UPDATE
John Harris/IFL
Image Is more Important than pollcles in the new 'Improved" Labour Party
Blackpool Conference 1990
As the strains of
'Jerusalem' faded, were
Neil and company satis- fied with their week? What, exactly, had they achieved? THERESA CONWAY sums up this year's events at Labour conference.
The leadership looked smug: 1
Moments ot glory had been i carefully executed, like the encore to upstage Maggie. And the few occasions on which conference asserted it- self against the platform were no more than troublesome rip- ples on the pre-election pond.
Thatcher's well timed an- nouncement on the ERM success- fully cut off debate in the press on the outcome of conference. The images of the week were undoub- tedly of a cheery platform, with
Page 4
seemingly little trouble at home - but at the same time little to offer the electorate. This year's con- ference did nothing to change recent opinion poll findings that 61% think Labour's policies are vague.
The whole tone of Looking to the Future - offering no more than tactical changes within the framework of the capitalist free market - the atmosphere of con- ference, and Kinnock's vacuous speech were all attempts to con-
vince us all that we would march
together, but they gave little idea of what, beyond the election, was supposed to be our purpose.
Dual aim
The leadership had a dual aim in Blackpool; to continue the process of sanitisation - creating a party 'fit for government', a party of 'the nation', not of the working class - and at the same time make it clear how little could be ex- pected by the labour movement
from such a government once in
office.
There were three crucial vic-
tories for them on this road: the
acceptance of Tory anti-union
laws; the insidious economic
policy of John "only spend what
you can afford" Smith, and the
package of measures that mean
that Party Conference will be-
come even more of a rubber
stamp for the leadership.
The NEC proposals on
'Democracy and Policy Making'
will create a new series of hoops through which party activists will
Forum, the NEC and Conference Arrangements Committee before finally getting to conference.
European model
All of this has been sold in the guise of making the party more accessible(!) as well as more like her sister parties in Europe. At the same time the NEC will only be elected every two years, and the CLP section will be elected by one-member one vote, further reducing accountablity at the top and collective decision making at the bottom.
Its true that these changes
have to jump to have any impact have only been approved in prin- on decision making at all.
ciple; the leadership still has to
Key changes include; holding come back with rule changes to conference only every two years, enact them. However the fight to and then based on a rolling policy tum them back will be difficult; programme; abolition of the and it is also clear that the NEC amendment stage; and the dead- would wish to make further at- line for resolutions brought for- tacks, particularly on local ward to April - before they go functioning. through a 4 stage vetting process
On the anti-union laws, Tony
on Standing Committees, Policy Blair wants to keep most of the
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 28, November 1990
UPDATE
Tory's chains, especially the ban noticed. On the question of pen- on solidarity action, on picket sions, delegates felt that the lines of more than 6, and on NEC's junking of the commit- strikes not sanctioned by court- ment to restore index-linking at approved ballots and on the 1979 levels was really too much closed shop. The TGWU-backed to bear. Last year's conference Composite 39 was a small step policy on cuts in defence spend- forward from the platform's ing was re-iterated, but so was position, but it was a disgrace the platforms intention to again that only the NA's Tony Dub- bins from among the trade union leaders supported Composite 40, which called for the repeal of all anti-union laws.
The NEC did an about turn this year by supporting a Black Socialist Society, hoping that this will derail the more troublesome demand for Black Sections within the party, and at the same time enable them to sell the party more effectively to the black electorate. On women, the situation was even more tokenis- tic, with support for quotas (and anyway too little too late) being played off against the long-ar- gued demands that the women's organisation have collective power within the party.
Despite a well organised and vocal campaign from 'End the Ban', fully supported by Labour Party Socialists (LPS), con- ference voted to support the ban on Socialist Organiser. There is little knowledge at the base of the party of the number of local parties now suspended and the plethora of witch hunts now taking place. The latest, just days before conference, was the suspension of Brighton Labour Party for its stand on the poll tax.
No alternative?
Conference, like the majority of party members in the CLPs and the unions, saw no clear al- ternative to the overall perspec- tive held out by the platform.
New realism has not only been absorbed, but was regurgitated wholesale by many bright be suited young men at the rostrum.
On the majority of issues, con- ference voted for right wing policies, believing that this was the only way to get rid of the hated Thatcher goverment.
