Lenin addressing a demonstration in Sverdlov Square, Moscow, May 1920 - Kamenev and Trotsky await their turn to speak
Seventy years after the October revolution. the
The
Russian
turned their backs on evere one
strengths which made that revolution possible.
consistene poolutio
ouventy Sovie
wolve programine
Soviet Union and the international class struggle
have evolved very differently from the political
Lenin and Trotsky.
programme of Bolshevism and the hopes of
strength-
I •alls to tree
una metho
To celer
15xtexth:•
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 4 November/December 1987
issues that laid the basis for the great October victory.
LISTER I October va
The official communist parties may still celebrate the anniversary of the October
17
absence of clementary democratic righis, they tealed rather to overlik the working class as a revolutionary tuece, and instead looked to liberal" elements of die capitalist class to lead
the fight for social democracy against the Toar
As che working clas began to deve lop as a signilicant force in Russia From 1870 onwards, the most rudical political surrent on the scone were the narduiks. who based themselves un the miss prasantry (80 per ccor of the population): "Though carly narodniks had fought couragemusly against bar- ist. They. too, Tater looked inurcas. ingly towards the liberal bourgeoisic to fight for ukanocracy.
Against this ircad. Piekhanns in 1na9 boldly proclaimed at the firs congress of the Second Intomationad that:
•The Russian revolution will eitner triumph as a revolution oftlic working class, or it will not tumph a all
By the mid 1890g a massive strike movement involving over hall u suil- lion workers gave a big impetus to the organisation of workers" circles. Ong of these, the Sr Petershung Leugur for the Liberation of the Working Chiss. Red soldiers on one of the armoured trains that played a decisive role in the civil war involved Lenin.
Piekbanor, us well as later Struve. which followed the October victory the author in 1898 of die manleste from the firsi Russian social democra
tic congress, and many other carly
figures of the tovement later them-
The Bolshevik Party liberal bourgeoisie Tenin. howeser
«cites defected to the camp of thie
not waly remained committed to build- THE GREAT October revolution which brought tie working class to power in Russia 70y cars ago was the product of events and strungles beginning far ear lies than 1917 and reaching lar wider than Russiu itself.
Indispensible to lee cventual over throw of capitalism. and consolidation of working class power was the rive of
for the working class.
ing a working rlas leadershup and
marcis party: he abo developed ant
strengtened the whole political and
theoretical frandation for this in pole-
mics against the nelorist currents
sating sway within the Scrond Baiter-
national.
Prepars Thi must docisive of these
polemnics was contained in tic pample-
lie 1hat 1, To Br Donr"(1902), which is
a frostal arrack on thi opportunist
actions of the leadetship of the large
Fiench par, and the dicories clal:
rated by Eduard Berustein in Grr
many.
The terms ofthis argument appuar
grimly familiar to us in today s cross
ridlen labour auxemen!
ficially "marsis" Remstein and wher
used the dogan frordom.of criricism
i their equivalot of today's an
realism" and policy revies
concr their shift to the right. Lenin and Labour l'ants (RSDLI) deve summied up
What is "new trend. which loped under very different political
adopes a: "critical' attitude towand- Opportunism corrainly had its in- "healele dogmatic" marcistu, repre-
sents has with sufficient precision been
stated by Bernstem, and demonstrated
by |French leader| Millerand
It was draed that there is ans
counter-distinction in principls bee
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK 10:4 NovemberiDucember 1987
the Bolshevik Party, a mique develop- meat translating the economic and polnical analysis of matsism into a practical programn and leadership
Bolsherism emerged from Lie sharp political barrles within the framework of social democracy, beginning at the turn of the century
Thr Securd International, just de- ven years old, still officially prulessed atherence to the theories and politics if marxism. However its larger parties
notably in France and Germany Lenin had developed their uwa burcatcratc apparams, and adapted themselves to purely parliamentary and traile union
within capitalism. 18 sion. the
forms of work, seeking only reforme pressures
Emerging comparatively lace (1992) pact: bur Russian opportunists were and weak (only cichr people at its tot so rasily dauried by parliamentary founding congress. which was raided illusions. Given the-small size of the be policey in a climate of brutal repres industrial working class. the back-
Russia Social Democrats wardnes of the cormomy, and the
tween liberalism and socialism. The theory of the tias atruggir was rejected un the gmunds that it could not be applied to a suctly democranc socic- ty. governed acconding to the will of the mugority. etc.
"Thus the demand for a resoluce turn from revolurionary social demo- cracy to bourgeois sorial-reformism
was accompanied by a no less resolute turn cowards bourgevis criticism of all the fundumental ideas of marxism.
Denouncing Millerand for joining a French bourgeuis cabinet which con- nived in the repression of workers?
means Cocodom for un opportunistic trend in social democracy, the ircedom to con- VerE sucial democracy into a democra- tie party of reform, and frocdon to
bourgenis clements into
Lenin came into conflict
struggles, Lenin concludes:
•Freedom of criticism
with the "cconomist"
wing of the movement,
which was preoccupied
with trade union struggles
and did not build a
vanguard party'
In rejecting this approach. Lenin wus obliged to devclop an alternative model of a genuinely marxist party. ensuring adherence to its programme and imposing a discipline over member. Freedom of criticism in in- ternal debate had to be matched by centralised discipline in implementing the majority decision.
