Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Always waving the bosses' flag

· Socialist Outlook no. 30, February 1991 · pp 15-18 · 4,147 words

Middle East Palestine Asia Labour Party

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 30, February 1991

GULF SPECIAL

The Labour Party and imperialist

wars:

The jingoistic support of the Labour Party (and TUC) for the imperialist war in the Gulf should come as no surprise. Since its for- mation in 1900, the Party has been almost unswerving in the backing it has given to British imperialism's foreign interests in general, and it's wars in par- ticular, reports PETE FIRMIN. In the run up to the First World War Labour, like all the European parties of the Socialist International, was opposed to war. At the Socialist International con- ference in 1910 it was the British delegates who proposed a cross-Europe simultaneous general strike in the event of war (though this policy was defeated).

On July 30 1914 the Parliamentary Labour Party unanimously passed a resolution ex- pressing the hope that on no account will this country be dragged into the European conflict in which, as the Prime Minister has stated, we have no direct or indirect interest'. It also called upon all labour organisations in the country to watch events vigilantly so as to op- pose, if need be, in the most effective way any action which may involve us in war".

As war threatened, huge demonstrations backed the Labour leaders" calls for peace. On August 2, Keir Hardie and Arthur Hender- son (the Party secretary) spoke at a mass demonstration in Trafalgar Square urging the government to keep out after Germany had declared war on France.

However, as soon as Britain did enter the war, Labour swung over to support. Ramsey MacDonald (later the Labour Party's arch- traitor for forming a National Government with the Tories in 1931) opposed the war and resigned as leader. Henderson took his place and the great majority of the Labour Party supported the government, took part in the recruiting campaign and accepted an electoral truce. Labour got its first taste of government when Henderson was rewarded with a cabinet post in Asquith's coalition and two

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 30, February 1991

Labour

John Harris/FL

other Labour MPs took junior office.

Keir Hardie and MacDonald didn't like the war but opposed any agitation aimed at ending it. In September 1914, Macdonald joined with four anti-war Liberals to form the Union of Democratic Control', which demanded democratic control of foreign policy, no annexations, an international or- ganisation to maintain peace, and disarma- ment.

In 1916 Party conference opposed the con- scription bill on principle, though saying the party would cease agitation on the question if it was passed.

When Lloyd George formed a new coali- tion goverment in December 1916, Labour- representation increased.

The Party's "Memorandum on War Aims"

drawn up towards end of 1917 demanded the establishment of a League of Nations and machinery to deal with international disputes.

One of the few honourable attitudes taken by the Labour Party in foreign policy came in 1920 over the issue of imperialist intervention against the Soviet Union. At the end of April 1920 London dockers had refused to load the Jolly George' with ammunition and other supplies for Poland in it's offensive against the Soviet Union.

By July 1920, the Polish army was in retreat with the Red Army in pursuit. Talks over a peace settlement broke down, and on 3rd August the British government warned the Russians that they would come to the aid of Poland if the Russian advance continued. On August 4, Henderson as Party secretary sent out telegrams(!) to all affiliated Labour Parties and Trades Councils warning of 'the extremely menacing possibility of an exten- sion of the Polish-Russian war and strongly urging local parties to organize "citizens demonstrations" for the following Sunday to protest against intervention and the supply of men and ammunition to Poland.

Party leaders signed a manifesto exonerat-

ing the Russians from responsibility in the crisis and waming that 'Labour will not co- operate in a war as allies of Poland'. The government proceeded to back off from giving armed support.

However, when the first Labour govern- ment was formed in December 1923 it had no no qualms at continuing imperial rule over the colonies as before, including the aerial bomb- ing of Iraqi villages in 1924. The National government of the 'pacifist Macdonald at- tempted to crush the Indian revolution in 1930 with the jailing of Gandhi and the shoot- ing down of workers and peasants.

In late 1935 Italy invaded Abyssinia (Ethiopia). In the run up to this both the TUC and LP conference overwhelmingly passed resolutions pledging 'firm support for any ac- tion consistent with the principles and statutes of the League [of Nations] to restrain the Italian govemment and to uphold the authority of the League in enforcing peace. Neither sanctions nor military action were supposed to be excluded by this, but nothing was done to check Italian aggression: on May 9 1936 Mussolini proclaimed Italy's annexa- tion of Abyssinia - and Labour did nothing.

