Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

No room for complacency

· International no. 2, January–February 1986 · pp 18-20 · 2,812 words

Lesbian and gay Trade unions UNISON Miners

Lesbian and gay rights

in the labour movemer

nthe labour movement

ement wr at the TUC conferences. CONWAY, NALGO,

Last Mov

the

achieveme facing

the

Lesbian

in major and Labo THERES a lesbian

the

the

reviews its and

mi

movement

art!

IN 1985, lesbian and gay rights headlines at the TUC and Labour P ferences, with comprehensive re passed at beth. Behind this success s long period of campaigning in the and gay movement and the movement.

Over the last few years, lesbians and gay men have become more vocal in demanding that the labour movement recognize our ex- istence and heed our demands. We have made a series of alliances, most often with other oppressed groups but also with those sections of the left who have come to accept the significance of our struggle. The development of Lesbians and Gays Support the Miners (LGSM) and Lesbians Against Pit Closures (LAPC) both represented and ‹ reated enormous changes. Since the growth of a radical lesbian and gay movement in this country in the early 1970s there have been lesbian and gay hanners on every major picket line and demonstration. But never before has there been the same breadth of support and solidarity among lesbian and gay people for an industrial dispute. This is partly explained by the nature of the miners' strike itself

The existence of LGSM and LAPC made visible the support of lesbians and gay men which would otherwise have been hidden in an assumed heterosexual solidarity move- ment. The groups were able to demonstrate that it was possible to fight the NCB, at the same time as challenging discrimination against lesbians and gay men; and so draw into activity a layer of people who would otherwise have been distanced from the strike.

It was not jus the activities of lesbians and gay men that were different, but the response of the labour movement. Previous- ly lesbian and gay contingents had been met

with verbal and sometimes physical abuse.

Thes attitudes did not disappear instan- raneously. But the depth of the struggle

made people from the mining communities

more reco e to new ideas. ' he length of

• development of the thinn the strike

pti and

hit the :ty con- lutions ory is a lesbian labour

ing system ed betwee licular cor ed our sol ing ready prejudices.

Needless to say that openess and will- ingness to change was most marked among the women and reflected the nature of their own radicalisation during the strite

It was not only at this level that our solidarity was welcomed. The NUM leader- ship. notably Peter Heathfiekd, welcomed lesbian and gay support as i valid and valuable contribution to the struggle. That stance was crucial in holding back a reac- fionary response from the base and in en couraging those who supported us. It was true that the acknowledgement could bave been more prominent and that Women against Pit Closures went further than the NUM itself. Nevertheless the fact that it happened at all is a tribute to that section of the NUM leadership.

meant that strong links were 1 • lesbians and gay men and amunities. Many people wel liarity wi h open arms, while to admit their initial fears

org par- OM- be- and

The motion passed the

TUC will not, indeed

cannot, be fully implemented unless there

are lesbians and gay men organising to do this work

While the significance of LGSM md LAPC should not be underestimated, it is important to understand that they were part of a more general process. Over the past few years lesbians and gay men have become more visible and organised within the Labour Party. They have built a strong nat- tional organisation, the Labour Campaign for Lesbian and Gay Rights (I.CLGR) which was able to organise for the debate at party conference. We have fought to have our needs taken into account in the drawing up of manifestoes to fight council elections. Together with sisters and brothers in the trade unions we have persuaded some Labour councils to adopt comprehensive equal opportunities policies and others to add sections on sexuality to existing agreements. In some places the demand has been raised for the setting up of lesbian and gay subcommittees of the council as an ongo- ing forun for consultation with lesbians and gay men in the community. In some councils worker: have been appointed in strapi e implease" these policies

nirs ichboards aret

Abra hicr

have been men have councillors.

Many of these changes have occurred because of the hard work of lesbians and gay men; but some of the doors on which we have knocked have been less firmly bolted than before. The Labour left which developed after electoral defeat in 1979 understood that the working class did not comprise only white heterosexual able bodied men, and that therefore the Labour Party needed to reach our to the doubly op- pressed. It is not surprising that it was in many of the places where the left held sway that lesbian and gay rights were taken up. The same places set up womens committees, and took initiatives around disability or race. Indeed it is in the field of equal opportunities generally that the face of local government has been most dramatically transformed over the last five years by the rise of this left. There have been difficulties and problems. li is not possible to take up in detail here the debates that have arisen over questions such as Heterosexism Awareness Training. But it is important to acknowledge that such con- troversies have arisen because we are mov- ing very rapidly into unchartered territory - with inadequate discussion as to what we are trying to achieve. Lesbians and gay men are beginning now to confront the argument that heterosexism is based on ignorance not on privilege. We have to explain that our op- pression is not accidental but is a fundamen- tal part of this society, with its sexual divi- sion of labour in the family and in the werkplace. Undoubtedly as these debates develop they will lead to new differentiation both within the lesbian and gay movement and among our allies.