Lenu insisted on the nood to fight for the scientific method of marxism.
its challenging reformist currents inside
the organisations of the working class Leon Trotsky Though workers are thrown sponta-
in his early suusly again and again into batuk. twenties, dus does not automancally lead to a from the
archives of revolutonary consciousness:
-The history of all countries shows the Tsar's that the working class, exclusively by secret polici is own ellor, is able to declup unly trade woo scroness Le, the convaction that it is necessary in combine in unions, fight the employers, and strive to compel the governmenr to pass
Such consumastes b a form of
consciusness: the consi
Decessary labour legislation, etc.
stent alternative had to be jought for by
Were the proleteriat as a whole capable of grasping ins historical task it would need neither party nor trade union. Revolution would come simul- rancously wich the proletariat." (Mars sim and the trade untions)
It was to the working class party that Lenin devoted himself. He speiled our demands for an all-Russian party and
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 4 November/Decenber 198/
ing reformist, hourgeois ideulogy in the workers movement.
However there were abso more di- rect exponents of bourgeois polities still atrached to Russian social demn- cracy. The scale of txarist oppression had created a current within the bour geoir which professed adherence 10 marxism but remained fearfulof work- ing class revolution, which would overtim their power and property. These "legal marxists' soughr simply to use workers" struggies to must li Tsar and establish a sufficient demo- cracy to allow a new "stage" of capital- ist development a free rein.
Loan's fight for a party based on the working class, and structured and
on the political stage.
disciplined through the principle of dichocratic centralism proved ana tema to these legal marxists'. Like Borstem and Millerand, they valued their "Ircedom" to act as they wished
From 1900 to the secondicongress.of 1903; Lenin urganised amund the newspaper Jokra the campaign lor a centralised, disciplined, all-Russian
would en
striker"
manus wurkers parts
On the other side, Martow spelled
our a very ditterent conception of al
party which would allow anyone to call
themselesa parry member.
The Manor conception - which
alter 1903 was upheld by the Menshe-
vik (minority) tendency
sure that the party would be got a
vanguard but a reagani, acapable of
Icading the masses because it was not
differentiated from them by idcology
or discipline. Tenin ridicated Mar-
to' argumen that every
could privlaim himself a party them
ber:
'Cle Martor carrito his mistake 10)
the point of absurdity. by louring
social democracy to the lene of mere
strikr-making.
We come only
rejoice if the social democrats sur-
creded in directing every strike, for it a political menspaper to cinify acid is their plain and unguestionable dury organise its ranks: and challenged to diner recry munilestation nf the those who were content to jog along case struggle- But we should be behind spontancous and localised int mail enders if we were to identily this
primary form of struggle which. is
no mom than a trade umonist firm,
with the ull-round and conscious social
riarives, leaving the political fild open
democratic strugele
1907-1910 were ycars of
IS TI EVENT Lenin's view won die
repression and
day at the 1903 congress, and die
reaction'
stip divided into two factions reflect-
ing opposing case prosures — fac-
in this. Lenin came into monilict toas which wore cocatially rival par-
wing of the tic with counterposed objectives, This
movement, which proo- conflict would continue right up to the cupied itself with male union struggles point of the October revolution, when and opposed the call for a vanguard the Mensheviks sided with the capital- political party of che working clare Su bis against the workers.
The working class itsell had conti- maller bow radical ibeir rhetoric, the
approach served only to aued to gaww in numbers and auditan- plurity the limited horizons of trade cy as forcign investment poured in to union conscionsness, thor strenuthen exploit cheap labour and materials in 19
for the liberal hourersic
907
with the wockers economists"
Russia, building large, state-of-the-arr production planes from modern indux trial economics in the midst of'a back- wand peasant cconomy
generation of Russian workers: were given no decades or centuries of gradual industrialisation,
зрасс to organic
burcaucratised trade unions, no crumbe from the bosses"
The new
no democratic sprawling.
class collaboration.
mass struggle.
lowed by massive strikes in 1902 in the cily of Rosmov, led by Iskra comrades. Political meetings atracted crowds of forry thousand, and showed the poren- rial for revolutinary des elopment.
By 1905 more sections of the work
tahle to beguile them with illusions in
Savage tsarist repression and a harsh, rapid transi- lion from village to factory confronted workers with a choice of passivity or
The mid- 1890s strike wave was lul-
ing class had been radicalised, linking vances with the political demands for in elected constiment assembly, the mmoval of the Tsar and a provisional government.
Lon of
In Jamuary 1905 a political strike uf one hundred thousand St Petersburg workers brought the city to a stand- still On 9 January, a mass demonstra-
workers dressed in their Sunday best and healed by a priest marched to the Winter l'alace to pres- ent a petition to the Isar. Dozcas were brutally gunned down by isarist of- ficers: but with the victims perished many illusions of peaceful reforms to the aurneratir regime. Barricades were thrown up in the working clace dix-
When the first wave of lighting
tricts, and street lighting broke out.
ebbed, towards the end of February 1905, the liberal' capitalists and ma- demics held conferences und banquets in politely press their request the sar mo establishi a constituent assembly. They were ignored.
Trotsky
arrives at the
Finland
station,
Petrograd, 4
May 1917
Wide the Mensheviks were careful not to upert the capitaliss, convinced Liat
the democratic Russia wonld be led by those dignina- ries Lenin and the Bolsheviks took a very dillerent, more aggressive line.
From exile in Geneva, Lenin ins-
isted that the bourgeoisie could not be entrusted with the tasks of the democratic revolution - and that only
u revolutionary provisional govern ment brought to power by the workers and peasants could establish a genuine
and lunclionig consti- democratic ment assembly. He expressed this in his call for the democratic dictator- ship of the proletariar and peaxantry.
