Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

The soft left's dilemma

· Socialist Outlook no. 11, December–January 1989 · p 14 · 866 words

UR E S

ex

available for soft left critics of Kinnock's Labour Cavendish/Reflex

BEN JONES measures up the political elbow-room

leadership, and finds barely enough space to swing a s cat.

try shadone cabinet and af

by shadow cabinet and

Labour NEC speakers, OTO:

and extensively trailed 9

in the press the week a

beforehand, it was Roy Hattersley: the choice is for him, or against

hilled as a major event

with up to 500 people expected.

This was when Peter Hain launched his up-

peal for a new soft left organisation, slamming

the Tribune group of MPs as Kinnock's

"payroll vote'. However, like Todd, Hain was

careful also to attack the hard left, accusing the

Campaign Group of offering little more than

'slogans" and 'aftacks on the leadership.

There is even a precedent for the kind of

realignment Hain was advocating: in Scotland,

parts of the Labour Coordinating Committee

(LCC) have broken away over the issue of non-

payment of poll tax to form Scottish Labour Ac-

tion.

However the Tribune conference proved a

In their different ways, the Ron Todd's speech at the Tribune rally in Blackpool, Tribune's own 'Hard Labour' con- ference, and Peter Hain's call for a new soft left organisation all highlight a growing disquiet on the soft left with the Kinnock-Hattersley leadership.

Unfortunately, these criticisms are rised in the context of support for the existing leader- ship: yet the soft left are up against the problem that it is impossible in make any criticisms of the leadership without the Walworth Road whispering machine labelling you an unaccep- table oppositionist.

The media dwelt extensively on Todd's defence of unilateral nuclear disarmament and common ownership, and highlighted his rather weak criticisms of the policy review, together with his quotable views on people with 'sharp suits and cordless telephones, clipboards and

scientific samples.

What the media studiously ignored were Todd's efforts to distance himself from the hard left He was scathing about 'the nostalgics who look back to a misty past", and leaned over back- wards to soft pedal his attack on the Aims and Values document, allowing that 'it's not easy to define socialism in a small pamphlet'.

What happened to Todd illustrates the dilemma of the soft left. All his sup-

port for Kinnock counted for nothing: 3

MPs queued up to voice their attacks on him to any television camera or reporter prepared to listen. Labelled 'dinosaur", and with his speech writer g hounded out of Blackpool. Todd g received what the NUM's Billy Etherington called "the Arthur Scargill treatment'

Heft

The leadership's attitude to Todd proved beyond doubt that for this leadership there is no such thing as a loyal critic: you are either a Kinnockite or an opponent.

The Tribune 'Hard Labour' conference oc- curred in the wake of Todd's speech, and was aimed at those who feel tom organisationally between the party's right and the sectarian left". Well publicised at Labour conference, graced

Heffer: holding back new realism flop. Only 150 tumed up on the first day, show ing any soft left momentum from the Todd speech had been lost; among those present there was littie enthusiasm for the Hain proposals. The exlent of Hain's isolation surprised even those such as Lahour Briefing who had correct ly argued that there was little space for manouevre between the Kinnock leadership

and those on the hard left such as the Campaign Group, Campaign 89 and the Socialist Con- ference.

Hain's hope of soft left realignment has failed. There is going to be no equivalent in

gomz to be no equivalent un England of Scottish Labour Action.

Imnically the LCC has a more coherent

strategy than Hain: they have no intention of breaking or even lonsening their ties to Kin- nock. Instead they used Todd's speech as a pretext to launch their attack on Labour's links with the unions, and advocating further water- ing down of membership participation in the CLPs through introducing one member one vote.

Al the Tribune conference. Labow Brefing argued that any realignment must be accom panied hy a decision to oppose all further witch hunts. On this basis, Briefing welcomed the move away from Kinnock, and advocated joint campaigns in defence of unilateralism and com- mon ownership.

Kevin Davey of the Socialist Society adopted a similar theme, encouraging wider participation in the Chesterfield prcess from which the soft left have excluded themseives rather than been excluded.

Socialist Outlook shares the view put by Briefing and Kevin Davey; but we would now go further. It isclearthat there will be no serious realignments on the soft left for the foresceable

At the

future

In our view there is no way you can defend unilateralism and common ownership without breaking from Kinnock: individuals whn try will simply be attacked as oppositionists. While the Socialist Conference may yet he able to wel- come a few refugees from the soft left, its most important task will be working alongside those fighting hack against the Thatcher offensive.

Fortunately the Benn-Heffer campaign and the Socialist Conference movement have kept ancialism on the Labour party agenda. Socialist Oulook will continue covering the debates that develop.

Page 12

00k no 11 December 1988/January 1989

← Whose block vote is it anyway? · Labour's disappearing youth →

Something wrong on this page?