future is not female. This may sound not quite the thing for any right-on feminist to say, but the book is largely a nu. with ideas which have increasingly become the norm in the women's movement and which Segal identifies as anti-socialist and idealist.
LITIC
• wellen ien nave
Many of these ideas have some affinity with traditional with the more 'radical' tinge
taken out of them. Segal takes issue in particular with Andrea
Dworkin, Dale Spender and Mary Daly. In a recent publication, Beyond Power, Marilyn French sums up their
view in calling upon women to assert the female principles of caring, warmth and nurturing to 'feminise the world' and thus
save it from destruction.
French defines patriarchy as a morality which worships power and has determined social arrangements for thousands of years. Segal refutes this view and the underlying assumption that as feminists we seek to accentuate the differences between men and women on the psychological level. She
explains that, 'this means not working for a future which is female but work which reiecr distinctions we now draw between women and men."
She points out that there are several problems with this emphasis on femininity versus masculinity. First, that men's greater power in relation to women is not simply a product of ideas or language 'but of all the social practices which give men power over women'. She goes on to assert that 'ideas and language interact with other tensions and struggles'. She
correctly takes up Dale Spender who says that 'feminism refers to alternative meanings put
forward by feminists' and that language itself determines oppression.
Spender and others constantly see the struggle in terms of female values of
security, nurturance, peace, versus the male values of aggression, destruction and competition. These values are seen as given and static and as biologically or rather
sociobiologically determined.
This leads these writers to
support idealist solutions rather
than practical answers to the problems of women's oppression. Practical struggles against women's inequality are even seen as of less value than the fight to recognise women's distinct ideas and experience. As French (by no means the most sophisticated but surely the clearest on these ideas says, although some feminists
consciously work towards immediate political goals, feminism as a philosophy does not include a political programme for the construction of a more humane world...(this)
would contradict feminist principles, for programmes
require uniformity and rigidity?
Segal is correct to single out these ideas and warn against their increasing influence inside the women's movement. There is an increasing tendency among some feminists to go for the soft option which these ideas represent; namely, that nothing much can be done apart from spreading feminist ideas
This thinking has informed the debate around the activities of the peace women. Segal correctly endorses the courageous action of these women whilst disagreeing with any notion that masculinity means war and aggression and femininity means peace and love. It is true that it is largely men that have been responsible for war but as Segal points out, many women have in the past supported this. Wars do not usually occur because men as a group have clamoured for it. Under capitalism it is nation states that are the perpetrators of war and which then whip up popular support for it from both men and women.
The question of the state and the various institutions which uphold male power and women's oppression is one which Segal does emphasize without always drawing the necessary conclusions. She does point out, however, that there are even those on the left who do not seem to understand this issue. Perry Anderson, for example, had this to say in his book, On the tracks of historical materialism; "There is never any overall centralisation of the structures of women's oppression and this diffusion of
Socialist Outlook No 1 May/June 1987
REVIEWS
WATTLE WIKES.
1184**
SUPPORT CROUP
Philip Gordon/ Reflex
it critically weakens the possibility of unitary insurgence against it.' Such assertions challenge everything socialist feminists stood for in the 1970s when they argued that women's oppression is centralised through state policies, as Segal correctly points out. In fact, it is precisely through using such policies to attack women and the working class that the Tory government has been able to assist in the process of fragmentation and disorientation of the women's movement. Such fragmentation was not an inherent part of that movement.
Segal then goes on to address this issue. Key to the decline of the women's movement of the 1970s was the corresponding decline of the socialist feminist current. This came about because of the difficulties of the objective situation, the failure to respond to new issues such as black feminism and, Segal argues, because of the role of the so-called 'sectarian left' within that current. By selecting women in left groups as the target in this way she presents a one-sided and rather sweeping view of what actually happened.
The problem for socialist feminists at the time was a generalised crisis of perspective. Women in left wing groups bear as much responsibility as anyone for failing to provide a complete way out. As one of the women who was eventually excluded from the South London socialist feminist group to which Segal refers — not because of anything I had said or done but because of my
membership of a left group - I can testify that this kind of scapegoat approach did nothing to resolve the difficulties and probably made the situation worse. In fact, if anything, socialist feminists were beginning to become obsessed with how to keep their structures and ideas intact, rather than with attempting to provide a perspective for the women's movement which corresponded to the changing political situation. Left groups active at the time were undoubtedly as guilty of this as anyone else and some were sectarian, as were some independent feminists. This was the time to reach out and make alliances with broader layers of women, to listen to black feminists for example, and this was not always done. Socialist feminist groups became a substitute for building broader alliances. Perhaps Segal would not disagree with this. It is odd then that in her book she so vehemently opposes one attempt to actually build such a broad alliance, namely the National Abortion Campaign (NAC).
