Shipyard workers leaving Harland and Wolff's yard at Queen's Island
— Loyalist workers established a
vigilance committee to keep
catholics out
The 1920 carpenters" dispute in Belfa
remarkable episodes in Irish labour history: a story of how one
British trade union waged a brave struggle against sectarianism and how the leadership of the TUC sabotaged that struggle and, in the end, sided with the sectarians. Here, GEOFF BELL gives the first detailed account of these events which we publish to coincide
episodes
Irela years on is trying to raise within the trade union movement the question of employment discrimination in the north of Treland.
32
SPEAKING AT the annual July 12 orange ral- ly in 1920, Edward Carson, former cabinet
member and by then the undisputed leader
of Ireland's loyalists: made a speech which by even his inflammatory standards was ex
Andrasing his supporters in
Belfast he said, 'We must proclaim today
cicarly that, come what may, we in Ulster
will molerate no Sinn Fein — no Sinn Fein
organisation, no Sinn. Fein methods sell you (the governient) this — thar if. hav
By the end fit the loyalist mobs had driven
10,000 cathulic men and 1,000 catholic women from their place of work The vast majority were never allowed in retum.
Among those virrimised in the shipyards
several hundred members of the
Carpenters,
WerE 11120,25 Amalgamared Society
We
Cahiner-makers and Joiners, The leaders of the carpenters' unwin. as the ASCCI was
known, had only recently been in trouble with seme of their Bellast members. Their May executive meeting had passed a meant- tion on Ireland, then in the trues of the war of independence. That issue had been linked with British intervention against the Russian revolution with the resolution derlaring. that the British government in refosing to allow Ireland the form of gocernment chosen by tie Irish people, and in assisting Poland in her attack on the Russian republic. is betraying all the principles for which our na- tion fought (in the first world war), and that the most effective way in which provest.can
ing offered you our help, you am yourselves unable to protect us. we tell you thar we
in. allered without action
will take the maner into our own hands... And these are not mere words, I hate words
tell nee It was
initiated by a group called the Bellast Protes- tant Association in one of the smaller Belfast
shipyards. A few days after Carson's incite- micht. its members produced revolvers at a
shipyard meeting and declared their inten tion of driving from their workplace every
be made is for the organised workers to
'Sinn Feiner" they could find. "Sinn Feiner
ULTR refuse to manufacture or transpor mini-
tions of war for Ireland or Polaod'
were nut just suppurters of Sion Feit but
Two Bellast brancles of the carpenters every known catholic, trade union militants and socalists The violent sectarianism sonn voiced deir disapproval of this motion. One
spread to other shipyards and workplaces. voted fourteen to two to strongly protest" -
SOCIALIST OUTIOOK wrt No-embar/Decomber 7987
The Harland and Wolff shipyard - scene of sectarian mass expulsions of catholic workers
out of a membership of 105 - the nher by iwenty two to zero to strongly object" - out
of a membership ul 283. A mass meeting of the carpenters union membership in une ol the smaller shipyards stated that the ex- ecutive should "cave polines aside other- wise it could cause dissension in our ranks'
The person who chaired rhat meering was William Barclay, a member of the Ulsrer Unionisr Labour Associarion, a body set up by the Unionist Party to wean away any err ing protestants from labour to uniunism.
Barclay's concern about causing dissension u: our was illustrated the following month when he chaired a further meeting in the shipyard which resived, "that we. the unionist and protestant workers. that we will not work with disloyal workers...
Also that in all future applications tor chiployment we respectfully suggest thar the first consideration be given servicemen and prorestant unionists
Members of the carpenters' union were, then, both being expelled from and expelling in the shipsards, but the unson itself was hot the only one discussing the evente in Ireland Indeed a special congress of the TIC was held on 13 July 1920 to discuss that very topic. One of the resolutions passed con-
xxx'
Irt.
/ Has... mabels...
