Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

A socialist media policy

· Socialist Outlook no. 1, May–June 1987 · pp 34-36 · 1,643 words

Labour Party

media play in a democracy, and to influence policy-makers'. The document includes demands for 'the right to fair representation, the right to make

contact, workers' participation, freedom of

the airwaves, the right to reply', and so on.

JL

JL: These appear to be very defensive demands,

geared to an acceptance that the media will always be in the hands of the present owners.

KL: Yes, it seems to me that these demands are useful only as preliminary to an

examination of the true function of the media. The 'right to reply' is a case in point. Even if it were granted, which is impossible to imagine, it cannot balance or inhibit the fundamental stance of those who control newspapers and broadcasting, and who appoint editors and journalists who share their views. For it to be effective, every news bulletin would have to be followed by a longer programme in which the assumptions on which it was based were teased out and

explained. Every time a strike was

'threatened' would the trade unionists be allowed to say it was 'promised'? Would

'left-wingers' be allowed to call themselves 'moderate' and 'moderates' be called 'right-wingers'?

Again, it in no way affects the problems of

agenda setting. Who decides which stories should be told and which ignored?

A more significant demand is that the

present structures like the BBC Board of

Governors, the IBA, and the Press Council

should be 'replaced by democratic systems of

capidined. E 'threatener.

" Uncook N. " May/June 1987

Ken Loach

Making a

programme for

the media 32

A Labour government which has no plans to combat the ideological powers exercised by the capitalist class through the mass media can be safely assumed to have no serious intention of undermining capitalist control. But the hard left and the Marxist movement, too, have a long way yet to go in developing a serious programme

and perspective for the ownership, control and development of the media.

To initiate a more serious level of debate, which we want to promote in the pages of this magazine, JOHN LISTER spoke with film director KEN LOACH, whose recent documentary work for TV has encountered repeated censorship at the hands of the supposedly 'impartial" broadcasting authorities.

regulation'. But here again, questions are begged. Should commercial television by scrapped? Should newspaper proprietors be expropriated? Is it conceivable that the state will give up its control of broadcasting?

This confusion will remain until we acknowledge that the media relate the prevailing ideology to the unfolding events of contemporary life. Thus peoples' view of the world is impregnated with the main tenets of that ideology, and become 'common sense'.

JL: Most of the labour movement response has been to react against specific witch hunts or outrageous interference rather than to look at these fundamentals.

KL: The relationship between the media and ideology is akin to the that of judges and the law: by its constant interpretation, the set of ideas and values is developed and extendea.

The labour movement - or its most active sections - will react angrily when the media present industrial or foreign issues in ways which favour the ruling class, but the steady

Socialist Outlook No 1 May/June 1987

DEBATE

and continuous assumptions that have prepared the way for those presentations go largely unchallenged. The use of language and images, the choice of subjects, the questions that are ignored, all combine to lead the viewer or reader to a particular view of the world.

Our first task is to consolidate our basic analysis: understanding the media as agents of an ideology. We need to examine how this works and the structures which preserve it. The ownership and control of the press by private capital, and the control of broadcasting by government appointees have a complementary effect.

Broadcasters take their news stories from the press, they feed off each other, prepare the ground for each other, even on occasion playing the parts of the 'good' and 'bad' copper. The crude attacks of Murdoch and Maxwell on - for example - Arthur Scargill had their more polite but equally vicious counterparts in the BBC or ITV.

We have to explain this structure of control: how it works and whose interests it serves.

JL: Of course it does not simply serve the capitalists: it serves all those who find themselves comfortable in the present balance of forces — not least the right wing of the Labour Party and trade union movement.

KL: Yes, as in other areas, this will bring us into conflict with the leadership of the labour movement, which has had a cosy relationship with the media in the past. The control of the press by big business and the control of broadcasting by establishment figures has never been challenged. Harold Wilson appointed a Tory, Charles Hill, to lead the BBC. Ex-Labour ministers George Thomson and Edmund Dell are present or past chairmen of the IBA and Channel 4. The right wing of the Labour Party likes to have it both ways: use and support the existing structures, while in public attack the media for being unfair to Labour. The use of the press and broadcasting by right wingers to attack the left has a long history.

