nature of the political forces present
the bureaucracy. But much
more importantly it would be deter-
mined by the level of working class
THE CURRENT UPHEAVALS in Eastern Europe have posed socialists with difficult questions. It is often said that there has never been a better time to be a Trotskyist - indeed even the 'Guardian' recently admitted that much of what is happening confirms Trotsky's theory of the political revolution!
However a nagging question on the minds of many socialists is whether this will all end up in pro-capitalist counterrevolution. Here PETER THOMPSON argues strongly against defeatist interpretations of the unification of Germany, and explores the progressive potential of the destruction of the Stalinist dictatorships.
and degenerated worker's states requires Marxists to re-examine some of our basic conceptions.
We have to ask whether there is
THE DEMISE n'
acing the Soviet Union
sher nost-capilanst stater
restoration int rapitalism. volomaty overthrow of the ay by the working clic • hv the -stablishment
anything worth defending in Easter Europe, and this means we must un- ravel the dialectical relationship be-
Europe
democratic socialism.
From bureaucrats to
capitalists?
European
In the find scenario, significant
sections of the hureaucracy would
grasp the opportunities to enrich
themselves and hecome part of the
new capitalist class. As a matter of
necessity they would struggle for the
Jestruction of the bureancracy as the
tween progressive and regressive aspects of the Fastern
albu
As an example of this it is useful to look at the fate of the GDR and the unification of Germany. While
cach country is different, the GDR embodies many "classical' aspects of the deformed workers states.
the deformed workers states.
Tronskyists tamed that then
ruling stranim.
The outcome of these altematives would be determined partly by the
consciousness, and the ability of the working class to construct an edu-
cated and organised political force to
provide a democratic socialist alter- native,
A major problem with the schema has always heen that while it easily fitted a degenerated workers' state
like thc USSR. there were major
problems in simply transferring it to the deformed workers" states like the GDR, where a socialised economy had heen created simply by the oc- cupation of the Red Army. At every stage the moves towards statisation of the economy were decreed by
were forced by imperialism, none theless the GDR remained half a country, effectively under occupa-
On the orber hand it was also a state where historically the hopes for the Left had always been highest. The dream of revolutionaries for the
whole of this century has been the
establishment of socialism in an ad-
industrialised, capitalist country. It centred on the creation of
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 29, December/January 1990/91
"The schema
fitted a
degenerated workers' state like
the USSR, but there were major
problems in
simply transferring it to
the deformed workers' states like the GDR,
where a
socialised
economy had been created
simply by the occupation of the
Red Army,
Page 17
SUPPLEMENT
"The single major obstacle to world socialist revolution was not the Western media or the success of US imperialism, but the existence of Stalinism and its objectively and subjectively anti-revolutionary
policies"
= revenutionary German regime which would come to I- rescue of tho beleagured Soviet Union and form the basis of a world socialist order. Lenin and Tmisky agr day one of the Russian Oc- tober revolution that if Ger- many did not join them then
in he Soviet
• order.
and
socialism Union would he doomed.
In inter-war thermany the working class grew to be come the largest and politi cally most advanced in the world. It was this danger to the international bourgeoisie which prompted their sup port for Hitler and which culminated in the Sccond World War.
Throughout the 20ch cen- tury the objective conditions for socialism have existed in Germany. The development of the productive forces and the socialisauon of Inbour
Housin has been greater than in al- most any other country. However. the subjective element, the unity and
revolutionary consciousness of the
revolutlunat working cho har boen fatally hampereil by those traditional twin enemies, reformist social democracy and Stalinism.
Socialism discredited
This meant that when the generalised slump of the capitalist world in the 1930s brought about so- cial and political upheaval in Ger- many it was the Nazis who were best able to profit from it. Socialism was discredited by the performance of the Social Democrats (who in 1918-19 putt down the revolution led by the Spartacists and the USPD); and hy the horrors of Stalinism in the Soviet Union Despite that. the Social Democrats (SPD) and Communists (KPD) emerged as the strongest political forces in post-war Germany: In 1945 a great desire existed within the rank and file of the SPD and the KPD to merge and create a socialist Germany as soon as possible.