Sunpa, it out
In 10- ev err
...eil Bruish of Ireland' and even recommended general strike астюп 10 secure British withdrawal from the country. Although this was a good deal less radical than it sounds - the reslution recommended that anions ballor their memhers on such a general srike knowing full well that such a course of action wi dave be wullowed the mention wak a fair reflection of where the political sym pathy of trade unionists in Britain were: with the 70 per cent whw lead voted Sinn Fein in the 1918 general election.
employed
were cleared out of the shipyard over five
hundred loyalists... had been taken on?, and
again it can he stressod thar "Sinn Feiner
Whar this last quotation suggests is that
the Insalist workers and the management
were now working hand in glove tu recrui
which the
cathulics had been chased.
organised themselves into vigilance commit-
lees in the shipyards and elsewhere and it
was these who operand a rather twisted form of 'workers control' in terms of who was
was a cuphemism for carholic
king h
lok ME lovans nurkue class
sher the nanular subcon We
not their British TU
sE Angust saw inn
uned nror
Such was the ratber difficult situation into which the carpenters" union decided to in tervene. On 24 August members of the ex-
ecutive committee went to Belfast and met the management of the largest shipyard,
Harland and Wolff. The union made a series
of propusals. These included reinstatement
of all the expelled workers, the outlawing of
or political uscrimination
employment in the shipyard and protection
for all the expelled workers on their return to
the yard. In response the employers claimed
they "deplored the troubles but would pro
33
declare
that we will not work with disloyal workers...
Mr "ten
new depths. A British newspaper described it to loval ex
as live weeks of ruthless persecution by boycott. fire. plunder
culminating in a week's wholesale violence
A loyalist shipyard worker boasted at the start of August that they had gained a great
victory and they had struck Sin Fein and red flag socialism the worst blow it had
received in Belfast for thirty years", while
another claimed that. "since the Sinn Feiners
octl
weeks
and ilesale vi
assault.
religious
• «tuation Int
recaded to in
» the ex-
and met
sniovard.
the union s propo The union judged
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK mid Noverber December 1987
as prevarication and decided to call a mass meeting of all their members to decide on their next course of action. to be privare and held indoors, At this point
tion of loyalty to the British empire and
state, ' do not helong or sympathise with
Sinn Fem, and I deplore and shhor all
and outrages
was a courageous move to make. but it was one informed by trade union principles so basic that for anyone who tonk those prin- ciples seriously there was little option.
The union could be criticised for condemn: ning management when it was their workers
involvement tarianism came ar the mecting suggested in Harlund and Wolff's letter of 12 September. At it the vigilance committee initially agreed to drop their demand that any returning vic-
The meeting was
nd
the British army and government interven- ed. The meeting was banned. According to one major general, EGT Brainbridge of the
IS ERUPTOL
British army's Ist division in Ireland, it was done un the grounds that the meeting would
In the next two weeks further expulsions occurred. Among the victims this time was
an executive
union, 'moderate labour man" the one union which had attempted to do somethine about the theniselves became the latest target of the loyalists
It was now two months since the expul- sions began. In thar time the carpenters
union had seen hundreds of their members
driven out of their jobs, including a member
of their executive: they had seen attempts to
management's Han
in the
araitcn ras
st Sirin
sec-
give rise to grave disorder"
In the
DA Boal,
member of the
protestant The leadership of
expulsions
carpenters"
and
the
their Bellast m'moersnin «an"
authorities; they had
chuon trom managemen
TUe Thev decided it was
timisod worker should sign a declaration of loyalty to the empire and hatred of Sinn Fein. But they reserved the right to ask for
tune to act thias September they instructed all th
ing members in the shivards
I1 10 maam coe 150 instructes all their remain
"word of honour of any WOLACE Sinn Fein'
More appren
the
Terurning
SUCA pus Wiet it met au
Such was the challenge facing the TUC
when it met at the start of September in Port-
smouth for its annual congress. Predictably
not one union had paid any attention to the
tirms attecrea by the expulsions 1 on strike. They explained:
agreed to the preposterous suggestion that in
future the vigilance committee would be given the role of "defending" any catholin in the yard from assault. The vigilance. commit-
tee had overseen the assaults in the first place. the transformation from poacher to
the vigilance
Mariand
Well!
in
ДОЕ ОДЕ «8078.F000 motion recommending a hallor on strike ac- tion passed ar the special congress in July.
