs: and in addition they are out
to dismantle virtually all of the protective legislation covering the condi-
tions of youth, women and the lowest-paid, some of which dates back to
the more enlightened liberalism of a few Victorian parliamentarians.
The Thatcherite drive towards decontrol and deregulation is also
having a contradictory effect on the media, where the proposed prolifera-
tion of television and radio channes runs counter to moralistic attempts
garsation, best. to dismantle VItuaTIv tions of vouth, wome.. the more enlichtened li
The 1 havins. ar lion or tel
• a133ter
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 12 February 1989
Page 25
uf flie: so-cane
newl with harre the head-banging Lord Chalfont installed on the IBA).
entanian moves to cen- = BBC anu IRA governing bodien wares nuncil under Lord Rees
xantcen the latest example beun:
-the IBA;
t the Thatener idea is oue un
surves are care-
* m the 'ISA. must people
nformation. Like broadcast
sod estrelite and other tv chan-
and that small quota would be
nd game shows - leaving the core
" polial information and ex- -nt evea tutber removed from ac
We should recognise here, however, that the Thatcher ideal is oue in
see rittle. se the put
AWarTO
•lite: no the-ams
petfise and mavul cess to mass forms of publicity.
Other Thatcherite irons in the fire include the sweeping 'reform' of
open them in tor privatisation along American Lines, and force home upon the working class a new reality in which, with the rapid erosion and eventual disappearance of the collective, social provisions of the welfare state, in Thatcher's famous phrase "there is no such thing as society, just individuals and families.
The common thread through all of these proposals is to break down the collective strength of the working class, break down collective institu- tions, and supplant in their stead individualism, self-interest, and divide- and-rule. For ever measure which strikes neavy blows and further alienates and antagonises the unemployed, the low-paid, the most ex- ploited sections of the working class, black communities, women and the more socially aware sections of the middle classes, Thatcher has - in the absence of any serious political or industrial opposition - heen able to counterpose a consolidation of her electoral base among the most prosperous layers, exploiting and pandering to their greed, their racism, national chauvinism, and anti-communism.
However the polls indicate that it is not so much the electoral appeal of Thatcher's policies as the lack of any credible opposition that has decisively strengthened the Tory hand
• the
"much the electoral appeal lack Of wiw.credibie.opposition that has
Despite appearances and the popular preoccupation with yuppy
more than a skin-deep impact on most voters, who are far from sharing the Prime Minister's views. Poll information suggests that on such ques
unconvinced by the Tory line. Indeed the new White Paper proposals on the NES seem to represent in tlus tespect one of the most risky projects
The sane situation applies in the industrial situation: though the
The sale xinloron apr employers by dint of brute force, appalling levels of class collahoration from many top union leaders, and the straitjacket of anti-union laws, have in some instances succeeded in raising levels of exploitation and produc tivity, this should not he read as workers accepting the employers' line. Time and again disputes erupt over pay or conditions as soon as workers feel they have an opportunity to fight back.
Much is made in Marxism Today and elsewhere of the changing face of the working class in the 1980s, and the supposed end of tractional trade unionism. Again this is largely an excuse for the failure of desig- ner left" forces to relate to the actual working class as it has developed In some areas it is clear that the traditional manufacturing industries have been all but wiped out: the old stewards" committees and union stron- gholds have also been hammered down - from the one side by manage- ment and from the other by their own bureaucratic union officials.
But the growth of the service sector - retail, catering and other jobs
ctail, caterine and other Jobs.
- does not mean that the working class has disappeared: simply that
ax disappeared: simply that workers who would otherwise have become manual workers in factories
manua workers in factones
have become unskilled, low paid workers in shops, warehouses, hotels
lave become unscilled. JOW pre
or burger bars - often under highly exploitative conditions. The Lusk for
onditions. The task for
the unions, as before, is to organise these workers and take up their fight the unions ac hefore for adequate pay, working conditions, health and xafety.
Yet despite the odd tokenistic and trendy glossy leaflet targetted at these often part-time staff, many of whom are women and black workers.
the absence of a wave of small and larger- scale disputes in the service the absence nf a wa sector suggests that the unions are not recruiting and not mobilising these layers. This should come as little surprise: the same union bureaucrats who have betrayed and ignored their previous strongest battalions of in-
pop ar preoccupation with yuppy •at Thaina rite politics have made much on most volers. who are far trom sharine
formation suggests that on such quen
she NHS and education, the Pall Tax
rers of morality such as abortion and
.. aeactorate has remained stubbornly
ans inn new White Paper proposals on
one of the most risky projects
POL.
.. horn
worKeL..