When the Spanish civil war started in July 1936 the international labour movement had a policy that 'in accordance with the existing rules of intermational law, the legal govern- ment of Spain should be permitted to obtain the necessary means for it's own defence". But by September the Labour Party was sup- porting the non-intervention agreement signed by Britain, Russia, Germany, Italy and other powers.

It argued that the non-intervention agree- ment might lessen international tension, provided it was scrupulously observed on all sides - a pious hope which no-one could seriously expect to see fulfilled.

As breaches of the agreement by Italy and Germany became clearer pressure on the Party increased, and eventually it adopted the

Page 13

GULF SPECIAL

slogan "Arms for Spain": but was not prepared was extended to 2 years. War between North . initia, th Vint of nomnsion whinh wae and Snuth Koms heoan nn 25th Inne 1050

policy. British military actions came to ani

end within days and Labour let the matter rest.

instead restricting itself to relief work.

The Second World War saw a re-run of Labour's policy in the first. In 1940 Labour joined Churchill's coalition govemment. Two of the five War Cabinet ministers were Labour. Most major figures of the post-war (1945-51) Labour government held high of- fice during the war.

One of Ernest Bevin's first acts as Minister of Labour was the passing of the Emergency Powers Act of May 1940 endowing his office with virtual dictatorial powers to conscript labour. These powers were used extensively against strikes.

In March 1942 Sir Stafford Cripps, a Labour member of the government, was sent to India to pacify the Indian Congress Party leaders who refused to support the war effort unless India was granted independence. He offered India full independence 'after the war'. Gandhi refused this "post-dated cheque and in August 1942 Congress began a campaign of civil disobedience to force Britain to quit India.

With Cripps' approval Gandhi, Nehru and other Indian leaders were arrested. Atlee chaired the cabinet meeting which approved the detentions and British repression led to nearly 1000 being killed by November 1942.

Labour's support for the U.S. in the Viet- nam war is fairly well known. In government Labour backed every horror the US unleashed on Vietnam. As Prime Minister, Harold Wil- son pledged unconditional support for the US bombing of North Vietnam and for their entire Vietnam policy in February 1965.

What is less well-known is the direct in- volvement of British forces in Vietnam at the end of the Second World War. A British ex- peditionary force intervened to bring to an end the first taste of independence that the people of Vietnam had known for 100 years. After the collapse of the Japanese, the Viet- minh, under Ho Chi Minh, had taken power in Hanoi and Saigon. The British force was tech- nically neutral, but refused to recognise the

Vietminh government: its task was to hand

Vietnam back to France which had controlled it before the war.

During this British occupation from Sep-

necessary if Republican Spain was to survive,

tember 1945 to March 1946 the nationalists were quashed at the cost of thousands of Viet- namese lives. At the end of October 1945, 60 Labour MPs issued a statement opposing the use of British troops to restore French im- perialism in the far East".

In March 1946 Atlee became the first peacetime Prime Minister to implement military conscription - National Service of 18 months. When the Korean war broke out this

Page 14

As well as his support for the U.S. in Viet- and two days later the cabinet unanimously ...ma TIe intonintion in mund of thee nam the athas maine foraina rulinu icono

endorsed US intervention in support of the South.

British troops were immediately sent to "assist". When the issue reached the House of Commons on July 5, only three Labour MPs voted against the government action. This same Labour government also helped to crush risings in Greece and Malaya.

Independence was granted to India, but what was depicted as a magnanimous gesture was brought about by the revolt of the Indian

faced by Wilson was the Unilateral Declara- tion of Independence by the white majority in Southem Rhodesia (now Zimbabwe) in November 1965. This was met by Wilson with a declaration that it was illegal and mild economic sanctions.

In 1964 Wilson had called for more helicopters to assist British troops fighting Adeni and Yemeni nationalists; had argued in the same year that it was time for Britain to

'get tough" in Cyprus and send in

tanks; but in Rhodesia the use of force

was ruled out.