1E311E indi
In Lenin's view this would still be a
bourgeois government: bur the workers
and peasants would be the driving
lurce of the revolution The workers
would need to continue their indepen- 20 dent striggles and build their own
Marx's terminology of the "perma neut (uninterrupted, unbroken) revo- lution Is wits to be the key to the October erents of 1917
THese DEBATEs were far from abstract
exchange The relative calm of tie summer of 1905 broke down will u new wave ofstrikes in October. Type- sellers in Si Pelersburg came out
demanding wage inercases, triggering stoppages in other industries. Political demands for constitutional rights were added. On T October Moscov Kazan Taibmarker joined the soppage and within a week the rail network was paralysed. Postal workers walked out, schools and ani- versities closed and commen mol lapsod
As Cossack troopewere so 10 repress the strikers, barricades weat up and workers raided gun shops.
Must significantly, the events saw on 13 October due birth of the St
irid telegraphi
Pelesturg saw trom the printers srike commiuer. Though it begun with delegates from unly one district. soon 500 delegates from across the counny wet amending, and an exe curive including three Bolkheviks. three. Mensheviks and three Social Revolutionaries Was elected. "The su- vict launched a newspaper Travitejo (Tirlings) on 17 Ortober.
Arthis point the Tear, in a change of tactics, picker a new prime minister and isued a manilesto promising a constitution, civil liberties, aal un versal suffrage.
While the liberal cook all this at face value and colehrated, Trorsky, speak ing at a linge rally at the university: hailed the deselments as the firs
warned:
class Icadership after the establishment of the 'democratic dictarorship".
Mensheviks, In contrast, looked for-
great victory of the wirking class, Inut
*Do men haven so crlebrare victory: it is dice yet complete. Does tie promis sory note weigh as much as pure gold?
Are: the gates of our prisons
The Tsar's manifesto only a scrap of paper. Today it has been given to us and tomorrow it will be taken away and torn into pieces as l um now tearing it to pieces, this paper:
The
r JUlalit yass wes itt - mertonzed pern st developenen open?
Trotsky, however, returning from
c first
exile, was the first to translate Pickha- novis 1889 insistence on the working
ciao character of the revolution, and
-2135
liberty, before your Very eyes.*
Thougli the general strike was called off, the soviet continued to organisc.
raiding cach major print works in tur to force them to print Telestiva, edited by Trotsky. The soviet threw down its challenge mo thr rearist srare on. the censurship isur, deciding that:
bonal churacter and uneven develop- ment of capitalism, is well as the
impotence of the Russian bourgcoisie
and the vacillations of the peasantry
Trotsky argued that the only consi-
Only those newspapers may be
publisted whose editors ignore the
censorslap committees, refuse to sub-
mit their issues for censorshup. and
gencrally act in die sane way as the
soviet in publishing its own paper
Newspapers which fail to accept the
present resolution will be confiscated
SOCAUST OUTLOOK 10.4 November/Decamber 1987
sently revolutionary class was the pro Jeterial, which had to take the leader ship of the democratic revolation, and to carry it through as part of its own, socialist revolution. — establishing the
For this analusis. Trotsky revived from their sellers
In this way the soviet had gone far heyond its original rask of strike coor dination: it was now championing pol- itical demands and workers control in defiance of the central state apparatus: The Isar muld not even lind a com- mercial printer for his manifesto. The- ie was it dual power in the land: the power of the sovier challenging the authonty of the state machinery.
Two weeks after the general strike ended, another mussive general strike showed the power of the movement. The demands were for an end to the Tsu's imposition of martial law on Poland, and against the court-martial and execution bf mutineers at the
A five-day strike
Krrinstade fortress
brought total victory for the workers
on the two issues which not even the most blinkered economist muki have claimed were trade unsin concerns.
This politicisation of the working class alurmed the liberal bourgeoise ar much as the Isur They began to swing buck behind the govenment. creating conditions for a new stace crackdown
'in January 1905 a
political strike of one
WITTHE outbreak of world war in
August 1914, the opportunist and reformist evolution of the majority of social democratic parties gave way mo the collapse of internationalism in the
* 21015
hundred thousand workers
Lenin in September cut through the
waffle and spelled out the harsh realiry of the war:
standstill'
Ar the end of November the pros dent of the Perrograd soviet was ar
was place. On 2-3 December be, and the enter oflicers of the soviet were also arrested Uprisingsled by the Muscow soviet and in Sr Perershung were left
peasant mose of the army: they were ruthlessly
experiences
brought St. Petersburg to a
elected in bis
ele
plundering foreign lands; the cager- ness to head off the revolutionary movement of the proletarial and to crush democrary within cach comtry:
rested: Trotsky
isolated from repressed
The
the unge to deceive, divide and crush the proletarians of all countries, to in- cite the wage slives ol one nation
mile slav
tion for the profits of the bourgevisie support and - rh- is ine real e
nakinori an 303m
ing of the war."
Under these continne wher
and political
lessons of 1905 proved a vital source of capitalist property relations and na-
tional boundaries served only to fetter strength to sustam and arm the revols-
rather than advance the development
tionary movement as well as a telling - the products
confirmation of Trotsky's warning of
BEETRIS TREE In TO the
Salve
the himations of paper-liberry
In the dark years of martion from tharke!
