REVIEWS
Lifting the lid on Thatcher's hidden
Choice and Responsibility The enabling state by The "No Turning Back' Group of Conservative MPs Published by the Conservative Political Centre Available at the Conservative Central Office, 32 Smith Square. London SW1P 3HH. Price
Reviewed by Nicole
Black
Be prepared for a shock. This is (in the words of the bloke who sold it to me at the Conservatives bookshop) the programme Thatcher would have adopted if she could bave got away with it! It is simply frightening - the sort of stuff we should all know by heart, and go out and cam- paign against as vigorously as they are arguing for it.
Such a pamphlet acts as a powerful reminder of the in- ability of the left to retake the of fensive against such violent attacks.
The pamphlet deals with a number of clements concerning the nation, the "free society" and the family. In all areas of society. the role of the state is envisaged as a reduced one (true to the desire to "roll back the frontiers" as she said): "The state should not provide, but enable; not stifle but facilitate, not control to the maximum, hut regulate to the minimum extent possible" (p.8).
In other words, privatise every public service possible and give maximum freedom to capitalists whether small or big. They even go so far as suggest- ing a "withering of the state" - but certainly not in the Leninist sense: the state they talk about is the Welfare State, and certainly not the apparatus that defends the position of the ruling class.
They describe this Welfare
State as 'socialist", and use - quite powerfully. I think, for the majority of the public - the col Lapxe of Eastern Europe as the evidence against state power:
"The last ten years, and events in Eastem Europe, have indeed graphically demonstrated that affluence can only be delivered through private
enterprise. Squalor is the preroga- tive of the public sector." (p.18)
They argue for an accelera- tion of the reforms undertaken: -We must intensify the assault on the very concept of individual dependence on state provision of health care, education and social security" (p.8) because "until the final bastions of socialism are stormed, a socialist revival can never be discounted" (p.19).
How is this translated into practice? "Our purpose should be to wean people off welfare. We advocate the systematic reform of the welfare system into one based on insurance - run on a private agency system" (p.20).
It is all very logical - from their point of view. You may wonder how people are going to be looked after when they need
it. There is a simple answer: the
family. " We do not believe that
the state can be morally neutral
in its dealing with the very build-
ing block of society - the family" I (p.8) or if you prefer: "We
proclaim unequivocally our I belief in the family as the build-
ing block of society" (p.12).
What does it really mean? For
the family to be able to provide
the services that the Welfare
State will no longer guarantee, it
needs to be a stable unit, and
people should not expect help
from outside. Hence the alfempt
to stop voluntary single paren-
thood by not granting single
parents "automatic entitlement to
state support"; to "impress upon
parents that fatherhood is for
life"; to limit the number of
divorces by making the proce-
dures mor difficult with a
"statutory 'cooling off period":
and to reconsider the position on
Child benefit.
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 29. December/January 1990/91
The free market should reign supreme in the eyes of these radical conservatives. A lot more should he privatised, if necessary finding "new ways of involving the manage- ment, work-force and the general public in the sales of public assets" (p.13). The list includes British Coal, London Underground, London Transport, British Rail, the Post Office, motor- ways and so nn.
The same wonderful logic ap- plies of course to the environ- ment and we can read astounding statements such as: "Market for- ces do not destroy the environ- ment. By fostering high technology and expanding avail- able resources, they protect it" , (p. 159. To iustify this disarming assertion, they take the example 1 of pollution in Eastern Europe. and simply ignore pollution all I over the capitalist world and the way the third world is used as the dustbin of the West.
Another type of argument is that of ownership given that if you own something, you want to protect if. Therefore, "The Brazilian rain forest is being bumt, and not replaced, because it is not owned by anyone"
But are the authors really in favour of doing away with the state? Naturally, not. They want the state which will defend capitalist interests nationally and interationally to be reinforced.
First of all, the pamphlet reiterates the key ideas defended by Thatcher in her famous Bruges speech, namely uphold- ing the supreme sovereignty of the UK, against the so-called bureaucratic or socialist control by another parliament, with another currency. Such as Europe for example. From people who defend multination- als and international finance, this can seem quite ironic. But more is to come. What they really have in mind is to transform Britain
into one of the most exploited and ruthless countries: "We can draw inspiration from the ex- amples of Hong Kong and Sin- gapore and other flourishing Asian states. We should set our- selves the objective of being to continental Europe what Japan is to continental Asia". Fancy being a woker in Singapore, Taiwan or even Japan? This is the "freedom" they advocate all along for Britain when they repeat their "goals of freedom and prosperity".
Necdless to say, the British state would have to be unitary: "We utterly reject the creation of devolved parliaments in Nor- them Ircland, Scotland and Wales. We are totally opposed to regional assemblies in England" (p.10). This state will also be made secure, The changes in Easter Europe require a review of the defence policy but not haste in dismantling the army. and we should build "an effec- tive rapid deployment force capabic of carrying out the tradi- tional role of the army in defence of British trade" (pp.16-17).
Of course, the poor citizen within the state - which will not wither - has to be 'protected' by privatised prisons, and a stronger police.
Why have they been allowed to get away with it? Because so many of their policies now find their echo in Labour's programme, and they encounter no opposition. Kinnock, you are pathetic.
Page 31
REVIEWS
Murder in the