F EA T U
"We are not going to get rid of the block vote and leave ourselves at the mercy of the constituencies*, said one unnamed 'senior member of Labour's shadow cabinet*, quoted in The Independent recently.
in this simpic and honest statement, be (odds on it was a he) summed up the very complex consitutional problem facing Labour's Icaders. They desperately want to respond to media pressure by doing away with the influence not only of the left in the party's policy making procedures,
far they have managed to marginalise the Edginton
but with the trade unions' key role too. So
left, only with the reliable assistance of trade union top brass delivering the re-
quired votes at conference. Party managers Wayno
know that they can't remove those votes
less reliable as they are presently or. PHOTO
without leaving more space for the much
ganised - constituency Labour Party (CLP) votes.
But the pressure in mounting. Hardly a week goes by withnut another leading Labour "thinker' (in the New Statesman mould) or "deer' (MP's and trade union leaders) rushing to pin their sail to the mast of constitutional reform. Most recently Robin Cook, Neil Kin- nock, Bryan Gould, Michael Meacher, John Edmonds, Gavin Laird as well as Ron Todd and Tony Benn have all come out in favour of chan- ges in principle, though with different formula tions up for discussion. The media have already been at it for months, with political commen- tators surely caucusing to produce a remarkab ly consistent shopping list for their required Labour Party sell-outs on unilateralism and the trade unions.
Since October's Labour Party Conference the debate has gained momentum. With the leadership of the Transport and Gencral Workers Union (TGWU) looking like it might have mind of its own by opposing Kinnock on some questions, an attempt to weaken the trade union link is now being billed as a prerequisite for Labour's electability, strengthening the leader's authority over conference. Although historically, of course, supporting the leader at conference has generally been what the trade unions have been best at.
The party's constitution gives the trade unions their present voting strength of over ninety per cent at conference. It has survived virtually intact since its adoption at the first full Labour Party conference in 1918. The deal, drawn up hy leading Fabian Sidney Webb. fobbed off the socialists with the never-to-be- implemented Clause Four and gave the much more conservative trade unions the control- ling votes.
Page 10
ficers of the union who have stond for
these positions against lay members.
Delegations to Labour Party Conferences
must follow their own union conferences
policies which are never, of course, total
ly controllable, and some important vic-
tones have been won here which have
then been carried through into Labour
Party policy making. They may not al-
ways be strictly observed, but when
they're blatantly breached, the member-
ship may have some come-back. But, at
the same time union general secretaries
can also usurily hold sway on controver-
sial decisions (which might be defined as
those they haven't managed to stitch up
beforehand), fulfilling their role of con-
trolling and containing their members
views and activities rither than repre-
senting them.
It goes without saying that despite all
this there have been occasions when the
block vote has been cast to the left's ad-
vantage - notably this year in the unilateralism debate. But in the vast majority of cases it is use simply to put a brake on anything left of the leadership - or even just a bit adven- turous or unknown. Even if the unions don't follow the Labour leader's line every time, they're preferred by party fixers as much more reliable partners for cosy deals, as against cav- ing decision-making to delegates and votes among the ordinary members of the trade unions and the Labour Party.
The current arrangements are clearly un- democratic. This has led to a situation where not only are trade union members effectively disenfranchised and prevented from having any real influence over Labour Party policy because of the way their vote is cast, but at the same stroke, party members are carved out too. CLPs are hasically irrelevant to national Labour Party policy-making, and they know it.
The case for allowing constituencies to take a fairer proportion of votes at conference has- been raised in the past by the left in the parry (prominently in recent years by the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy) and from time to time the more progressive union leadership have been pushed into responding to these demands. So far though, most initiatives in that direction have met what is a common fate in the Labour Party. They have been swallowed up in a swamp of bureaucratic mismanagement and manoeuvring
The issue was first raised in recent yearx at the 1979 conference. Consultation followed with decision in principle by the NEC in 1983, to redress some of the balance in favour of CLPs. This was followed by more consultation from which finally emerged the Kitson Proposals'. Under the outline drawn up by Alex
John Edmonds: In favour of smaller block vote
As more unions have affiliated to the Labour Party over the years, their share of the votes on its policy making bodies, and particularly con- ference, has increased correspondingly.
By 1935 the trade unions and affiliated or- ganisations held between them over 82 per cent of conference votes: by 194584 per cent, rising to 88 per cent by 1956. The present strength of the block vote is now around 91 per cent of all the votes cast al conference. This block vote is calculated on the basis of the affiliation fee paid by the unions - it is bought", rather than related to the actual number of affiliated members in cach union.
The trade unions also effectively elect 20 of the 29 National Executive Committee (NEC) places, and have a 40 percent share of the elec- toral college for the election of the party's leader and deputy leader. Between 60 and 70 percent of the party's bills are paid by the trade unions.
So the unions" affiliations bring two impor- tant returns for Labour's leaders. They meet much of the party's running costs and they also make sure that decisions taken at conference (which is still, in theory, the party's sovereign body), are effectively in the hands of four or five union general secretaries:
Trade union delegations to Labour Party conferences are top heavy and largely un- democratic. Most are composed of a combina- tion of unelected and therefore largely unac countable paid full-time officials, and elected (lay) executive committee members and usually regional and sometimes minority repre sentativeston. However, these "lay' individuals may, in some unions (like the GMB general union) themselves in fact be full-time paid of
.OOK no 11 December 1988/Jahuary 1989
Kitson, then deputy general secretary of the TOWU and an NEC mem- ber, CLPs would have had about a 20 per cent share of the conference vote. Despite receiving wide support from the con- stituencies as a useful (if limited) First step forward, his report was shelved and
1986 Labour Party Con- PHOTO: Wayno Edginton
never went to conference.