Labour's bipartisanship with the

Tories over Ireland over the last twenty

odd years is sordid, including as it does

a Labour Home Secretary sending in

the British troops in 1969 and Labour

introducing the Prevention of Ter-

rorism.

Other than for a short period in the

early 1920s, when discontent was at its

height in Ireland and Labour moved

close to a position of support for self-

determination, this repressive approach

has been consistent throughout.

The support of Michael Foot for

Thatcher's war over the Falklands/Malvinas in 1982 is again well- known, his previous record as a pacifist not preventing him waving the flag.

With rare exceptions we can see that Labour's record is no different to the Tories on foreign policy. Indeed various Labour foreign secretaries have expressed their pride that this is the case. This bipartisanship has made Labour willing to be used in both world wars by the Tories to discipline the workforce "for the war effort" in a way which the Tories themselves might not have succeeded in doing.

Often the opposition within the party to the leadership's line has called vainly for "negotiations", in the hope that they will bring a peaceful resolution to the crisis, or that the use of force must be under the authority of some international body like the UN. Rarely have the "Left' taken a principled line of op- posing imperialism's wars and building the opposition to them.

Labour is tied hand and foot to im- perialism. Just as it accepts the concept of the

Indian leaders refused Labour's con navy and massive civil disturbances where it was admitted that to stay in India would have needed an occupation force of 500,000 men.

In 1948 the Nationalist Party in South Africa won an election and established apart- heid. Labour's reaction was that the Nationalists in South africa could be useful al- lies, being "terrified of communism' and in "complete sympathy" with the aims of British foreign policy. A cabinet paper of September 1950 wished to cultivate South Africa's good- will from the general strategic and defence points of view.

Labour's backing for NATO throughout the post-war period is hardly surprising, since it was Bevin who established it in 1949. Atlee also introduced the nuclear arms programme, keeping it secret from everyone, including most of the Cabinet.

Out of government, Labour had one of its few serious disagreements with the Tories over foreign policy in 1956, over Egypt's nationalisation of the Suez canal. On Novem- ber 1 1956 Labour declared itself profoundly

shocked by the British govemment's attack on "national interest" on the economy, so it ex- Egypt and called on it forthwith to cease all tends this to 'foreign policy", often more. so,

wanting to prove its respectability. military measures against that country.

There is another tradition, of socialist in-

The Labour Party organised public meet- ings on the theme 'Law - Not War" but the temationalism in the history of the British limitations of this are seen in its call on people working class, one which the Labour and to "use normal constitutional parliamentary Trade Union leaders would like to keep methods to to bring pressure to bear on the buried. Our task is to take this up, and for as government and to refrain from industrial ac- long as these leaders can claim to speak in our tion as a means of influencing national name take up the fight against them.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 30, February 1991

GULF SPECIAL

The fight for

unity of the

Arab nation

Saddam Hussein has attempted to link the issue of his invasion of Kuwait with the oppression of the Palestinians by the Israeli state. While Saddam raises the issue of the Palestinians for his own demagogic reasons - to pose as the champion of the Arab nation - there is indeed a clear link between the question of the annexation of Kuwait and the denial of the rights of the Palestinians: that link is the issue of the Arab nation.

To understand this question it is necessary to look at how the present Arab states came into being. Here, GEOFF RYAN looks at developments in the Mashreq (the part of the Arab world east of and including Egypt).

In the Middle Ages the Arabs established an empire stretching from what is now Saudi Arabia to present-day Mauritania and as far North as modem Turkey and parts of Europe. The development and growth of the Arab empire created a single Arab nation - not a number of dif- ferent Arab nations.

The conquest of the Arab empire by the Turkish Ottoman empire did not change this historical reality. The Turks created different provinces - but this was essentially for ad- ministrative purposes. Under the Ottoman em- pire there remained a single Arab nation, which waged a united campaign against Turkish oppression.

The creation of the present

states

The present states that exist in the Arab world are all products of the conquest of the Ottoman empire by Western - particularly

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 30, February 1991

British and French - imperialism.

The process of British and French in- tervention into the Arab world began in the 19th century. By 1830 France already controlled Algeria, from where it was able to gain control of Morocco and Tunisia; and by the end of the century Britain emerged as the dominant power in Egypt, even if this was still formally at- tached to the Turkish

British troops in Palestine empire and didn't be- come a British colony until after the First divided it up into two small states - based on World War. In 1899 Britain gained control of the Allaouite and Druze religious faiths - in

order to try to weaken the Arab national Kuwait.