Bolsheviks and thr
min
1907-1910 che workers"
Nadezhda this movement under ol the 1905 revolution.
movernent had to barrie against the deleatist and opportunist
ism pressures unni a fresh revival of the
worker in the service of the bosses. class struggle hegan, as described by
ne Bolsh
Krupskaya, Icading
this internationalist. Bolshevik and companion to 1.cnin,
alves. The oppor
Every month saw an increase in the strength of the labour movement. Bur should be exploited by the workers
was Bow growing
different
conditons entirely from those in which the labour move ment grew before 1905. It was deve loping on the basis of the experiences
The revival by 1912 enabled the Bolsheviks to launch Prarda as a daily newspaper, sustamed by, and leading. sections of the working class •
SOCIALIST OUTLOUK
reformist social democracy, wedded to capitalism, could only play the most rcactionary role, reinforcing chauvin-
LOUISIO!
seker
class
to turn their guns on their own' rul- ing class, and turn the imperialist war
into a civil war.
The war was both a disgrace and a
ates rophe by any te wen million Russians and mother 1hixe million or wounded
err kille
aidi
112•
to October
my were peasants, and the warrinc crisis coincided with a new twist in the problem of the agrarian revolution in
A wave of peasant rebellion took shape alongside the emergence of thie numerically small hut cconomically powerful working class. While Rus- sian capiralists sought to exploit the war as a chance to make fabulous pro-
Russia.
Trotsky addressing a demonstration in Sverdlov Square, Moscow, May 1920
tits, the workers quickly rejected the patriotic propaganda and had begun to fight back by the summer of 1915.
The autumn of 1910 saw growing agitation and mohilisation in the fac- tories, increasing Bolshevik propagan- da: political strikes and demonstra- rions, fraternisation between workers and snidiers, and revolutionary arrivi- ty among the sailors of the Baitic fleet.
Bitter resentent against the Isar
developed at all levels. Even the rank and file nobiliry, the grand clukes,
showed their irritation in Decemhor hy ordering the murder of Rasputin, the mystic who had exercised a hyp notic power over all aspects of royal
By January 1917, 573.000 workers were out on political strikes, and the
nonc p policy
of hread rationing provoked mass resistance on February 19. On 21 February workers at the giant Put-
ilos Petrugrod Petersburg) were locked out after demanding a fifty per cont increase
But it was women textile workers. defying Bolshevik advice and walking
international
on strike women's day (23 Fehruary) who trig
(SI pay
the events of the February Revolution Joined by the vast bread queues who had been told there would he no bread that day, they marched on
Res
Per municipal duma (assembly) demanding food. Next day 240,000 workers were on strike. with 21
the
22
transport halted and school students
The women workers - in their ac-
tions far ahead of most revolutionary groups — also played a key roic in
resistance of the troops.
February the first company of troops
LEN TENIN
mutinied and shot their commander. They swiftly approached other bar-
racks, and began setting up
distribute arms and free jailed political
The same dav sam
Petrogad soviet formed once again.
IT DOUCE led polincal
at te Taurice Dasace
where the dura sat.
The soviet leadership was at this stage firmly in the hands of the Mien. sheviks and (peasant-based) Social Revolutionaries: bur the editorship of the new daily paper lastiye went to a Bolshevik, Bonch-Bruevich
Unable to mobilise forces to contain the Petrograd rebellion, and begged
by his generals to abdicate, the Tsar
did so on 2 March. The Mensheviks
and the capitalist Kadet party were still both terrified of a revival of tzarism and even more fearful of the awakening working class. Though the workers and soldiers called upon them to take power, they would not do s0.
vna*
do
The workers and soldiers controlled Petrugrad, holding the state hank, the treasury, the mint and the post oflice: only the soviet was recognised as the
Social Revolutionary leaders of the soviet promptly dropped all of the
authority.
peace
demands for which workers had been
fighting — the cight-hour day, land
and the repubuc
Incread they meekly sought freedom for political parties and an elected con- stituent assemhly some time in the
reform.
It was on this feeble basis that the leaders of the soviet gave their en- dorsement to a bourgeois provisional
government which included the Social Revniutionary Kenensky
glaring: the Sh's main base was the
they lined op with the
ne Sir....
• minister The contradictions were
peasantry. yet they made a coalition
with the landlonds; and while the Mensheviks rested on workers votes.
cmployers. rather than take power in their hands.
Only fifteen out of nine hundred
the provisional tition wall between knocking it over. din-
government, but Trotsky pointed out:
•In voting for such leaders, the pro- letarians and peasantry erecied a par-
their own aims. They could not move forward at all without knocking into
This began quickly, when militant
soldiers marched to the soviet deman-
ding support for political rights and
themselves and
INTE
themseives,
UPIt
the right of army units to clect their by scialist rolation with the working
class taking the lead in resolving tie
question of dual puwer by establishing its own dictatorship, he argued. The rising clamour for an end to the war
leaders were obliged to agree and en-
St ...
dorse this in general order no. 1,
which also asserted soviet control over all troop movements in Petrograd, Ir
all troop movements in Petrograd, Ir
pu!" distributed far and wide.
The worke werr the next to challenge the line of the provisional government. refusing tu work without pay increases and an
power." eight-hour day. They stayed on strike another twenty days after the soviet had urged them to return tu work, for- cing the soviet to negotiate with the employers on their behall, and winn- ing their demands.