There were some things that it would not swallow. Mandatory reselection must be retained, though when the majority of the NEC report was sneaked through without discussion on Friday morning, while virtually no-one
lists, calling delegates by name
and on one occasion calling
someone who wasn't in the hall.
A number of speeches appeared
in the Press office before the
relevant discussions had even
started.
The debate on the Gulf had
perhaps more of an air of un-
Crest Thompsa reality than even the rest
PARTY GONPARRNGE
of the stage managed
show. It was impossible
PARTY
to grasp that what was at
issue in this discussion
was Labour's complicity
in the possible murder of
millions in the Middle
East. Kinnock's speech,
which had talked of
'extending the interna-
tional community'
(more than shades of im-
perialism) and of the
permanent monitoring of
Iraq for chemical and
nuclear weapons - surely WITH TORY AND LABOUR POLICIES
only possible through GETTING SOSMILAR WE COULD HAVE I SOT AWAY WITA FILING THE SAME •permanent occupation -
COPY FOR BOTH CONFERENCES. had set the tone for the
discussion, but aroused ignore it. Again, conference reas
little comment, even on the left. serted its commitment to the Per-
Confusion on Gulf gamon strikers, but despite a
Confusion on the left was rife large picket, was unable to prevent people such as Donald on this issue. We were told that Dewar defying delegates' wishes the way to defeat Kinnock's
anatoran bipartisanship was to rally be- ...1 attralian
and Robert Maxwell's reception.
These victories for the left did show a groping towards a different economic policy, a dif- ferent vision of what a labour government could and should be, but they were more an indication of a slow time bomb ticking away in the belly of the move- ment than any imminent threat of explosion that could rock the leadership now.
Ireland
Many key issues did not ap- pear on the agenda at all; there was no discussion on British withdrawal from Ireland, or on Lesbian and Gay Rights. And other crucial debates were given little time. During the abysmally short discussion on the poll tax, the Liverpool delegation were surrounded by stewards and prevented from leaving their seats, and one delegate was pushed and verbally threatened.
Jo Richardson's chairing was appalling - it was clear that she was working for pre-prepared
hind the resolution from the FBU. This not only agreed with sanctions against Iraq, but would even support 'offensive military action' - as long as it was sanc- tioned by the United Nations.
The majority of delegates with emergency resolutions in opposition to the line of the leadership accepted this position, and dissenting voices were effec- tively silenced: the result was that conference had no oppor- tunity to debate a position which called for the withdrawal of troops. Many accepted Benn's sincerely held (but in our view mistaken) belief that the UN can and should be an instrument of peace; others given way to the notion fed by the new realists that debate can only be divisive.
Positive work was done by Labour Party Socialists( LPS), at its first conference since its launch. LPS led the fight for a debate on troops out of the Gulf, gaining support from over 50 delegates, and put out extensive material in its daily bulletin ar-
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 28, November 1990
guing this position. It was unfor- tunate however that LPS also decided to call for support for the FBU resolution; this was a sign of the amount of pressure ex- erted on even the principled left.
Unions
Useful contacts were also built up amongst anti-poll tax ac- tivists and councillors. LPS, together with the Socialist Movement Trade union Commit- tee organised a successful lobby of conference demanding that "Labour Unshackle the Unions', led the debate on this issue on conference floor, and held a major fringe meeting on this theme.
Conference confirmed that it is unlikely that the overall situa- tion in the party will change before the general election, so great is the feeling that our eyes must be kept on this prize. In this context, the importance of LPS, a force on the left prepared to hold its ground, cannot be under- estimated.
While other organisations such as the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy have played an important role particularly on constitutional issues, this year more than ever their overall posi- tion left much to be desired. Not only did they participate in the stifling of debate on the Gulf, they also failed (because of a typing error!) to support the one resolution that called for power to Women's conference, and completely ignored the fight on the anti-union laws.
Between now and the general election, it will be important to continue to consolidate LPS by linking up with activists inside and outside the party, working particularly on the poll tax, the Gulf and the witch hunt.
We need a profile, particular- ly during the election, for socialists fighting for a Labour victory, campaigning in the in- terests of working people. And we need a strong organisation of the left in place for the period after the election. Then, whatever the result, the situation in the party will begin to unravel again as the tightrope Kinnock has so far successfully trodden finally frays.
Page 5