ES CHEMINOTS EN GREVE
CHESTED
January 1986, striking French railworkers demonstrate in Paris - today, left-wing presidential
new workers' struggles in Italy and the
for example. al
SOCIALST OUTLOOK
As part of our continuing coverage of
political developments in Europe, we are
publishing below articles on the left-wing Juquin presidential campaign in France, the
THE EUROPEAN workers" nosement, conimates! with long-term economic depression, mass unem- ployment, artare on social security and the weltar state, and attacks on democratic rights, is roerywhere hampered in replying to these attacks by die rule of the burcaucratic leaders of the trade unions and mass working class parties. But the working class has not lee able to simply politically by pose the mass organisations. The most combative sections of the working class continualls push torward, and rest out. new alternmive leaders from within their own.ranks.
The blockage represented by the ditterent Euro-
Hope. we are the
growing 18o DAVE PACE thoughrs
develops in ditterent countries
growing crisis in the West German Greens.
DAVE PACKER opens with some general
There are important differences an how this junes
though the Labour Party let wing as polially rather different trom the left wing renovateurs" (henriers)
representative of the watte seneraltrends: The tempo has saried from coatey to country, bur all chose reformist parties and urganisations which continur cither to hase their politics on the post was consensus. or love become new realists, are sliding into crisis
the kind of political cries whirh the European workers movement has not seen since he last world
dint in
French Communist Parry, they are both
pean variants of right-wing new realism irreating war. the proconditinns for esplusive deselopments within
Lconomic depresson, austerity and the consequen
class polarisation are forcing the pace of polital the traditional noganisations — and even splits trom them. Revolutionary socialists have to address them- change on both left and right. For cxamplc. in trance
Jean-Marie Le Pen's Natumal From has ten per cem selves to this political recomposition from within the
of the not — ten per cent for anco-fascist pany Thie miss organisations
1s 5: lanuary Fetrary 1098)
17
18
But one of the key factors determining the form of
the political recomposition is the response of the ruling class and the right wing to the growing tussle over the system of international alliances which the Europcan states should adopt. Simply summed up. the United States, through its cold war offensive against ihe Soviet Union and the rastern bloc, is
and am easiern bloc. is trying to force the west Furopean states into a morr determined atlanticist" posture — political, mintary and economic subordination to the United States. The "
class opposition to the Reagan-
right-wing pan- Thatche
Europeanism — counterposing a closer integration of Europan:
the common market nations against the domination the conn of the Americans. "This implies much closer technolo-
closer technolo-
gical, economic and military links than currently
was inKaL..
But cue of th the Denn
tatives were flown into Britain to attend the recently held Chesterfield confrenco. Benn and Scargill (who Icd an attemptod standing ovation for the Sovict representatives), appear excited by Gorbachevism.
Gorbacher's approach to Furopean social democ- racy is far from being an attempt to turn these parties
into idcological fellow-travellers of Moscow. rather an alternative to atlanticism', an appeal that
atlantic plays on the desire to preserve welfarc state capitalism in western Europe, together with citective trade union and civil liberties.
All this is a far cry from the traditional atlanticist' preoccupations of the old guard social democrats like Schmidt, Healey, Craxi and Soares.
But reformist pan-European ideas are emerging as an important trend within European social democ- racy today, and they have close parallels within a number of communist parties. They are as bankrupt
as the old atlanticist ideas as a socialist international
tor the S
Sov
vno rict
an appcal that
= state capitalism ...... trade union
atlan::
wet nations
iplic
* much
links
1wo questions immediatcly arise: where does the Gorbachev Icadership in the stano
conflict, and where should socialists stand? As far as
the Gorbachev leadership is concerned, their stance is
determined not by socialist internationalism but by
burcaucratic calculation. In order to give themseives
the breathing space for the programme of economic
reform (perestroika) they above all want international
stability. They want to get Us military and political pressure off their back. Moreover, they want closer
Mireover they wänt closer technological and trade links with capitalist Furope to
unks with capualist Europe to develop their economy. Therefore the political line of Gorbachev in Europe is for the capitalist 'European" option and against atlanticism. In other words, while wanting to see more political independence in western
Europe vis-a-vis the USA, Gorbachev is a stout defender Europe ne of the basic and political status guo on both sides of the
- on born «des of tne Furopean divide.
