FEATURES
id Coen
sovereignty as a result of Many elements in Ireland, not E
joining the EEC which even- JUSt nationalists nut
rually split it. Because it unionists, are coming round to
wouldn't tax farmers who the view that the solution is
were doing well from the one of economi, but not
post-EEC boom up to the late necessarily political, union as
1970's, and it couldn't tax the a region of the FEC. For that
multinationals - after all, low to work however requires a
tax rates were one of the at-
tractions of investment in the loosening
BOt JUST
South: the Fanna Fail economic but also political
government found itself with ties with Britain. There is a
a growing debt problem. Part more than evens chance that
of the reason for the debt was such a solution will be op
the suhsidy to multi-national posed by a significant section
capital in the attempt to win of the Conservative Party.
and keep investment. By the
DUBLIN MACH
early 1980s, the Free State's:
Charler Haughey - Fran....
ITH
Fail Party in the 26 counties has
debt per capita was among traditionally got its support from
the highest in the world. three different.
Des O'Malley and the forces. Firstlv. Iron. small •..elt Franna Fan 1o farmers. attructed by form the Progressvr (and very limited) commitment to
Democrats (now back in an lind redistribution
SUPPORT/
uneasy coalition with Fianna from the small business people
Fail) did so because of the who gained from Fianna Fail'- Ti financial irresponsibility of
"go it l import restrictions and
govemment. alone" economic he- ARMACH in diffeman. tween coming in power in 1932 and 1958 and third, and most im- portantly, from the working clars wan over by a combination of job creation and puhlic spending
Even when Fianna Fail under Sean Lemass ahandoned the old Sinn Fein self-sufficiency policy in 1058 and opener the ec:my Fianna Fail has always trumpeted its nationalism to foreign capital, it managed to
on military spending was feeling the chill retain its base, its appeal deriving from its
winds of recession as Britain pulled back "cast ability to deliver jobs and to increase state
spending, as against Fine Gael's "balance the
At the same time, it
also
of
often opposing
secondly.
policies
denving rom is
increase state
malane the
managed to placate its traditional rural and
small business support by comhining a con-
servative Catholic populism with careful dis tribution of state jobs and benefits to its own
book» api managed to mall busın ervatıv ( tabution of
approach.
0 Dien
Its claim in republicanism rested mainly on the notion that the best route towards unity
was suslake th wean the unu» far- state. repuolicanısm veemed init.- when in 1065 ster O'Nem Nurthem cconomv.
wean the unionists away from the British wel
This modernisation
republicanism around bread and butter issucs
seemed initially to be having some success
when in 1965, the Northern Irish Prime Mini
ster O'Neill met with Lemass in Dublin. The Norther economy, which depended heavily
of Suer"
Foreign investment, the changing pallems
of trade, and entry to the EEC in 1972 meant a gradual lessening of dependence on Britain. Republicanism for Fianna Fail mostly been a mutter of shifting the economy out from under the shadow of Britain, a policy which ap pealed especially to the farmers who felt ag grieved by the cheap food policy of the British. It also provided a helpful few of funds (especially through the Common
It asser provided
respectally through
ural Policys to t emment from 1977 wr war ancad cu the ability or
spenung
pay for it through taxation.
strangely for paity that
ed its no
stil. st Was
ho
Haughey's There ann
with Haughey over divarce. contraception and particularly
Haughey's tendency, espe-
cially when out of power, in play the nationalist card.
There is very little dis- agreement among the ruling class in the 26 Counties on thr question of European unity. The old ruling class, rge landowners and the hanks,
ur of free trade. They were
mmitted to the idea that
and crand survive wthout
wav or another of the
a clients of
in particular
im the Com
"ased.. are heayau in anyway never
nitalion .. Ire
EE
..Ients u.
snatch»
mon Agricultural Policy. Ir is a bit ironical that they are among the fiercest proponents of
- hit arnical - proponents of
FRC. and the
free trade and the need to end subsidies.
Despite the unity over the EEC, and the
fact that the split in Fianna Fail was over debt and issues such as divorce and contraception, there is nevertheless a serious split in the
was nver debl i spuit in the
lo the
mail's
Souther ruling class on the national question. The hitter divisions which gave rise to the
Lenihan affair arise mainly from Fianna Fail's
Page 24
00!
FEATURES
attitude to the North.
Despite Haughey's betrayal of the Hunger Strikers, his implementation of the Anglo-Inish Agreement and his support for extradition, a substantial section of the ruling class considers him to have a "flawed pedigree", that is be cannot he trusted not to try to whip up nationalist sentiment for hix own ends (The original charge against him was that be at- tempted while a Govemment Minister in 1969 to import arms for the IRA " he was ac-
in IRA
theless be a massive blow to the republicans.
In May of this year, Haughey, as President
of the EEC Council was well received by an
Institute of Directors Conference in Belfast,
this dexpite Unionist complaints about extradi-
Tion decisions in the Dublin Courts and a
demonstration outside led by lan Paisley.
