fight hired in in leological back to esplain how Kinch anil Gould une wrong. Bus che debore i likets to be formied in the edicts of the stick mocker prade In a period of ccimomic depression and
SOCIALIST OUTIQOK me Noverse Deserte: 1997
acting shame ownership it is going to be bureaucracy did not have it all their own harder in alk зини an increasingle wax. The continued willingness of the affluent working class and the mares of working class in fight back against it- e sharc-owning democrace" Sonethe macks on jobs and conditions was re
flexted in the defeats which the confe- desermation of the party: leadership to nene plattorm sullered - on their push through their policy resus, whirh handling of New International. no- despite being presented to conference as strike deals, oppusition to the new round single seport, will love policy implica of ami-union lass — and indeed in the
tight taken onto the floor of congress liy Fioris rightaross live Twand.
Wille this vear's rue was not nearls Scargill and Macreadie. so dramațic nethe Taliour Pars confe- sence. it represented a continuation of the dritt tosards the right. Barthe union
In looking ar the prospects for the left. i the light of the deepening attacks of the Labour leaderstop, it is necessars to
AFTER CHESTERFIET D
look at the resistance at the Labour Party conterene and ar what happened at the subsequent Chesterfield Socialist Conference.
Betore the Labour conference some members of the Labour Co-ordinating Committee (ICC) scering committee and of the Labour Left Liaison put out a jomt fourteen-pomt aflirming left wing policics. atrong the
protests right up to the singing of the "Red Flag' It must be said that there isa developing process of political differen
tiation within black sections and among
This was a correct apprach; and it is one which noods to be counterposed to any approach on the left which sticks obsessively in internal Labour Pany
One of the things which dominated the scound half of the conference was an understanding that the stock market crash heralded important changes in the political situation in which the lest operates and will tend to undermine the
Another positive aspect of the confer- cree was the iceling that the. co-
socialists which was beginning there ought in lie continur A further conference is to be held in May, and regional and local report- backs and conferennes will be held in
of two thousand socialists in Chesterfield in October was
a boost for the left. A large propurtion of
ThE .... The conferene
structures and caucuses.
credibility of Kinnorkism. erence
ordination of
statement
Prominent
signatories WEIG Kcn Livingstone. Ann Peutifur. Joan Rud- dock. Vladimir Derer and Peter Hain. This starement was a good initiative.
right wing of the LCC and left the editor of Marism Today protoundly depressed". Its main weak- ness was that it remained simply at the
Labour goverument, and the consequences herr and now for labour movement action
The key
the conference were rank and file trade union and Labour Party members. The conference revealed a deep hostility to
* the -
whuch infuriated the
Irvel of demands on a future
were not immediately obvious.
Ar the Labour Pane conference arself the response of the left, and especially the sott lett, was very weak. questons of the economy and delence of nationalisation wen hardly addressed at all by the main lett leaders
'the Chesterfield conference was a boost for the left'
push the party to the right. As one delegate said: "this conference has drawn
who are in the last analysis prepared to fight back against pared to go along with it.
• line across he lel' — a line of those who are in the last analysis prepared to
nigh
many areas before then. Kinnockismi
One tinal point about Chesterficid needs mentioning - the major speech by Ken Livingstone. In his speech tr rejected the notson, alten pur forward by Tony Renn and others, that the figin in
*How can sou
against those who in the end are pre
pared to go along with it.
The big turnout at the conference: despite the clash with the marional anti-
cies. nor personalities.
Just as in 1986, the sections of the stone.
Ramsay Mac Donakd?" Labour Party least willing to lie down and be crushed by the rightward-moving steamroller were the most oppressed sec-
women and black people. Women showed their resence by refusing to be tobbed off several times
ship's policy review • during ronference and continuing their
Ramada Man: fact or fiction?
tions of the class
DECADEs AN experts and commen- tators were taken in by a skilful fake. The discovery of the supposed prehisto- tic remains of "Piltdown Man" gene- rated all kinds of wild theories on evor- Intion.