The response of the more idcological leaders of the
Gorbachevism has won applause from the rightward- leaning eurocommunist parties. munist Party (PCI) after years of distancing itself from Moscow, is singing Gorbachev's praises at the top of
as the old ar
inkrupt ational
'TInIn Dunsauct iha brear TeCrit n stabilt:
determined not by socialist internationalism but by burcaucratic calculation. In order to give themseives
internat order t
a cicar alternat. tr
capitalist 'Europeanism' working ss solute .apitalism, war ano planned economy on would incide the caste the task of unitino the
It is necessary for revolutionary socialists to present a cicar alternative to 'atlanticism' and rcactionary working class solution to the problems of European
dins
nart
capitalism, war and trade war, is a socialised and
planned cconomy on a pan-European scale that
• a vialiscu and opean scale that iries. This poses
would include the castern bloc countries. This poses
the task of uniting the west Furopean working class
and its allies with the 300 milhon people of castern Europe including the Soviet Union in a united socialist states of Europe basod on a new international cconomic co-operation and division of labour.
Such a solution would be a goal for the workers in the west, in the framework of a socialist transforma- tion, and for workers in the cast in their struggle to throw off the fetters of the burcaucracy and establish workers democracy
1 As Trotsky put it each natunal situation is an uneven crystallisa- bon nihe rements of the world procco: fara brief summing up of his views on the relation between national specificities and the international sitariom sor the: prefor to the: Girman erfition in his book Perrunt Rroiation. The same ideas are expressed at length in FAr Communise Inbratanal Afte Lous. Al a time when many socialists are expressing concern only for "national specificities'. it is important in emphasise some of these ideas. 2 Even the former leaders of the far left 7/ Manifeno, who base gone into the PCT. are now saying that Gorbacher shows that they "underestimated" the Soviet Union.
SAVANI
and a
CroruaL.... leaniny munist P
Jacolo. at le
been
th
e rightward talian Cr 10 itself f1
.... ICtECT: 01 In. workers democracy
Fontn . As Ti
Mess. its voice?
/nif
Gorbacher's "westpolitic" is also having its impact on European social democracy, not only within the German SPD. but also in the icadership of the Labour Party and others. It is significant that Soviet represen-
ДУ11 onl
ap 01 th
thin
Lah
SOCIALISTOUTLOOK nod Jonuaryifebreary 198E
ir pcop.- ui castern
... carinet
- he workers Is
* transforma
.Ir strugg. to
d ~tal
AT LASt something's moving. The message on campaign badges indicares the reaction to Pierre Juquin's deci- sion to stand in the French presidentia!
Juquin Icading
dissident Communist expelled from the Communist Party.
Although the elections are not until May 1988, French political life is al- reudy dominated by the opinion polls. and specularion ahour who will be the
Miniat
right-wing runners are
candidates
elections. 'rénovateur"
final candidates in the race.
The main alrewis known. These are Jean-Marie Le Pen of the men-fascist National Front (too much for even the lories
swallow!) and two from the present majority of the na rional assembly: prime minister Jac ques Chirac for the gaullist Raily for the Kepublic, Raymond Barre for tse
LA POLiC
UDI
On the left things are nor quite so straighttorward. has nor ar the time of writing an- nourend whether he re-cicenion us president. He is still daing well in the upinion polls and calls on him to stand are multiplying. His main rival within the
Francois Mitterrand
will stand for
Socialist
Scene from student demonstrations
Party (5I) is Miehel Rocard from the cight wing.
The Juquin effect SINCE THE BECINNING of 1987 a left
wing has tentatively begun to take shape within the st led by Jean Pope- reu and Jean-Pierre Chevenement as a delayed reaction to the experience of
SP dominated ment, the last winter's struggles and the ellect of the Juquin campaign. Like Jugum, this current calls for dissolution of the national assembly in the case of a left victory in the presi- dential election, that is agaitst colla
boration in government with the right as is the case at the moment current. however. does not have any serious candidare for president.
