The Bureaucracy
that lost its ari
Things began to unravel for Hungarian leader Rakosi from the time of Stalin's death in March 1953. The change of leadership in the Kremlin was a protracted and uneasy process which disrupted Rakosi's close links with the Soviet leadership. Worse, the break in the continuity of repression, and marginal conessions made by the new Kremlin rulers to contain demands for sweeping changes, encouraged critical voices backed up by the reappearance of former show- trial victims from labour camps.
Summoned to Moscow to meet the new ruling circle, Rakosi was closely questioned on his simultaneous role as Party General Secretary and Prime Minister. He would neither hand over one of the posts nor suggest a deputy.
In June 1953 came the Berlin uprising, riots at Pilsen in Czechoslovakia and strikes and demonstrations in Hungary itself. An alarmed Kremlin leadership, fearing that Rakosi's brutal repression was storing up an explosion of revolt, ordered him to hand over the Prime Minsterial post to Imre Nagy, who in Moscow's eyes had the advantges of being a reliable Muscovite with a popular base, not involved with Rakosi's excesses, and - unlike Rakosi and his sidekick Erno Gero — not Jewish. Nagy outlined a substantial plan for reforms of the economy, and began moves to close down its internment camps with their 100,000 political prisoners.
Nagy's handicap was that he was seen as linked politically with Malenkov - a fading star in the Kremlin constellation, whose more "liberal" line of economic development emphasising consumer goods and improved living standards was echoed for 18 months under Nagy in Hungary.
The boat was also rocked in Hungary by the publication in autumn 1953 of an account by the Communist poet Kucska of the conditions in the collectivised countryside: Rakosi had presided over a collectivisation strategy that had been opposed within the party leadership by Imre Nagy at the time.
Rakosi never accepted or co- operated with his new Prime
Mi: chi Na lea the in !
unl che hai
ast Gernan youth resist in nister: in early 1955 the climate anged and enabled him to sack gy — who was hounded from the dership and later expelled from : Party — and appoint Erno Gero his place.
Vagy's reforms however had leashed far greater pressure for ange than Rakosi and Gero could adle. Thousands of political
returned to 1L
prisoners nau returned to inelr families confirming the horror of the Rakosi police regime; peasants had been able to withdraw from co- operatives and return to private farming; overtime and Sunday working had been cut for industrial workers.
Encouraged by these concessions, circles of intellectuals had begun to organise and demand academic freedom - and this was not simply switched off by the ousting of Nagy.
1953
The factor which most decisively pulled out the rug from under Rakosi was Khruschev's move to consolidate his domination over the Kremlin leadership with his famous "Secret Speech" to the 20th Soviet Party Congress in February 1956.
Among the revelations which rocked the assembly of bureaucrats was Khruschev's denunciation of Stalin's split with Tito:
"The 'Yugoslav affair' contained no problems which could not have been solved through party discussions among comrades. There was no significant basis for the development of this 'affair'; it was completely possible to have prevented the rupture of relations with that country."
(in The
256)
(in The Stalinist Legacy, Penguin,
This left Rakosi - the executor of Rajk and jailor of other leading Hungarian Communists for alleged collaboration with the "fascist" Tito - out on a limb.
The following month, Rakosi was forced to admit that the 1949 show trial had been a gigantic frame-up. As Rakosi lost the confidence even of sections of his police apparatus, a new ferment animated the intellectual and journalistic circles, but reaching even army officers and technical workers. Rajk's widow, Julia, emerged from obscurity to demand that her husband be rehabilitated.
Struggling to retain his grip on the Party leadership, Rakosi made a few economic concessions to opponents, and released some of the country's political prioners, while making vicious political attacks on the intellectual circles which had become the main focus of opposition to the regime.
His days were clearly numbered, and an anxious Moscow leadership intervened to replace Rakosi with his no less objectionable and unpopular sidekick Erno Gero.
Meanwhile the Polish workers had erupted into mass strikes and demands for reforms. By the autumn of 1956 this example had spilled over to Hungary, with a 100,000-strong demonstration called in Budapest on October 23, at least partly in solidarity with the Polish movement. It was far from politically homogenous, with some workers and students carrying pictures of Lenin, other pictures of the former Prime Minister Imre Nagy. The Internationale and the Marseillaise were sung; but there was unity on one level — a gigantic statue of Stalin was pulled to the ground!