The
ant1-TasCIsE committees which sprung up spontaneously at the end of the war were hmken up hy
KPD stoogee under the leadership of Ulbricht. The unifica- tion of • the two parties was
prevented. Stalin's policy of peaceful
coexistence and agreements with im
perialism to carve the world up
meant that Soviet policy in their oc
Page 18
tion of the reforms from above and the consequent revolutions from below. The question for Marxists is how this process will develop and, more impor tant, how can
we make it direction wr
want?
At a superficial level it ap-
pears that the capitalist restora-
tion scenano is the only one
which can win. I argue strongly
that the developments in east-
cm Europe could lum out to he
entirely positive, despite ap-
pearances.
The debate about whether
the developments in Eastern
Europe are progressive
regressive often follows the
same sterile course as the
debates on Gorbachev. The
"act is that Gorbachev. al-
though trying to force through
objectively anti-working class
policies, has had to introduce
measures which have im-
measurably 'ncreased
capacity and readiness of the
workers to fight for their interests.
New possibilities
The throwing off of Stalinist
repression in Eastern Europe has also opened up new possibilities for revolutionary activity in both Eastern and Western Europe. There is one tact which snould always be borne in mind when examining the collapse of one party rule in the Sovict Union and Eastern Europe: that the single major obstacle to world socialist revolution was not the Western media or the success of US im- perialism, but the existence of Stalinism and its objectively and subjectively
anti-revolutionary policies.
Imperialism conld only be so suc- cessful hecause it was measured against the tyranny of an apparently "socialist" system. Because of that, it could integrate sectors of the work- ing class and its reformist leaders in the advanced countries into "welfare
capitalism', while mercilessly ex- ploting the underdeveloped countries. This was compounded by the Soviet bureaucracy having ab-
solutely no interest in promoting socialist revolution, and doing every- thing it could to stifle it worldwide.
Stalinist betrayals
Most socialists should not need reminding that the list of defeats in- flicted on the working class by Stalinist machinations is long and in-
will be an Immediate problem for Germany cupied zone was "the completion of the bourgeois revolution of 1848' rather than any moves towards socialism.
Forced unification of the two
the ta workers parties and moves towards
towards establishment of Soviet power in the GDR only came al when sha Stalinists could be sure that they would he in complete command; and b) when it was clear that the West was not going to play ball over reparations. At every stage it was the West which determined the state of play and it was the German working class who paid the price for geo- political manipulation.
1953 uprising
This culminated in 1953 with the 17 June workers uprising. The workers quickly raised the demand for German reunification and all- German elections. This could not be allowed by the new Soviet leader- ship. After the arrest of Beria in the USSR the leadership of the SED (Fast German CP) was purged in favour of hard-line Stalinists who would end talk of reunification and consolidate the GDR. Self-deter mination of the workers was xubor- dinated to the self-preservation of the burcaucracy.
We are now living through a new revolutionary period in which all of the certainties of the pust-war world have been cast aside by the combina
At a supertr pears that the e time where ran win.
spitalism
the the
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 29, December/January 1990/91
SUPPLEMENT
famous. The collapse of Stalinism nor only removes a counter-revolu- tionary obstacle and robs the West of its "favourite enemy". Ir also breaks up the bloc system which has been central to the stabilisation of im- perialist hegemony in the post-war world.
The collapse of the old world order is not arbitrary, but organically linked to the long world conomic crisis and the reappearance of serious inter-imperialist rivalry. This new round of inter-imperialist rivalry is. suing from generalised oconomuc crisis will make the upheavals of the first half of this century look like a garden party. It will bring with it an enormous economic. social and political upheaval - the breeding ground of revolution.
The post-war settlement was built upon the cosy relationship between the Soviet bureaucracy and US im perialism - and the attempted subor- dination of various areas of the world to this dual hegemony.
The uprisings in Eastern Europe have broken this world order. Thus the revolutions of 1989.90 are far more fundamental and wide reaching than the 1968 events; they are likely to have far more damaging conse- quences for the world system of ex- ploitation. This is bocanse the East European upheavals come at a time of serious economic crisis for world capitalism, and indeed are related to the effect of that crisis on the deformed workers" states. The col- lapse of Stalinist hegemony in the Bast also means that its restraining influence over the world working- class will he diminished accordingly.