Despite the unanimity of ins rocent congress, the Communis Parry is still suffering the elects of the crisis which culminated in the 15 October announ cement by Pictre Juquin that, at the request of the coordmation of Com- munist rénovateurs (renewers). be would stard as a candidate, thus lead ing to the expulsion of lumself and
the 1981-86
poser- Juquin campaign gathers momentum
"Something's moving'
(Workers Smugle, and Phra-Toni-
bert who is standing
(Movement for a Workers Parsit
Iron for his organisates cue 29 18 Pare
Communise Interestinie: lars
is the first time that the Tankelets
have stood m thr prouderal co-
tinns, a decisin they took after dein-
ing not to support lierse Jugua
Alain Krivine. whella soned o le
cartilate of the Lugar Communisit
Revolutonnaire (L & Fraction)
19
e02853
This
hundreds of his supporters from the party Direct intervention from the party centre has succeeded in norma- lising" all bur two Iocal Communist fedenitiuns. but one of the two remain- ing is in the arca of Doubs, a bastion of the Pougoor car workers and reported
current irsclf is uneven. In some places it is little more than groupings of individuals, else- where it is a real split within the local party apparatus. The first national meeting since the current was expelled
to be 8O per cent appositional.
The "rénovateur'
Ju
mill be on 9/10 January in Lyons where 400 icprescutatives urt ex- ported to attend
The present standing of the CP can didate Andri Tajoinic hardly puts him ahead of the "marginal' candidates Arlette Laguiller ol Late Ousniere
of the Fourth Intestinah in in ris presidential dection sine 1909. wal drew once Pierre Japan's candalu- rurr wax announced foreseen by the LOk - and enorsed bo conlerence 10
movelicht able to rally greate LCR alone. defencina aspecis of a clear platform: determinativa right. to delein! workers and not to repeat the espe ricoc of the left gorthluent of 19011 36.
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK ne 5 January/Fabruary 1988
December 1986 — French students protest at the murder of Malik Ousseline by police
Juquin campaign supports mass
pain for activists trom the seen since 1968. A number of taenly-
from the far lett based cumminees hav already been
CENTRAT. planks of Pierre organisations supporing Jaguin, or Jorned Juquin's campaign are: anti rarism trom the renovateur curcat itself-
One of Tuquin's ccutral concçrns 1s and the right to vote for immigrants; thar is people whose mam esperience that the rampaign should refleet die the 35 hour week: independence for is within the Coltradition — t0 discuss ideas and aspirations of those that Kanaky (New Caledonial: scrapping)
participate in it and not have a pro- the French nuclear lore de Irappe
grammie unposed upon it. The grise against nuclear power, and lur equal
mate commitice are therelore draw- representation of women in the astitu
ing up local appeals of support for the tious through 50 per cent goutas.
Iquin candidatur to usc as a basis
for attracting activists to ile com
suitoes. However, until tiese com
20
Juquin cam muvements THL
juntion social movements.
and exchange their different ideas and experientes.
Activist committees tu build
campaign
THE BASES OF support for the jaquin
campaign are the comminoes that are of last winter He las insted represen
lative figures from all these move- •Alain Krivine withdre
meals lo participate in his national campaign leadership. The two nost
These tennes are a rellection of the social movements" and the struggles
minces begin to develop real activis, the rampaign is tughly personulised anand the figure of Jugain, of course this is partly inevitable given the struc
once Pierre Juquin's огонши, members are David Assur line who was a national spokesperson lur the student movement in De cember 3936 and Kaissa Titos Inin
announced
springing up like mushrooms in Incali
and workplaces. Their number about J00 nationwide. In Pars itself there are 35. some 25 ol which are in workplaces, including
government departucuts,
Oue oF thie most successful merrings
ture of the presidenrial system candidature was
The naconal meeting of the com
mittees caller for january will make
pussible a real assessment of che forces
now
the nanonal bureau of SCs-Racisue and nine of the main insigators of the Lies first march for equality" in Dermher 1993.
Also included in his staff are Rene Bull, lormer confederal sccretary of hospitals.