A subsequent intiative, a *Balance of Votes Work- ing Party' set up from the
ference, met an even worse
PHOTO
fate. It was wound up after only one abortive meeting
Despite organised left pressure from within the consituencies to establish a fairer system, it's not surprising that progress has been slow in com- ing
But clearly the new interest in reform ex- pressed by the people who really count under the present system (that is, those who have the votes arcady) has got little to do with "justice' or democracy.
The right have got their own, different. reasons for their sudden concern with con- ference voting. Whatever proposals (if any) are brought forward under their recently an- nounced enquiries into the extension of one- member-one-vote and the reduction of the block vote, the are unlikely to result in handing over decision making power to the rank and file.
Because at the heart of what they're up to is this parallel concem with one member-onc- vote. Initial proposals which went through this
yeur party conference add up to a charter- yeur party conference add up te for members rights - but for total control by the leadership over a passive, if massive, mem- bership. Kinnock and more explicitly, right- wing GMB leader John Edmonds, want to trade off a reduced block vote (variously, 40, 50 ot 60 per cent), if individual memhership can be increased from the present 300,000 orso to their (unlikely) one million target. At the same time they'd like direct access through computerised records to those members. Member whose par- ticipation in the party will, they hope, wither to just filling in ballot forms (on as micry oppor tunities, presumably, as the party can afford). rather than participating in building the party and policy-making.
That way conference can be kept safe, he- cause, if it is left with any role at all, it will still be run from the top down. Such a move would also have two other advantages. First, it will answer recent media criticisms (the evermedia- sensitive party managers don't seem to have twigged yet that there will always be more!) Secondly, it will leave wide open the party's options for future deals with the SLD/SDP (who have always paraded the block-voting system and more generally the trade union link as their sticking point). Failing this (the "mass" membership/block vote trade off), moves will be made anyway to reduce the role of con
at ander ho have the
Justee
IF the
ference to a media event - and proposals are al- ready heing considered by the Conference Procedures Committee.
Sa it's no great coincidence that at the sinte time ther are now renewed calls recently from the New Statesman, and Ben Pimlott's nauscat ingly mis-named "Samizdat" project, for unity • deales under the banner of 'non-Tory citizenship. And a founder member of the SDP, writing in the press recently, explicitly cited trade unionism, unilateralism and Clause Four as the obstacles to such a pact.
With a conference which is potentially even more tame than under the present system, reck- on the party fixers, "unpopular" policies like unilateralism and Clause Four will be all the easier to ditch.
So the moves are aimed not just at the party's top structures. They go through policy, right to its roots. Under attack is the link - which, al- though it may be imperfect, abused and misused under the present system - ties the Labour Pauty to the working class. This is a fun- damental feature of the British Labour Party which sets il apart from purely bourgoois par- Lies:
It is the link too, that the left should be vigilant in defending. Removing the class hased structures of the party will make it all the caster to remove what class-hased politics it has.
Such a defence need not imply a rejection of any moves to increase CLP's voting strengths in the party structures. There are a number of possible forumlations under discussion on the left already, including a 50/50 split, an electoral college-type division, and "proportional repre- sentation" of minority positions in casting of block votes.
All these options deserve serious attention. and the left more than anyone, should he dis- cussing the alteratives and preparing to come up with some specifics. It must be ready to cam paign hard for them too.
But it can't stop there.
Regular readers of Socialist Outlook will know that rocent discussion in these pages has highlighted the need for socialists to tackle the block vote problem - and that of union
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 11 December 1988/January 1989
democracy and politics - more fundamentally. That is, from the boltom up. Because at the same time as we will he arguing for more votes for CLPs and defending the party link with the
unions against the right's attacks, we must be conscious of the urgent need to democratise the block vre
It's an easy demand to raise, but it needs
sume detailed attention to address it seriously.
To the right wing, it mean simply the "nights' of members not to attend meetings (yes, really. this is point one of part general secretary Larry Whity's member's charter'1), and to be asked to fill in a form every so often. The press is al- ready demanding that "Mr Kinnock should in- dicate that he doesnot intend to pay the slightest
attention to future conference decisions... reached as a result of block votes being cast without adequate prior consultation" (ic ballor-
ing).
But with a vision of a more genuinely socialist Labour Movement, the question of union democracy must be approached from the starting point of the need to build a participatory and genuinely representative movement, with its sights set clearly on the interests of the work- ing class.
This, of course, raises many difficult ques- tions. Like how can membership participation be increased? What realistic measures can be taken to enahle memhers to make sure their voices are heard, their decisions count and car- ried out? How can the interests of minorities best be safeguarded, promoted even? How do you fight the tendency for a bureaucritic layer to develop, and at all levels of organisation?
As with all difficult questions, there are no easy answers But the experience in some unions (of building shop stewards" committees,
of the growing pressures representation of regional and minority interests) should be our starting point, and are useful building blocks for developing our strategies.
And of course an organised left at all levels of the movement will he an ahsolute prereg- uisite for building and developing that democracy.
Jane Wells
Page 11