Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Share-owning democracy

· Socialist Outlook no. 4, November–December 1987 · pp 9-11 · 1,395 words

Britain Labour Party

Thus it is a massive blow to Thatcherism ideolo- gically. Millions of people, including those who bought shares, are going to get a swift, salutory lesson in some of the rcalities of capitalism. At the same time. Bryan Gould and Neil Kinnock have been made to look pretty stupid in their headlong pursuit of sub- Thatcherite share-owning mythology. Indeed what has happened is going to make millions of people question the rationality of a financial system which puts the world cconomic ordc.. and the livelihood and well-being of mil- lions of people, in the bands of a tiny handful of immenscly rich financiers. It will make anti-capitalist propagan- da and explanations much more cre- dible and popular: and of course this will have its biggest impact in the labour movement.

SOCIALIST GUTIOOK s04 NovemberDecember 1987

slump

Will the left gain from this? There is no automatic rule which says that financial crash means automatic growth and victory of the left. After all, the crash of 1929 led, indirectly, to fascism in Germany and another non-socialist solution - the new dcal' - in the United States. But in Britain in 1987, the left has a massive opportunity to ensure that it is a major beneficiary of the political fall- out of the crash.

12 Britain - dealing floor of Barclays de Zoete Wedd

The crash politically undermincs all those who tend towards "moderation" and business as usual". It will shake up and recompose politics at every level — both bourgeois and working class politics. It will tend to streng- then those who put forward bold and radical solutions. There are signs that after Thatcher's third electoral vic- tury the left is beginning to reorganise itself, both in the Labour Party and beyond. Far right currents like the National Front could also grow as a result of the slump, especially if the left fails to take advantage of its op- portunities. But at the moment the left is much better poised to make the running.

Of course, the scientific theories of marxism which have consistently ex- posed the contradictions of the capi-

scientific theories of have consistenti dictions of the

« api-

talist cconomy, and the inevitability of periodic slumps and booms, are the only theories which can provide a framework for understanding what is going on. But now the left must ad- dress itself to political solutions of the scale necessary to solve the crisis in the interests of the working class. Those can only possibly be anti-capitalist solutions: Kcynesian reflation' of the economy will only prepare the ground for a bigger slump.

Overcoming the anarchy of the capitalist market is absolutely im- possible without nationalising the banks and the major financial institu- tions: nationalising the major firms and monopolies; instituting a na- tional. and hopefully international, socialist cconomic plan; and fighting for workers" control over production as the only way of ensuring the imple- mentation of a socialist economic plan.

These are the kind of programmatic demands which need to be raised in the labour movement. both in struggles and in the political and iden- logical debates. Such socialist perspectives are a million miles away from the right wing economic think- - ing of the Labour leadership. But they are also some way remored from the kind al lashionable and confused ideas on the soft left in recent years — like the notion that local plans, small co-operatives. and new forms of social ownership were the answer. To be frank, all such ideas are fiddling around the edges in comparison with the scale of this crisis. You can't have local enterprise initiatives or local co- ops without finance: and in a slump you won't get it. Period.

Nothing could more justify the idea of socialist planning, on a national and international scale, as what has happened over the past lew weeks in the world'- financial markets. The crisis has shown that those who stand against the irrationality of capitalism are right.

The Chinese written character for the word crisis' is a combination of those for "danger" and opportunity'.

Socialists now have it in their hands to

strengthen the movement in a quali- tative way if they seize the opportun-

ity. If not, then the horizon is clouded

with dangers for socialism and the

working class.

7

AFTERCHESTERFILLD

After the TUC and Labour Party conference

Will the left fight back?

alSocialis Oulook

luge attack by the right wing. Chesterfield shows the basis surge of the left. PETE FIRMIN reports.

Kor Leninge onga dd harte Anh proteis tring

"SUB-THATCHERISM" — that is the apt phrase used by the left at the Labour Party conference to describe the new policies and principles which Kinnock and Gould are trying to Inist on the party. Bryan Gould's speech extolling the virtues of share ownership, and Neil Kinnock's gem about the necessity to appeal to the (mythical) £100-a-weck docker, were only the tip of the iceberg of the leadership's operation.

In elfect, they plan to roll hack all the policy and organisational gains made by the left since 1979. The ferocity of the right wing's attack and the boldness and scope of their proposed policy changes caught some people by surprise. Tr aims

in the

spr nership

- Ne

l-a-lnck

docker, were only the tip of the iceberg

…eration.

...k ail th.

....1e be

..e fc..

incir caught some people by surprise. Tr aims at nothing less than crushing the left and all traces of its influence. A simple list of the leadership's objectives will show what is involvei: • To progressively redefine a "non-

nuclear defence policy away from any- thing to do with unilateralism and io

make it a simple multi-lateralism. In this

receiving some assistance from the soft

it must he said, they are

tension of public ownership, and indeed any pledge of even renationalisation of privatised industries; to replace clause ic

with talk of 'new forms of social owner

What i. new forms e ownership are was clearly claborated by Bryan Gould when lie supported waler

share ownership as a tricans of spread

ship*

opcration mated by the policy review which will be undertaken in the next two years. Tis aim. to quote trade and industry spo-

This

will be

hich will

kesperson John Smith, is to review the words move fundamentally to the right

and accept some of the basics of That-

There is no doubt that this is one ot

and:

cherite philosophy

and d herite

review th- - in other .. the right is rh That-

*the key questions of the economy and nationalisation were hardly addressed by the

main left leaders'

ing power more widely' - a fatuous notion at the best of times, but looking

distinctly sick after the collapse of the

Listine

.. best

the most profound debates inside the party since the attempt by Ganskell t

abandon clause i in the early 1960s.

Indeed, the present situation has some

interesting parallels with that debae Kinnock is saying, as Gaitskell did, char the working class is now, in its majoriry. an affluent' working class, and that we have therefore to shift our appeal away from the poor and the dispossesse. who

JallSKe arl 1900x

# Has hat di

ell dic

....d th. poc.

stock market.

are a 'minority.

made in the party, esperially those relat

ing to the rexlection of MPs, via the

intenduction of the clectoral college ver-

sion of tone member, one vote. * To seize control of every aspect of the party structure by attacking the LPYS.

Lavour Party women simieren the ing down Labour Wcekly and so on.

iw the

nade

i the p

E a00, mer matis

HO All

Kinnock is in.

using half-baked pop sociology about the demise of the work- ing class, which was rubbish when

Gaitskell floated it and is still rubbish when much more lightweight figures like Kinnock and Gould spout it.

The hissing and booing which greeted

now-infamous Gourd owning' speech is indicative of a general

SOCIALIST OUTIOCK As 4 November/Derambar 1987

"share:

mobel of renomen anol unease amoug many at the conferenee be what max being done be the karlership. On the iter hand there is alo no doubr nut sections of the conference, creathese generall opprsol to the leadership's претатов. leit

doubt as to whethen then taight be some truth in it

The left is going to hate to

← Meltdown - the crash of '87 and the coming world slump · Will the left fight back? →

Something wrong on this page?