The CUT union federation: Maya Sur- shops, ricays and the postal service durs. a well-known feminist activist The local areas where commitees! from Paris, Manic-Thérese Parry from have heen formed include the Paris the class stooggle opposition tendeney 20th arrondissement, the main immi- in the l'aris region CFDT union ledera- graml area and where the National tion and Bonvallot, fortner representa- Frost got over ten per sent an the 1983 tive of the CGT lo the Workd Federa- municipal elertions tion of Trade Unions in Prague
This catal stail works with com- missions on thee differcat themes where i broad layer of activist can contri bure to preparing campaign material. the inevitable Tuse commissions can be a resetisl
draw into the campaign so far Many of them hope that thic campaign with open the waw to the creation of a new political force in France. to the tell of the SPand cl. The committee will be a test of whetlicrat is possibile for lorces that have not worker rogether tor scab (lor exampir in workplaces where Col and CFDT members are
chetan, howver. the man tasks of the crammittees will be to win sapport for the campaien, and then schieving a zed enough resalt in the elections to drontate thar there isthe space and a role ou the French tell for thi-mave-
SOCIALIST OUTOOK no5 Januaryifebruary 1988
amni. to work together.
MEN.
In the perind leadine up to. tic
PHILOMENA O'MALLEY
so far was at thr Sorboate where students parked into the mom amphi- theatre to listen to Juguin. provoking
mimark that such ment parked political meting had not bren PH
PCI loses one million votes
Italian rank and file
FOLLOWING LABOURS election de fear Marcion Today theorist Stuart Tall, casting about for some slurce of hope in his Guardian article, avion ins alt to look forward to the performance of tho Ttalian Communist Party (PCT)| in Iraly « June generul elections.
Thr Prit sullered ibs warst election defeat since the 1940s Losing one mit- lian votes aral 21 MIs. A lot of the lost voses -weat to the Greens (in parlia- ment lur the firer time with 2,5 prt cent), and to the hard left Proletarian Democrars (Democrazia I'neraria,
15l) The PCT subsequently changed its positions on the uti-nuclear referen- da. Its internal debate, unfortunately mostly between various reformist posi-
The same Smart Hall on a recent dricary Channel 1 discusson on Gram- sci's relevance today speculated un tire importance of PUl-organised "festits (estivals) for developing working class
ricins, has bolted up.
begemouy. On borh nocasions he gor ir all wrong. The ic looking at the wrong bart of the Pel and hax certainly mot heen ny very many festas
In the last six months it is not the PCI leadership and its convoluted de- bates on a new "eurosocialism" that has
made the running, but another resur gence of rank and tile industrial mili cancy involving lens of thousands of
hid the PSt the smaller secular lelt of
forees (Social
workers, particularly in transport and edacation. As for the testas, a rocent one 1 attended only drew a decehr crowdl when the raftie for the Skoda car was held - hardly threatening benr gross hegerony there!
The new Goria-led govcrument is more of an armed truce than anything else between the two main protagon- uses in the coalition, the Socialise Party (rst and the Christian Demerats (DCI). PST success at the polls (up t per cenr) allowed PSi leader Craxi to veto
more heavyweight DCi prime mister and giver him time and space for his grand project of drawing be
parties or
else b centre"
Democras, Radicals, even parts of the Greens).
If Craxi can pull off some sort of realignment he believes he will have builr a force big enough to seriously take on the Communiss — as any realigned grouping wouk come in amund 23 per cent which is not far short of the It's declining 26 percent share of the vote. It is even being
PCI secretary Natta — sporting
the kind of snappy suit that every well-dressed eurocommunist should be wearing this year
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK 10=
suggested that he could then threaten They have now developed again in plas the Christian Democrat his presenr NCT partners with a new certain important sectors in the last six influenced CIL) called a onc-day gen-
eralstrike on 15 November in response PST-PCt alternative.
munths,
A feature of these struggles, all of to the finance bill's proposed
In any case Goria's goverment is
increases and against legal regulation
govern of trade unions. The the three-ycar Crasi government.
