Amazon forests
Fate of the Forest Susannah Hecht and Alexander Cockburn Penguin
volves a murderous campaign against all those who live in and from the forest, and whose presence is an obstacle to the destructive exploitation of it by big ranchers, land speculators. and big husiness interests.
These people, the real defenders of the forest, whose Livelihood depends on its preser vation, have forced concessions out of the government, winning some extractive reserves. Legisla- tion has heen passed to defend the forest. Yet the government has not shown the least will even to impose this limited legislation. These laws are ignored with im- punity by the hired guns who as- sassinate union leaders and seek to drive the forest peoples off the
land.
The future of the forest will largely be determined by these social struggles, connected as they are with those of the Brazilian workers in urban areas. The rubber tappers union is af- filiated to the CUT, the inde- pendent union federation. Chico Mendes was a member of its na- tional commitlee.
As Hecht and Cockburn point
out, the proposals of the rubber tappers and the Forest People's Alliance (with the indiansi. arr very radical.
"In other words, they called for popular control over the means of production and distribu- tion of forest commodities, along with the provision of commercial credits to producers rather than middle men. They also called for justice and legal protection of their rights to land and life. These are the concrete clements of a socialists ecology - the only strategy that can save the Amazon and its inhabitants."
The struggle to save the forest is intimately connected with that for social justice in Brazilian society, the eighth largest economy in the world, in which fantastic riches co-exist with utmost poverty and destitu tion. Rarely is it mentioned that Mendes was a member of the Workers Party, committed to the struggle for the destruction of Brazilian capitalism.
Hecht and Cockbum debunk the naive and patronising idea that benevolent ecologister and en. lightened international opinion
will save the forest. Their future will be determined by the suc- cess or failure of the real defenders of the Amazon whose interests coincide with those of the urban workers whose enemies are the very ones who support the rural rich, and tum a blind eye to their bloody warfare against the forest dwellers.
It is unfortunately an indict- ment of the trade unions in Britain and cisewhere that the rubber tappers' union had to depend for money on Christian Aid and Oxfam, to be able to launch their health and education projects which have been so cru- cial to strengthening their or- ganisation.
This book provides a salutory reminder of the need to develop solidarity with the workers and oppressed peoples of Brazil: a country which has a key place in the class struggle in Latin America. Socialists and mem- bers of the "green" movements should demand the unions raise a fund to support the struggles which will have a major role in determining the Fate of the
Forest.
Reviewed by Sam Stacey
Much has been written on the deforestation of the Amazon, and its relationship to the greenhouse' effect. Any number of solutions have been touted, including its "internalisation". But in reality both the causes and the solutions are to be found in the dynamics of Brazilian society, as is explained by Hecht and Cockburn in their excellent book, Fate of the Forest.
For decades now there has been a bloody struggle taking place in the Amazon between the rich, and the poor who live in the forest: the indigenous indians (who have faced a genocidal wary, the rubber tappers, and those who live off fishing and gathering Brazil nuts and other forest products. Deforestation does not only destroy trees. It in
Ripping
Proved innocent by Gerry Conlon Stolen Years by Paul Hill
awav the mask of Britis!
Reviewed by Liam Mac Uaid
The horror of the tale of the Guildford Four told by its two best-known protagonists prevents you from discarding these books in mid chapter. Written in a competent jour- nalistic style with the aid of collaborators these two books should be read without a pause in immediate succes- sIon.
Names and photographs are provided. You can see what In- spector Tim Blake, who tortured Gerry Conion during his inter- rogation, looks like. Nothing is
vay
left vague or abstract, about the backgrounds of Hill or Conion, the treatment at the hands of the cops, the ordeal of prison or how the judiciary performed.
The great strength of both hooks is that they make flesh the torturers, the judges and the brutalised and brutalising screws - and they make you hate every damned one of them. the screws and prison govemors in par- ticular.
The next time you see some oozing weasel from the Prison Officers" Axsociation on TV tell- ing the world what a caring hunch of lads the screws are in Long Lartin or Wormwood Scrubs, you ask yourself "did he piss in Paul Hill's tea?"
On virtually every page of both books, the naked hatred of the prison system, the police, the judiciary and the British govern-
ment for prisoners associated. however wrongly, with the Republican movement, is in evidence. The Irish are given spe- cial treatment. They are habitual- ly moved to prison hundreds of miles away the day before a much-anticipated visit from rela- tives who have travelled from Ireland. Contemplate for a few moments the type of minds that would get their kicks from that sort of thing.
In my opinion the most tragic aspect of the case of the Guildford Four was the fate of Gerry's father Guiseppe. He went to England to help Gerry, and was himself arrested and framed. Not content with framing a transparently innocent man, the