But the expulsions affected the unions direct- ly and a deputation of the expelled workers met the TUC on the eve of the congress. It agreed to
Ship,
WHO SAYS WE'RE TO HAVE
HOME RULES
ganckeoper was rather rapid! The crux of the matter is that by these actions — inviting
negotiaring with them on the return to work of those victimsed, and giving them a future role at the shipyard - the management had officially recognised this sectarian grouping. endorsing its right to operate in thie yard. Henceforth the management permitted the vigilance committee to hold mucetings in worktime and even set aside moms for theen
standing orders committee of the
commitice to the meeting
table an emergency resolution. This was moved by JH Thomas, the railway workers leader and presilent of the TUC. Members ol his own union in Ireland had recently taken industrial action over the transporta- tion of British army munitions. This had not pleascil Thomas and when he moved the emergency motion there was a sugeestion of mixed feelings. from working, he explained. their religious and political opinions", but he leated this victimisation in the anxiety to uphoid the umion jack in Belfast
The resolution instructed thr parliamen- tury committee to call together the executive
taking a common
Constructon Association.
MI "Men are being prevented
where they could conduct their businces
So the strike call did not have the desired ellect on Harland and Wolff, although one enginering firm. McLaughlan and Harvey. did agree to cosure that all religious or
emplosment withdrawn. For the rest ofthe companies in volved the test for the carpenters union con! cerned how many would obey the strike call. It could hardly have surprised the executive that only a minority of theit members came out. six hundred obeved the strike rall, bro thousand did not The strike-breakers were
"beratise nf
*the vigilance committee said
that any expelled worker who
political Tests wanted to return to work
would have to sign a
of the various trade unions affected by the re
declaration of loyalty to the cent disturbances in Belfasr with a view 1o
line of action for the reinstatemen of all the trade unionists ex-
British empire'
pelled from their work in the Belfast arca" Despite the protests of a delegate form the
Have benea
0 100 10 H0072
and Stupwrights
Mr Swan from Sunderland. who wanced to leuve the situation to the
the solidarity of our urganisation. The vic- timised met have observed the rules of our
ers promptly expelled inum the union.
In taking this action there had suhan-
rial support among the rank and file in Bri-
sain. Even before the executive acted one
workers of Belfest the motion was casily car- agreed upon herwcen our Bellust members
JAM 21101 AmON
Bellustl branch in Elam had passed a resolution
favouring sucke expulsions. When they did
ried However, given that the situation had been developing for two months it could be askes why the parliamentary committee had not acted sooner. Or why did the resolution not siegest what sort of action could be taken?
and the empioyers In is a gruss violation of
these rules for emplovers to allow muen to be
driven from their employ beanse they an
necur only four branches of the union are un
record as opposing the action The contrary a pe view can be summed up in a motion from a
branch in Carlice, passed by 58 to zero
stintott tols
religious opimons... If the employers elect to discriminate between our members, then we have no option bur refusing to allow them the use of the labour of any of our members. All or none must in ordinary fairness be our
We are convinced that the Bellast
MEANWHILE IX Belfast, the employers mithr
finally replied to the carpenters union pro poxals made at the meeting of 24 August. rule. The rapunse
letter of 12 September. No suecific reference was made
Ibe. That we, in realising the difficult task our
EC had to: face in tackling the Beltast
religious unrest among the membere of nur
organisation, hearily congranulare them in
the action they have taken and expriss our
full confidence in their judgement. The
December edition of the union journal
employers could, if they had su desired, have prevented this disgraceful and vindictive hoycott of sections of their workmen. The recurds 15 branches passing such a resole test of the value of our society is its ability to tion. As for the strike breakers, they went to
i sulicitor to seek legal advice. He was alto
keep the avenues of employment open to all
our members." (Original emphasis.)
the socretary of the Vister unionis. councl
to the carpenters demands. Instead, a fur- cher meeting was proposed betucen Harland діне с
anx Wolff management and all the unions involvod. The vigilance committer was also invited. It made its position clear when it se this
said thar any expelled worker who wanted to 34 renurn to work would have to sign a deciara- Will
In taking this action the executive knew the leadenship of the unionists in the noril of the difficulties the union faced, given the Ireland.