Haughey's speech was on the benefits of a
unified approach to economic problems, North
and South.
Professional optimists like the SDLP's I John Hume seek to carry this further, arguing I that European economuc and political integra- tion should allow greater regional autonomy
mistake of trying to explain the British presence simply in economic terms, when the real reasons are a bit more complex. For the
are a bit more complex. For the British to withdraw from Ireland in any condi-
tions short of a massive and thoroughgoing
defeat of the nationalists would have devastat-
ing effects on British politics - not just the
whip up ands The lat he at.
descat
efte kind of
run 1900 1e SCA
'he Portuguese of withdrawal
- and Angola. which were
nuitary antont, but a tear-
tabne of the British lee mack to the incorporation of
as in "em fate 18th century.
Thatcher's anti-EEC rhetoric and pro-Unionist attitudes were all of a
piece. To contemplate breaking the
Union (and here you can include
also Scotland and Wales) by
European political union, or the
break up of the United Kingdom in
withinkable, She has
described herself an a Unionist. Ap-
parentiy against her instincts,
was prevailed upon to sign the
Anglo-Irish Agreement in 1985. And
this was only an attempt to stem the influence of Sinn Fein.
again in the Presidential election. Haughey was forced by his Coalition partners, Progressive Democrats (PD), to sack his Deputy. Minister for Defence and long time associate, Brian Lenihan, for heing economical with the truth. (Rarely does selfless loyalty to the party require voting tor your non dismissal as Lenihan, in effect, did!) But the dis- pute goes far beyond the PD's claims
abour low standards in high places.
The "flawed pedigree" argument surfaced
partner
ing of the whole political fabric of the British
HA-• has much more to do with the political
direction of pulitics in the South, and direction. the threat posed
any rexidual nationalism in Fianna Fail to the project
- manject
Despite the official rewriting of his-
tory and the down-playing of anything
anti-British (there is to be no official
celebration of the 75th anniversary of
the 1916 Rising), the miling class fears
crisis could up
nationalist sentiment and strengthen the
Republicans, who are identified as the
main threat to the ruling class, north
It
main threat to the ruling class, north and south.
This is why Fine Gaci, while denouncing new president Mary Robin-
son for having the support of a "revolu tionary socialist party 'helieve it ar New iris not. the Workers Party. was happy to negotiate cross voting with her to try to keep Lenihan and Fianna Fail out, And this is the dilemma for the left in Ireland. Robinson deserves support because of her defence of women s rights including contraception divorce and abortion. However, she resigned from the Labour Party over her right-wing ob- jections to the Anglo Irish Agreement and she supports the removal of Articles 2 and 3 from the 26 Counties" Constitution because they
the timing of this referendum would have to take into account a wider range of issues than simply the difficulties it could cause Fianna Fail and it is hard to see it taking place outside of a new attempt at a British settlement in the North. Defeat in this referendum would none-
- will be part of miles 2 und s of that the nationa alties. ould be
New İrish president, Mary Robinson - a moderniser After 1992, the border will anyway disappear as an economic frontier, all that will remain is the 300 mile line of British Army watch- towers.
The whole question of whether a settle- ment of the Inish problem can be achieved within the BEC is however closely lied to British politics and particularly in the debate within the Tory party.
Ireland, was the source of one of the major I divissons in the Party in the 19th century. The other was on trade, centred on the repeal of the Corn Laws. It looks like we are now seeing a third split, potentially as damaging, over. Eurupean union.
Few but the most naive rand least of all those who have first hand experience of the British, or any other, empire) believe that the
reasons for the British remaining in Ireland has anything to do with "peacekeeping". On the contrary, the British are expert in fostering intemal divisions in order to divide and mule. However, some sections of the left make the
Eurupe.. break un simply
sign in 1985
rik.
about talre dragged nu over the past cly to
on the question of whether
"foreign government" - the
21 BayP
tall once agaur.
whether
the 26
Counties, can have a say in the
political structures of part of the UK.
With the magnation of Sinn
Fein's support, there is less pressure
on the British to meet even the mini-
mal conditions on participation pul
forward by Dublin.
Maves toward even economic
unity in Ireland, like the general
progress towards cconomic and political union within the EEC, threaten the dismemberment of the British State. makes the problem in Ireland particularly acute from the Tones's standpoint is that many elements in Ireland, not just nationalists but
also umonists, are coming, round to the view
that the solution is one of economic, but not
necessarily political, union as a region of the EEC. For that to work however requires a loosening of not just economic but also politi-
cal ties with Britain. There is a more than evens chance that such a solution will be op posed by a significant section of the Conserva- tive Pouty.
Making concessions on Ireland or political
that tha
appeestions on Ireland or political ine in in FEC would risk a meltdown at the
with ruling class, though the
both is strong from the
of big capital, if not national
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 29. December/January 1990/91
Page 25