Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

BL victimisation

Socialist Viewpoint no. 7, September 1985 · pp 11-12 · 1,252 words

Hard Labour

for BL?

THIS pamphlet ought to be subtitled "Planning the Unplannable". It presents the problem as simply lack of sales by the motor industry in Britain, and tries to offer solutions which make no real changes.

This should be no surprise, considering the pamphlet is written by Patrick Gray, a right wing academic from Oxford Labour Party, who had a brief sojourn in manual work at British Leyland's Cowley Body Plant. It is warmly weicomed by Neil Kinnock, and undoubtedly reflects the thinking of Labour's current leadership.

Gray outlines the well-known decline of the industry. In the early 1970g motor maufacturing represented 11% of industrial output in Britain: today it accounts for only 4%. But the whole thinking of the document begins from an acceptance of the current situation and trying to make minor adjustments.

Ford and other multinationals, he points out, are importing many more cars: yet he is also at pains to praise these firms — in case they might im agine a Labour government would be hostile to them!

Gray predictably sees the answer as Imposing some kind of "control" on the market while leaving these multinationals and the capitalist system Intact. The most obvious line is for import controls.

An obvious difficulty here is that the very nature of the world's motor industry is that the big firms need to

A stockpile of BL Maestras. "Labour and the Motor Industry" (Jobs and Industry Campaign consultative document). Published by the Labour Party, £1.75. Reviewed by an Austin Rover export in order to get the benefit of large scale production. If this does not occur, the industry will die. There is so much overproduction of motor vehicles (in market terms) in Europe that any firm which does not export on a massive scale must go to the

Gray cannot confront this contradiction. So his document calls both for import controls in Britain, and for an increase in exports of "British" cars! As if other capitalist countries are going to accept this in order to allow the British (capitalist) car industry to survive at the expense of that in West Germany, France, Italy or elsewhere!

This is clearly no solution, even in hedges its bets and retreats even from speculating on what might happen "ll temporary controls on motor industry imports do become necessary

So right wing is this pamphlet that African "unfair trading" as providing an "unjustified obstacle to the expanSocialist Viewpoint, No. 7, September 1985, Poge 11 sion of Britain's exports" (though the South African police gave been some of the most loyal consumers of BL land-rovers and other vehicles).

In fact there can be no solution within the capitalist framework for the crisis of overproduction, other than an attempt to salvage one capitalist company by driving others to the wall.

Import controls are a nationalist solution. They mean siding with your "own" capitalist class against the "foreign" capitalists of Japan, France or Italy. They mean demanding that workers in another country be put out of work.

This is not an abstract question. It has to be drawn out to its logical conclusion, because it cannot save" the workers who embrace the policy. In fact the oniy real way to drive your "foreign" competitors out of business is by cheapening the commodity you produce. Behind the nationalistic. flag-waving facade of import controls lie the vicious speed-up, job loss and wage cutting of management rationalisation.

Gray's pamphlet makes the point that a good quality family saloon car sells for only £3,000 in Japan. This highlights the real "trade barrier"; the level of exploitation of Japanese car workers.

Yet the document draws the logical conclusion, that "we too need the Japanese "highly efficient production systems"

"It is a matter of fully utilising human skills in management, in supervision, and on the shop floor."

Of course all actual production takes place "on the shop floor". It is a neat political trick - not unlike admiring the "productivity" of the slaves who built the pyramids - to describe the incredible shouldered by Japanese workers as "utilising human skills",

The reason is that Patrick Gray and the Labour leaders have fully accepted what has already happened in the British motor industry. There has use of Japanese methods of organisation of producand a closer approach to Japanese levels of exploitation. But Patrick Gray no longer has to work in a car factory, so it doesn't bother him that the agreements which gave workers paid time to prepare for work and wash-up afterwards have been crapped. He does not care that they now have to come to work earlier and go home later; that they get fewer reliet breaks; and that as breakdowns become less frequent and more efficiently covered the whole workforce is driven harder and longer each

JaKlongside this speed-up

greater exploitation have come attacks on union organisation. Capitalist companies cannot allow interruptions in production if they are going to compete. This is why BL has series of victimisations from Derek Robinson and the Longbridge

8, through to Alan Thornett and now Bob Cullen at Cowley

Gray gets around the question of industrial relations by saying they are "outside the scope" of the document: but his references to it make it clear he is proposing giving more information to unions but not control. He is certainly not looking at a full restoration of the union rights crushed in BL since 1978, which must include the reinstatement of the abovementioned workers victimised under the Tory government.

This is not surprising. The pamphlet is a propaganda text, and not designed to deal with the real blems faced by car workers. continuously praises the record of previous Labour governments. He ignores the fact that it was Labour who first and lan MacGregor on the British workers' movement!

The super-exploitation of BL workers and the weakness of their trade unions dates from then. Will we see more such appointments under a Kinnock government?

Gray's pamphlet is so right wing and much angled towards businessman's audience that it doesn't make a single even vaguely radical proposal. At most guarantees to give BL some more money for investment.

It says that BL has been weakened by hiving-off Jaguar: but it makes no call to renationalise Jags. Instead It proposes to keep the "Golden Share"

in order to maintain Influence: yet even the Tories are not proposing to get rid of this!

Is this the future Labour enviseages for all the companies privatised by the Tories? Are they all to remain in private hands?

No matter how many glib words are radical policy ot nationalisation of the uttered about planning"

whole motor industry its suppliers and distributors, would ofter any real chance to plan its operation. This would also imply a nationalisation of the banks and financial institutions, to whom vast interest payments are still being made.

Control of the nationalised in dustries must be in the hands of the workers, as part of a planned socialist economy: on the basis of this kind of example alliances and links can be made with car workers and their struggles in other countries. Instead of a nationalistic alliance with

"British" employers, cutting the throats of more workers at home and abroad, there must be working class action aganist every section of the capitalist class — beginning with our

"own" exploiters at home.

That means rejecting the Labour leadership's approach as spelled out in Gray's pamphlet, and adopting instead socialist policies for the car industry and every sector of industry in

Britain.

← Hard Labour for BL? · Unfairly sacked: but Tribunal "no" to reinstatement →

Something wrong on this page?