Esplaming its action the executive said 1t
divisions with their Beltast rank and file, l
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK 101 November/Disember 1087
R A N D ER
ULSTER•
Demonstration against
RULE •
• HOME
HOME
M BELFAST 27
ULSTER HALL
PORTRUSH OMARH PARTARDEN
BELEMENA NEWTOWNANDE
Licir
L/INCONDENNY, ENNISKILLEN
BALLYHONEY, COLERAISE PHOMONE LISBURN CHUMAN
sunsidiary issue
their Pugh, war later to say.
clusion that them wax one problem that had
jobs of the victimised
Unionist rogues gallery circa 1914
regret that the other
had taken up the only possible position to reserve the union of our organisation, They adon. we deeply unions whose memhers have hec flung out
seriously At September meeting three of their members were appointed with plenary powers mo go to Belfasr with a view of "bringing abour such a change in the situation us would ur least be
helpfal to trade unionists in Belfast involved in the presenr. conflict Alter this initial burst of energy things slowed down. The
the fact thar
At first the committee seemed to be taking
instructiotis
As onc of their number, A
we came to the con
mo be overrome in view of the general situa tion", which was nor the winning back of the
workers. but was rather the dispute winch existed berween the executive of the woodworkers" (carpenters union) and their people in Belfast" So the major issue the delegation dealt with was not the victimitation of 10,000 trade unionisrs.
many of them back been
physically avaulted, even killed or driven not just from their jobs but bomes as well, no, the chief issue was, according to Pugh, to
the situation berween the carpenters executive and those they had ex- pelled for strike-breaking
Sume of those the delegation deciden 1n 35
on the streets have not yer thought fit to stand by us in this important struggle. In vur judgement the trade union movement, if it will act buldly, can, by firmly insisting on the
observance of its own principles, end the in- ternecine strife in Ireland which is fostered and fanned by unscrupulons employers for
December meeting of the iC: was told that it had not yet been found convenient to gus to Belfast, and it was not until 6 Doccmber. nearly five months after the first victims- tions that the TUC deputation arrived them
their own political and industrial purposes
SO. WHAT OF the rest of the trade union movement, and the TUC in particular whose
had instructed parliamentary commitree to formulate a common policy on behalf nf the victimised
SOCAUST OUTLOOK my 4 November/December 1987|
congress policy
workers?
108 131704
the
However, as the three
congress was to formulate a line of action to "clear up win hark the johs of the victimised workers.
person delegation went abut their work that hecanic a sery
LABOURANDIR ELAND
Belli included the district committee
of the
mati
view of ine Viguane
nat the existence of such a rethods employed in regar-. re those expelled. can harture
nstitutional machI
-was the tar •covernment nas bri und oracraur. its relle
anv "urprise
slerance it is b
could furth
the vigilance
- perfecin fre
surprising tha
the nece
mass meeting members of the union declined t withdraw
They remained expelled from the onion, and
persuade the leadership of the union to take back their ex-members the union stood firm on the principles of the freedom of our
the Jormer
hdraw
carpenters and two commitices representing
consulted the management of two shipyards,
the unionist lord mayor, a representative uf the government, a group representing the
But the TUC also
strike-breakers, the loyalim-inclined district committee of the engineering building trades, and the "joint vigilance.com mittee of the shipyards. The TUC met them twice
Waen the delegation submitted their report to the 1921 congress it reflected the fact that the majority they had met were cithe- unsymparnar to the victimised workers, or actively hostile to them. In a sct- tion of their report entitied causes of the trouble the aélegar. mention reasons. First, that during the war "then was a large influx of men from the south and west of Ireland" into the shipyards, and that of a number were either active Sinn Feiners or were strongly symparhetic to the Sinn Fein movement' 'number was, was nre stimateu. Bir the delegarion did say that it was alleged that many of these have openly avowed their in- tention of obtaining the domination of the Sinn Fein movement in Belfast', although nor one specific instance of 'open avowals" was provided. Instead a further allegarion is meported that a number of Sinn Fein sup-
porters carried arms*.
Thus, I presen
"law ant COTINtIEES
and ship-
tal
iken in Bellust nel
With such a
report that committee andl, spirit it the deleg: rounter the
members and the solidarity ol our organisa- tion first nunciated when the strike call was made
In September 1921 the 11/C again met in congress and the sad history of whut had
happened in Belfast and of the role ol die
TUC in those events was recalled. A delegate
from Belfast, although not a member of the
se ol die
aven A delegate - = member nf the
offered a fitting
who
judgement.
-rimised he
• west at int
e strike-breake aptly expelled
union'
ers w 1 fro
TC
Engusn trade
JI assistanc We
a action wel nd taxe. ..i: the soiers
ard wuners umon aline
nathoe- en the
took strong acnon...