strike since 1981 was a success bist it This is similar in some respects to Thatcherism: attacking one by one all
war a one-off means of pressure used
by the bureaucracy.
continuing the cough, Arronimo of which have been in delence of jobs or
working conditions against
ment restructuring plans, has been the
opposition of rank and file workers 10 the gains made by working people in deals negoriared by the reformist appa- the struggles from 1969-75. It was ratuses. Time and time again at Alfa epiromised by his successful attack on the sliding scale of prices and wages lia or on the rail we have seen votes
against
TAX
firer general The bourgeois
A further
corpora-
Ronico, with the leachers and at Alita
mechanist. union
Occasionally,
Up to now, however, despite the frontal offensive on working class liv- leachers, svetl ing srandards and working conditions. newspaper) has had to recognise the Tralian governments have not been alicnation of the union membership able to go as far ax Thatcher, Partly mom their Irader this is because there is less to attack
and PC press were aiso keen to present it as a reassertion of the official unions? authority over the dangerous desrabi- lising mole of the CORAS
The latest developments u the CORAS have revealed someof the pol- itical difficulties in organising such an anti-burcaucratic currenr. coordinating meeting of the COBAS in
the planned 12 De
comher demonstration ended in a split
betweet the more rightist,
leaderships (usually
with thie
Unita (the PCE
Naples before Talian social security cover has siways
'significant mass rallies been less extensive than in Britain but mainly they are hampered both by the bourgoos political sustern itself
in Milan and Rome'
as
tist (anti-political) forens and the hard Jef activists. The left won a majoricy but obviously thes dispute
mobilisation for the demonstration. At the same time the bureaucracics and the press did everything to tar the COBAS with the brush of oxtremism and in fact the police banned the demonstration in Milan.
Nevertheless significant mass ral- lies were held in Milan and Rome With the big trade union confedera- tion committed to further campaigns on the upcoming contract negonanons and the finance bill there will be plenty
In fact, Occhetto, heir appareat to and by comtinuing defensive struggles
But perhaps the key question for the The POE "adershir
bourgeoisie and central to the new fiance bill they want adopted, is ger ring the state budget delicit reduced.
Currently the deficit stands
balane» st
recugnised
the PCI's electiun losses: In is signifi cant thar Democrazis Proletaria: luck votes from rhe POt in its northern
aller
nearly 13 per cent of CDs. For the bosses it is the maggor growing higger each year gnawing away at the 535950333- buoyant growth and export success. The media's lascination with Italian
industrial strongonids as a result of whar has been happening in the
Not only are trade union members voting against their leaders they are organising independently in the COMAS (Cominari de Base — base
Another reason for this sense that
performunce overtaking Britain's (El corpasso) does not fool the committees.
real masters who are looking enviousis towards Thatcher's medicine for cutt- ing state deficits
The Italian deficit is partly a result of the political patronage system ende mic in much of the state sector, that is johs and pensions are often distributed in return for political loyalty. A That- cherice line of managcrial efficieney/ privatisation comes up against the tra dition of sharing our different heldom» in proportion to political influence in the majority coalition. Despite this the new finance bill will ferociously ratio malise the health servicc and other state services.
Alongside the battle over the finance bill there is one attack that does trea- ten prr-1969 gains — the proposals to
sectors, particularly transport.
attempts to carry out new austerity policies is the resilience of working. case resistance. Undoubredly thix is
the apparatuses do not belong to the members is the way thar union posts are divided out at the top on a regional or national level between the PCI and PST factions of the bureaucracy, with- out any relerence being made to the membership or the real support for
lop *Democrazia Proletaria
cach faction at the base.