The Bolshevis forces, however were seriously disorientated, Son vecred towards a defencist position on the war: some meresy events, others appeared on the ultra- left, calling for an immediate new uprising Marters worsened with the return trum exile • Sralin Kamenev, who immediarely took over
could only be sarisfied if the capiralists
to democratic peace, one thar is not in- posed by force, without destroving the
In order to br-
ing a permanent end to die war it is
and weir stare were toppled!
is impossible power of rapitulist... essential that the proletarian
carlier analysis of Trotsky
make a
take
Scancely a single leading Bolshevik supported Letin on any of diese ques. rions, though his views echoed the
Only the day belore, led by Stalin and
Kamener, an all-Russian Bolshevik
congress had endorsed a quite op-
echoed the
in 1905.
posite line
The richte
•Thr
The party had to be won over at the
eleventh hour. This is mo hissorical ex-
ception, Trisky later explamed:
instrument of
proletarian revolution is the party. On
- even raking only one ycar, from February 1917 to February 1918 — and on the basis of the supplementary exponence in Finland; Hungury, Italy, Balgaria and Germany, we can posir as almost an unalterable law that a party crisis is inevirable in the transition from che preparatory revolurionary activity to
30. (c)
Tun
ception, Trisky later explamed:
73
fundamental
ad:
*Trotsky argued that the proletariat would have to take the leadership of the democratic revolution and carry it through as part of the socialist revolution -
his theory of permanent
revolution was to be the
key to the events of 1917
al on the
sentlin!
the immediate struggle for power
Lenin was able however to rely on suppor from rank and file Bolshevik workers and soldiers in his campaign to reverse the leadership's policy. By
the time of the next all-Russian con-
ference on 24 April, the majority of
144-
conrral of Prada. The paper promprly dropped the line of opposition to the war. Instead it appealed for the provi- sional government to make an at tempt to induce the warring countries to open immodiate negotiations," pro- mising thar until then every man re- mains ar his fighting post
Tenin's celegram Marh 6 was to insisr:
Our tactic: absolute lack of con fidence; no support to the new govern- ment; susport Kerensky especially; immediate clections to the Petrograd
150 delegates representing
The successful resolution opposed
union with the Mensheviks and de
nounced the provisional government
as a government of landowners and
2153822003
opposcu
and de «Overmen! inuners and
power in the belligerent countries as
rking clas Countles s ar. anc
Bolsheviks began to raise the slogan of "all power to the soviets".
" Kerens
Lenin however lost on his demand for a break from the pacilist Zimmer- wald grouping of socal democrats, und his call for the party to change its
Is reality
maccate
This was ignored: the Bolshevik line name to the Communist Parry
~zalin Spontancons
from the Meas
ignored: the Bolshe
Stalin less and less
line: in many areas the two parties began operating as one
When nin returner any. the his first words were of the imminence
of socialist revolution He went un to of necialist revolus fight for this line on the central com- mittee, spelling out his views in the pamphlet, the April Theses:
The democratic gains of Febraary could only he defended and completed
Febr
PAL-TUN
rude ur pr exposed again the precarious balance
of dual power between the soviet and
Military 401818718803
General Korniloy wanted to mobilise
vehicles against
state
The provisional government
destabilised - and restructured with SOCIALIST OUTLOOK 104 November/December 1987
armoured stop this.
the
workers: but the soviet asserted 3ts authority under general order no. 1 to
six 'socialist" ministers, including top Menshevik Tieretelli, alongside the capiralises: Against
Bolsheviks steadily gained
MI and June. unionisation, factory committees and strike action continued to grow.
Ar the first all-Russian congress of
this. the
ground
finitstere uitnee oul
ascHe r
LeAsuUWk When SR
agriculture, Chernov, came out to the demonstrators and declared good rid-
dance to the Kaders who had left the
he was greeted with
the
government, ha
minister
of thel
of the revolution which was possible in April, May. June and up to July 5:9,
ice. up to the time when acrual power passed into the hands uf the military dictatorship.
"This slogan is no longer correct, for it does not take into account thar power has changed hands and that the
soviets, 1,000 delegares represented
over 20 million workers and soldiers.
Less than twenty per cent of delegates were Bolsheviks, though the party was rapidly winning support.
anger: Take the power (-..) when they give it to you! yelled one angry
revulution has in fact been completely betrayed by the Mensheviks...
SRs:
*Let us gather forces, reorganise them, and resolutely propare for the armed uprising, if the course of the
country-wide scale... The aim of the insurrection can only be to transfer power to the proletariat, supported by the poor peasants, with a view to put- ting our party programme into cffect."
A sign thar despite the witch-hunt the Bolsheviks awe gathering forces, came carly in August when Moscru Bolshevik calls for a strike on the day of a state conference Kerensky to consolidate his coalition
But it was the attempts of the ex treme right of the officer corps under
to carry military coup against the sovicts and
and the
mass,
cunvented by
through a
provisional
of their
who
The reactionary line of the com- promisers was exposed to ridicule on 24 June, when the Bolsheviks intervened
in a demonstration called by the con- gress of soviets — and the vast majori-
banners carried
the government resigned that afternoon, only to be
who refused to accept their resigna-
gave them a vote
forestalled by the sovict
of Bolshevik demands "down with the ten capitalist ministers!" down with the
confidence! the
*the war was a catastrophe
allensive!" "all power to the soviets!