*.wan worken
dustrial workers are scarcely likely to become transformed now into model fighters for the downtrodden and oppressed. The bureaucracy has never shown much enthusiasm for recruiting workers whose subscrip tions are low, but who bring with them a host of problems and possible confrontations with management.
Once again we retum to the question of leadership as central to any venous explanat- Even with firm leadership, victories cannot be guaranteed: withoutit, under such adverse circumstances, defeats and set- backs are certain.
Under Thatcher's decisive leadership, the Tory Parry in government haseffocted far-reaching changes, reversing or preparing to reverse many of the progressive social refons carried through by successive govern- ments: but there is no sign that it has quelled the class struggle or won over substantial layers of the working class to Thatcherite politics.
Rather than resorting to unprocedented "bonapartist" measures to con- tain the working class, Thatcher has followed the more established path of previous authoritarian Tory govemments - such as that of Stanley Baldwin, which organised massive scabhing operations and defied the 1926 General Strike, and followed it up after the TUC capitulation with brutal anti-union laws and savage wage-cutting before the 1930s ushered in the new horrors of the means test.
Indeed "strong govemment" was also the style of Thatcher's hero Winston Churchill in the leadership of the wartime coalition, with its ruth- less repression of strikes and trade union nights: Churchill also led the post-war Tory apposition into the lobbies to oppose the National Health Service Bill, representing a continuity of that strand of Tory thought which always - long hefore Thatcher - rejected the welfare state.
It is instructive to rememher that even Churchill's largely uncontested
Tamin «argely uncontested personal prestige in 1945 was not xufficient to prevent the working class, among them returing soldiers, sweeping him out of office and deliver- ing a landslide victory to a radical Labour manifesto. Thatcherism has
sunk no deeper roots than Churchill's patriotic wartime bandwagon: it sunk no deeper roots that. could be defcated given the right combination of circumstances and a
-unstances au a determined Labour leadership.
A measure of the truly wretched political level of today's trade union
serip
und ser
a many
*crablisher nath
•at of Stanley merations and defied the In TUC sapitulation witt.
Te the 1930s ushcred
and Lahour leadership is that Baldwin's government had to organise a full-scale scabbing operation and confront a General Strike before it could establish a balance of forces favourable for its attacks on the working class: Churchill required not only the 'patriotic" fervour of the war period but the total complicity of the Labour, trade union and Communist party Icadershipsto impose his vicious anti union laws. Yet Thatcher has since 1979 been allowed to confront and inflict huge sethacks on a much larger and stronger trade union movemeat without undergoing the ordeal of a General Strike, or any sustained united fightback by the trade union movement whatever.
Indeed the defcatist politics of the union leaders have now also trans-
aces have now aiso trans- lated themscives, via "new realism" into the total collapse of the Labour Party as an effective opposition, despite all of the opportunities that there have been to combat the evils of the new "free market" economy
Though workers continue from time to time to rebel against particular Tory altacks, the full-scale political reireat that is taking place under the banner of Labour's 'policy review' threatens to change the political profile of the labour movement for years to come.
As one correspondent points out (Lellers page), if we have Kinnock, who needs bonapartism? It is indeed ironic that while most workers remain relatively impervious, the section of sociely most impressed and affected by Thatcherite propaganda and values should he the political leadership of the mass working class party that is supposed to lead the opposition.
Asa new year of struggle begins with inflation again on the increase, mortgage-payers under pressure, the economy unstahle and the gover- ment still on the offensive, it is important that discussion on the politics of Thatcherism is focussed on the element of the situation that we as class struggle can hope to do something about: the necessity for a new, socialist leadership fighting at every level for mass action by workers to defend democratic rights, the welfare state, jobs, housing and every other post- war gain that is now under attack.
This means fighting tooth and nail against further concessions t0 Thatcherism in Labour's policy review, but also spelling out a more coherent, socialist response to the economic and social crisis of the 1980s- 1990s. Instead of using "Thatcherism' as an excuse for defeatism, a sober recognition of the coniprehensive scope of the bosses' offensive must be a stimulus to develop the fighthack.
indi fan.
11201 d. are a
st today shade taon
went und to oreanuse s
i Strike hefore it could
on the working
- our of the war period .*.. nd tommunist pair
ews yet Thawder nas since "e enthackenn a much larper
fier ack ho the trade umon
-wave Kinnock, . that while mos workers sociely nunst imprescod and
Alth. no inc politicas in supposed to lead the
i met the increase
..d the govern-
Tox lodo
on the police alhat that we as class * for nnew, socialist
workers to defend
every other post-
This means fighting tooth and nail against further concessions t0
nee Concessions to
ing nue - more
Ines of the 1980s-
featism, a sober
tensive must bo
recognition of the coniprehensive scope of the bosses' offensive must be
this hose
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 12 February 1989