However, it was primarily the carve-up of movement. However, given the lack of en- the defeated Ottoman Empire at the end of the thusiasm of the Arab peoples of all religious

First World War that brought about the crea- tion of separate states in the Arab East. The states that came into existence - Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Transjordan, Palestine, Yemen, Egypt and the various small Gulf states - did not correspond to any nation- al divisions; they were essentially geographi- cal names. Hence Lebanon is the name of a mountain; Transjordan means "across the river Jordan", while "Saudi" Arabia is the name of the ruling family. The borders of these states corresponded to the imperialists" spheres of influence, not to any real geographical boun- daries. Hence the borders of Iraq correspond to the sum total of the concessions granted to the Iraq Petroleum Company.

Although the Ottoman empire did have a province called 'Syria' (the name refers to the long dead Assyrian people, not to any existing nation) it was not precisely delimited. In fact the Ottoman province of Syria included the whole of the territory of Palestine. In the 19th century the terms Syria and Palestine were even used interchangeably.

And "Syria' provides the most extreme ex- ample of how the present Arab states have no real historical basis. The French initially

beliefs this plan had to be abandoned.

The carve-up of the Arab East was not. however, simply a product of inter-imperialist agreement. It also contained large amounts of inter-imperialist rivalry which had its effects on the Arab national movement. British im- perialism in particular recognised the growing strength of Arab nationalism and was prepared to use this nationalist feeling for its own ends.

In 1915 Sir Henry MacMahon, the British High Commissioner in Cairo promised Hus- sein, the Sharif of Mecca (and father of Faisal, future founder of the Hashemite dynasty), an Arab kingdom in return for Hussein leading a revolt against the Turks. Whilst Hussein was far from being a revolutionary nationalist - in fact he hoped by his alliance with British im- perialism to defeat the rising nationalist move- ment - he allied himself with Nationalist army officers whose goals went much further than those of British imperialism. (Just to be on the safe side Hussein proclaimed himself King of the Arabs in 1916 whilst continuing to negotiate with the Turks both before and after the "Arab Revolt" of June 1916). Because of the weakness of its leadership, the "Arab

Page 15

GULF SPECIAL

Revoll" was, however manipulated by British tinue to enjoy their privileges, protecting their imperialism - via the famous "Lawrence of social, economic and political positions. Arabia". Hussein never gained his Arab French imperialism was particularly adept at kingdom, though his imperialist allies later manipulating religious differences to further gave the thrones of Irag and Jordan to his sons divide the movement. Finally there was the Faisal and Abdallah.

problem of the Zionist colonisation of Pales-

The Sykes-Picot agreements tine.

Despite all these problems the Arab na-

At the same time as MacMahon was dis- cussing with Hussein, more meaningful tional movement did grow, and gained an in- negotiations were going on between the fluence in all the states of the region. British and French diplomats Sir Mark Sykes Moreover, the limited industrialisation that and Charles-Francois-Georges Picot. These occured created an Arab working class which produced the famous Sykes-Picot Agreements rapidly became involved in the national move which agreed on the division of the spoils of ment. Its ranks were joined by peasants the Ottoman empire between British and thrown off the land. Previously confined to a

movement of intellectuals the Arab national French imperialism.

Obviously the Sykes-Picot Agreements movement became more and more a move. were totally at odds with the promises made to ment of the masses.

Hussein making no provision for any inde- pendent Arab kingdom. Naturally they were kept secret until published by the Bolsheviks

after the Russian October Revolution. The revelation of the Sykes-Picot Agreements finally broke any alliance between the Arab nationalist movement and Britain.

It was for this reason that, not convinced of the ability of the Hashemites and other reac- tionary Arab leaders to keep the national movement in check, Britain turned to another source of support - the Zionist movement.

Balfour Declaration

In November 1917 the British Minister of Foreign Affairs Lord Balfour wrote to Sir Lionel de Rothschild to inform him that "His Majesty's Government view with favour the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people".