Now, years after Piltdown Man was exposed, the Kinnock leadership is at- tempting to palm off a new myth. Wc
call this "Ramada Man. after Brighton's
luxurious
Ramada Renaissance Hotel, at which Kinnock and his camp followers held court dur- ing this year's party conference.
Descriptions of this new vary. According to Ron Todd, he is a docker on 1406 a week, (rumours thar Todd was referring to Brian Nicholson have not been denied) and has a holi- day home in Marbella.
species he is a
10
But Dv common cin Man is male wwn. a shares, and feels well-off.
How many Ramada Men are there? We know there are not many dockers left. Latest government figures show that average weekly pay for the top ten per cent of manual workers is only
Isenı Kamada house. . Tew
apartheid demonstratin, mrvealed new mood of wanting to organise for a tightback and to reassert basic socialist
principles. One of the reasons for the
success of the conference was the fact that the orgarisers sought to bring to-
gether militants from inside the Ladur Party, together with those trom the trade
unions, campaigns — and indeed social-
Hurr
E261: if Ron Todd is right about the 5400 a week figures, there can't be many votes to be won there.
Even the top ten per cent of all male workers fall 150 a week short of Todd's docker.
Of course some manual workers are known to carn f400 a week or more: most well-known have heen Fleet Street printworkers. But national newspaper jobs have been axed, provincial news barons are booting out unionised print- workers, and thousands of socat and NGA members are learning how flimsy has been their prosperity, which rested on trade union strength.
Ramada Mian alonwns 3 houses siter Tory policies have stifled council hou- sebuilding he probably has little choice. But do mortgages stop workers challenging capitalism? Thousands of miners with mortgages joined a year- long strike to defend their communitics and the industry they depend upon: millions of Labour votes have always come from owner-occupiers appalled by Tory policies.
Ramada Man owns a few shares —
the labour movement is just abour pol-
have socialist policics, asked Laving
if sou are led by someone like
ation of war against Kinnock and Kinn
ockism. Whether it was or not, such a
war dearly needs waging belore next
year's ronlerram considers the leader
maybe "5fm worth. sO. has gambled a year's cquivalent of C10 a week at the bookics: his return on that investment may equal one good win on an vutsider. His shareholding is in- significant in relation to the stakes of the banks and trusts — and he gets no voice in company policies. While his share income 1s welcome spending money, he can't live on it: in no way does it compare with the share income
of the capitalist class. If he loses his job he will have to sell the shares to avoid hassle from social scurity.
Behind the defeatist mythology of Ramada Man lies an uncomfortable fact: there has always been a non-
socialist, even Tory-voting section of the working class, particularly its more privueged layers. Old-stvle union bureaucrats like Eric Hammond have always reflected their prejudices. But
now the trendy Labour line is to allow this backward rump to dictate policy.
At least Piltdown Man's creatur pro- duced a bag of bones to back up the
prank: Ramada Man carries as much conviction as Cinderella's coach at five
past midnight •
SOCALIST OUTIOOK na 4 November Dacembor 190/
This sounded to many like a deelar
HOT * B33 SARMIE NEW
SHARE OWNING
Share-owning democracy?
BRYAN GOULD'S Labour Party con-
This is often used a a sop to push
damaging ference speech calling for a re-valuation
relatively of Labour's attitude to share ownership by workers was rightly met with con-
organised workers. The shares issued on
But in fact
favourable terms to the workers in Labour leadership was touting this idea
privatised industrics are one example.
Another is the issue of shares 'in ex-
sharesen. Of the mual
Brish Airwave for example
-ent have vend our In British Gar
-old... first tour month- the otter
I share
65 p-
restructuring
well-
LOUS U
before the clection. John Smith David Blunkett included worker share ownership as a major part of their of ficial proposals for 'new forms of social
ownership' in 1985, and it was an im-
and
the privatised
among their own workers, does not in
any way enhance 'democrary'. The ma-
jority of shares are already in the hands
of the financial institutions:
privatised half of BT only 24 per cent of
shares arc: now helo bv *111223
shareholders. while fi4 percent arr heir
as by only 340 owners, -aint institutions
and firms. Even if the shares were equal-
ly distributed throughout the
population, there are no mechanisms for
debating and determining company some workers policy.
