Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Salmond puts Labour on the hook

Socialist Outlook no. 28, November 1990 · pp 4-5 · 1,883 words

Britain Scotland

EDITORIAL/UPDATE

economies has spilled over into the 'third world' in the form of a

No period has more clearly underlined the need for an interna- huge debt burden, a fall in demand for 'third world" exports, and tional movement to link socialists in their struggles against ex- the imposition of savage austerity measures on the toiling clas- ploitation and oppression in the various countries of the world. ses of the less developed economies by imperialist agencies such An international voice is needed for the independent demands

and interests of the working class, to fight for solidarity, and to

The capitalist crisis is now making itself felt in the agony of offer political guidance in the confrontations that will occur with the economies of Eastern Europe. With the near-collapse of most layers of the old leaderships of the labour movement.

In Eastern Europe, workers in struggle must be offered a mar- of the bureaucratised state-owned industries, the new, regimes have been uraed bv Western ideoloues such as Thatcher to xist alternative to the reactionar cocktails of restorationism.

privatise, capitalise and marketise. Yet even as they attempt to do so, they run into a serious shortage of Western investment capi- tal, a slump in Western markets, finding even big corporate firms mortgaged to the hilt and far from keen to set up new plants in countries with such poor and outdated infrastructure.

Yet whether it be the latest Gorbachev or Yeltsin plans for reforming the Soviet economy, the grinding austerity being suf- fered in Poland and Hungary, or the prospect of mass unemploy- ment and poverty for workers in what was East Germany, the I moves towards 'marketisation' all involve attacking workers' living standards for the benefit of private profit.

The story is similar in imperialist countries such as the USA, where a recession and rampant budget deficit can only be wor- sened by the Gulf war effort, and Britain, where the much-hailed 'discipline' of the Exchange Rate Mechanism on the economy

relies upon the simple threat that if employers put up their prices i

too high, their workers could wind up redundant.

Whether they are attacked by privatising "communists',

patriotic flag-waving social democrat defenders of the "mixed

economy', rationalising transnational corporations, or simply by capitalist governments seeking to slash welfare spending and

obscurantism and monarchism served up by the imperialist media, and the crass capitulations to capitalism reflected in the

'reform' programmes of communist and social democratic par-

ties.

In the third world, as workers are confronted by insufferable levels of exploitation and poverty, it is vital that marxists join for- ces to draw the positive and negative lessons of the struggles that have gone before, and offer support to the marxist groupings that are emerging from the mass movement.

And in the imperialist countries, it is crucial that socialists recognise their obligations to counter the aggression of their "own' ruling class, build solidarity with anti-imperialist struggles, and wage the class war at home against the employers' offensive.

For over 50 years the Trotskyist Fourth International has been struggling for its existence, defending the perspective and programme of revolutionary politics against Stalinism, social democracy and fake 'anti-imperialist' demagogues. Its sections are prominent in the fight against the Gulf war and solidarity with every anti-imperialist struggle. It is a leading voice defending a socialist perspective in Eastern Europe as the stalinist edifice crumbles; and it is campaigning on the issue of the Third World

boost profits, workers face a formidable line-up of forces. All

seem agreed that the crisis of capitalism must be 'solved' (albeit

temporarily) at workers' expense.

debt crisis. Its forces are to be found in the struggles of the op-

pressed in every country where it has supporters. If it did not al-

ready exist, now would be the time to invent it.

Left swing in SNP leadership

tish politics.

These tasks show prospects of being achieved. Latest opinion polls show the SNP up 4% at 24% and Labour down from a height of 55% last year. The Tories remain in third place in Scotland, with 19%.

Senior Labour figures whilst publicly discounting the SNP, privately admit the new Salmond leadership to be a serious threat.

Although we can expect a radical change in style from the SNP leadership, the change from traditionalist to left nationalist leadership has not been unex- pected.

During the referendum of 1979, the SNP took an equivocal attitude to the proposed Scottish

Assembly, which they saw as an attempt to block independence.

despite majority sup- Wayne Edgington

When Labour failed to deliver an Assembly

port in the referendum, the SNP withdrew from any further co- operation with Labour. Labour: threatened by new SNP leadership? Many felt the then SNP leadership had disastrously cut themselves off from political realities. The "79 group was formed consisting of most of the youth and the ex-Labour mem- bers who had joined the SNP.

The "79 group became the Left SNP and quickly gathered sup- port from around a third of SNP members. SNP conferences be-

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 28, November 1990

came increasingly divided. Lead- ing members of the group were Jim Sillars and Alex Salmond.

The "79 group attempted to get involved in industrial strug gles, much to the distrust of many Labour Party members SNP councillors, who were large- ly traditionalist, invariably voted with the Conservatives.

UPDATE

The "79 group showed the potential of a

left nationalist PEAK

HE TORY

programme. SNP votes were highest in the high-

TELL TAX

lands but also in the

housing schemes with OL 1on1 collect

monolithic Labour Do Worker ant Day

Councils. The SNP was

REA"

THE TORY

effectively a left protest

Worker vote in the cities and radical nolicies tended to IT CAN AK Dai.

increase that vote.

