THE MOST alarming aspect of the Madonna discussion is the dismissive tone of the polemics.
Rachel Wingfield writes in a measured way, but says: 'it is a shame to see Outlook going in the same direction as other left journals of male dominated organisations...' and demands the balance is 'redressed'. We should favour a broad expression of views on cultural topics. It is wrong for individuals to claim they speak for all feminists on these topics.
Rachel Wingfield and Kathy Kirkham argue that Madonna is a caricatured co-option and distortion of feminism by the capitalist entertainments industry.
They say that her cultural production represents no threat to capitalism or patriarchy. That society will not be transformed by art, music or culture in general is true. But Madonna is clearly perceived by the resurgent moral right in the USA as a threat to the family and to the moral values of young people.
Her images of the family, gender roles, religion and repression, race and sexuality, provoke outbursts of hatred and vilification from these reactionaries. This is certainly not 'predictably what women performers have been doing for years'.
When millions of young women and men see her as a symbol of rebellion against authoritarian attitudes we should look more closely. Rachel and Kathy fail to recognise the ironies of Madonna's work.
She does not just reproduce fantasies and sexist stereotypes. She investigates them, parodies them, and often mocks and subverts them. However I don't entirely agree with the focus of the original article, which looks at Madonna the person and not enough at her cultural production. But it does capture the essence of the phenomenon.
Rachel says, 'Sexuality in our society is constructed in the context of male domination and women's subordination...' This is only part of the equation. The 'context' is the sexist, sex negative, repressive bourgeois family, school, church and state. Women as well as men are reared in this 'context'. In reality, sexist and aggressive male sexuality cannot be contrasted to the somehow pure and unsullied female sexuality. That's why Madonna strikes a chord with female as well as male fantasies.
Today's women and men can't fundamentally transcend the effects of the bourgeois family. As materialists, we understand they continually reproduce themselves, socially and in bed. Their worst effects can be challenged collectively and reduced to the public sphere.
But they will continue to reproduce themselves long after formal elements of the bourgeois family have been abolished. What sexual radicals like Madonna help us do, is develop our critique of bourgeois sexuality and possibly point to new directions.
Madonna's commercialisation, her bourgeois feminist and individualist attitudes in her work must be criticised. But her music and imagery allow us to explore the complexities of our sexuality. That's not so bad compared with most of the 'bimbos', male and female, in the entertainments industry.
Dave Packer, London SE5