FEATURES
Socialist Outlook and Labour
Briefing - a statement
address
BRIEK
During period we have also seen the develop- ment of the Socialist Move- ment and, associated with it.
Women for Noc the Socialist Movement Union Committee, Labour Party and the Red-Green Network. Both Briefing and Socialist Outlook supporters have wel comed and heen involved in huilding these important initiatives.
For the past year, the Socialist Movement has been discussing whether it should produce a newspaper to further these developments. Socialist Outlook supporters have argued that such a paper is necessary if the potential al- ready shown by LPS and the SMTUC is to be built on, and have argued for such a paper to he campaigning, democratically run, wit clear orientation to the labour movement, in cluding a call to 'vote Lahour' in the coming General Election.
Others involved in Briefing initially agreed with us that such a development would be positive in furthering the building of an op position to new realism across the labour movement. Indeed, at a Briefing Readers. Writers and Sellers meeting in July, it was common ground that this should be fought for.
However, while Socialist Outlook sup-
Aidank porters argued that a successful outcome to such a development would pose the question of whether continuing to produce Briefing would be a viable option, it became clear that other Briefing supporters wanted to maintain Briefing regardless. They refused to recognise that a Socialist Movement paper which aimed, amongst other things, to build Labour Party
Trade
Socialists
and Socialist Outlook supporters have wel
Corbyn speaks at Briefing fringe meeting - LP Conference 1988 Socialists, would be competing with Briefing at a time when its sales were already falling.
This developing divergence produced a crisis over the summer when some of those in- volved in Briefing declared that they wer ning to produce a new monthly Brishing from the new year come what may, and that they had already decided in advance that the Socialist Movement Paper would not fulfil their criteria and had given up the fight for them.
This attitude was shown in a resolution tahled by some Briefing supporters at the recent Lahour Party Socialists AGM. Rather than laking the positive approach of arguing for a Socialist Movement paper of a particular kind, including a clear call to "vote Labour". in an only oblique reference to the paper, they argued that "this objective [of securing the highest possible vote for labour in every par- liamentary constituency] will be reflected in all public initiatives undertaken, sponsored or xupported by Labour Party Socialists". This negative approach did not even pretend to stem from a view of what LPS should be pushing for.
In the course of these dehates, some Brief ing supporters have not heen averse to mis- representine the position in the Socialist Movement. So far, the Socialist Movement Organising Committee has had only a prelimi- nary discussion of what "line" it should take in the General Election, with no decision reached
Wayne Edgington
other than to continue the discussion, though
the Socialist Movement Officers have come
out for the "vote Labour" position. This has
not stopped some Briefing supporter claim-
ing that the Socialist Movement has decided
not to call for a Labour vote: This is not only
untrue, hut also sees a debate as concluded
which Socialist Outlook is committed to seeing through, not least through Labour Party Socialists input into the debale. Yet to Listen to some Briefing supporters, you would not realise that LPS is an integral part of the Socialist Movement, or that they are con nected in any way.
Different proposals at the Briefing AGM showed the difference in approach. Socialist Outlook supporters who had been on the Briefing Editorial Board put forward a resolu- tion to confirm the decision taken in July to argue for a campaigning Socialist Movement paper and assess the viability of continuing Briefing when it appeared. Other Briefing supporters voted against this and supported a resolation to launch a 'new monthly" Briefing from the new year.
The discussion at the AGM showed not just a difference over the possible continued production (and frequency) of Briefing, but also of political perspective. Several speakers, including the mover of a successful resolution. made it clear that they had never been con- vinced of the correctness of the change to a fortnightly Briefing which attempted to relate
not
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 29, December/January 1990/91
to wider struggles, and welcomed the oppor- tunity to revert to a monthly, appropriate to the rhythm of Labour Party meetings. They also made it clear that, for them, the 'twin-track" strategy consists primarily of telling those in struggle that they need to come into the
Labour Party.
It has been claimed by some Briefing sup- porters that Socialist Outlook is encouraging people to desert the fight in the Labour Party. This is untrue. We continue to see the struggle in the Labour Party as an essential element of a socialist strategy, and are as committed as Briefing supporters to building LPS as the fighting opposition to new realism in the LP and to bringing in new militants to join that
and to bringing in new militants to join that fight However, unlike those who intend to launch the 'new Briefing, Socialist Outlook believes socialists have a duty to provide an overall perspective and strategy for militants. oF which the struggle in the Labour Party is only a part - if an exsential one.
