IMPROVE LOCAL services" is the trade union movement's official strategy tor tighting privatisation in local govern-
ves, bur no more so
Unlikely? than the double think which has enabled Labour councillors amund the cuuntry to argue in recent months that cutting jobs is a means to saving local services.
When the local government bill. now in irs committee stage, becomes law, it will make compelitive tendering for all the major services presently run by local authorities compulsory by 1989
The policy is essentially the same as that instituted for the NHS in 1983, when the THISS instructed health authorities to
Tom Sawyer: NUPE's low profile leader
The tender trap
remaining with their pcople
with none of the disadvantages" of an
principle
scrvices.
test' their laundry, cleaning and cat ering services against open competition. Since then nearly 2,000 such exercises have been completed, with around 20 per cent lost to the private sector. Wages ankl conditions for workers in these ser-
wholly at the expense of the people whir produce and use those services: And of
course once services are run under thesc
services have been saved, it has been
91122013
but
in-house service NUME Jocally and ta tonally have condemned the deal as insuler bidding" and remain opposed in
face that in was romperitive pressure that
management and joint union management buy-outs of public
More senions is a jun anon management bid — in competition with the DIO feuda — for the relise collection service in Milton Keynes: There, the counc's former chief executive has sel himself up in the cleaning business. signed a single union deal with the CMB Jocally, and put together a bid for the service which they are jointly trying t persuade the workforce (who are cur rently emploves liv a private contractor)
The regional GMB officul involved has publicly said that ass in his view, the council would be opposed
vices have been cur drastically - and right across the board. The situation is measurably worse under the private con tractors, hut in nearly every case where services have workers have had to trade their hours. bonuses and other benefits to keep their
been put to tender.
much higher for the trade umons: more members, anil more core members (in terms of the unions" basc), as well as their recruiting ground → the services
With a 'strategy" that says simply "win
jobs — whether the contract has gone private or staved in house.
But in local government, the "instruc- con' to render will have the force of law. closing many of the loopholes used by
the service, al any cost" . aml with mounting pressures to recruit and retain
tuc to xept. ability
sympathetic employers to keep services with direct labour. Tendering terms are strictly commercial, and workers will very quickly become locked into the same ever-depressing downward cycle of cuts in wages, conditions themselves the private sector.
Ar a time when local councils arr tacing vel another round of ratecapping
- when the comfortable fudge of creat ive archuntancy is no longer possible and whilsr councile of all colours arc collapsing in lancial crisis with redun dancies left ns well as right and centre — the possibility of improving local ser
let alone relying on that as a vehicle to deliver you from privatisation,
and in some cases willingness - to fight privatisation electively
Under thoss circumstances it's all 100
cass for the unions in seck 'creative" solutions in the privatisation problem
in a return to direct labour on the contract for political reasons (i we formerly organised by NUPE) the GAR had mus to gain by going along with the deal, which, he alied, would probably invaler the union taking scats on the
What he didn't spell out, and what a probably of minst central interest to the GMB in all this, is the new members that
and services - in order to compere with
which scek to dodue but effectively witch
the central (and still publirly espoused) principle ofoutright opposition to prova-
tisation - in some casex lor them to
carry workers with them, who, in the
isoride boand in the long nu.
incin positi
The recent experience of competitive
chase pror privatisation councils which are more advanced" in the process is instructive. In West-
minster, for example where a mamber of services have already heen subjected to competitive rendering, and some pri- vatised, three senior managers→ all NUPE. members - are drawing up a
The union approach is essentially the same strategy as that which was tried lested, and to a large extent failed, in the NIIS: of damage limitation. was to tighten up the service standards. submit a competitive in-house bid, dis credit the competitors. employers, cut your losses and maximise vour recruitment where possible. Indus- trial action was to be led locally, if at all,
The idea lobby the I'n
(E13 million) refuse collection contract. drawing up the specification for the contract, are allowed work time by the
management bid for a very lucrative
The trio, who were all involved in
big disputes at Addenbrookes and Bark- 16 ing) nationally. T 80 per cent of NIS
and usually just sanctioned (increasingly reluctantly after fingers got burnt in the
council in which to go round the work-
force to sell them the idea — which for
the council itself is attractive insofar as it
the success of the tender would deliver The CMB nationally have not made their position on this particular deal clear
publicly and their have been conflicting
signals ahmur how far up the hicrarch
support for this kind of deal goes. But the union has suffered heavy membership lossex from the decline of manufacturing industry — and the health service and local government are now top of its list of seven target meenuting arcas.
Whether or not the deal has the
public, ur even lacit support of the CMB radership - or whether it is simply a one off adventure by one of the regional 'barons' who are known for their anto- nomy in the GMB — the intense pressure to rocruit remairis, as docs the lack of leadership from the top of the umon(s) 1n the fight againss privatisation
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK ney Janwary/Fatihuary 1988