When Gero hit back by broadcasting a stinging attack on the demonstrators,
angry crowds converged on the radio station - only to be fired upon by the hated secret police, the AVH. The fighting spread, and Soviet troops garrisoned in Hungary moved in.
The next day saw the start of a general strike, with the fighting and upsurge spreading beyond Budapest to the provinces. Nagy (with reluctant Mooscow acquiescence) took over for a second term as Prime Minister.
Nagy did not call for the immediate withdrawal of the Soviet troops; nor did he make a clean break with the old Stalinist regime. But while failing to meet the demands of the workers, he made a gesture towards the right by including two leaders of the suppressed right wing Smallholders Party in his government.
Meanwhile the workers had begun to sense the potential power in their hands, and rapidly organised themselves into workers' councils challenging the control of the hopelessly bureaucratised ruling Party;
"In the space of forty-eight hours all the factories in the country had their elected councils. and at the moment of the ceasefire (November 29) several central councils. representing the workers of a whole town or department were formed, in particular at Miskolc. Magyarovar and in certain suburbs of Budapest."
Midlos Molnar, Budapest 1956)
On October 321 a Parliament of Workers Councils for the whole of Budapest spelled out the extent of the frontal challenge to the power of the ruling bureaucracy, and the extent to
CUBA
Radical face
of Stalinism
If you thought the only choices on Cuba were to support Castro or support Ronald Reagan, then you should read Cuba Radical Face of Stalinism.
Dissecting the politics and evolution of the Cuban leadership this book reasserts the need for a Trotskyist party and pro- gramme in Cuba, and presents the events firmly in their global context.
Copies available now (£5.00 including postage) from Left View books, Box 3956, London WCIN 3XX
(bove) Stali
The ruins
which the leading layers of workers saw the revolution as taking their nationalised economy under their own control. A statement on the basic rights and responsibilities of workers' councils ,contained nine points, beginning
"1) The factory belongs to the workers. The latter should pay to the state a levy calculated on the basis of the output and profits. 2) The supreme controlling body of the factory is the Workers' Council, democratically elected by the workers. (...) 4) The director is employed by the factory. The director and the highest employees are to be elected by the Workers' Council. (...) 7) In the same way the Workers' Council resoives any conflict concerning the hiring and firing of all workers employed in the enterprise. 8) The Workers' Council has the right to examine the balance sheets and decide the use to which the profits are to be put...
Lomax,
Hungary emphasis
1956, added)
If tanks in Poznan, Poland In 1956
after the Russian assault
On top of this challenge to the economic control exercised by the Hungarian bureuacracy, workers on the streets had linked up with students and with Hungarian troops in joint committees, and had turned their pent-up anger on the savage forces of the AVH secret police — the nain arm oi political epression - which had files on over 1 million of the 10 million population.
Many AVH were beaten, hounded and even lynched when they fell into the hands of the workers they had terrorised for years.
Such a far-reaching attempt to unseat a Stalinist bureaucracy from the base of its power and privilege in Hungary would have been disturbing enough for the Moscow leaders, who since Stalin's rise to power at the head of a vast conservative state bureaucracy in . the 1920s, had increasingly viewed any workers' revolution as a threat to its own power and privilege.
But it was compounded by Nagy's insistence upon a complete removal of Russian troops, followed in swift
succession by his announcement of intentions to leave the Warsaw Pact, and declaration that Hungary would become a neutral.
For the Kremlin this was too much they set up an alternative Hungarian government under veteran Stalinist Janos Kadar, and on November 4 set about instaling him in office over the dead bodies of the Budapest workers.
Despite the bombardment and the deployment of 200,000 Russian troops, the workers' councils and sporadic strikes continued right through to January 1957. On Novmebr 14 a Budapest central Workers' Council was formed, and both Kadar and the Soviet forces were forced to negotiate with them.
Krealin tanks in Budapest
As late as December 11 the leaders of the Central provoked a solid 48-hour strike.
While the workers showed huge courage in their attempts to lay hands on the positive gains of the nationalised Hungarian economy, they found themselves politically limited by the effects of ten years of Stalinist repression of independent working class politics. Following on decades of dictatorial rule under the Horthy regime. However there is no serious evidence that the Hungarian workers looked in any way towards a restoration of capitalism as was predictably claimed by Moscow.
arrest of Council general
New issue
Socialist Viewpoint
Anti union laws Hungary 1956 Print • NHS • South Africa Labour conterence id much more!