Hud the other traule
unions took similar action... had they then,
if the Belfast trade unionists continued 10
refuse to obey the union order, prevented
goods and raw materials guing to Belfast.
und coal and steel and other things required!
for their industries, 1 fearlessly assert that
one fortnight of that action would have settl-
ed entirely the trouble in the north of
It is difficult to disagree with this argu- ment. Ir is hard to imagine, if British trade
tarianism of the vigilance committee and the managements as their main task but instead concentrared on the carpenters dispure. Referring to the decision to throw our the strike-breakers from the union the TUC 'ex-
pressed no opinion' but a nod was as good as
a wink and throughour nur stay we were
Ireland
continually met with the view that in the cir- cumstances, the course taken was a mistake"
The TUC delegation ollered two con- cluding pieces nf advice. The first concerned the victimised workers and those who had driven them from their workplaces. The most broad minded of the men on both sides should be brought togther for the purpose of discussing the difficulty was the facile recommendation. The advice given in the
POTEES C
Thus, porters was the first reason given for the ex- pulsion The second was the murder at Cork, on 17 July, of colonel Smyth, DSO, an alsterman who had served in the war, the thind was that 'on 22 August district inspec-
Swanzy
in the streets of Lisburn and the fourth was that on 25
one tourta September two policemen on duty in Falls Road, Broadway, were shot'
These were the limits of the TUC's ex- planation of the expulsions. No mention was made of Carson's incitement speech, no
the presence l reference was illaue organisations such as the Belfast protestant association, and there is no listing of the scale of the pogrom carholic families suf- fered. It was almosr as if the TUC were justi- fving the expulsions and that in reporting that representative bodies of workmen were emphatic in their declaration against work- ing with adherents of the Sinn Fein', were deciding not to challenge such attirudes.
Similar prejudice features elsewhere in the point of view of business
..visiness management" was relayed without comment thar the present position under which firms have in fact conceded to the vigilance com- mittee the right of deciding on the question
irned • had
was killed
treare
nention was speech.
'the presence of Sinn Fein supporters was the first reason given for the expulsions
carpenters' union was much more specific: means should he found whereby the rela- tionship between the ASCCI and their expell- ed members shall be renewed. In other words, the scabs should be readmitted.
Such was how the leadership of the ti tulfilled its mandate from the September congress to secure the re-emproment ot those victimised in Belfast because of their religious or political belicts.
For their vart. the warpenter» unIon maintained a firm bur flexible approach. Shortly after the TUC delegation returned from Belfast the executive of the union
the unu.. agreed to meet a delegation from their ex- most memvers. The central request foom th union was that they should withdraw a cir- cular they had sent our saying they would work only with those who proved to be 'loyal subjects' and gave their word of honour that they were not connected with Sinn Fein'. Al
point of view of business
of reinstatement of their workman... is but the least of two evils'
Those victimised by the expulsions is
underestimated b pusse bur perhaps breathtaking - mecting held with the suzu:
The delegation rocorded una with strous rejudices --
•he British Bae
10,000 breathraking of all is the account of the
313151 .. th.
walls a120
unionists had organised a blockade of Bellist until those victimised were allowed to return
to work, that the sectarians would nut have caver in, or their emplovers would not have
what the couscquences would have been of such action. Certainly the appareat intran-
and sectarian "Invalismi" of the
Belfast shipyard workers was used to good
ellect by unionists when they argued for the
partition of Ireland the following ycar. If, in
the summer of 1920, the British trade union
movement had challenged and defeared such
atritudes then that would have been one less
then thar
argument in favnur lite
made sure they caved in. And who knows
what the couscquences would have been of
such action. Certainly the appareat intran-
Ana who
mood tor a dinterent course. Twr
am up what dear un. The
sten in the mmutre of the
smmittee of the That: of Tune
Ir was decided to comply with a request from Mr Gorman, secretary of the vigilance committee, that he should be supplied with the report of the delegation to Belfast as A
win a request
of the vigilance or supplied witn • to Belfast as -
And then, a few months later at another meeting of the parliamentary committee.
U800 181313730331
cil, arrangements for a special congress,
ironically on unemployment and the interna-
tional situation, were being discussed when
it was reported that a delegate 'bad applied
for permission to take a collection in the hall
In aid of the catholic workers expelled from
Belfast'. The minutes of the gencral council recond: "resolved: that no collection of any
saer
11a5 a1тs in collect
kind he taken in the hall'. •
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK 604 November/December 1987