Peaceful coexistence
Thus a very profound and sig- nificant contradiction has emerged. Perestroika represents a deepening of peaceful co-existence and betrayal of revolution. But on the other hand it also removes much the bureaucracy's material ability to im- pose that hetrayal. Revolutionary movements will now he thrown hack on their own resources and be able to act more independently of Moscow control.
All of the successful revolution- ary transformations since 1945 have taken place against the express desires and orders emanating from Moscow. From Yugoslavia to China, to Vietnam, Cuba and Nicaragua - those revolutions have succeeded against the instructions coming from Moscow
The US has recognised the im- portance of perestroika on a world scale. It socks to switch its attention away from the "Soviet threat" lo uplinaval in the third world, and the instability caused by recession in the West.
In order to switch attention else- where it is necessary to give the green light for increased European comperation and integration. In has reduced the importance of the Atlan- tic Alliance in relation to other US global strategic moles. This project is meeting with some resistance, not only within hardline cireles in the US but alsn from those forces in Western Europe which see the Atlan- tic connoction as the fundamental political and economic comerstone of capitalist hegemony.
It is for this reason that Thatcher opposed so vehemently any reduc- tions in defence spending or US commitment to the maintenance of troops in Western Europe. It was why she gave such a grudging wel- come to German unification (one can hardly imagine that her objection to unification is on the basis that it might produce a right wing govern- ment!). Her realism enabled her to see thrugh the short-term euphoria to the dangers for capital which lie ahead if Western Europe drifts out of US control.
Obstacle
It is clear that the major obstacle to German unification since 1945 has not boen the Soviet Union's desire to hold onto the GDR, but the West's desire to shut out the possibility of Soviet-West Eurpean cooperation: This could have led to the switching of European economic dependence from the dollar area to the Soviet Union. It is this fear which has un- derpinned the Cocom agreements (which prevent the export of technol ogy to the USSR) and has been the political motivation for all switches in strategic military relations within
When the British government says that in order for Nato to remain relevant in the 'post-wall era it must emphasise its political role, they are really saying that it must openly ex- ercise the political mole which it has alwayx operated covertly of main- laining US hegemony over Europe.
The unification of Germany and Europe represent potentially entirely positive developments. But thix depends on the nature of the Europe which emerges from this present
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 29, December/January 1990/91
It's the free market, not paradise! peniod of turmoil. And this in tum depends to sume extent on the way which socialists act, and on the analysis which they have
Crisis key to change.
Murxists have always maintained that the division of the world and the dual hegemony of the US and the USSR was not immutable - and that cconone collapse and crisis would at some stage overtake it. We have always said that this collapse was a precondition for real social change. Where we perhaps made a mistake
was often tacitly assuming that the was often tacitly as crisis in the West would come first. The assumption was often made that we could then export real socialism" to the East by encouraging political revolution.
It was correct to say that the na- ture of revolution in East and West will be different, in other words, so- cial revolution in the West, political in the Fast. But political revolution in the East always had to come before there was any hope of social revolution in the West.
The Marxist analysis of the dual crisis of the imperialist centres and the post-capitalist boreaucracies has now been proved completely correct. Far from being the 'end of history' and "the final victory of capitalism. as the American enciolozist Fukuyama has recently contended, the present collapse in the respective hegemonies of East and West repre- sents an unfreezing of the "locked" system which came out of the post- war order.
Class struggle
The post-war period has been characterised hy a divesio..
"The uprisings in
Eastern Europe
have broken this world order. Thus the revolutions of
1989-90 are far more fundamental and wide reaching
than the 1968
events; they are
likely to have far
more damaging
consequences for the world system
of exploitation"
20000
Page 19
"To imagine that the unification will simply be a simple and smooth matter of incorporation, privatisation and marketisation resulting in one big happy capitalist German family is to fail to understand nature of the
economic crisis facing the Western economies"
Page 20
SUPPLEMENT
bescon but as a warning light
of "socialism'.
How long will It work? Kohl pursues the voters between states and societies but also within the working class. In the East the political struggle for the develop- ment nt worker democracy and
communism has been held back by the weight of the bureaucracy and its clinging onto its privileged position.
That the hureaucracy resisted for
so long and with such repression.
