Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Unsung victims of Ho Chi Minh

· Socialist Outlook no. 88, August 1995 · p 12 · 482 words

Reviews

Trotsky

Revolutionaries They Couldn't Break, by Ngo Van (tr. Harry Ratner). Index Books, London 1995. 234pp £11.95

Ngo Van deserves our sincere thanks. As an eyewitness and participant in the events he restores a forgotten chapter in the history of the international workers movement.

Revolutionaries They Couldn't Break is a gripping account of the struggles that exploded between 1930 and 1945 in Vietnam, with special emphasis on the role of Trotskyist activists.

New light is shed on the origins and formation of the Indo-chinese Communist Party (PCI), fore-runner of the Communist Party of Vietnam.

An amalgam of nationalism and stalinism, the PCI was a devoted follower of the twists and turns of the Soviet bureaucracy. Far from leading the masses, the PCI was often way behind the consciousness of workers and peasants in their struggle against French and Japanese colonialism.

While Ho Chi Minh was looking for help from the Chinese Guomindang after their massacre of communists in Shanghai and Canton and cultivating the support of landlords and capitalists, a number of Vietnamese political activists in France came into contact with Trotskyism. Among their number was Ta thu Thau.

From 1933 onwards Thau and his comrades became active in Saigon politics. The authorities repeatedly annulled election results, arresting and torturing members of the group.

Ho Chi Minh was also concerned about their growing popularity. Although his supporters had collaborated with Trotskyists between 1934 and 1936 in the publication of a common paper, he wrote to the Comintern in 1939 that the time would come soon to "politically exterminate" the Trotskyists.

In September and October 1945 he delivered on his promise, arresting and killing their leaders, including Ta thu Thau. The repression destroyed the groups. The handful who survived in Vietnam had no choice but to abandon active politics.

The Trotskyists of La Lutte (The Struggle) and the League of International Communists had exercised a real influence, particularly in Cochin-china. They organised thousands of militants and, according to colonial records, were more popular than the PCI among the urban working class.

During the "mini revolution" of August 1945 La Lutte published a daily newspaper with a print run of over 15 000 copies!

The Trotskyists were also well implanted among the peasantry. Their literature shows close attention was paid to rural grievances and revolutionary potential. No "underestimation" of the peasantry here.

Today the organisational and political continuity with those brave fighters for internationalism and socialist democracy and against the bureaucratic Communist Party is maintained by their comrades in France who publish Chroniques Vietnamiennes.

The recovery of Bolshevik-Leninist ideas and the construction of a genuine revolutionary marxist party in Vietnam are inter-related. Ngo Van's book helps that struggle.

Other reading:
Revolutionary History Vol.3 No.2 (Autumn 1990)
Vietnam and Trotskyism by Simon Pirani (1987)

← It's a fit-up · Burmese pro-democracy leader freed Whose tune will she sing? →

Something wrong on this page?