The large number of sharcholders in
companies,
'n worker: doe
weil
dudi
change tor massive ruts in pay which have been negotiated by loss-making Us •Your pay is cut now, but the corpora-
portant element of the Greater London Enterprise Board's policy before that.
in the
tion will recover its profitability
message. In these cases, worker share ownership is a short-term expedient for the emplovers.
Workers share ownership or proft sharing schemes can also help manage ment in the long term, by Dexibly link-
and eventually vou'll do well out of it is the
Lacking any clear economic strategy. even sections of the hard left have fallen for: chis: tune. On the same day Gould's speech, campaign group MP
Brian Sedgemore proposed that a third
shares should be transferred to a workers trist, with the
would become milhonaires overnight'
Gould's proposal was characteristical- ly vague, and muddled together two dif- ferent forms of worker share ownership: ownership of shares in general, and ownership of shares in the worker's own
The first of these has been pro-
10E IL
protir
A member of the rank filofax?
ing wages to profits and by crcating an
atmosphere of "cooperation' in the firm. A cooperative policy may seem a far cry from the present government's policy of junking cooperation with trade union Icaders and smashing union organisa-
But a policy of management- labour cooperation — on managemen's
moted by the government through the markering of shares in privatised in- dustries on an unprecedentedly wide scale. This way of sclling shares has had the aim of making renationalisation mure difficult and for this Thatcher (and British capital) have been willing to pay
necewary to ensure a wide rake-up have been scarvely half the companies real valuc. On BT and British Gas alone, the government has forfeited a profit of over
terms — can have big advantages for capital. lowering labour turnover and absenteeism and inrreasing the quality
This can be very attractive to the Labour and irade union leadership since it offers a new excusc for class collabora- tion: they can appear as representatives
management and the
42. et
share-owning democracy.
bill: the it has 1o
give-away
prices
share ownership have on the new share uwners? Con-
am locals contentio.. ano rclations
contrary to the suggestion in Kinnock's
monce speech, huying snares n
privatised industries does not necessarily
either require or encurage a conversion
to Thatcherite'
What effect does
of 'enlightened
midwites of new, harmonious industrial
While share-ownership schemes are always a risky option, they may appear But they are a danger for the working
Share ownership tends to increase
ay appl
With these lavish handouts, and the
low threshold sct for minimum sharr ap- plications, it is only surprising that mor people have not bought the shares. Only
per cont of adults now own shares, compared with seven per cent in
Clearly most shares have been bough by the middle class and a comparatively small mumber of better-off workers. As of last year only four per cent of share
- workins
valucs.
Hili ot savitten
All that is ano a desur
to double it.
liere s
Where workers have retained their
shares this is essentially an alternative
form of saving to the building sociely. Te issa way of keeping the value of money
divisions berween workers within m- dustries by weakening the role of na- tional collective bargaining and strug- gle. In tends to increase divisions within firms, with long standing, often skilled
workers disproportionately
The degree of influence on manage- ment that may accompany worker share ownership (especially through a pooled trust) tends to draw workers more strongly into helping their
thin m-
ole of na-
-Bruns тe HIEM SUOH
•en skilled
benefiting
• alternate
"alue of m accumulatio maic untertaka
for future use, not the accumulation of
capital. Saving has been undertaken by
the better off parts of the British work- ing class for the last 150 years and is
owners were unskilled and semi-skilled workers. There is little indication that these completely exceptional share sales have whetted the appetite of many of the new share owners fur normal specula- tion in shares, despite the steadily rising
hardly an invention of Thatcher. For the
average new shareholder, the profit, in the form of dividend income, is small.
... Fo.
exercised
£25-100 a year.
prices on the stock exchange of the last few years.
Morcover, money, many people have cashed their
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK ne 4 November/December 1957
having doubled their uter
nualle much ITE OwICIs sew. and the
menlight
worker.
fun
firm to compete, deepening the com-
petitive anarchy of capitalist organisa-
own company.
tion. It is not a weak form of industrial planning. It is the appuse of planning
no democrary in share
strial
Sur 1312
11
abor