Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Unofficial Secrets

· Socialist Outlook no. 12, February 1989 · p 31 · 507 words

Child Sex Abuse: The Cleveland Case Beatrix Campbell Virago Press, £3.95 Reviewed by VALERIE COULTAS

CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE is a secret and difficult crime to detect. As with otber sex crimes it relies on the willingness of the victim to

testify to prove a crime has been committed. When the perpetrator is a close male relative (as is usually the case), admitting abuse can involve enormous psychological and emotiona! difficulty for the victim.

Unofficial Secrets tackles some of these issues in the context of the Cleveland case

where in 1987 165 boys and giris were diagnosed by paccatricians at Middlesborough General Hospital as having suffered suspocted sexual abuse. Despite admitting that Drs Higgs and Wynne (the two paediatricians involved) were not conscious feminists, Beatrix Camphell comes down firmly en their side. Using medical evidence and the

conclusions of the Butler-Sloss enquiry in 1988 she argues that the anal dilation test the doctors uscd as a basis for their diagnosis was vindicated, despite the campaign of vilification against the doctors and their diagnoses waged by the 'popular press.

The police in Cleveland 'as a practorian guard of mascolinity were incapable, Camphell argucs, of dealing with the sexual side of child sexual abuse. Photographs taken by the doctors of the abused children's genitalia were dismissed as

Sharp!

addressing 'special problems. 'Art of the South African

had an organising committee Townships'

which did not include one black Gavin Younge,

person. It is not possibie to

examine the development of art Published by Thames

in black South Africa without and Hudson 1988 £6.95

looking at the syxtematic

attempts to degrade, isolate and

dehumanise black pcople. A

situation of second class

education, brutal state control

and lack of materials forms a

common starting point for the

work of artists of widely

differing styles. Much of the

cultural heritage of Africa was

long since borne away to adorn

the museums and drawing rooms

of colonial rulers. Younge

provides a detailed analysis of

these processes as a background

to the 134 photographs that form

the basis of this stunning book

In a country such as South

Africa, the very notion of black

art is political. The South

African govemment, hax used

the provisions of the Stale of

Emergency to enforce new and

broader delinitions of what

constitutes a 'subversive

stalement". Section One of the

Public Safety Act (1953) allows

the hanning of any picture.

photograph, print, engraving.

lithograph, painting or drawing.

The provisions of the act are so

wide that even the publication of

hlank spaces where material has

been edited out can be

considered subversive. In 1987

Benjamin de Bruyn, appeared in

court on charges relating to a

number of tattoos on his body.

one of which read God give ine

Reviewed by

TRACY DOYLE

'SHARP! is an exclamation of approval among South Africa's urban proletariat. American in origin, it is applied to anything which

puts one over on "whitey", or

which offers a purchase in the slippery world of getting ahead.

So states Editor Gavin Younge in his book "Art of the

← Can Stalinist parties make revolutions? · Art of South African Townships →

Something wrong on this page?