Fatherland being his first feature film for eight years — is no stranger to controversy around, or censorship of, his work. His TV productions, A Question of Leadership and The Price of Coal, were never broadcast by the commissioning companies. Recently, his theatre production of Jim Allen's Perdition was hounded off stage before even one public pertormance. Fatherland can at least be seen, but if London's ICA cinema isn't your local and you don't have a progressive independent cinema near you, then you may have to wait some time to see it.
Trevor Griffiths, who wrote the screenplay, also has direct experience of what can happen to radical scripts, with the reworking of his script for Reds for the multi-million dollar Hollywood production.
Fatherland the first collaboration between Loach and Griffiths, has been eagerly awaited.
In the film, dissident singer/song-writer, Klaus Drittemann, refuses to tone down the critical lyrics of his songs in his native East Germany and eventually accepts a one-way visa to the West. He travels via a brief, alienating stay in West Berlin to Britain. A young Dutch journalist accompanies him on his search for his exiled father, a classical musician and former dissident, who left East Germany after the suppression of the strikes in 1953.
The film is structured in three sections: the first, set in East Germany is titled 'Actually Existing Socialism'; the second, in West Berlin, 'Great Freedom Street'; and the final section, set in Britain, 'Stalinism isn't Socialism, Capitalism isn't Freedom'. The narrative, developed around Drittemann's parallel journeys in search of the
ROSS KEITH
SON 1863
SON 1867-
'true' socialism and his father, is interrupted by grainy black and white nightmarish dream sequences.
Fatherland is a dense, complex film which raises big issues: the tasks for socialists in bureaucratised workers' states;
the reunification of Germany; the nature of repression in the West ('repressive tolerance'); the problems of developing oppositional cultural practices in the East (overt repression) and the West (commodification and recuperation); notions of
(our) history and heroic myths; the nature of the family. Arguably, there is too much here to expect any one film to deal with adequately, but Griffiths' script is dialectical and subtle. At times, however, there appears to be a tension between the script and Loach's direction; sometimes this tension works excitingly, such as in the early press conference, or in the late scene where Drittemann eventually meets his father. At other times there is an awkwardness, heavy-handedness even - for example, the party in West Berlin or the Molesworth/miners' picket scenes. The dream sequences, which employ paranoid chase images alongside enigmatic images of a gesturing father, seem laborious.
Drittemann, isolated as he moves through Western landscapes, evokes the melancholic protagonist of many an existential German road move. This is effective at times in making us rethink 'natural' aspects of Western culture. For example, when pressed to sign a recording contract in West Berlin, Drittemann asks for more time as he is unaccustomed to thinking of himself as a commodity.
The scene which perhaps works most forcefully is the father and son reunion. Here, resonances from different strands in the film come together in an extraordinary synthesis of the personal and the political, the past, present and future, myth and reality. The devastating effects of the international machinations of Stalinism as represented here in the crushing of one human spirit are handled in a supremely sensitive way — script, camera and editing working with an intensity that holds the contradictions in uneasy tension; there is no moment of catharsis. Fatherland avoids easy answers to the more difficult questions it poses, and Philip French's derogatory remark about a 'one-sided political debate notwithstanding, should leave its audiences with plenty to think about as they leave the cinema •
Socialist Outlook No 1 May/June 1987
SOCIALIST
OUTLOOK
N° 1 MAYDONE 1987 80P
LABOUR
RETERS!
Union
Need a
YOU
FIGHT FOR SOCIALIST POLICIES
VOTE
LABOUR
SUBSCRIBE!
Annual Subscription rate: (10 issues) • £8.50 for inland subscriptions • £17.00 for inland multi-reader subscriptions • £18.00 for overseas airmail subscriptions, (U.S.$25.00) • £54.00 for overseas airmail multi-reader subscriptions, (U.S.$75.00)
Name
Address
Post Code
Make cheques payable to International Please return to: Socialist Outlook, PO Box 705, London SW2 5UN
INTROD
ING.
MARXIS M
SOCIALISTOUTLOOK
HE LEFT in Britain is under seige. The defeat of the 1984-5 miners' strike gave a new boost to Thatcherism,
and a further twist to the move to the right inside the Labour Party and the trade unions. The move to the right
has cut deep into the Left itself, producing apathy, defeatism, and more and more accommodation to the right
wing. Journals like Marxism Today, New Statesman and New Socialist have all abandoned any pretensions to radicalism. An inauspicious time then to launch a new Marxist journal in the labour movement? We think not.
The move to the right inside the labour movement has taken place against the wishes of tens of thousands who want to stick to socialist principles. SociaLIst OutLook will give a voice to all those who stand by the fundamentals of socialism — the central role of working class struggle, the fight for a democratically plannec economy, the tigh it for workers control, for internationalism and against racial and sexual oppression.
SOCIALIST OuTLook believes that Thatcherism has done nothing to solve the crisis of British capitalism and that British
nsis of British capıulism and that British politics will continue to be in turmoil. We believe that the forces exist — in the Labour Party, the trade unions, among women and black people — to fight back against the right wing tide.
SOCIALIST OuTLook will be an organiser and a weapon of struggle. We aim to produce a magazine of debate and analysis to arm activists in the labour movement and the mass campaigns. We plan in-depth coverage of developments in the unions, the struggle in the Labour Party, of the recomposition of British politics and changes in the British economy and class structure.
uf debate and velopments in L economy and
developments in world politics, and
SOCIALIST OuTlooK will be a journal of Marxist education and debate. We reject the view that Marxism is 'old fashioned' or 'disproved', but believe that only the analytical tools of Marxism can explain the upheavals in world politics.
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK represents the fusion of two Marxist currents in the labour movement, those organised around the magazines International and Socialist Viewpoint. We think the new magazine will be a significant step forward in the fight to build a Marxist movement in Britain.
SOCIALIST OuTLook is being launched in May but will become a monthly in the autumn. We think that a monthly journal is the very minimum that is needed, given the urgency of the political situation and the speed of events. But to have a regular monthly, with the range of coverage that we want and our readers expect, we need money. We need money for full time staff. We need money for typesetting and printing equipment. We need money to improve the quality of our design and production, and the range of our coverage.
e strength of ou
are asking
to subscribe tc (€8.50 for 10 issues)
Name ....
Address ....
I enclose a donation for
-ondon sW2 SUN
r existing support, and the ill our supporters, and all