But the forces of counter-reslution
attempting to mobilse. Militant factories were closed down; union members were lucked vut; divi- sions at the front were disbanded for
and top army officers. protected by the capitaliss Kadets and
bankers and allied em-
prepare for a
- out of fifteen million
Russians mobilised, two
Were also Minrant tar
and a half million were ed to.
killed'
disubedience: funded by
began to
The state, meanwhile, still had reserves of repressive strength, and the compromisers were still determin-
Kerel.: with the capitalists
ad The
barsies. crackdown. ment claiming
prevent demonstration came to an
ning the first relable troops.
the
batallions,
and
end, on
HAFTV HEA
hand- most reactionary
arrived
General Kornilov
against Kerensky's: government which finully enabled the Monste to break vut isolation.
Kerensky's fellow ministers resign- ed on bloc on August 26, leaving him confronted demanded
On 2 July, four Kadet ministers pulled out of the provisional govern-
thar the ministers would not act against the
The workers und suliders for their part, were pushing forward
"socialist"
but at
workers who walked out
picked from guards Petrogard
begun arresting
'it was women textile
workerx.
Par an uneven pace
The end of lune and
Bolshevik leaders
with Kornilov,
thar the provisional
should surrender all puwer to him as comtnander in chie! The workers, however, muved swiltiy 10 prepare their self defence.
This was the period of rapid growth of the militia forces of the Red Guards, a rival to the armed forces of
and trained by
beginning of July saw the Bolsheviks struggling in vain to restrain the spou
masses, who had developed far faster than workers in the provinces or the
rowlin
mili
Petrograd
women's day, triggering
the events of the February
on strike on international
troops at the front. feared thar a premi cuulu give for a crackrin.
could be inclared
However, when the workers of the Putilos works and soldiers of the machine gun regiment voted solidly for an armed demonstration on 3 July. the Bolsheviks had no choice but to lend support. The march went to the provisional government and the ex-
mpromises
The troops had been fed on a dict of
lies alleging Lenin to be a German massive hit back
workers - to the delight of the
tie capitalist state militant soldiers. The Red Guards an- nounced that thcy could mobilise 40,000 workers with rifles to combar Kornilov's threars.
Me.. while Tail and telegraph workers developed their own style of workers control, brilliantly sabotag- ing Kornilov's troop movements and communications. Workers fraternised
from Kornilor's. most feared divisions - whn then
their oflicers. and
spy. This was to prove the start of a
witch hunt Bulsheviks as the counter-revolution
against th:
ecutive of the soviet, both of which sat in the Tauride palace. Their demands: were for the removal of the ren
10 July.
Lenin was forced into hiding. On
Trotsky
I SEMINCEA
iilee
3 nine thi was
amested.
suppress- sRs ne
delled
with troups began arresring holding mass meetings.
capitalist ministers, all power to the soviets, a hale to the offensive, con- fiscation of bourgeois newspapers and printing plants, nationalisation of the Tand and state control of production.
While the Mensheviks and SRS prevaricated, hoping that loyal troops would return from the front to rescue them from the workers, the Kronstadt soldiers and sailors just down the river
line te
further their war ellort.
own coalition capitalist ministers and to back the
with
The episode ended when Kerensky "arrested" Kornilor to save him from a
firing squad. These events had brought the Bolsheviks back to the forefront; they had en- couraged new layers of workers to arm and organise themsclees, and they had totally discredited the compromising leaders of the provisional government, who were seen as having opcned the
and ans
While
Since these same parties were still
лет Tenan on
revolutionary
dropped the slogan of all power to the
reemphasised the lea
thent romm decided
role of the working class and of the
Parry in completing the
Bolshevik
the
next day
revolutionary struggie:
all pawes
ur Deacelul deve
"Loyal' army units called in by the SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 4 Novembw/December 1987
was a slogan for peaceful development: door for Kornils •
23
ROCKED BY thr failed revolt, Kerensky's provisional govem- ment had collapsed. Worse from his
capitalist October!
Komilov 10 the
more of the most hated arrested or murdered.
The Bolshevins stept avitation throurhout *
in idleness, the workers insisted rhat the garrison remain snact.
The soldiers in return campaigned for the workers to be armed, The com promisers themselves unwillingly helped this process along, when they suggested to the soviet a resolution for setting up a 'commitice of revolt- tionary defence, supposedly to pro- icer the capiral against the advancing
point of view was the new insistence from his own social revolutionary par- ty that be should not lead another government containing ministers.
question was cresH
which clas
Workers m the arn cerablishe methods at transition
He was reduced to a directorate of five: Meantime from his hiding place.
five: Meantime from his hiding place. Lenin wrute (WO letters Bolshevik central comminice urging the leadership to prepare the seizure of
German army.
To their surprise the Bolsheviks ac-
cepted the proposal: they had often
thus discusscd HANDE up any armed
over the organisation of the Soviet to lead the
insurrection - how the Mensheviks
themselves had proposed to set up a
body that could do just that!
The central commince met. on Oe-
tuber 10. with Benin secretly in atten
dance. He movod a resnlution calling the on party organisarions to turn their al-
tention to the practical questions in-
volved in the armed insurrection Ou- the ly Kamener and Zinovies vrited
Lenin Lund until this prost
been isolated on the question of insur-
rection now the leadership had swing
in hix direction.
The same meeting set October 15 us
the target date for the insurrection.
but this proved ampussible On O-
cober 10. al Lenins insistence, the victorious finish and a sepurate peace
central committee met
Kameney and Zinovier again opposed aimed against Russia: while the petty
fixing any darr for the insurrection.
while Krylenko argued that it was still
too soon to set a date because events
were still developing lavourably apd
"the thing is already begun"
Lenin pressed a new resolution call-
ing 'all organisations and all workers
power. While the objective conditions had not existed in July, the situation
"The point is to make the task clear to the party. The present task must be an armed uprising in Petrograd and
Moscow (with its region), the seizing
overthrow
The vanguard of the working class
swung hehind Bolsheviks, as demonstrared by their dominant positions in the main soviets (they had won control in Petrogad; Mascow, Kiev, Odessa, and other key cities): a revolutionary upsurge was
throughout the
developing tryside; the once. united allies were now wavering between a war to the
bourgevisie, under the pressure of the masses, had hegun to move politically.
