IN DEPTH
The boot seems always to be on the other foot: and the other foot is always on a policeman! The March Poll Tax demo.
The news that fewer young poople in Britain rcognise the name of Neil Kin- nock than Nelson Mandela or Mikhail Gorbachev will surprise few Labour activists: it is perhaps more surprising that a Labour Party which has veered from low profile to no profile on all the key issues of the day should be 20- 24 percent ahead in the opinion polls.
This lead has little to do with Labour's policiés. The Tories hanaling vi the economy, sogether with the massive hatred of the Poll Tax and Kenneth Clarke's NHS reforms. have followed the massive popular support for the ambulance workers, helping to make the Thatcher govemment the most unpopular for a long time. Since the self-destruction of the "centre' parties which formed the 'Alliance' in 1987, Labour has been ine main beneficiary.
tacular by election victory in mid Staffordshire; now there is the prob ability that on May 3 the Party could even improve on its previous peak support of 1986.
Confidence in the Tories" handling of the conomy, usually the issue over which they keep a lead over Labour in the polls, has
seitt nan
mark. wit
aide Rank optimistic
A sun
ana
As the Tories' crisis worsens, swinging votes Kinnock's way, Labour's response seems to get weaker, argues PETE FIRMIN.
But is this simply the new leadership style of Neil's team, or the fruits of Labour's commitment to reforming a capitalist system plunged deeper into crisis by Thatcher's policies?
ra Dope upport for the ambulance -anchet suremment the most unpopular
ine centre parties which
mine main beneticiary.
* anu achieving the spec
stine, now there is the prob
...DEOVc one Its previous peak
the wills. has
opping
an. orgage
*Te under at t the C'BI and the nance! ne John
ring invesumeni.
mists 10r
interest) rate. lacx trom their governor or the Major = more
the Tories
two-thirds Deneving that
Labour's John Smith would make a better
Chancellor than John Major. Even the
(Eddled) figures for the fall in unemploy-
ment are no longer heralded as a major
achievement, since the Tories recognise
them as double-edged. The removal of
high unemployment as a psychological
deterrent to fighting for significant wage
rises is the last thing the Tories want at a
time of rising inflation.
The Tories" matural allies' have
deserted them on other issues 1o0, with
the banks withdrawing from the student
loans scheme and the Engineering Employers" Federation criticising the loans scheme anc
proposed arrestment of wages of non-payers of the Poll Tax as proposed arresu-. "detrimental to industrial relations".
adds to the impression that she is a lame duck. Now that the Tories are on the run over their economic policies they seem unable in recapture
lost ground on anything, even their usually reliable standhys of law and order" - with crime figures still sky-high, and Thatcher's barmy
with cr. «gure
foothall identity card scheme abandoned - and racism, with Norman
Tebbit leading a reactionary revolt over the immigration of Hong Kong
showed Lannur
a wide range Ol assues only a rame duck. Now that the Tones are
-. recapture
renabic sandhs of law
.... their ........
foothal!
and order" - with crime figures still sky-high, and Thatcher's barmy foothall identity card scheme abandoned - and racism, with Norman
del
... and Thatcher'& barmy
and racism. with Norman iver the migration of Hone Kong
-him wadership scem like woolly
se That.
liberal
liberals in comparison.
Skilled workers desert the Tories
Thatcher won the support of an important layer of the skilled work-
ing class in 1983 and 1987 because her strategy for restoring the
profitability of British capitalism not only seemed to be working, bur
Brisr also seemed to be in their interests.
The share-owning, property-owning democracy" was always a
ing class profitabilly
perty-owning democracy
Page 20
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 24, May 1990
IN DEPTH
gained from it in the short term. The ideological benefits of privatisation and council house sales were easy to accept while the share market was buoyant and interest rates were low. Now they begin to be revealed for what they always were - part of a
shan but the much.
tuse who
ideongical 'sales were
was Duovant hegt. sa ne
revealed for what they always were - part of a strategy of putting all industry into the hands of large financial companies and attacking the "welfare state".
part or -
ands or large
welfare state nonateiv benefit
conger offset
4 the Poli
Tax cuts, even ones which disproportionately benefit the rich, look different once they no longer offset higher mortgage payments, inflation and the Pall
Thatcher's policies have always been a direct and
immediate attack on that section of the working class
sections. shu managed to persuade them that her policies were in their interests, despite pangs of conscience which have meant that the Tories have always done worse in the opinion polls on issues such as unemployment and the NHS.