This is not a matter of whether individuals are active in their unions, anti-Poll Tax groups, women's groups or whatever, but whether they (and the newspaper they support) argue a political and organisational way forward for these struggles.
This cannot be simply reduced to an orien- tation to the Lahour Party as the Briefing sup porters argue. It also involves providing tacti- cal answers in struggles, and strategic answers, such as the type of opposition which needs to be built in the unions - and beginning the task of building it. The strategy of the Briefing sup porters is at best only half a strategy, and a one-sided one at that, not to be excused by claims to be "bending the stick"
To bolster this onc-sided emphasis on the
FEATURES
struggle in the Labour Party, some Briefing
Rather than a 'new' Briefing, the comrades supporters have taken to denying reality. In wish to retreat to what they sce as the heyday recognise that the Left in the Labour Party 1s ar st Briefine in the carly 1980c a very dif. present very weak. as Socialist Outlook does enment nenod for the Labour left to the one we is not to provide an excuse for 'opting out.
are in now. It will revert to being the "in-house but to reach a realistic assessment of the tasks
we face and to undertake them without over. blown claims to a strength we do not have.
In addition to building Labour Parv Socialists as the nucleus of a new left opposi- tion in the Party which can stand up to the political and organisational tasks ahead, it also invoives a recognition that such a left will not be rebuilt by a simple emphasis on the struggle in the Party, but by showing activists that it is
part of a wider strategy.
Previous examples of the growth of the Labour left, such as from 1974, show how its resurgence is likely to lag behind, rather than precede militant struggles. To concentrate overwhelmingly on the internal struggle in the Party, using as a promise a denial of the weak- ness of the Left, is to refuse to face the fact that this can only lead to a further ghettoisa- tion of the left, merely leading to the demoralisation of those who are exhorted to engage in continuing trench warfare with the right. A serious approach to rebuilding the Labour left has to recognise the importance of other struggles in this.
Their attitude to the Socialist Movement paper is also, at root, a conservative one. Socialists worthy of the name are always look. ing to widen the field of those they can engage in dialogue and attempt to convince of their ideas. Yet the attitude of many Briefing sup porters is to deride the political "broadness" of the Socialist Movement, rather than see this as an opportunity.
journal' of the Labour left, even if it has some reportage of trade union and anti-Poll Tax
struggles. They have made it clear that to be involved you have to make a long-term com mitment to this format. Socialist Outlook sup porters could not participate on the basis of building Briefing until we make an assessment of the Socialist Movement paper. Furthermore it has been made explicit that those associated with other jourals are not wanted. For all
these rcasons, Socialist Outlook will not be supporting the relaunched" Briefing.
Socialist Owlook supporters had argued that the Briefing current should have a major input into the Socialist Movement puper. In this context, the Socialist Outlook Editorial Board had begun to examine the posibilities of changing the format and frequency of our magazine. Some Briefing supporters have ar gued that we wanted to close Briefing to make room for developing our own publication. rather than developing it to fit in to the Socialist Movement rhythm. This is not true - we could have developed Socialist Outlook to fit into the Briefing rhythm at any time.
Socialist Outlook takes no pleasure from the break with Briefing and with comrades with whom we have worked closely for several years. We hope to continuc to work with them in Labour Party Socialists and the Labour Parry, both nationally and locally, as well as in other areas of work where we are both active.
SOCIALIST MOVEMEN:
Convention for Democracy
12-13 January 1991
Lambeth Town Hall
The words "freedom, democracy. 'nghts have been hyacked. We are told thar we nave personal and pout
market economy which is the best and only system in which human rights are guaranteed We are told that liberty and democracy are simply individual rights: consumer choice, propertv ng) every years.
The experience of millions of people is that: under the power of the market vital personal, collective and politcal rights are ineitably denied without property we have no rights racial and sexual discrimination persist trans-national companies and collusion by goverments • movement.
The Convention tor Democracy will enable sociausts te to develop the struggle for socialist democratic rights.
Plenary/workshop sexsions will focus on: he ways state structures work politicallv economically ncluded forms of oppression of individuals and collectives, operating outside state strictures. what socialists mean by democratic rights.
Campaign workshops on different strugeles for socialist democratic nghts will explore Convention.
suttocate out struggles for self de
meet together to analyse these ahuses and to explore the strategies and tactics needed
and idcologically to denv us our richts. Implications for the local state and EEC will be
For further information contact: Convention for Democracy, 3 King Hear's Yard,
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 29. December/January 1990/91
Londo
SAP
Page 23