Iver been

ants. 1. selected

•stria

is

fill

and

Despite these limitations, the action of Labour left leaders such as Livingstone and Benn have been crucial in legitimising les- bian and gay rights as an issue for the labour movement. They have had a similar effect to the attitude of the NUM leadership. The fact that the GLC increased its popularity despite its prominence in taking up the issue gives the lie to the notion that lesbian and gay rights is a vote loser. as does the election of a

number of open tainly a whole la came into polit firmly rommiter gay rights, while to carry through

In the trade r big changes. Fir lesbian and gay

I-sbians and gay men. Cer- yer of younger activists who ics during this period are I to advancing lesbian and not always very sure of how this perspective. inions ton, there have beer

the carly 1970s onwards

incuses were set un par

IM

These

International. No c Jammary/februn 19026

were able to intervene into rade union con-

ferences, get some basic policy passed and

launch useful propaganda campaigns — for

example the campaign to get the unions to boycott places such as Scarborough who

refused to let CHE, a prominent lesbian and gay organisation, hold its conference there. These groups did build links with sections of the left particularly around issues such as the content of education in the teaching unions or the treatment of lesbians and gay men by the medical profession. They laid the basis for actions such as the strike by NUT members against the sacking of John War- burton who was dismissed for telling the children he was teaching that he was gay, or similar actions by NAIGO members after Tower Hamlets council sacked lan Davies.

One of the most significant breakthroughs came with the developments in NALGO. Until 1983 the situation was similar to that in other unions. But in 1983 the London District made a decision to organise groups

whose meetings would be open to any member facing a particular discrimination. Thus a lesbian and gay group, along with a women's group and a black members group were set up as an officially sanctioned part of the union structure

The 1983 union conference took place in Douglas on the Isle of Man where all gay male sex is illegal because the 1967 Sexual Offences Act does not apply. NALGO organised the submission of motions to con- ference saying that it was incompatible with NALGOs existing policy on lesbian and gay rights to organise its national conference in such a place. They also organised a large protest demonstration from the Conference to the Manx parliament.

That autumn a national conference for les bians and gay men throughout the union was organised which was supported by the Na- tional Equal Opportunities Committee and therefore had the seal of approval of the General Secretary. The conference claborated a detailed policy motion for sub- mission to the 1984 Annual Conference. It went much further than any previous motion passed by NAL.GO or any other trade union in detailing the steps that should be taken at all levels in the union to combat discrimina tion. Bur perhaps most significantly, it established lesbian and gay groups as an of- ficial part of the unions structures to be en- couraged and consulted.

The fruits of this victory have ben evident. NALGO has produced a national campaign- ing pack on lesbian and gay rights which is available to every branch and every member. A number of schools have been organised at district level on fighting discrimination against lesbians and gay men. Three national conferences for lesbians and gay men have been organised which have been advertised in union publications and through letters to all branch secretaries. NALGO was involved both at the Womens TUC and the TUC itself in the debates on lesbian and gay rights. At the same time, through that official support, NALGO les- bian and gay groups have developed at branch and district level so that there are far more lesbians and gay men contributing to

International, No. :. Jamar/Pebnan 1986

DEFE

ITH WILLIA

FOR GAY RIGHTS AT

MS.

WOR

the discussion on policy than

union.

But again this process has its limitations.

Developments in London are far more ad- vanced than elsewhere, and this creates dif- ficulties in taking forward the discussion. The right wing in the union has always been hostile to these developments, and is now feeling strong enough on the NEC to begin to challenge them.

Regrettably the gains made in NALGO have not been repeated elsewhere. The mo- tion passed at the TUC will not, indeed can- not, be fully implemented unless there are lesbians and gay men organising to do this work. The National Association of Probation Officers which submitted the motion has on- ly just affiliated to the TUC and is just developing an equal opportunities structure. NALGO will obviously be heavily involved but cannot take on the full responsibility. The LOLGR understands that it has a role to play in the trade unions but this area of its work is very underdeveloped. It will be necessary for LOLGR to grasp this nettle, and to find ways of working with existing trade union lesbian and gay groups if the achievements of 1985 are to come to fruition.

