Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Carry On Cynthia

· Socialist Outlook no. 1, May–June 1987 · p 40 · 597 words

stuffy hypocrites ('V for Victory and Vouchers') to run her sex parties again.

Terry Jones' film gives us a lighthearted look at the British establishment caught with its trousers down - but I'm sure there's something more sinister lurking there than frilly knickers and gymslips. What the film isn't, of course, is a 'shock expose' of why women are faced with so few opportunities for work that, for some, prostitution can be an obvious and sometimes the only option to take. The question it begs is, what is it in society that makes for this depressingly familiar — and ultimately dangerous - selection of re-cycled male fantasies? (because in fact the fetishisation and exploitation of women is what these little boys' tales are made of. But then again there aren't many laughs in that.

However, some of these issues form the background - if not the selling point - of the biography of Cynthia Payne, An English Madam. The story told here by Paul Bailey charts some excruciatingly painful and sad episodes of Payne's early life — the early death of her mother, her cold and critical father, a succession of hopeless men and her struggle to raise her own children with no money and no

support. Cynthia Payne is not a child of the permissive sixties. It was from a stern lower middle class post-war youth (a time when independence for young women could mean nowhere to live and nothing to eat; a time marked for Payne by a real ignorance of sex and its pleasures, and by backstreet abortions), that Cynthia Payne emerged to champion sexual expression - for men and for a price.

In the 1980s when AIDs backlash has given the moralisers the chance to gratuitously read a moral lesson of divine retribution from a public health problem, a film which unashamedly celebrates gratuitous pleasure in sex is quite refreshing.

But the winning and liberated humour of the film is its cover for something more serious and neglected. While for once it is men and their bodies that are being exposed, men that the audience is invited to scrutinise and inspect, this is nevertheless a film that panders exclusively to male sexual interests and values, subtly campaigning for a 'healthy' non-judgmental view of unfettered sexual expression - for men. We are asked to join in and have a laugh, to accept and not to

condemn those men whose sexual needs might be outside the 'norm' , or who need to pa for sex. Fair enough. But the real costs of men's unfettered sexual expression is of course usually met by women.

Both the book and the film largely ignore the stories of the 'girls' -who worked the London streets, paid rent over the odds and pay-offs to pimps, and ultimately paid with their health and independance. In fact by telling the story exclusively from Payne's point of view, they fail to portray prostitution as anything more cheeky than a joke.

Perhaps most importantly, both the book and the film fail to question the serious side to men's "harmless" pleasures in fetishising, humiliating or ridiculing women, that the film in particular glorifies. Personal Services is an enjoyable and witty reply to the eighties moral backlash, and a funny dig at British hypocrisy about sex, but it's all too familiar in its limitations. Like the wave of sixties sexual rebellion that followed the repressive fifties of Cynthia Payne's youth, as a plea for sexual tolerance and even a vision for sexual liberation, there isn't much in it for women

Socialist Outlook No 1 May/June 1987

← Is the future female? · Planetary prospectus →

Something wrong on this page?