PHOTO: Carlos Guarita/Reflox
PHOTO: Carlo
URES
Mass support for Rock Against Racism: no such echo for Tom Sawyer's plans
disappeari
youth
vears Labour Party confere! beyond racoanitior.. DAVID SHEPI
= made constitutional changes wh iRD asks: whatever happened to th
Let's bomb Russia,' quipped Kenny Everett during the only national youth event of the 1983 general election cam- paign: a reactionary jamboree or- ganised by the Young Conservatives. In that election more young people, in the 18-24 age group, voted Tory or Alliance than voted Labour - an historic low- point in Labour's electoral fortunes amongst young people. After 1983 the task of reversing the disastrously low youth vote for Labour was seen as a priority by the party leadership.
By 1986 Neil Kinnock had been seen in a pop video with Tracy Uliman (remember her?) and Red Wedge was touring the country, taking poppy, populist pro- Labour propaganda to the nation's youth. Labour had started to "listen" to young people - or. at least to those who were Listening to Billy Brage and Paul Weller.
But, alongside the agitpop and PR. another process war initiated by the party leadership in 1986: - als coctions of the
a wax initated hy
a consuntation on the subiect:..
ganisation.
Was there a connection between the party's poor electoral performance amongst young
pertomm.. "nonst young people and its youth structures? The conven- tional wisdom amongst the Kinnockitex was that, yes, an organisational restructuring was a prerequisite to regaining the youth vote. And at the heart of the organisational problem tax ofen many problems according to the world-view of the soft left) was the supposedly pernicious role
of the Militant tendency - the leading force in the L.PYS since 1970.
In the words of Tom Sawyer, NUPE deputy general socretary and chair of the party nation- al executive's youth committee, The present style and approach of the YS, allied to com- piacency in the party as a whole, has meant that we have tumed off large numbers of young people. Generously, Sawyerpointed out in this 1986 Chartistarticle, "The hlame forthe party's inabulity to capture the youth vote cannot be placed solely with the YS. (Emphasis added.) (The implication, of course, is that it can lake most of the blame!) So what was the problem with the LPYS? Here is Sawyer agam. 'We al know that the LPYS is dominated by the Militant tendency,' Case proven.
It is barely credible that these people believed, in all honesty, that the activities of the LPYS (7000-xtrong in 1983, according to generous estimates, and without a single party political broadcast, television interview or even major newspaper article to its credit) influenced negatively the voting intentions of hundreds of thousands of young votem. Surely the general presentation of Labour's policies by the party leadership during the campaign had more of an effect? Nevertheless, such was the 'common cense upon which the consultation was based.
In 1987 there was an improvement in Labour's youth vote: a marginal incrcase amongst young men and an 11 percent increase anongst young women. According to Sawyer's logic this increase should properly be attributed
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 11 December 1988/January 1989
• alter the party's youth structures _abour Party Young Socialists?
to the L.PYS! Or perhaps it was due to the fact that young people were aware of the ongoing reorganisation of Labour's youth structures? A senious analysis of voting trends reveals, of course, a much more complicated web of causes and effects. But what of the results of the "consultation"?
Conveniently cough, given the general witch-hunting policy of the Kinnock leader- ship, bashing the Militant in the LPYS emerged as a key way of winning back the youth vote. Conveniently also, given the leadership's at- tempts to create a more centralised, top-down party, national executive control of the party's youth campaigning emerged as a key way of making the party more relevant to young people.
Lahour's 1987 conference endorsed the es- Lahlishment of a National Youth Campaigns Committee (NYCC) and provision for the set- ling up of regional youth campaigns commit- lees. Membership of the committee was to com- prise representatives of the LPYS, the National Organisation of Labour Students (NOLS). youth trade union representatives, Red Wedge and the chair of the national executive's youth commitice.
To all intents and purposes this committee was to become the leadership of the party's youth campaigning work, under the diroct su pervision of the party's national executive. From being the party youth organisation, the LPYS was reduced to the status of a participant in the NYCC.
Any doubt as to whether the reorganisation
Page 13
F E A T U RES
actions. All regional LPYS youth committees were abolished: the LPYS age- Limit was reduced from 26 to '23rd birthday' (that is, 22): the LPYS paper Socialist Youth was effec-
was an attempt to smash the LPYS was shattered by other agreed proposals and
PY.-
tively abolished and it was decided that the youth rep- resentative on the national
but by a 'wider franchise' whose exact dimensions were left deliberately
change, in line with the new structures, to the 1988 party
1988 LPYSconfer.-was Wayne Edginton
conference.