Now the economic crisis, and particularly the Poll Tax, mean that the chickens are coming home to roost. Until now the Tories have heen very careful to attack only one section of the class at a time. Indeed, this was part of a pre-planned strategy, down to the detail of what order to take on different unions
order to take on different unions (steel workers first, miners only after other significant sections had
w: aller other sienificant sections had
ank diti
which is low paid or unemployed. But in providing
The Tories have their chickens coming home te roost the Labour Party has these two
ith the Pou Tax 1s that they are attack-
ing nearly everyone at once.
Of course, the Tories have been ably assisted throughout their 11
we working -lass by the
Labour and trade union bureaucracy. From their
persistent refusal to lead any defence of traile
union rights or jobs and working conditions, to
their political bankruptcy in failing providing any
convincing ideological anternative to 'the
market, which is now the starting point of the
Labour programme, Thatcher couldn't have done
Labour's electoral
The supposed high point of Labour's general election cam- paign of 1987 was the Kinnock video, widely acclaimed by those who matter the public relations 'experts') as 'much better than the Tories'. Yet the Tories still won, because more people still preferred their policies to Labour's bland 'washing powder adverts'.
Come the next general elec- tion, Labour's campaign promises to be even less politi- cal, judging by the standards of the mid-Staffs by-election. To Kinnock, cashing in on the Tories unpopularity means making no policy statements or promises whatsoever.
Kinnock's favoured type of candidate is Glenda Jackson or Peter Mendelson, polished media personalities with right wing politics.
An indication of the deter mination to prevent the left's voice being heard in the elec tion is given by the way in
tegy
which Walworth Road clamped down on those constituencies threatening to produce manifes- tos which differed from the "official' line on the Poll Tax for May's council elections. Those Parties whose manifes. tos promised not to fine people for non-payment of the Poll Tax were told to remove this or have a manifesto written by regional officials imposed upon them, and face suspension of the Party.
Yet in the general election the stakes are too high for the Left to allow its voice to be silenced. To keep our heads down and campaign on Kinnock's policies, or to duck out of the campaign al- together, would be to evade our responsibilities. There has to be a Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory which, while calling for a vote for Labour, demands that a Labour govem- ment implement policies in the interests of the working class.
it without them.
As the Tories" crisis becomes starker, this be-
comes more and more obvious. Al the height of
the Tories' unpopularity, the TUC and Labour
Party are not willing to defend the working class
against the universal attack on its living standards
and democratic rights represented by the Poll
Tax. Instead they unite in condemning any notion
of non-payment, refuse to call even demonstra- tions against it, and merely say 'Pay up and voic Labour when the time comes
Sirin neconting Lahour Leader in 1983, Kin- nock has avoided giving support let alone en-
couragement, to any section of the working class.
in conflict with the Tories, from the miners
through to the ambulance workers. The most he
has ever done is call for arbitration. More often
his contributions have been seen to attack or un-
dermine the working class fighthack, as when he
condemned violence by miners who fought back
agamst police brutality without even the notional
odemnine police 'even-handedness" of
violence. and called on railworkers to call off
their strike and accept BR's pay offer last year.
Even within the rules of the parhamentary
game, Kinnock has refused to attack the Tories,
backing them on 'national security" grounds over
the Zircon spy sattelite affair and leaving it to
hackbenchers (occasionally even Tory ones) to
probe issues like Colin Wallace's claims of
psychological warfare in the North of Ireland and
even refusing to go onto the offensive when this
ccepi BK the mada
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 24, May 1990
Page 21
IN DEPTH
DUCE
POLICE
Smile! It's candid camera! Has Kinnock persuaded these keen photographers to run him off a set of contact prints to aase axpulsions?
unearthed a can of worms.
Kinnock's concern has been solely with a
fruitless search for issues on which he could unite
The witch-hunt and the
Poll Tax
The witch-hunt that has been going on for years against individuals, particularly Militant supporters, and Constituency Parties is once again focussed on Merseyside, with the Labour Party machinery stepping in to protect Frank Field by attacking both Militant and Socialist Or- ganiser. The additional objective is to prevent Wallasey from selecting a left candidate. But the witch-hunt is also being stepped up a notch around the Poll Tax.
Councillors from Brighton to Strathe- lyde are facing disciplinary action for refusing to vote to set a Poll Tax. Many on the left with a track record of opposi- tion to cuts and the Poll Tax have been prevented from standing as councillors on May 3. In Swansea the selection of the Chair of the Wales anti-Poll Tax Federation (a Militant supporter) to replace the sitting mayor has been over- turned, the party suspended, and the in- dividual concerned now faces expulsion.