JL: This year's NUJ conference adopted a composite resolution including a section from my branch calling on the national executive to draw up proposals for the 'abolition of the present unrepresentative quango bodies of appointed dignitaries which control established radio and TV channels, and for this replacement by elected and accountable controlling bodies, to include representation from media workers at all levels. ' Do you think this offers a step in the right direction?

KL: We certainly have to explore new ways of organising all of the media. How can we make newspapers both independent and democratically accountable to both workers and readers? How does editorial freedom relate to this accountability? Similarly, what is the relationship between independence and accountability in broadcasting? How can we use the extraordinary technical advances of cable and satellite? Should we try to steer people viewing away from the box in the living room, and the consequent passivity of the viewer, towards more public screening?

In a socialist democracy, based on a socialist economy, capitalism will have no

place in either newspapers or broadcasting. How do we fill the vacuum?

Before that happens, in what terms do we discuss the reform of the media, if we recognise the central part they play in social control? Broadcasting in particular has to be considered in the same light as the police and the armed forces, in its defence of the state and the economic system the state is there to protect.

JL: We hope to pursue this debate much further in the magazine: certainly this outline of some of the key problems to be confronted should help us to convene a wider discussion. Would you be willing to be involved?

KL: Yes, perhaps we could each think of additional people whom we could bring together in a round-table discussion that could begin to hammer out some answers to these questions, and discuss how to take them into the labour movement •

34

The Revolutionary Communist Party (RCP) has been publicised recently through standing candidates in the Knowlesly North and Greenwich by-elections. Its strident propaganda activities have given it a certain base of support in the student movement. But, argues BOB PENNINGTON, the 'alternative' of the RCP is thoroughly sectarian and ultra left.

THE GRIP of reformism over the British labour movement, has been a great obstacle to building a widely-based marxist move- ment in this country. Time and again, the far left, frustrated by their struggle against the bureaucracy in both the unions and the Labour Party, have attempted short cuts by creating an organisational alternative. Fol- iowing the defeat of the miners and the printworkers and the ascendancy of Kin- nockism in the Labour Party, the idea of the new, independent party once again carries a certain attraction.

Firm advocates of such a course are the Revolutionary Communist Party who say what the workers require 'is an independent programme that can challenge the Labour Party' and claim 'this programme can only be developed in total opposition, both politi- cal and organisational, (my emphasis) to this party' * Having reached such a conclusion the RCP was then compelled to turn reality on its head. You can hardly describe a group or even a league, as an organisational alterna- tive to the Labour Party. Only another party can be seriously considered as an organisa- tional alternative to Labour. So blithely ig- noring the norms of political nomenclature, in 1981, a couple of hundred people - hardly enough for a social never mind a party - immodestly appointed themselves as the Party. While this deceived the leaders and the members of the RCP, strangely enough it left the rest of the Labour movement un- moved.

Since then the RCP has stuck doggedly to its self-appointed role as the alternative lea- dership. When the Tories brought in legisla- tion which was designed to stop workers paying the political levy to the Labour Party, the RCP found itself in alliance with the SDP, the Liberals, the Tories and the employers who were all against a 'yes' vote. The RCP were of course being logical in arguing against the 'yes' vote; after all you can hardly be in favour of giving money to something to which you have decided you are an imme- diate alternative. The fact that the conse- quences of not voting 'yes' would have meant that the unions would have been denied funds to run political campaigns was by the way.

: ATE eu have Led My SoR (Shattered Ky

LIGHTS

amunist Part

RCP supporters barrack the bigore who ut

RCP - an

Ves"

A Crumper Lemard in 1986 The

← French Communist Party in crisis · The RCP - an infantile disorder →

Something wrong on this page?