Glyn's economics and
socialist strategy
In the first issue of International,
ssue
published a sho Andrew Glyn's Campaign Group pamphlet 'A Million a Year' . Our the pamphlet right-wing NEC, but only hinted at differences which revolutionary Marxists would have with Glyn's approach. We continue the debate here contribution by FINDLAY.
rt review
of
Jok
review welcon
ed
let as a riposte to the statements of the only hinted at the
with a JEAN
REGISTERED UNEM MENT the UK rurrently running at 32
hon and expected by most forecasters to be around million for the next four years. This means that discounting any pre-election reflation which the Tories may try to engineer, any Labour government elected in the next few
in mil
unemployment
million and unemployment important issue government wil therefore it must to bring down within one term
years
will
come i
figures of around rising. Conseque will be the single
which a future Li
have to deal with begin now to prepare unemployment drast of office.
nto
office with
real
four nily, most abour
and plans ically
mornalty ne present leadership nas already abandoned any attempt to do this. Roy Hattersley, in a speech last year (Financial Times 26/9/95) announced that Labour would not be able to 'indulge' in a 'dash for growth'. Far from 'indulging in a luxury' socialists should be emphasising that bringing down unemployment is an absolute necessity, and any failure to make a serious attempt to do so within the life of the next parliament will serve to deepen the apathy and mistrust felt by many unemployed people, especially youth, towards the Labour Party and could lead to greater social unrest of the type seen recently in Birmingham and London.
The statement by the NEC to the 1985 Labour Party conference con ains Hattersley's proposed employment and industria policy - which subsequent statemen have begun to water down already. The measures outlined in the statemen are quite simply insufficient
Hattersley - architect of Labour's future economic policy?
deal with the deep-seated crisis which the economy is now in, even if they were implemented fully. The proposals mark a clear shift away from a policy of large-scale nationalisation of major sectors of the economy — a move which has not gone unnoticed or unwelcomed by the capitalist press (cf Economist 28/9/85, FT 27/9/85) — and a move towards a policy of encouraging
co-operatives and 'semi-private' small-scale
manufacturing units as an example of real social ownership'
The main feature of Hattersley's policy is the setting up of a National Investment Bank to provide long-term investment finance for industry. The NIB would be funded by the repatriation of funds currently invested overseas and by requiring a certain
proportion of all pension fund and company investment portfolios to NIB loan stock. The stock which used to force financial institutions with these regulations would be th withdrawal of fiscal privileges, concessions.
The investmen
i funds used to
insurance consist of
would be to comply e threat of
e. tax
created by regenerate
such a British
manufacturing industry and to rebuild our industrial base. This, of course, is fine as far as it goes, except that it is extremely unlikely that the financial institutions are going to allow themselves to be forced into the scheme. As the Economist (29/9/85) points out, technological advances in telecommunications mean that capital market flows are instantaneous and global, therefore if a general election were to be held this Thursday, most of the investment funds Mr Hattersely wants to reclaim would be registered in overseas funds as early as Friday night. The idea of all those dealers poised over their computer terminals waiting for Vincent Hanna to give them the word on election night may seem far-fetched, but it is precisely what would happen.
The current Labour leadership seem to have no answer to this, apart from saying that at least we will save on tax concessions. This would be small compensation for the drastic reduction in investment which would occur at a time when UK investment in manufacturing is already far below that of its main competitors in fact the lowest of any OECD country.
Internator
Internannal Do amateur 10
The ma do menth:
i saling. Interest rates pasted u funds we dier competed
Clearly then, the to come up with Campaign Croup-st Million Jobs a Year Andrew Glyn is a direction. This pamph studied by all sociali: beginning of the deba
While there will agreement with mar contained in this pa number of problems w all the discussion of ho created there is very li kinds of jobs and who By which 1 mean th simply concerned existing structure of en on a larger scale. We ensure that the frui should be divided equa are presently disadvan and pay should be gis any jobs created.
Converse,, an arca puts too touch stress dispel worries about a to a massive increa outlines how we wor inflationary expansion While I am not against
ratee of the poured.
ilie hire worth
scotties agained loose of the hardespe
As nir site ass of me bored.
Inic way depr
bite s192 i banks
Clearly, then, the defi has a esponsibility
Sone it were
be ()xte
major let shoul sts, but lc.
111 Isnl
The
DIN thi:
probabl ly of t mphlet, ith it. He. •w jobs ar tle spare is going 1a1 socia vith uploymes
should
of all
y and ti
ager in
in their
pro re stan ing 'en get
ing K1 V uyi xpa hosi 18 0)
shi
najor osals re a e, in to be o the hem.
not
caith 1g 10 ision
who jobs re of
expansion
is ny se uld diu.
d Suisn
price co
which
in a in in
ink 'pri ion
Glyn 15 (r) sling
He
SU
nfl would engineer a non-
ric
111
is l
101) - rols hink
it would be better pe question from another both Labour and Tor made the running in co inflation is the mos problem. However, evidence to suggest tha
fi..h...i....