The formula of "a national home" was of course deliberately vague in order to win sup- port for British imperialism's plans from the Zionist movement - and particularly to en- courage the Zionists to mobilise American

Unfortunately, in Palestine the Arab na- tional movement remained under the control of the big landowners. They were able to divert the nationalist movement into violently anti-Semitic channels, including allying them- selves with the Nazis. This aided not only the bourgeois nationalists and the British rulers, but also the Zionists themselves. In fact many of the leaders of the national movement were actually in the pay of the Zionists, some of whom were themselves quite willing to work with Nazis.

Nevertheless there were major clashes be- tween Arab nationalists and British im- perialism. In 1933 a General Strike took place, for once directed not against the Jews but against the British Mandate. Small scale guer- rilla actions began in 1935 and a further General Strike - which lasted 6 months - began in 1936. Gradually the movement

developed towards full-scale rebellion in

which the workers and peasants played an ever increasing role.

The British Civil Service and police force were driven out of Arab towns and a rebel ad- ministration was set up in the liberated areas, including the Old City of Jerusalem. Support committees were set up in all the neighbour- ing Arab countries, whilst volunteers from Syria, Iraq and Jordan joined the guerrilla struggle.

The Second Arab Revolt lasted until 1939, and was only defeated by massive British military intervention, including by the RAF; it confirmed a number of points about the nature of the Arab revolution. Firstly it showed that the feudal land-owners and the Arab bour- geoisie were incapable of leading any real struggle against imperialism. By 1939 the Mufti of Jerusalem, head of the powerful Hus- seini family, had succeeded in diverting the Nasser: no democrat struggle into virulent anti-Semitism. The Mass camnaions were led in Rovnt hu the Mufti wae in fart mauinealone.and olnoor.to

and Russian Jews to support Britain's continu- ing war effort, as well as isolate the Bol- sheviks - whilst at the same time avoiding in- censing Arab national feelings.

The "Balfour Declaration" was certainly a long way short of agreeing to the setting up of a Jewish state in Palestine and at times British imperialist interests were to conflict with those of the Zionists. For Britain the "Balfour Declaration" was simply a way of creating another useful tool to use against Arab nation- al aspirations.

After the partition of the Arab East the Arab national movement found itself having to face up to a very new situation. Firstly, in- stead of being oppressed by a single, and rela- tively weak, power - Turkey - it was now confronted by two major imperialist powers, Britain and France.

Moreover, the movement now found itself divided up between a number of small states, a situation which suited the reactionary Arab feudal landowners and politicians, since it per- mitted them to cling to imperialism and con-

Page 16

nationalist Wafd party in the 1920s and 1930s, which forced the British to make major con- cessions, and in Syria a 50-day General Strike led to promises of independence by the French. A major insurrection took place in Iraq-

The movement was marked by strong secular tendencies. The founder of the Egyp tian Wafd party, Said Zaglal, who played a major role in developing the revolutionary nationalist movement in the early 1920s, put forward the slogan "Religion for God and the Fatherland for Everybody", which contrasts very favourably with the dominant current in present day Arab nationalism.

The extent of this secular approach can also be seen in the attitude taken towards the partition of India by the Arab nationalists. The nationalists supported the Hindu-dominated Congress Party - which argued against parti- tion - and denounced the Muslim League as agents of British imperialism for their support for the creation of a Muslim Pakistan.

Nazism. Morcover, the Husseinis were more concered with maintaining their own posi tions; they carried out terrorist attacks against their political opponents within the nationalist movement.

The Revolt had begun in 1936 as an al- liance of the big landowners, the middle class and the intellectuals supported by the work- ing class and peasantry. However, even by September 1936 sections of the bourgeoisie and landowners had withdrawn from the struggle. Some were even prepared to accept the proposals of the Peel Commission, which called for the partition of Palestine. When the Armistice of 1936 broke down and the strug gle flared up again many of the landlords fled to neighbouring countries.

Secondly the Arab working class was very weak - Zionist policy of only employing Jews made it very difficult for an Arab working class to grow to any great extent - and unable to win the leadership of the national struggle away from the feudal and bourgeois forces.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 30, February 1991

← Students rock Greek government · The fight for unity of the Arab nation →

Something wrong on this page?