South African Townships', in a chapter where he examines the relative history and significance of music and ait as a focus of culrural and social life for black people in South Africa.
Music har always been a site of resistance. After many years during which hlack musicians were ignored and marginalised the mnsic industry discovered the profit-making potential of thesc same musicians and many have now achieved a degree of popular success. There has not been a similar breakthmugh for black visual artists. Galleries cater for an exclusively white chientele. A national art conference held in Stellenbosch in April 1988. aimed at
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 12 February 1989
irrelevant and unscceptable evidence, whereas bruises and scarx were seen as acceptable evidence of violence. Disbelief in the doctors" diagnosis was the basis of the reactionary campaign of the press, the police and the right-wing local Labour MP, Stuart Bell.
The book is strong when it discusses the evidence on child scxual abuse, the breakdown in relationships between police. rocial services and the modical protession, and discord between doctors and nurses as the crisix developed. It is also sensitive to the debate about child sex abuse and the fact that there are no easy solutions available, espocially when social workers seem to have more power to disturb working class lives than middle class lives.
But what I was looking for was a chapter that discussed socialist and radical feminist strategy or thinking on child scx abuse and violence against women in much more detail. How did socialists and feminists campaign in the nineteenth
century and carly twentieth century on these matters? How had the Domestic Violence Act
got on the statute books in 1976?
Shouldn 't feminists now be campaugning for a child scxual Violence act that calls for child referral centres and for socicty to
place the blame for child sex
crimes on the (uxually) male perpetrators? What implications
does this dehate have for an
analysis of power relations in the
The commentarist
conclusions are the weakest
point of the book Campbell
touches on the problem of the
silence of feminism in the Cleveland dehate only to apologise for it. "Activists felt lom by conflicting allegiances both to professionals and parents
she writes. The other flaw that rans through the book is that male scxuality is assumed to be responsible for child sexual abuse. This idea deserves discussion and duesn'l get it. What about the scxuality of men
who don't commit child sexual ahuse?
Than
POSLA
'Heart in the Oven /Avashoni Mainganye
freedom but the whites take it away that's why lam (sic) ANC". He was ordered to have the tattoos removed and was sentenced to an efffective 3 years imprisonment.
What also cones out through the book however is the persistence and resilience of black artists. Working with the materiais to hand means that many artists have developed a style based on the use of such diverse things as scrap metal and corrugated card. Derrick Nxumalo works in felt pen wiule Tito Zungu has a particulariy unique form of art. His first drawings, and in fact the greater volume of his work, was done in ink with a ball point pen on ordinary envelopes which he kold to his work mates for less than the price of a picture postcard; these envelopes were used to send letters back to wives and children in the countryside. Geometrical portrayals of trains, jets and city huildings, his pictures show ne sign of human life. His world has an alluring innocence, one which renders redundant all social or political issues. In a
curous but surpassingly human way lis glorification of city life found working-class support trom his friends and colicagues precisely because it provided a way of coping with life in the
ghetto. For white buyers bowever his delightfully zany creations serve to convince that life in the backyard ghettos can't be all that bad.
Based on meetings and discussions with many black artists and containing u large
numher of brilliant photographs taken by himself. Gavin Younge's book is fascinating and heautiful. It combines an insight into the work of 51 artists with a focus on the extraordinary Blowering of black South Alncan aft in the 1980s and an examination of the struggles which have shaped it. He
describes the efforts to establish a black arts educational
programme and looks at the ways in which the work of individual artists relates to native and foreign influcnces and the development of an ant of protest.
This is a book not to be missed!!
Page 29
Marxist History?
The Labour Party - A Marxist History Tony Cliff and Donny Gluckstein, Bookmarks, 1988. 67.95.
Reviewed by
JANE KELLY
BOURGEOIS history. pretending to be objective, is generally written from the point of view of the ruling class. A work of