of opportunity for the CORAS.to.deve-
Revolutionary arrivists in Iraly ure encouraged by the opening presented by the slightly increased vote for rad- ical policies at the clection and the shengaent rank and file militancy. However they are aware of the limula- tions of the movement It only affects certain sectors and has not vet reached even the scale of the autocotocati ol
took votes from the PCI*
recent years. At the same time there is the same oid problem of how to buikd a more permanent clask struggle lestlen-
cy in the unions challenging the hald of predominantly the ict. Such a ten dency is nended in huild on the gains of carh waw of seif-activity so that the next wave can go even lariber. Al-
More worriu for the upe
are the first attempts to condinate the latest rank and file committes, the COBAS. A meeting of about 200 rep-
reschilalive helu on. 21
resentatives of different COBAS was
among other things it decided to call The other difficulty for ruling class. for delegarions to a demonstration in
tempts in the CGIL, die most impor- tant union, have highlighted tie prob-
Connilion (Council Democracy) was set up in 1981 coming:
defence of the right to strike on 12
December. The Socialist-Jed Ull trade union confederation has more or lew accepted such interference with inde pendent trade unionism. The PCt-led Coll. opposes much laws but has pro-
letus. rike Democracia
uneven from sector to sectur.
accented s
vered from their big delcats, and some all opte rank and Ile auvists have a corporat-
ist econutrist approach disinte- strike in such rested in overall political: solutions for working poople
posed self regulation of the right to
sensitive" sectors as transport. Mass sentiment in such sectors is understandably reluctant to hand over the strike weapon to the
Not wanting to be outflanked, and with the government refusing to con- code un any case, the three trade union confederations (thie above mentioned
The phenomenon of rank and file commitices goes right back to an occa bosses: sionally ulira-leftist version from 1969-74 and then resurfaced with the with the
Kantuces around the
22 contract negotiations a fen years ago. unlear
our of the entererorati experience. Many of it leading lights belong to DP but independent activists and the la- han trotskyists of the Revolutionary Communist Leaguc (1CK) are also involved. A mecting in October tried
to draw a balance sheet of the tenden-
Sume of the differences at that meet- ing revolved around a dillerent con- cepton of low to light the burcaor racy. DP, with its Ml's and icam of full Lime trade unot officials - who often play a positive role: — tends m skirt
SOCIALIST OUTOOK 10.5 Jampory/Fehruory 1988
cy's activity.
amund the question of trontally chal lenging the ICT on the key program- matic. quesrions lue the unions. can be further seen in general political fertus in their "open letter to the left" wluch attempred, correctly, to inter-
This PCI militants debating
However it is
The German Greens in crisis:
vene among their parry's deleat.
The letter makes several general points aguinst the idiocies of the POT's search for the holy grail of the culture of government by realfirming the need for a real changr. a real break with the system. i remarkably unspecific abour who it is challenging, being careful not to nail ibe ICT with specific responsibility for
ile gains made by the righr since 1975.
Fach sector — the unions, ecological
movements and winnen for example - is more or less corroctly deait with but the dillicult question of how the
left can refound itself is vague.and rouk even be interpreted as a relar ively painless conng together
Whatever
of
The exact role of the working class is fudged and the nurs and bolts of the fight with the majority working class organisations like the PCI are nor exa-
Coming hack to Democrazis Concilhare we can see thar DP's general frame
mined
work would favour its development as au ideological current farmuring rank
and file demorracy, hut not as a ca- cial organised movement challenging the PCT's bold over the working class.
The trade unions become "just another
Whatever happened
to the 'new politics'?
imperialism and 'social imperialism"
wearing 'swords into
badges Caricature?
Certainly, but the speed ar which thco-
ry and the class struggle went out of
This is not to suggest that the rise of
the Greens was merely a matter of the
IN the iritish and wasti fl the rise of the (ire
Parry in West Germany since the early
years of this decade has served as the
model of a new politics': a radical
movement which not only managed to transcend the fragmenration of a Gier-
v.manazed.to
transcend the fragmenration of a Gier- than far left notorious for sectarian
TOOk to ploughshares' fashion was still brearhraking.
Greens arrive in the Bundestag for the first time in 1983
movement and the importance of pol- itically organising against the POt is underestimared or is left to the DP and the scries of movements in society. There is an element of how the British SWP sees united front work in the uns. a sort of reflex not to get too
involved in the nitty gritty of united front tendencies because it detracis
1112.123
lead with the hig working class par-
Contilar should have democratically urganised structures of activists which can bring, in wider lavers than just those whu agrce ideologically with the D or the LCk on a national level.
approach would be a more down to earth trade union bulletin for organis-
lead with the hig working class par- Hence critics of DP say Domscrazie
consequence of such
an press
Unfortunately the British (including the Morging Star) has barcly mentioned rocent developments in Italy. Newsis.