The Menshevike and SRs, however, still fought tooth and nail to hold back developments. Through their hold on the executive of the all-Russian soviet they convened a democratic con- Terence, wlich in turn voted to set up a new talking shop, known at the pre- parliament. Meanwhile, fearing that the Bolsheviks could win a clear ma-
postponed the already
overdue recall all Russian congress of
Lenin argued for a bovcott of the
of Trotsky, who had now been releas
ed from jail and reciccied president of the Petrograd soviet → this time. as a
Bolshevik. He led the Bolshevik fac-
tion out of the pre-parliament amid
cries from the Mensheviks about "Ger-
man gold But the Kadet Miliukov
Mi. feeling a power
sent i telegram to the central ex- ecutive COTEIETEETE removal of Kerensky.
calling for the
and began holding up the movement of govern- ment freight.
A similar state of affairs was also developing within the army, where fraternisation began again after the witch-nuntine
fraternisation began again after the
.. lass.
Nadhezhada Krupskaya, organiser of contacts between the exiles and the Russian underground
manufacture to peacelul production.
of factory he Moscow comeri and shop committees declared that in
shop comttutier future all strikes chn decre of establishing soviet power
establishing capitalists.
the
local
soviet,
again.
Bolsheviks in the
лк list ot
and soldiers to an all-sided and most vigorous preparation of armed insur- rection". It was rarried by twenty votes to the two of Kamener and Zinovies, with three abstentions.
The next day, the soviet executive. cumruitlee — appalled by the massive
Perrogad sovict (the Bolshevik list of candidates won 443 votes, to the left. SRi 162 and a mere 11 for the Men
again postponed the open- ing of the congress ul soviets, to Oc-
These five extra days were to. be usefully employed by the Bolsheviks in preparing the insurrection: but on the same day. Kamenes and Zinoviev
victory of tic
Day by day the rival government of the soviets grew. 6d 25 capitalists began themsciv sabotage the war effort in an attempr to discredit the revolution — only to be usurped ny factors CUI which stepped in and took control of production.
The enormous growth of support for the Bolsheviks, and their success in
Bolshevik forcing the executive commitice to
ine Men
sEC-
attemp
-25
hear sure
broke ranks and denounced the
convene the congress of sovicts for Oc- rober 20 made Lenin even more impa- tient to begin the insurrection.
Events leapt forward when the government issued an order for the reorganisation of the Petrograd gar- rison units in preparation for a new offensive.
The response was. immediate
supplies,
monng the capitalist accusatione e Petrograd soldiers
plans in the press. Though Tenin branded them strike-breakers of the revolution and
demanded their expulsion, the central
non-parry
committee would not agree
Meanwhile
the committer of
conamed
immittee
had gone about its work with a will.
setting up departments of defence.
and in
telligenice. One regiment after another
SOCIALIST GUTLOOK no 4 Novamber/December 1987
A poster by Victor Deni depicts Trotsky as Saint George slaying the counterrevolutionary dragon
Stalin - when he and
Kamenev returned from exile and took over control
of Pravdo its line became
less and less
distinguishable from that
of the Mensheviks
The satirical magazine Red Pepperintroduces its readers to the
Soviet United
football team
SOLIALIST OUTLOOK
25
Petrogran and garrison.
into the hands of the organ ol the
ANViCT soldiers" deputies, the mulitary revolu-
of workers" ind
rinnary committee, which stands ar the head of the Petrograd proletariat
The cause for which the people were fighring, immediate proposal ofa
peace. abolition of landlord property rights over the land; labour control over production; crea-
democratic tion of a soviet government recolitice peasants."
cause is sccurely achieved. Long live the
of з0orimn soldiers
By the carly hours of October 26,
the winter palace had surrendered and
that 26
the ministers
government were placed under arrest Kerensky was not amongst them: he had fled in order to bring
troops to rescue the compromisers:
At 8.40 in the evening of October 26, the pracsidium of the congress of soviets, headed by Lenin, came in to the congress, greeted by thunderous
of the provisional!
loyal"
Octor
the congress, greeted by thunderous
red the
rostrum, and when the cheering had
We shall now proceed to construct
He went on to outline the soviet
no annexations, no indemnities, and the right of peoples
A patrol of Red Guards from the
Putilov factory
Petrograd 1917
soviets.
was placing itself under the conimit- ice's command, refusing to go to the front unless ordered by the soviet.
The prolonged period of dual power was giving way to the power of the
with ever fewer dependable troops.
rison conference called on
vehicles, The insurrectinnary forces wen now.ready for action.
In the early bours of October 25.
applause. Lenin died down he announced: the socialist order! terms for peace to self-determination.
Ked Guard detaclie
The provisional government
found itself more and more isolated.