The traditionalist leadership became con- cerned that the '79 group was dilating their policy of pure nationalism, so they disbanded the group for factional activities and suspended its leader- ship.

Time however, was

SHE TOI CHI

POLL TAX

ILL TA TORI THE TORY Don't collect MAK

DonT IL TAX OLL TAX ToR

TH

n't collect pont collect John Harris/NUJ

DonT Day

nonl nay Don Pir

The Poll Tax changed the SP's prospects back the proposed Scottish Con- stitutional Convention. It was equally felt Labour would not support it, particularly as the Claim was in many ways revolu- tionary, asserting that *sovereignty resides in the people not parliament."

Labour did participate however, and quickly wrong footed the SNP. The SNP withdrew from the Convention claiming amongst other matters that the Convention had rejected independence as an option. In fact, although the consensual proposals of the remaining mem- bers of the Convention is for a federal relationship with Westminster, the proposed powers of the Assembly are greatly increased over proposals of even three years ago - the As sembly would have tax raising powers and possibly powers to nationalise. However even these powers would prove unable to solve the structural crisis of the Scottish economy and would be seen as inadequate. Clearly the Assembly if established would be a major stepping stone towards independence.

For withdrawing, the SNP were portrayed in the media as sectarian and acting against Scot- tish interests. Labour had a major boost. Sillars compounded mat- ters by silly predictions and un- founded claims. SNP support col- lapsed to pre-Govan levels.

Stalking horse

As the SNP convenor Gordon Wilson was retiring, it had been

not on the traditionalists side. New members supported the left, and by 1987 a clear majority sup- ported Sillars as senior vice con- venor.

Poll Tax

The Poll Tax changed the SNP's prospects. Sillars was elected MP for Govan in a huge swing immediately after labour voted to implement the Poll Tax. The SNP vote surged nationally to around 30%, having been 14% at the election. Everyone an- ticipated a major turnaround with the SNP threatening to overtake Labour in the polls.

But although the SNP gained from clear opposition to the Poll Tax (and their opposition has un- doubtedly boosted the campaign), their policies lacked coherence. They refused to participate in the STUC's campaign against the Poll Tax, and instead set up their own purely propagandist cam- paign for non-payment.

Thus at a time when non- registration was the key and the unions had not voted on im plementation, the SNP proclaimed a million non - payers* Although they suh- sequently modified their position and now collaborate with the anti- Poll Tax Federation, this per- l mitted Labour to downplay the non-payment campaign by ridiculing SNP claims. The SNP responded with vituperative at- tacks on Labour.

When the Claim of Right for Scotland was published in 1988, it was expected the SNP would

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 28, November 1990

thought by many that Sillars would take over. Instead he put up a stalking horse by backing Margaret Ewing, an arch traditionalist. Salmond stood to challenge the perceived continua- tion of the old failed leadership.

Salmond gained the support of the left, those concerned with the policy errors, and a considerable anti-Sillars group including many traditionalists. His victory was substantial. More surprisingly, the main Poll Tax spokesman, Kenny MacAskill, a Sillars supporter, was defeated narrowly by a Sal- mond supporter.

These personality and tactical differences are not too deep however, and Salmond is by far the best spokesperson the SNP has.

The SNP

conference meanwhile reaffirmed its opposi- tion to payment of the Poll Tax, maintained its denunciation of the proposed assembly and remains opposed to nuclear weapons. On the Poll Tax, a very few delegates wished to end support for mass non payment -they were roundly denounced. Non payment was reaffirmed by acclamation.

On the Assembly, the SNP overwhelmingly voted to par- ticipate in elections and argue within for independence. This, mind you was only if an Assemb- ly was set up - which in tum as- sumed Labour were elected to government in Westminster. Both these were thought unlikely. Nevertheless this was a major step forward in policy.

Three way choice

Conference also voted to push for the independence option to be included in any referendum. This would make the referendum a three way choice - status quo, Assembly or independence.

With this change the SNP and Salmond put Labour on the spot. The last thing Labour wish is an Assembly - and particularly not I one which could vote for inde- pendence. Yet senior Labour figures such as Bob Gray, the leader of Strathclyde region, have suggested local authorities should organise exactly such a referen- dum. Under Salmond, the SNP executive has now unanimously backed Gray's call for the local authorities to organise the referendum. Under the old leadership a similar suggestion was defeated. Clearly changes have occurred.

Salmond's approach will be to try to establish the SNP as the main opposition party to Labour in Scotland. This will mean developing and presenting their policies on a wider range of is- sues than to date. Their policies are generally to the left of Labour although still nationalist. But then again 40% of voters favour inde- pendence although only half of these support SNP - most of the remainder vote Labour. Salmond can only increase SNP support. If Labour loses the next election, the SNP could quickly become the largest party in Scotland.

Gordon Morgan

Page 3

← Hands up for PR · Kinnock creates a party fit for capitalism →

Something wrong on this page?