Ruh's problems-with the ratmario. and not rurning up to see the Wind- sors. Even Marsim Today which seeks so much inspiration there tends to look aver another interminable BUt senu- nar rather than the experience of the
DAVE KELLAWAY
a porno star Mr, Tan VAY
division. but even succeed in thie arca of cloctoral politics - which hi- thermo had appeared the impeherable
Ipp
fortress of social democracy
the snif
Imitators sprang up all over western
ung sd gonn
~ Even in Britain = of Cireen Ecology Parry
candidates tay well have cost Labour
a handful of seas in the general elec
olu ww purely electora!
scene. the chief impact of the Greens
has been on the terms of debate on the
intellectual left, where the appeal of
the 'new politice often served as cover for a lasty retrcat from an 'outdated, sterile' marxisms,
ries".
able.
Bex the
It was in West Germany, of course,
where the collapse of marxism's liege: mony among the radical post-1968
generarion was most specracular: In this former hotbed of critical universi-
Der Kapital reading cindles, quotation-hurling polencists and left wing bookshops overflowing with re prints of the socialist classics, theory suudenly became decidedly unfashion-
The distributors of red traits at the factory gates abandoned the early morning shitt in favour of more rural target-groups in the vicinity of nuclear power stations, and the apologists of China's homh as a defence againse
old radical left dressing up in new clothes. A new awareness of ecological issues had gradually spread ever since the wil crisis of the carly seventies had put energy onto the political agenda.
The subsequent rapid expansion of
The subsequent rapid expansion of nuclear power schemes provided a focus for spectacular mass resistance The women's movement and the citi zen's imtiatives had spread poiltical
zen's imtiatives had spread poiltical
the trade unions and laid the founda- tions of a ciew, participatory political culure muside the traditsonal struc- tures of parliumentary and party poli-
The prolonged death agony of the
fies,
Th
The prolonged death agony of the ruling SPD-Liberal coalition in Bonn, now shorn of its initial reformism of the Brandt years, had disillusioned a whole generation of young voters. Thus, by the turn of the decade, the gruund had been prepared for a politi-
cal phenomenon such as the Greeus, provided there was an issuc capable of focussing the disparate forces of dis shr into a coberent challenge to the
establishment in Bonn. This issue was provided by NATU's decision in De- comher 1979 to deploy a new genera-
rion ul nudear missiles in West Ger- many and four other western Furo pean countries. It was the peace move- ment and its repercussions both within and outside the SPD that brought down 23
the Schmidt government and opened their wronghnld of Hamburg, and ment, tyiny to loyally implement 3A
parliament for the accelerating the abject capitularion of TO's missile deployment and is own
the 'nalos" to the sPo's demands of nodear energy programme agaist
The hundreds of thousands who. public professions of loyaly to tie growing rosistance from its own basc demonstrated in the streets of Bonn "democratic state' before any collabo- it was surly naive to expect the S/3 to
blindly continuc on this disastrons
Thus what initially appeared to be conse once in opposition. Faced with Green Party beyond the critical live mercly tactical differences mo many - growing programmate consergence per rent harrier!, did nut represent a have publirly solidified into prolound with socal democracy and the chal- sudden dramatic increase in the forces programmaric divisions just when the lenge of a red-groc" alliance to 112st of die far left. But inside the organis decline of the peace movement and the Kohl-Stranss-Cienscher, the Greens ation of the new party, and particu- discovery of the vote winning powcrof lost their political nerve.
