other aspects of the Community's cconomic
policy, hut puts forward no clear alternative.
It is noticeable that a number of key politi-
cal questions are completely missing from the
Wayne Edgington
JANE WELLS tries to work out what is new about Labour's latest policy review
SHIBBOLETHS are very important in
couldn't find many doctrines or formulas
which had been around long nough to get old the Labour Party these days, and every Labour Party member ought to know what they are.
The dictionary says they are the old fashioned and generally abandoned doctrine
or formula of a party or sect?
So wnen the New Statesman s editonal market forces socialism.
In 1961 Labour had just lost three elections recently urged I abour's policy revisionism in the Policy Review further, on to new heights, away from Labour's internal squabbles towards the concerns of the electorate: away from worn shibboleths towards fresh thinking about basic issues.... 1 decided to chock out these shibboleths.
What first threw me was that the supporters of the Policy Review scemed to think that there were so many shibboleths about.
ac:: wed
arship ot the means ~ Frun always more
wally polic. and attack foym Kinnock N
in a row. There had been witch hunts of the left. The hierarchy were ro-examining some
of the party's founding principles, including
links with the trade unions, and were asking
themselves if the working class really existed
any more. There was a Liberal revival and
there were moves to form an clectoral alliance
in asl three elections
or the
some
any more. There was a Liberal revival and there were moves to form an clectoral alliance
mn. Q Actober 1988
Hammond out -
but TUC right
wing rules
EXPELLING the Electricians" union (EETPU) from the TUC for breach of the Bridlington Agreement is like kick- ing PW Botha out of a social club for poor table manners.
Compared to the conscious strikebecaking actions of the FETPU at Wapping and its in- creasing role as a convenient tool of anti-union employers, the fact that Fric Hammond's men beat rival hureaucrats to a few single-union
few emote-s «CIT deals and "poached" a few members of other unions is a total irrelevance,
By refusing to address the outrageous union- busting role now being played by the EETPU. and carrying through their expulsion purely on the most burcaucratic niceties of a widely-dis-
* widery dis regarded agreement, this year's TUC Congress ensured that even with the departure of the hard right's guru there would be no real political break from collaborationist politics.
Indeed Hammond's closest co-thinkers, the AEL leadership, remain key voices in the TUC hierarchy, while plotting their own merger with the EETPU.
the most burcaucratic niceties of a widely-dis- regarded agreement, this year's TUC Congress
The party leadership then mounted an at- tack on two main fronts: Clause Four (they
wanted to delete it from the constitutiony; and the unilateralist defence policy just passed by the Party Conference (they pledged to "fight
and fight again" to reverse it).
-They were hampered by a temporanty un- reliable block vote (the TGWU was left-led). so they compromised on the first with a fadge. but won the second. A new defence policy.
Policy for Peace" was drawn up jointly by the
NEC, TUC and PLP for 'consultation" in the party and the unions. The right hegan to or- ganise around it, through the Campaign for
Democratic Socialisn.. Their policy docu
ment was accepted by the next party con
ference, and the witch hunt of the left con- tinued apace.
But there had already been a good deal of revising of the content of Clause Four before it ever got onto the party membership cards.
In 1918, to be exact.
It was the first resolution to be debated at
the first conference of the Labour Party
proper, affer it had adopted the constitution
that survives almost intact today. It concerned the rebuilding of the economy after the war.
and it proposed "co-operation in production
and distribution, the sympathetic approach to Ta healthy equality. the widest possibic part ticipation in power, both economic and politi-
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK ~
Nor is there much substanci to the mainstream 'left' alter- native. While Ron Toda cast the TGWU'R decisive block vote in favour of expelling the
EETPU and later in favour TUC withurawal from col- laboration with Norman Fowler's outrageous "Employment Training' (El) scheme, he was at the same time manoeuvring hehind the scenes to deliver the unanimous vote of the union's "left" Executive members in favour of Kinnock Hattersley for Labour's leadership
And as Fowler aimed to exploit divisions in the TUC by prompily putting the boot in and closing down the Training Commission. on which some TUC burcaucrats liked to sit with employers and government, it was Todd him- self who led the pack of union chiels in the hunt
C. Guarita/Reflex
Strange kind of left': Ron Todd
1992
for new "irilateral' quango poses at Furopean level after the new Single European Act in
cal. and the general consciousness of consent which characterises a true democracy.
A left-wing delegato taircaav being referred to by the Fabians at the time various ly as nonentities, fanatics, cranks or extremists") rose to object. He pointed out that the resolution failed to propose the con- trol of the means of production by the work- ing class.
Sidney Webb, founder of Fabianism. replied to him that since there was so much work to do and so many resolutions to be con- sidered they did not want repeatedly, over and over again, to ring the changes on the old shibboleths*.
Old before their time and apparently failed
- but never tried or tested: I reckon these shib- boleths have just had a bad press!
Now, with Kinnock's team of bright young men listening to the media months before Labour Listened officially, it's not surprising that the series of policy documents published since the last Labour Party Conference (Aims and Values and above all the Policy Review) reflect policies for Labour advocated there
Drop the unions. And unilateralism. Any vague notion you might have entertained about threatening capitalism. And package it properly too. Try calling it modemising the party - that way perhaps nobody will notice it's the oldest trick in the book.
the
Linium leaders who seemed divided on some issues were largely agreed in ignoring the British clacs struggle, makig no mention of fighting the huge job losses in Austin Rover.
and giving only tokenistic support to the strik-
ing P&O seafarers. But they were most of all
agreed that turo quangos offer bigger and tas- tier free lunches, longer and more luxurious visits to tellow officials across the EEC: there were more motions tabled on the 1442 changes than any other issuc on this year's Congress
XurIOus there
The scal of new realism was scurcly affixed
txcd
with the rejection of a resolution from the telecom engincers" union (NCU) calling lar a policy af nationalisation. Insicad a resolution from the acine of new realism, the GMB, was
camiod, which called for legislation to ensure consumer rights" from private corporations.
Despite a superficial left' garnish of resolu
Tions realtiming unilateralism, demanding a
phasing-out of nuclear power, and as usuai call-
resolution MB. was
ing on Thatcher to impose sanctions against
South Africa, there was no doubr that the hand
right and new realists remain firmly at the helm. andlong only for a chance to mend their bridges
Two decisions however do offer campaign.
ins • Ihc opposition to the El programme
should be used as a green light to build local and regioral campaigns to expose the real na- ture of these schemes, keep them out of
unionised workplaces, and fight to unionise those unemployed workers unlucky enough to
• The decision to sponsor a national demonstration against the Poll Tax must also be
follwed up in every union and labour move-
ment body in the fight for a serious campaign.
John Lister
Page 11