Dan Smu (eds), Prosp planet,
THIs Is a u: inflated ano contains surne Inte analysis, parucula, Kaldor. Dan s. Tonatnan Stecie
irritar
thoughtful refle insignts in tos P Soper, anu a u» provucative for Europe In socialist, Jiri Dr Charter 77. It IN prospectus un u opinion and cur END. But what" is spell our eithe uf, or the condi securely habitar.
The mam Is in the book 1s Kaldor right: legitimacv cr people livino she also rigno changes in Burn great importan world. Jir Dien forward a project for a demilitarised, neutral European «une ult re-unified Germany and underwritten bv.. Soviet Umun and By recognising in. the two super-pr grasping the let a trank way Dirn: produced a pr... claim to offer * . habitable Europe. is one of Europe a: and beneficiarv of whose main actor super-Dowers ar could torm the ! serious punutal al
Yet the book ... contributions fron seckine a difteren. Europe: Eurn: ai agent in world per perhaps a vulce of perhaps a uvus on the crude eli super-powers *
nis 1.
mediatui encouri Russians aud te to cease theur dar pointless quarrel least, in EP Thui contribution we ! of a Europe ur tle independent ai nations if ..
Socialist U...... ~
OLIVER MACDONALD and the (apparently non-
European) Russians,
Ukrainians and so on withdrew. Nowhere is this
vision vigorously argued, yet
it is inescapably present in Thompsons's piece.
trelv absent
.. as any
ne problem
act securely wuelmingly a * prain truth
-ases the
REVIEWS
new right - all such notions are extremely harmful to the future of the peace movement.
A Europe without the USSR and without the USA of "independent' nations indifferently capitalist or socialised would be a Europe dominated by West German capital. Thompson should argue the case for this if he supports it. It would also be a Europe of seething tensions between states: Thompson must explain why this would not happen or would not be important. It would also not in fact be 'without' the USSR and the USA, only without (for a while?) their armed forces. Thompson says it would mediate without being a force, a bloc. But how can an 'area' mediate?
Against this vision we would argue the following: for socialist neutralism in Western Europe (or socialist non-alignment), rooted in the labour movements of the region as well as the peace movements; for a socialist 'Helsinki' charter of denuclearisation, and demilitarisation, of massively expanded trade and scientific-technological collaboration, of social and civil liberties across Europe, and of pan-European cooperative trade and aid programmes towards the third world. Far from being excluded from all this the USSR should be drawn into the middle of it. At the same time the socialist-neutralist forces in Western Europe should engage in a vigorous ideological criticism of the Soviet political model and seek to establish a principled dialogue with socialist democrats in the East. The end result of this process would be a united socialist democratic Europe, a federation including the USSR, which would indeed be a 'super-power' in the world, though not a militarist menace. A tall order?
Certainly. And even then only a step towards a securely habitable planet. But the alternative to socialist advance looks increasingly like a Reaganite day of Judgement •
39
planet is today eminently habitable - a 'beautiful
mr other- nan can be -renious and
barbaric violence of the
capitalist classes against the
great mass of people is
absolutely central to the world we live in. - compson does
not see this twentieth century
reality. He puts American
imperialism in quotes, saying
it derives from nationalist
populism in the USA. Yet it
was there before the
Reaganites. Was Nixon a
populist, or Eisenhower?
Also absent is any notion
that the state is an instrument of violence serving class interests. Thompson has reverted to a liberal
populist, or Eisenhower?
NeIt
ing class inson has
...w us the
neutrally reflect the will of
nations and so long as no
nation succumbs to bullying
hine sechn he will of
ideologies like big power nationalism, all states will
tend to live in harmony.
The biggest danger, he tells
us, comes from the existence
of only two power centres. Gain polycentrism in the
Gain polycentrism in the
world and the world will be
safe. On the road to this goal
the European nations can play a big part by freeing themselves from the Russians and the Americans and
becoming what he calls a 'mediating area'. And he
thinks that 'Britain' can do a lot because of language links with the US, a past alliance with the USSR and the Commonwealth!
The irony of Thompson's: view is that while he
Carlos Guarita/Reflex
Hinckley Point
erroneously attributes the source of the cold war to nationalist ideology within the USSR and the USA, he simultaneously himself succumbs to a liberal nationalist conception of international politics. He does not even discuss the socialist, internationalist alternative to his vision.
That socialist alternative begins by refusing to dismiss the class divisions of the world as irrelevant, by recognising what every alert bourgeois takes to be obvious: that there is a great struggle in the world between capitalism and socialism and whatever the nature of and policy of the Soviet leadership, the Soviet Union as a state remains rooted in working class interests. The terrible crimes committed by the Soviet leadership in the past upon its own people and the peoples of Eastern Europe are the burden which all socialists must confront. And political democratisation within the USSR and the Soviet bloc is a fundamental task in making the planet securely habitable. But to equate the USSR and the USA or to imply that it is a matter of indifference as to whether Eastern Europe returns to capitalism or whether the labour movements of Western Europe are crushed by the
40
'WHAT BEGINS as a one-sided political debate unworthy of Bertolt Brecht turns into a verbose thriller without suspense or excitement....A comissar posing as mass-observer, Loach has directed in his hyper-realist style.' (Philip French, reviewing Fatherland in The Observer.)
Ken Loach, perhaps Britain's best known socialist film maker — despite