This hostility to NAC is actually out of place in a book which in general is so refreshingly inspired by and supportive of the actual struggles of women of which NAC was surely an example, whatever problems you may think accompanied it.
This apart, however, we can all agree that what we are seeking to build now is not a replica of the old socialist feminist current but something
new and perhaps broader. Segal points out that the broad appeal of the women's movement's ideas must not mean their dilution. She cites all the positive signs that have arisen in the last few years when things have been so difficult for the left which can give pointers to the future. The struggles of women inside the Labour Party and in local government; the struggles of women at Greenham; the healthworkers; the miners' wives. It should not be forgotten what tragic errors were made by some women in rejecting struggles like those at Greenham and even the miners' wives as somehow not feminist. This is the point at which sectarianism became a real problem in the women's movement.
Contrary to those feminists, however, Segal welcomes these struggles, though the impact of the miners' wives merits more discussion than it is given in the book: Here were working class women organising autonomously on a mass scale and explicitly influenced by feminist ideas. What sort of influence will they have on the women's movement of the future? Do they signal a new type of movement altogether? Or was their struggle specific and merely an isolated example born of the environment in which those women live? These questions are not even raised by Segal
Segal tends to look uncritically at the effects of women working within local councils for feminist policies.
Undoubtedly, such experiences
have their positive side Feminists can use the existing power structures to further their struggle. However, this should be done in such a way as to promote action and expose the way in which the state operates both locally and nationally to perpetuate women's oppression. Segal does not allude to the potential hazards of localism and co-option which can result from involvement in the structures of the local state
In looking at the future of the women's movement, such questions as these need to be addressed more thoroughly. Segal attempts to deal with some of the theoretical or philosophical obstacles impeding a clear perspective but there is also a need to address more concrete issues being put forward by feminists in this country. Bea Campbell's ideas on redistributing the wealth between men and women in the family, for example, are but an extension of the idea of female versus male values. Yet they hardly get a mention in the book
Lynne Segal has had the courage to challenge many views which have become accepted as the norm within the movement, but her book is only the beginning of an urgent
debate. Segal's conclusion that
making alliances with the workers' movement combined with autonomy, as opposed to any outright rejection of
alliances with men is correct. It is vital that the strategy and tactics this requires be addressed by all sections of the women's movement.
37
Socialist Outlook No 1 May/June 1987
38
versatility of the
voucher dem
JANE WELLS
Personal Services is on general release Paul Bailey, An English Madam, £2.50 Fontana
YoU HAVe to admit that there's something very funny about the idea of a bank manager being strung up, smeared with baby oil and then pelted with the contents of a hoover bag, or a middle-aged pin-striped politician begging to have his 'bot-bot' spanked
This is the basic appeal of Personal Services, and of the myth that is Cynthia Payne. It's about breaking the rules of respectability and pointing the finger at the hypocrisy of the morals of the British establishment - and the film (quite affectionately) pokes fun at a few well chosen stiff-upper lipped representatives, using the best 'carry-on' traditions to do it.
Whilst disclaiming 'any resemblance to persons etc...' the film is clearly a fictionalised version of part of the life of Cynthia Payne (of the Streatham sex-for-luncheon vouchers fame). According to Paul Bailey's more comprehensive and slightly more serious 'real life' version in An English Madam, most of the most outrageous and unbelievable escapades shown in the film are true.
Personal Services charts Christine Painter's rise from waitress to prostitute's landlady and maid, to hostess and brothel-keeper. From her respectable suburban semi she ran 'kinky' sex parties especially for middle aged, elderly and infirm gentlemen: her clients were clerics, policemen, judges and politicians. The women who worked for her were mainly part timers (often with other, quite 'respectable' lives), specialists who did it for next to nothing or not at all if they didn't want to. No riff-raff, criminals or drugs, insisted the real life Payne.
In the film Christine gets away with it at the end - hauled up in court she just gives the judge a wry little wave (he's one of her favourite customers). In real life the customers disappeared and got off scot-free. Payne got a prison sentence. But she came back again waving two fingers at the