This systematic witch-hunt has now extended to letters from Walworth Rd telling parties to have nothing to do with
the All-Britain Federation of Anti-Poll Tax groups, threatening to take action against the activists involved.
Kinnock's offensive against the anti- Poll Tax movement fits nicely in with the altempts of the media to label the move- ment as the puppets of Militant, the Socialist Workers Party or Class War (with the additional neat touch of the right wing and the press blaming Militant for the NUT conference decision for industrial action). At the same time we have the scandalous decision of Labour-run Hackney Council to suspend Andy Murphy for being interviewed on Class War's attitude to the Trafalgar Square "riot'.
The left must have a principled pasi- tion of fighting this witch-hunt both in- side and outside the Labour Party with the broadest possible defence of democratic rights. Socialists must refuse to accomodate to what the witch- hunters consider acceptable, and in- stead step up our involvement in the mass anti-Poll Tax movement.
PIE
with "wet" Tories or even the Lards against Thatcher. Defence of working class interests hasn't entered his thinking. Now, at a time when the Tories are less popular then ever, he doesn'l even call on them to announce a general clection
pulling their policies "to the verdict of the people".
something Harold Wilson regularly called on the Tories to do. Instead he only seems to ccho the
bleatings of the Tory "wets' that Thatcher is had
for the country. It is almost as if he is arguing for
a change of Tory leader rather than confronting
their policies - perhaps not realising that
Thascher's personal unpopularity is a major factor
in Labour's electoral support
Kinnock's strategy
The Labour leadership's concem has been
solely for respectability and acceptance by the
ruling class and their media. Tuming their backs on the working class, they have done the full round of businessmen's lunches and conferences to win the capilalists" confidence. This quest for. respectability reached its most sickening depths
50 81
cho
mat Thatcher 18+40 -..menk arguing en
.. unfronting
Teasing that
their naca
SVP CO
AT 111 3 witeren
when Roy Hattersley, in his role is Shadow Home Secretary, called - without benefit of trial
or evidence - for "the stiffest possible sentences"
• depin shadou
for those involved in the Poll Tax "riot"
This has gone hand-in-hand with a remorse- less drive to ditch every last Labour policy which
contained even a whiff of socialism, and clamping down on the party democracy which could threaten this course
The 'lesson" Kinnock drew from the Wilson
Page 22
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 24, May 1990
IN DEPTH
the "Winter
of Callaghan in Mav
the adoption of lett
of issues. wide-ranging
ny democracy. and the mu Benn .. deputy leader in
of
meals and incr
c appearea that the anon "undamentally, to be
minen to note than
tinkering reforms.
As a party based on working class support,
there are, in the last analysis, two possible routes
Labour can take. One is to embrace the system,
and reassure the ruling class that - despite its
more unruly volers - it is a respectabic party
committed to policies in the interests of
capitalism and better able to control the working
class when the Tories are unpopular. The other.
would be to break with the system, and fight for
the interests of the working class and socialism against capitalism.
Kinnock, like every previous Labour leader.
Kinnock's style of twist could leave us all on the rock and roll
and Callaghan govemments of 1974 79 is not that they came to grief because they attempted to resolve the crisis of capitalism by attacking working class living standards, but that they weren't ruthless enough in doing so, and failed to suppress the revolt within the labour movement
and Carraghal. against these policies.
" inal ley ame to gret
alism by attackine
ther than there 15....
.,cie
The austerity measures of those governments met increasing work ing class resistance, both through strikes and within the decision making bodies of the labour movement, culminating in the autumn of 1978 in the rejection of incomes policy by both the TUC and Labour
Labour Party Socialists
vapitan».
Conference
MAY 19th & 20th
This conference offers the opportunity for the building of a broad, democratic organisation of the Labour Left at a time when Labour is riding high in the polls and active resistance to the Tories is greater than at any time in the last
eleven years.
In addition to discussing what policies we
should be fighting for labour to adopt in the
1990s and the democratic changes we want to
bring about in Labour's structures, the con-
ference will be discussing campaigns over the
witch-hunt, Poll Tax and general election.