Soon afterwards the
executive- foe the fiest time Wayne
rancelled by the nationar
for many years no LPYS
conference tonk place.
such an assault on the g party's youth organisation is not without historical precedent. In 1936 a right wing Lahour leadership Appealing to you moved against the left wing Lahour League of Youth, closing down the National Youth Ad- visory Committee and the youth paper New Na- tion and redacing the age-limit to 21. Again in 1955 the League of Youth was dishanded, with the abolition of all national and regional stric- tures, Predictably enough, Lahour's youth movements have tended to come in for attack in times of right wing ascendancy within the party - and have bounced back when the left as a whole has been on the offensive.
not hu but nv
IC Winn LPYS
vague.
An annual "broad" youth conference would be con- vened, involving the
groups represented on the
NYCC, at which the youth representative would be clected by
"electoral
college'. A review of PYS rules was commissioned, with the aim of bringing proposals for constitutional
- mice a
This year's party conference brought the current chapter of the chequered history of Lahour's youth movements to a Con- stitutional changes which destroy the LPYS as the national youth wing of Labour were carried on the leadership's recommendation.
The administration of the LPYS itself is no longer the job of the LPYS national committee, whose function is now to 'advise' the national executive on such matters. Standing orders governing the proceedings of LPYS national conference are now subject to approval by the national executive.
Even the rule which allowed the LPYS to or- ganise 'summer schools, rallies and political
uth? Bryan Gould. the new face o.
activities" has heen axed! (One wonders just what is the LPYS now allowed to organise?) The quorum for LPYS branch meetings has been raised from five to six for branches with less than 25 memhers and to eight per cent for larger branches, the minimum number of mem- bers reguired to set up a branch has been doubled from five to ten and a number of other rule changes in relation to branch functioning have the effect of putting branches very much at the mercy of constituency Labour parties and regional officials.
The role of the NYCC and the 'national youth conference have heen codified in the new rules. It isclearthat this "broad' conference is to have no policy-making function: its role is in "organise workshops, debates, discussions. exhibitions, meetings and events of a political, cultural and sporting nature. The view is clear- ly that youth in Kinnock's new model Labour Party are to be seen and not heard - expecially on guestions of policy.
There are some on the left who have argued that the Milttant leadership of the LPYS have brought all of this upon themselves because of their undoubted sectarian propagandism and
Page 14
their failure in huild the
LPYS into anything like the mass movement it had the potential to become
(especially in the early 1980s). Such views are
completely misplaced.
Consider the Labour Party women's organisation
For many years the women's conference was a pillar of the left, passing
socialist policy positions on a range of issues. IL was not Militant-led - and yet it was not spared the Kin- nockite steamroller in the form of a reorganisation
designed to marginalise tie
left and reimpose
control. It is clear that the
party leadership would
Jersh..
have moved, similarly. against any form of left leadership in the LPYS -
'TIV
leadership in the LPYS -
and the duty af all prin- cipled socinlists should
have been unconditional
defence of the LPYS
against bureaucratic inter-
against bureaucratic inter-
There is another parallel with the experience of the
ference.
women's organisation.
Sections of the left, includ
ing Militant. Socialist Ac-
ion and
ganiser, took the view that
it was appropriale to par-
ticipate in the 'consult-
ation process wiuch led to
the destruction of the
LPYS as Labour's youth
inovement, just as Socialist
Action argued, amongst
others, for participation in the review" of the women's organisation. This was wrong, It was also unprincipled. From heginning to end tho "consultation" was an excrcise in witch hunt ing: participation by the left gave it legitimacy which it did not deserve. So what of the future for Labour's youth?
Socialist Or.
Despite the difficulties which they will face. young socialists should continue to participate actively in the new youth structures of the party - at every level. The demand for a real youth movement - with its own structures, campaigns and policy-making proceedures - remains valid. and will be taken up increasingry an the future, especially when the left regains the in itiative in the party. Meanwhile the task of regaining the youth vote for Labour is far too important to be left to the dead hand of the party leadership. It involves developing and fighting for socialist policies which really address the predicament of young people in Thatcher's Britain - and it must be done in the teeth of op position from a party leadership which has shown itself to be more intent on silencing criti- cal youthful voices than winning youth back to Labour.
OOK no 11 December 1988/January 1989