•moenas CCanckn hu explained bv the
antroi of the severs va- capıtalist state 1s
to 10sc privileges.
Precisely
because bureaucracy is not a property owning class, but a parasitic layer, it must hold onto administrative control of socicty. Because the hureaucracy has its roots in the nationalised property relations of the post-capitalist societies, it has been forced to do this in the name of Marxism, Leninism. socialism andcom- munism. It is precisely this empty rhetorical justification, basing itself in socialist phrascology, that has. however. in tum discredited socialism and helped hold back the class struggle in Western Europe.
Warning light
Ar every attempt to entroduce excialism in Western Europe (and there were precious few of those) or even criticise Western policy, the response has often heen "hugger off to the Soviet Union".
Nowhere has this been more so the case than in West Germany. where the most poseiful and best or- ganised working class in Europe was reduced to relative passivity and ac-
ceptance of the capitalist status quo
by the presence of the GDR, not as a
access to mateta!
the
The collapse of Stalinism therefore offers great opper- tunities to revolutionaries, not because we have some abstract and idealistic attachment to na tional unification but because it provides the basis for the unity of the working class, East and
West and the
For us the social question
and the prospects for furthering
socialist revolution must al-
ways come before questions of
national self-determ aton.
But equally we must recognise
that the denial of national self-
determination can be the
greatest hindrance lo revolu-
tionary action and bring about
general disillusionment.
It is in this situation where workers tend to tum to other, non- socialist, "liberation" movements and the danger of national chauvinism in- creases greatly. In the case of Ger- many, therefore, national unification was be the tactic but working-class unity must be the strategy.
To imagine, as most bourgeois analysts and commentators now do. that the unification will simply be a simple and smooth matter of incor- poration. privatisation and marketization resulting in onc big happy capitalist German famier 15 tol fail to understand nature of th economic crisis iscing the Western economies. Such a view also fails to grasp the limits the crisis places on the whole project of "recapitalisation"; and the resistance which will inevitahly come from the majority of the working class in the GDR
The first GDR government col- lapsed precisely hecause the process of unification is not as simple and unilinear as bourgeois commentators would have had us believe. They knew all along that it would cost an extraordinary amount but are only beginning to admit it. The workers of the GDR have received their find taste of the reality of promises made in the "free West'. Those who predict only demoralisa tion and defeat are giving up the struggle in advance.
The end of the bipolar world and the relative stability of the "ycars of stagnation under Brezhnevite ani Keynesian social contracts means a refum to inter-imperialist rivalry and the struggle for scarce resources and
ČE 2
the
A new pre-war period?
In this sense 1990 marks a return not to 1945 and a new "Marshall Plan " for Eastern Europe provided by • hegemonic US, but a retum to 1925, when the struggle berween centres of "Lebensraum' (living
imperialism. for
space) in
Eastem Europe ended in the bar- barism of the Second World War. The real danger is that the end of the post-war period actually marks the beginning of a pre-war period.
The events in Germany since Oc-
tober last year and the
reunification of Germany bring all of
the issues 1 have mentioned above
the agenua. In contradis
Faxuvama's recent con- - story has new ended. lutions in « entral and urope on w that it 15 just 'g agar after the song un-
of the vears of
retormined hu the
are that history will akr
we havr
"valutions
e quality ni
of those
seen, the course of those revolutions will be determined by the quality of
nerstup
popular
movements.
The main danger for humanity is
that the lessons of the last period of
inter-impenalist tivalry -not heen leams and that the in- ational sourgerise will ence
reach for some tonnoi
militaristic. authoritarian or even semi-fascist means to reimpose con- trol and hold down a reinvigorated workers' movement. If the left were to enter this new period as divided and unprepared as it was in 1925 then that danger will again be realised.
The
are sall
"socialism or barbarism", the latter having just as great if not greater potentiality than the former. The only way to avond that fale is fo deepen the fight for socialism - at a time when the death of Stalinism and
the crisis of imperialist capitalism
opens up new revolutionary oppor
alleralives .. barbarism
This is not the time for socialists
from the struzule in
ot new reansm. The only «.sm we shnuld rocognise is
- analvsis
the realism of materialist analysis and revolutionary action.
• Peter Thompson writes for Labour Focus on Eastern Europe
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 29, December/January 1990/91