Those whose political activist bad
never been informed by ay grat
concern forthenry, strategy or urgan-
isation
reed amaritists like
eculugical concer by the established
parties have robbed the Groens of
much of their momentum. of this maoist socts of the 1970s soun
The losses in the Hamburg elections played a leading part.
were follower by the failure to win
While the publir face of the Greens krats in Schleswig-Hoistein, and a was identified with individuals like total failure to benefit from the l'eiru Kelly and the former 'Bundes- Barschel scandal shaking that nor-
wehr general Gert Bistian, The politi- herumost state since the election.?
cal infrastructure came to he damn From all sextiuns of the party, loud hard by the Hamburg-hased group complaints about political paralysis amand Rainer Tramper and Thomas are vowed, and public talk of an im- Ehermann formerly ol the "Commun- pending split has been rite for months st League). the remmants of the dis- solved pro-Chinese KPD, the former utraleft. Frankfurt-based "sponta
indisinualist radical demorrars like the civil rights lawyer One Schily, old armpaganda of tee
Danic Cobn- Bendic und Joschka Fischer — joined demoralised cx-maoiss in boxing tol tec "art of the possile This is rosta list in the neaky fartin which de- fends the state's monopoly l violence. thinks the police are angusty cru tised, urges the Palestinians to cotoc to
The crisis is really abour the collapse
of the illnsion that a new politics
transending traditional concepts of nicists around Daniel Cohn Berlit left and right, of as strugale and and foschka Fisher, und the erstwhile welture-state reformism. KEW. Their influence was helped by founded on the programmatical basis the fart thar despite their electoral of the croingy moment. xuccesses, the Greens never acquired a mass sucmberslup and moss of their
*a left wing has tentatively local party branches lead a marginal
terms with Israeli wrupation, and ac- cepts NATO mcibership lest a disa armod Federal Repubhe shouid find itscif exposor mo Russian hlackmail.
By contras, those whose mode of political operation has alwavs: been sectarian now reven back to a sterile denunciation if sucial democrane be- tracals and the quasi-stalinis world
canid be
view of their maoist period wond begun to take shape within
ering alond whether (inharhen is hor
preparing a capiralier restoration in
the SP'
the USSR?
Yet the temptson to gloat over the
The widespread noton that thr crisis of the Grocus — which may well
Greens air an "ernlogy party" is. in
deraid dicir imminent demier as d any case, mistaken. While the ecolo-
significant political force — should be pical issues provided a reat, and by no resisted. Not only have thes forend the
means only tactical, bond between the carous component
parts of the left to widen its theorctical horizons
Devond the coonomism and carism
which still passes in many quartere as
ordox maris, bur they have this It was based on the peace masement
also, and in prostie, exposed the myth as well as on a road range if ther that in non-revolutionary mimes the sies which ahenared sections of Luc
radical let must, by necessity: be mar
population from social democracy and
ginal mo "mal politics" and reduced 10 helped constitute a kind of rambow srie propaganism.
'third
Their demise, particulariv il it were
to perer nose under the present cur
cumstances, would be at setback for the
whole European left and a most unwel-
come, negative confirmation of mars
ist orthodoxy
GÜNTER MINNERUP
Footnotes
with 1 Under the West German saem of pro
poctional asparsentalant, a muminum share
ul 5% of the national vote is required in
gunmpo scatation in ta Barlestas
On the eve of the clection, the Christian-
Greens, their political success was nor
exclusively or even primarily based on
nice tick сок. from feminism to
worldisn
This multicoloured protest vote was never solidified into some kind of iden- logical or organisarional coherence. Ver it propelled inro parliament (at narional, regional and local level groups of arrivist who now loun themselves in the unfamiliar role of direct electoral competition groups with more secure social and idcological roots and the abiliry to nimbly take up the Greens isoes of
come harder. The outright rejection of peare and coology with unsuspected
Demeral permict id Selicoin Hoicin
and tapidly tung star in the CDL, Uwe
The present crisis does little more
Parslal, was ravaled m law emplord Rau, during the election campaign than to lay bare the flawe which have special branch agents against his sol oppo had the elfect of simultanconsly har- characterised the Green project fron dening the soctarianism of the "funda- its inception While it could tempo- crodit hum with leaks about his private lite mentalists. who subsequently suf- surily calch the SPD on the hop as it Barbel, whar denied be allegations, has 24 fered a crushing electoral deleal in was eking out i long years in govern sinue committed suscide:
SOCIALIST OUTOOK n05 lanotyifahroory 1983