We must not be complacent. Lesbians are losing custody of their children daily in the courts solely because of their sexuality. Gay men and lesbians are harassed by the police, including by agents provocateurs, and this will increase further with the new Public Order Bill. The Customs and Excise have at- lacked Gays the Word and other bookshops. preventing the sale of literature which presents positive images of lesbians and gays. And the press hysteria around AIDS has increased harassment & lesbians and gay men in the workplace and on the streets

in any other

The question of AIDS provides a fairly ac- curate marker as to where we have got in the labour movement. On the one hand the left bureuacracy has taken some steps to raise the health and safety issues and the question of resources in a crumbling health service which are raised by the disease. But they have been extremely reluctant to confront directly the way lesbians and gay men are being victimised by other trade unionists. Some good literature has been produced par- ticularly by NALGO and NUPE, but it is necessary to go beyond this and into the workplace to confront ignorance and prejudice.

The period achievement local government was one when the left in the labour party was on the ascendant and seem- ed united. The disintegration of the struggle against ratecapping, the victory of the Tories over abolition and now Kinnock's attacks on the left make further gains at this level much more difficult. The defeat of the miners strike has had profound implications for every single political struggle. Over the next period, leading up to the general election there will be increasing pressure to drop fi- inge issues' and concentrate on returning Labour at all costs.

The task of defending the gains of lesbians and gay men in the labour movement is a task that the left has to take on board, as part of an alternative strategy to that of Kinnock. Implementing Labour Party and TUC policy should be raised through every trade union branch, and in every constituency Labour Party. Lesbian and gay rights has to be more than the flavour of the month, it has to be understood as an ntegral part of the struggle for socialism.

17

18

TI

WOI

FE

THE FiNANCIAl deal conc between Liverpool city er banks represents an enor struggle waged in the imposed spending 1 criticisms should be mac city council and its Milit: is no doubt where the pr for this defeat lies — w trade umon leaderships in their power to sabo struggle, and with the other rate-capped and councils, who with Lambeth capitulated when the crunch came

The response of the party to the NEC: eng District Labour Party whether or not expuls from the enquiry, the witchhunting one, whic ground for expulsions

luded in Vovember suncil and the Swiss mous defeat for the city against Tory- imits. Whatever le of the role of the int leadership, there imary responsibility ith the Labour and who did everything lage the Liverpool leaderships of the

heavily penalised the exception of

the Tory attack

SC

15 ions whol h wi

ry

left int

'wirl lisgrace. irectly

prepar future

111

th Xx

expulsions directly result

lor sult IS a the

date.

Whether they like it Labour Co-ordinati plicit with the witcl the party must now Liverpool Labour I there are important the role of the city stem directly from tant's political line struggle.

or not. Tribune and the ng Committee are com- 1 hunt. Socialists within close ranks to defend the "arty. Having said that, criticisms to be made of

council; many of them the limitations of Mili and conception clas:

The first phase of the The Militant-led Labr of the council in May disastrous financial Liberals. Since 1979. most deprived cities 1270m in government were faced with a sit needed cither to raise cent, or make cuts tot alternatively to fight. decided to fight.

Substantial job losses would have been a disaster for Liverpool; already the Liberals had cut 4000 jobs in the city since 1979. The response of the council was to make a deficit budget for 1984/5, which, however, involved i 9 per cent rate rise.

When the council made their first budget ip April 1984 there could be no doubting the enormous popularity of their stand. On the day that the council decided the budger, the streets of the city were thronged with tens of thousands of workers demonstrating their support for open defiance of the Tories. In the May 1984 council elections, with a third of the scats being contested, Labour increas- ed their representation from 51 to 58 seats against a combined total of 4l for the Liberals and the Tories.

The budget which had been doubtedly illegal, and coukd challenged as such in the court spring and early summer of !! paign aga ist rate capping Wils

struggle sur Group took ontrol 1983. They inherited a

situation from the Liverpool, one of the in Europe, had lost aid. Thus the council uation in which they

the rates by 170 per alling 5000 jobs — or

To their credit they

set have . But 34 the e gett

the

«lIl Init

198

thon to be

CANCHLORS 1989

Liverpool Labour councillors on the march

The

← Glyn's economics and socialist strategy · The defeat in Liverpool →

Something wrong on this page?