defeat in Liverpool
Tragedy and farce
began to make itself felt. By the summ r 1984 the council was faced wi a chie cither to make a deal with the governme involving concessions on both sides, in situation in which the Pories were under pressure to compromise, or to go for a full- scale confrontation, an all-or-nothing battle. In the end, in July 1984 the council decided a deal involving a large package of govern- ment aid in return for a 17 per cent rate increase.
Given that Liverpool do cluding somet working class.
60 per cent of household not pay rates, probably hing like 80 per cent of the this deal could not be called a
$ in
in-
Carlos Augusto Guarita/Reflex
Derek Hatton - a lot on his
lind
full gear, and Tories feared a the defiant cou resulted in send all-out strike by ported around preferred to bic
Nonetheless.
a deficit bu
there is no dou that the head-on collision with any of ncils; a collision could have ing in commissioners, and an council workers, widely sup-
the country The Tories e their tune bra Live get. litt
Nonetheless, because Liverpool's budget
the
lal
's be
ISIS
get
savage attack on working class living dards. But its tactical wisdom must be to question. The reason is simple: if was a time to go into confrontation wit Tories it was surely during the mi strike. at ime when mass enthusias
Stan- open there h the ners' m in
Liverpool height.
for
the
defiance strategy was
at its
As against rate-capped to support Li have been in that they had ed the financ another dav'
inat, ine readmess or me omer nd heavily penalised councils verpool in such a move ru
doubt, for the simple reason by no means themselves reach- ial crunch. The live to fight annrach of the Inlv 1984 deal
was based heavily on the assumption that in spring 1985, when all the rate-capped coun cils simultancously adopted a 'no tion, Liverpool would be in a n better situation to fight As we shall • this
shall see this
en re be rs jin its
jer ils 161 on
ht :al lin
.er
rdon Reflex
assumpton honourable no real will
was ill founded excepton of lambet for a showdown with the
With
h, there
Tr
the • Was ries.
1985 — increasing isolation Liverpool city council again decided on a deficit budget strategy for 1985. Teet pically, this was again illegal, or subjert dor being declared illegal, but the governme decided to bide its time and face down he rate- capped councils which had declar 1 for the 'no rate strategy. If carried our, the 'no rate strategy would have had the effect of confronting the government with around a dozen councils going into illegality, and eventually with no option but to send in commissioners and face the inevitable strug- gle and storm. But it seems likely that among those leaders who declared for this strategy of illegality there was at least an clement of bad faith. They doubtless hoped that the very threat of mass defiance would force the government to back down and make a deal.
But Thatcher and Jenkin were not so cast- ly bluffed. They counted on two things: first, that if they refused to budge, a series of council leaders like Livingstone, Hodge and
Blunkett would eventually cave in, and se- cond that where there were leaders deter- mined to fight like Hilda Kran in Hackney, they would have difficulty keeping their ma jority for defiance in their own Labour
groups. This assessment proved a sound
The ignominious capitulation a the GL.C
was pivotal in determining the course of
events. Livingstone, in proposing the setting
of a maximum rate instead of urging con-
tinued defiance as did John McDonell, was
able to present himself as the 'realist . Alter
all, he could argue, there was no real majori
ty in GH.C , given the spli the Labour
grou a the no rate opt y wouldhav
was
•pel
lity
If Wat strategy, then Lavingston for it anyway and precip GLO: Labour group. TI the responsibility for the wing of the Labour gree have resigned as GLO: l take responsibilty for ( Hilda Kean in Hackney. sent out the worst pos
11 he insibi there
11? SS.
nt:
14
ical
i det nee
have voted
crisis in the
ki have put
at on the right
le should then
and refused to he debacie, as cd
By capitulating, he sible message at realisni read: so
Itated a 1s Wou deic
aden
crucial time - render) woukd sabotage by the Labour groups.
As the othe penalised coun one. Liverpoo But the Milit were running making whe workforce. The city NAI.GO workers taken scheme and the around £10 per ton's comment workers in this right arm for a strong imphcati ple should be si not exactly conc the unions.
But much disastrous Sam ment of Milita
would prevail in the face of the
that realism' prevail in che f right-wing minor
-.I1 he he
Pi
bega one, Liverpool became increasingly isolated.
Igi!
