Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

The RCP - an infantile disorder

· Socialist Outlook no. 1, May–June 1987 · pp 36-38 · 1,356 words

Miners

RCP supporters barr

The consistency of the RCP's ultra-leit approach goes right across the spectru. Mike Freeman, a leading theoretician of the RCP explains that 'the labour movement should leave it to the capitalists how they want to run their own industries and ser- vices. Our only concern is that in both the private or public sector, workers' interests

'hardly enough for a social,

never mind a party'

are safeguarded.' Fortunately, workers have up to now shown a lack of reverence towards the RCP's theoreticians and have kept insist- ing that they don't agree that it's the bosses' prerogative to run their urms or hospitals just as they please.

This ultra-left posturing really roaches rock bottom when the same author writes: 'middle class left wingers who work as sa-

al si!

laried professionals in the state sector may strongiv «dentifv with pur public housing, hospitals and transport. But working class

people who work for the low paying councils, health authorities and bus and rail networks, or have to rely on the cut price services they „ovide have nu such pr prejudices.'

viously the 'ideal' RCP militant is the person

who is stoically indifferent to the quality of health care, cares nothing for the state of public housing, and is in the realms of politicai ecstasy when they stand for an hour and a half in the rain with their fellow workers waiting for the bus that never comes This gives them a 'god sent' opportunity to explain to the rest of the queue the need for the 'alternative'

Ob- MOT.

asing an

"ansport sle

-hce ... "lIs viewed n… avergence num me ical str.

workers 1 raim

hat

neir altn

ICX- reca

Socialist Outlook No 1 MarJunc 1987

FIGH

FOR

GAY

RIG

POLEMIC An infantile disorder. The RCP campaigned vigorous!

depoliticisation of the working class' accom- panied by a decline in rank and file res- istance.

Commenting on the workers attitude to the last Labour government they say they were a rejection of 'the consequences of the government's policies, rather than a rejec- tion of labourism itself. Accordingly the RCP considers there has been no significant break from labourism, that the resistance at rank and file level is on the wane and the process of depoliticisation has not been halted. If their analysis is correct, and things are as bleak as that in the labour movement it is hardly the most propitious time to launch a new organ- isational alternative.

For a party to constitute an organisational alternative it should lead a significant section of the working class and the oppressed, and be in a position to change the relationship of forces in the class struggle. None of these qualifications are met by the RCP, but such realities do not deter them, they explain: 'the vanguard does not exist at present - it has to be created'. They add: 'the form of organisa- tion appropriate to building a vanguard in modern Britain is the propaganda party. The RCP is such a party'. So while the rest of the workers' movement carries on its pointless struggles — all guaranteed to be betrayed - the RCP will get on with the main job of creating the vanguard.

The description of itself as a propaganda party means that its work will be concen- trated not on widening and extending the struggles of the masses, but on explaining that neither the leaders, nor the organisa- tions of the working class are effective. Presu- mably when enough workers have suffered sufficient defeats at the hands of the capitalist class, because of the bureaucratic role of their leaders, the RCP will become big enough to form a real party. This schema boils down to saying 'when they have seen the light they will join us' and can only lead to disillusion- ment and demoralisation; it will never create the basis for a mass marxist party.

Like all sectarian organisations the RCP doesn't start from how best it can advance the interests of the working class, but rather how it can arithmetically increase its mem- bership. Furthermore its other main touchstone is necessarily how can it separate itself from other far left organisations, who also like the left leaders in the unions have equally to be exposed. The 23 January issue of The Next Step is a bizarre illustration of this sectarianism. Apparently papers like Socialist Worker have been crossing class lines on the Aids issue. In an article entitled "The dangers of safe sex it accuses the left of endorsing the Tories' targeting of gay men by advocating the use of condoms. This it claims means the 'left has fallen for the Tories' presentation of Aids as a medical problem requiring a technical solution'. Now you know, it's not a condom that's needed for protection against the Aids virus, it's a copy of the Next Step!

• Mike Freeman 'The Road to Power': Confronta- tion (RCP theoretical magazine) no. 1, Summer 1986. Unless otherwise credited, all quotations from the RCP are from the same source.

35

uf to ban

33

RCP in action

miners and dockers, along with the prin- tworkers and others who have joined in solidarity action in defence of the NHS must learn to stop pursuing their own misguided conceptions and get into step with the RCP, who after all know what's best for them.

This ultimatistic approach showed itself with disastrous results in the miners' strike. For the miners and their supporters the main issue was how to stop pit closures. This could only be done by the miners taking strike action; by a campaign aimed at getting solidarity action in other sectors of the labour movement and by building up financial and political support in the working class and among the oppressed groups. Those tasks overrode all else and they had to be the first concerns of every militant. The stakes in the dispute were high. Victory for the miners would have shown jobs could be saved by class-struggle methods, it would have stimu- lated the confidence of other workers and without doubt would have strengthened the left forces inside the unions and the Labour Party. Defeat, as we have seen, would under- mine confidence in class-struggle methods and strengthen the right wing inside the unions and the Labour Party.

But the RCP was having none of ina nonsense. It knew what was best for the miners and had its own prescription for them - a campaign for a national ballot. This would have disrupted the strike and given one group of workers the right to vote

Socialist Outlook No 1 May/June 1987

another sections jobs away. But the RCP claimed this was the only way to challenge the class collaborationist strategy of the union leadership' — these "class collabora- tors' are the exception among national union leaders, in that they actually wanted to win their strike!

So determined was the RCP to oppose the NUM leadership, they decided to withdraw from the miners support groups claiming such groups helped the NUM bureaucracy. From the outset they failed to begin from the

'Workers don't have the same

prejudices as the

RCP...fortunately'

premise of how best to aid the strike and widen its support, instead they saw their task as being to "expose'

the left leaders like Scargill and Heathfield and thus win some individual miners to the RCP. No wonder at the height of the strike (in what I can only assume was a Freudian slip) their paper the Next Step carried a banner which read 'RCP hits the Pits' — what more can I add to such political eloquence?

This type of exposure politics is a consi- stent thread through all the interventions of the RCP. It stems from the tact that they consider there has been a '..longstanding

36

Is the

future

female?

JUDITH ARK WRIGHT

Lynne Segal, Is the future female? Virago,

14.95

I HE TITLE of this book poses a question for the women's movement. It has sometimes mistakenly been referred to as The future is female. But author Lynne Segal sets out with a question which she answers in the negative. The

← A socialist media policy · Is the future female? →

Something wrong on this page?