Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Why the family has to go...

· Socialist Outlook no. 3, June 8 1991 · 541 words

Lesbian and gay

IT IS INTERESTING to note that the two subjects which have excited controversy on your letters' page are lesbian and gay oppression and liberation and Madonna. It seems that it is still sex which gets the punters going!

However, while I have some sympathy with your correspondents on Madonna's feminism, I have absolutely none with either on the question of the family or the biological determination of sexuality.

The subjects are of such fundamental importance to an understanding of the struggle for lesbian and gay liberation as to warrant a fairly comprehensive reply.

The letter proposing a compromise (in the best liberal tradition) between the analyses of sexuality as biologically or socially constructed seems to have badly misunderstood the meaning of the original Supplement and therefore to have confused a number of different arguments and concepts.

It is obviously true that the social construction of sexuality operates within certain biological parameters - humanity is genetically sexual. However, that fact is a million miles from the liberal belief, shared on many sections of the left, that the object of that sexual motivation is determined by biology.

Clearly the statement that people are born sexual has a rather different meaning to the statement that people are born heterosexual or homosexual. Moreover the former assertion can be scientifically, historically and empirically substantiated which the latter cannot.

Nor is social construction synonomous with 'social conditioning'. It is a complex process in which both objective and subjective factors constantly interact.

A similar set of confusions are illustrated in the letter in defence of the family. It fails to separate the institution of the family from the actual individuals which exist within it, and therefore comes to very reactionary conclusions.

The institution of the heterosexual, patriarchal nuclear family is incontrovertibly oppressive.

It is an institution which directly and often violently oppresses women and children. It recreates and reinforces these inequalities of power and presents them as natural and unchanging.

It is an institution which mediates women's entry into the workforce, underlying the gender segregation of employment and gender differentials in pay...

The family is an institution with which lesbians and gay men are incompatible, which necessitates compulsory heterosexuality. It directly and indirectly exerts control over the sexuality of people within it, again often violently...

None of the above means that the individuals within the institution may not be kind, loving, progressive, even revolutionary, though it does make it a lot harder.

What it does mean is that the institution must be destroyed and people (including lesbians and gay men) enabled to determine for themselves the relationships they want to have, the situation they want to live in, free from inequalities of power between men and women, children and adults, heterosexuals and lesbians and gay men...

History shows very clearly (as the supplement understands) that the form and structure of the family has changed radically over time but that its essential oppressive and exploitative role has not. It must therefore be abolished, it cannot be reformed.

Rebecca Flemming, London SE11

← Falling for the hard sell · Subverting sexist stereotypes →

Something wrong on this page?