•ade were running into problens of their own
rship i ecl the
Wn
'That
WilS branch ab
under 1 downgra‹
werk in w that there
disi Ino the led. SaSE
are
the
• with the
group of
b creation
th a loss of • Derek Hat- thousands of
chry wno job of anv on that the
would give meir kind' - with the downgraded peo-
itisfied lucive
with their lot - • good relations
was with
more important
Bond affair. The
pporter Sam
nt su
was the appoint- Bond as
race relations advisor was a slap in the face to the black community in the city, and drove a wedge beiween Militant and many Labour left supporters who had backed council without supporting Militant H duracy in the face of the ou ry only worsened this mistake.
Hatton's ob-
in
- (10) cit
"There could be no doubting he enormous popularity of the
Council's stand...'
do popularit 's stand.
bti
TI
Sam Bond
affai
some ng ragne at toe proach a manipul mass support for the beginning to take this and set their face democratic structures 1 decisions were taken it Their manipulative. 12 lantan approach culmir decision in September ...nl.fo.r
ative attitude the council. They were support for granted, against any open, o the campaign. Real i the Militant caucus. ndemocratic and sec- lated in the ludicrous
1985 to declare the Thin une
workorce regunual. not subject to any disc
Ine WOrKIO ton and M it to Bake promptly conference
The re alicnated t
rio the ar
ree memseives. Dyl ulhearn loaded a gu r and Kinnock - fired itat the
ussion (
scrutiny by :....:. 11...
i and handed and Kinnock abour Party
he SUll
WI
ision
11k
Coll ether
leade
iletel
bac
into the arms of their own union leaders and
Labour leadership limb-down compromise.
The union leaders and ine A Metropolitan Authorities sponse duction of the Stonefrost report up with a package of measures the city. This involved making 1! rially viable again through a rise, borrowing, and a partial ce of its spending funds which
ssociation of ored the pro- which came for "saving' le city finan- limited rare ‹pitalisation'
would have
nad the enect of am ng tae nouse o programme. The only alternative Stonefrost approach would have bee the city run out of money, « so a strike in the ely and pre commissioners
There is workfor 1985
111
milding to this
"gal pare
1 to let yeneral ety the
There is no guarantee that the council workforce, in the circumstances of autumn
• agreed
that
1
counci amlan
alg'
Bond
ffai
di
stro
But it shoukd have the democratie decision. The factors workine against it were of cou
the council w now nearly isolated its defiance of the government. If the counci workforee had voted against this kind of mass action to defeat the government's spending limiis, then the council should have accepted some variation of the Stonefrost report as the best compromise which could be achieved. What happened in fact was that the council presented the workforce with the ultimatum of accepting the redundancy notices. When this ploy failed, it then reverted to its deal with the Swiss banks which it had been negotiating for months.
It has to be said that in the medium and long term the Swiss banks deal is infinitely worse than any variant of the Sconctros report. As the debts and interest charges mount up, it will have a devastating effect on the capital spending programme. Militan have been forced back into waiting for a Labour government to bail them out — the precise opposite of what they sought eo achieve, and indeed what all the other coun ‹ il leaders are now relying on. It is a sorry end to a campaign that won such suppor among the people of Liverpool
in
)UI he•
Vultures By alienating their own workfore che coun eil leadership have now opened hemselves up to attack from all sides. Kinnock and the Labour NEC are determined to exact max- imum revenge. Reactionary forces in the ci- ry, supported covertly by the Tories and Liberals, have organised Liverpool Against Militant, which has organised big rallies. The stage must now be set for an eventual defeat of Labour at the polls, and the regaining of the council by the Liberals or a Liberal-Tory coalition. This would be a disaster for the people of Liverpool. But if it happens, despite Militant's sectarianism, those responsible will be all hose who obstructed a serious fight over 1 decapping, frst and foremos the Kinnock leadership
19
mpressions. rational and US hegemon
Wars, it
cond
trategic
depict
to most
irration
about US mi superiority. But, argues OLIVER MACDONALD, these are mistaken
iew of the United States, Star Wars h
- the re-establishment and maintena e. MacDonald here charts
, and the crucial role
nfluence Eu
The Wars either
From the point of deadly political logic y in Western Europ
f the su
of
outcome ( American
wer
mmi
and
Defence people - al or solely
lati often
1 maintenan( the course of of NATO
20
Star Wars and the summit
The struggle for western Europe
WITH THE EXCEPTION of a single article (by the former director of Chatham House in The Times), the vast press outpouring on the Geneva