On October 21, the Petrograd gar-
the all- Russian congress of soviets to "take
of the strategic points in the capital, with hardly a shot fired. At-seven am the telephone exchange fell, and com munications to the winer palace, where the provisional government was still in permanent session, were cut
He then read out the proclamation to the peoples and governments of all the belligerent nations. adopted unanimuusly by the congress
Next Lenin read the doeren on land.
ownership of land was
all landowners
the power in its hands, and guarantee to the peuple peace, land and broad" The next day the Petrograd sovies had called a peacelul review of its forces. It was a huge success with very large hall filled with workers and soldiers demanding down with Down with war! All power in the soviets
The high command asked for talks with the military revolationary com- mittee: the committee agreed - in urder to reconnoitte
which was
When the second congress of the all- Russian soviet prasants" deputies eventually openod
workers
at 10.40pm everything had gone ac-
cording to plan except that the winter
palace had still not fallen - and the
and
Mensheviks and SRs railed against the Bulsheviks for attacking it
All private abolished,
vote against: canguard had honuured its commit- ment to the agrarian revolution, and the peasant delegates were overloved
The Bulskeyiks made clear they were prepared to share power with
on this: basis.—
people's commissars
whatever forces
Kerensky!
_estates were transferred to land committees and peasants' soviets. The land decrec was debared and passed with only onc
Lie working class
However. the clections for the
talk the
presiding council saw the Bolsheviks win fourteen scats to the SRs seven, the Mensheviks three and the Interna- tionalists only one. Seeing that they were a minority, the compromisers denounced the Bolsheviks and march- ed angrily out of the soviet.
Jolm Reed, the American journalist
the Bolsheviks:
ww the Bi
insirie enemy's headquarters. hut warned
that the conmissars, as represen
any socialist party which was prepared to accept the legitimate transfer of the power to the soviets. Only the left SKA
ratives of the soviet, are invinlable.
Tronsky pointed nur that in this
period the military revolutionary com- mitter was crowding out the govern- ment with the pressure of the masses, with the weight of the garrison. Ir is taking all that it can without a bartle Ir is advancing its positions without
It was the provisional government itself which gave the pretext for laun-
were prepared to join the government
and the Bolsheviks welcomed them into the council nt.
The capital had been conquered. Now it had to be delended against
.. standing up with a pale, cruel lace, letting our his rich voice in cool
"All
these so called socialist compromisers, these frighten- ed Mensheviks, social revolutionaries.
firing.
Thanks to DAVID KING for
the use of ched troops to photographs Bolsheviks* printing press and shit off
from his the phone to the Smolny institute
collection. which was headquarters to the soviet
as well as the Bolshevik party: The
milirary revolutionary
26 machine gunners
Kerensky could muster, and the rest of Russia had to be won over to the revolution. This was the daunting task that confronted the Bolsheviks on the third day of che
Bund — let them go! They are just so much refuse which will be swept away
ching the insurrection, when it dispat- into the tartare neat ol ...
Papers appeared on the streets car- revolution
close down the
committee and the
rying the proclamation of the military
'To the citizens of Russia!
committee responded by fortifying Smolny with sehe government is
and armoured
The provisional deposed. The state power has passed
Bur whatever material and political
problems later beset the revolution. the conquest of power by the armed working class and its revolutionary party stands as a toming pomt in history: This was, and 70 yars later still is, our revolution e
so & November/December 1997 SOCIALSE CURLOUR
US S R
There was a time when the bourgeois press would with the apparent dynamism of the West. Now it
looks a lot like the other way round. But what is
Gorbachev and the left
contrast the gerontocracy in the Sovier Union
rcally going on behind the rhetoric of glasnost and perestruikn? In a challenging article OLIVER MACDONALD asks 'should socialists support
sorbachevism avainst Bi
THE LEFT is still very fur from achieving a consensus on the Gorbaches leadership. It would be casy and half-true
31. se
half-true
to say that this is because of decp differences of analysis and programme in relation to the Societ Union. Yet this cannot be the whole story: tendencies which share the same programmatic tradition on the USSR differ sharply
on their appreciation of what is happening there. Indeed.
there are differences within this or that tendency on this
ITE For e sane pres on their appe there arr titter question.
mele
: Ter this dare the
sharpl
Indeed,
this
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK: nod November/December 1987
Dems Dorde Rolle
Mikhail Gorbachev - should socialists support "Gorbachevism' against 'Brezhnevism'?
Solidarnose - 'we cannot expect the rise of a similar movement within the Soviet working class in the present situation'
genuine events ankar neativ into out the bchaviour into supertieras, Gorbar ‹ shoul he sho be de what ne will
Such differences must
woblem
at least partly derive from
hand.
he should he denounced for Y on Tuesday: who knows what he will do on Wednesday! We haven't penctrated 27
Duncirated
28
US SR
11.
bencath the surface of events to the inner logic of the
If this is the state of our thinking then there is only one solarion: an open, discussion in which wr use a clash of opinions to reach a higher understanding, grasping the process in the Sovie Union as a whole and grasping is contradiction. If we look back at the debate which the trotskvist movement had in the late 1940s over what was happening then in Eastern Europe, we will have a model
PERHAPS ONE of the main roots of our intellectual anxietics about Soviet events derives from the following puzzle: there seems to be a dramatic break berween the policies of the Brezhnev cra and the present policies. especially in Soviet timestic puitics, vet there has teen no political upheaval. Is there a genuine break with the past,
There is a clear break with the Brezhnev heritage if we define that heritage in terms of three key idcas:
• the idea that the USSR had for the first time in its history achieved a decisive and irreversible degr security through its strategic arsenal and its relations with
• the idea that the USSK was an society requiring only minor adjustments and quantitat- ive improvements in order to progress uninterruptedly