Th
aps to ngle. goverı incing seriol *re
Vc:
ST
ik a tOO nts ker 'cor TOS igh
the long lave that ›mic
no vels
or macon are cosuy. standards of those oi should index-link the uncompetitive compa parters, we should lov
Only variable inflatir academic economists costs by creating unc discouraging private-se we only have to look i levels to see that we
11
11 ane fixed
lu
the e has be
entai ainty or inve
not rel
ne l
take
nge lov bsti
the ent iest 1 Dr
*111
ver Only variable inflation has been showa by
1 C1
erti
:Ct.
It (
‹cl
> w0 Sn s. aimg rate. vn by irial reby . But ment ivate
sector investmer costs of inflation of index-linking changing prices i as Glyn correcti phenomenon of with efficiently 1 and a pubiie increase pi eliminated.
Another in his appa nationalis nationalisin he seeins e planning industry n by
any are thi
and 1 a supe
ca the
TIll
'y. 11 dmint
phys larkets
out i
ks m1i malise
The only real
2.11
SO)
real costs its of : case
is a
and
trie.
poi
silence with efficiently run nationalised industries
thesiment
gons is
pply. indus
pe granne
in his apparent shymg away beem talleal
Another weak pome in kilyne malpis a
Whils i
ren atie
ont gr th:
10:
hanks
(cle industry will ens agree teng policed
ame fi
lic!
the
11he
alastries modded only be taken into potitio
!0! iled
$1e00 I1S attentie amplemure plens, Trave true
frustra successful government amitted investment: expansio
Gilyn dismisses de arg' bring lanen out of the er through the use of electre money' on the basis that nuclear war we would exchange controls, so it Surely he can see that Br tish capital has ar
ibe: o the
with the
gNes
« ha
bul
111
rial it ny
(:) IT: apital
abo
investment and expansion.
iment abo ›untry imı onic transn if there wi SOOn
be
tio
lte
stu rest
ut capital nediately rission of is a non-
effective possible. n where
taking
Salvador Allende - is Glyn's the Chilean road!
richar lutire The that indu such comes.
To come back
an carlit reason why it is so crucial that any expand the economy and create jobs 1 seen to be in the interests of al! w including black workers. women and
abom gor situation we workers in t stry are organ a movement
the crument would would be facin he finance an ised and ready of rapital whe
work is
situate
be facing. ig require: • banking 1o prevent
the time
poi
ni. the plan to nust be orkers. vouth
is because we need to organise in defence of the plan. Only b mos ement mass action would fond off the kind of onsla genernment would face.
What appears to underly sor
di's anales to his fai
Hely the mobilisatio
requied to
these workers y sold labour
able to ugh such
in Gly adequately which
workers
dh would be required to can thanagh
kind of cooperie pocks persons lo wires luil rado thent diss !!....
. 11:
Stepment canoded in even dr Kind of
in Clone pamphlet
politi ...pit.e
cristantee to soriade policies would foes fora its des: inception a massive attark by
Ciliti
This rank
abi! of i
only
tion r sition.
unfronted
• working o and
10 lutak t
capitalis
every field. would quie swerping measures workers ontrol and supervision of industry and the banks to prevent sabotage, the closure of plante and the massive political campaign which the ruling class would wage
The real character of the government would be tested in such a confrontation. A genuine workers' government would mobilise the working class to impose power on the capitalists. But a left reform government, like the Allende government Chile, would rely on the institutions of t capitalist state to break he mobilisation the workers.
Maybe Andrew Glyn agrees w But Tony Benn's reartion when i on Newesnight abour the Gilvn exposed the ambiguit at the heat position. Benn argue multinationals and the big un be forced to collaborate witt agreements. This is naivety
The British ruling class, backed s United States and the EEC, would nount the most furious resistance to even compulsory planning agreements, le alone full-scale nationalisation. It is not a question of forcing the capitalists to collaborate but ol mobilising the working da to break their power once and for all
Here we see a qunt inescapable logic imposir say 'A million jobs a ye directing the investment basis of human need and capitalist profit. Then you nationalisation of the financia. big monopolies. You also I sliding scale of wages and workers control
In other words, you have to completeh override che functioning of the capitalis economy. And that leads you slap bang int a confrontation between the classes, decisive test of strength between Capital and Labour. Once you say 'a' , then you have to say 'b' and 'c' '. all the way to the barricades.
Now I am all in favour of the project of proposing a plan for the new Labour government to get full employment. througl sweeping soicalist measures Through: fighting for such a socialist econome plan me can begin to explain what it would real take 10 get people back to work, outside of a new capitalist boom. But Marsists cannot be
likr the Militant, to imply that
mpl series of measures legislated
diament would be end ugh. Onh
the dynannie of the struggle for
marol, which leads in ably to
ruggi ith the capitalist stat
gislat is be imposed
The plic , of this argu
of
in he
ith all th
nterview
pamph
of Glyi
that thi poles could he planning
exposed the ambiguity at the heart of Glyn's
nevitable self. Once
then you capital on the bas
have to
Si
ar .
of not
sort lave
bene
•fits
and
yOu
sal!
the
sof
sav I the
! it and
Pa
nothing purside of a determined attache ¡apitalion and its institations will start to sole de problem of enemploycame. Mr shade chant this logic. I i sadle cur
HiVE
positin
15