This is an essential conference for all Party
members interested in fighting the politics of
'new realism'
.. ike every previous Labour leader.
re. tirst road ari.placably opposen
an see no fur-
gens medi.. That
kir crass support
- challenge to
even the
acement with
-itithesis of
epitore of Kinnockism.
two. issues: firstly, reversing all policy commitments unpalatable to the ruling class, such as nationalisation, repeal of
anti-union laws, increases in public spend-
ing and unilateral disarmament. Secondly.
he has attempted to close down all avenues
of resistance to these policy changes both
now and in the future. This explains his
opposition to the self-organisation of black
people and women in the Party, the closing
the Labour Par. Young
Socialists, and the prolonged witch-hunt
involving the suspension of Constinency
Parties and districts which dared to cross
him, and the expulsion of individuals (primarily Militant supporters).
The attack on Party democracy con-
Kinnock has been preoccupied with
pied with -ll polIcy the ruine
na
doors w.
The attack on Party democracy con-
tinues relentlessly, with the proposals to
reverse mandatory reselection of MPs (one
of the gains of post-1979) for all sitting
MPs, the extension of 'one member, one vole' (and postal hallots) to all local party decisions, the downgrading of party con-
ferences, both national and regional, from
sovereign bodies to talking shops, and ul-
The
Of
Socialism In
The
Labour
Party
SHEFFIELD POLY
The Student Union, Pond Street
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 24, May 1990
timately the abolition of the block vote.
The eventual abolition of the block
vole is the most far-reaching of these chan-
ges, intended to cut off the possibility of working class opposition to a Labour
HIV 01
working class opposition to a Labour government's policies reaching into
Page 23
IN DEPTH
to tie the bureaucrats to sup port for Labour policies, such as wage controls, without any backlash "rom thei members. He has of course, had to tread carefully over the speed with which he has moved on this, altempting to ensure that the CLPs are fully "tamed before giving them sole decision-making rights.
*Sit back and wait
to be elected'
With ihese elements in place, Kinnock's approach has been to wait for the Tories to become unpopular.
He couldn't do otherwise, given that Labour has no fun- damentally different policies to offer. Indeed, given Labour's response is always "why should we say
what the Tories should do with the economy, we're not in government' what the Tories chur it is hard to see what the economists "prefer" in Labour's programme.
Above all else, Kinnock desires a smooth change of government without unrest as part of dampening working class expectations of a Labour government.
The risk: - one Kinnock is prepared to take because he puts the stability of capitalism even above his own desire to become prime mini- ster - is that the Tories could tocover by the time of the general clection. Harold Wilson's Labour government nearly did after facing a similarly large deficit in the polls. A change in the Tory leadership (not unlikely if their crisis continues over the summer) and an oconomic recovery in 1991 could make this at least a remote possibility.
The Tories lagged a long way behind in the polls during stages of the miners" strike. The way to ensure they don't recover would be to support the struggles against them, but this is of course the exact op posite of what Kinnock wants.
Labour's contradictions
In wanting to suppress Party democracy, Kinnock recognises the contradiction for the Labour Party. While desiring the endorsement of
the ruling class, it relies on the votes and support of the working class.
Regardless of Kinnock's insistence that a Lahour govemment will
promise nothing of any substance, a Labour clection victory will raise expectations in the working class that it will carry out measures in their
interest.
Indeed, as the Tories hit more and more problems, working class
confidence is boosted even in advance of an clection. Conflict between
contidence in boosted even -
a working class fighting for its interests and a Labour goverment com-
mitted to austerity measures in the interests of capitalism are virtually
inevitable, even if we can't predict the how and when.
This is already coming to the fore over the Poll Tax, where
Kinnock's line of "Pay Up and Vote Labour" - the quivalent of the old
promise of "pie in the sky' - conflicts with the desire of millions to
defeat the Poll Tax here and now. The Labour leadership's insistence
that it would take them two years after an election to replace the Poll
Tax with an unspecified "roof tax" makes their line even less attractive,
Loday... the tool
Page 24
POLL TAX?
ABOMINATION
and is an indication of their problems to come.
The Tasks of the Left
The view that Thatcher was unbeatable, or at best could only be beaten by pacts with the Liberals and SDP. put aboul not so long ago by Marxism Today, has been replaced by one that says that Kinnock's policies are the only way to beat Thatcher. Yet a Labour government carrying out the Party's current policies could be a disaster for the working ciass.
Unless we build a pole of attraction which can offer an alternative political lead, against a Labour government if necessary, conflict be- tween Labour and the working class will lead to demoralisation and dis- illusionment, with the possible replacement of Labour by a Tory government even further to the right, as happened in 1979.
The tasks of the Labour Left are clear. In addition to building the largest possible opposition now to Kinnock's policy and constitutional changes, we have to link up with those engaged in struggle against the Tories (especially over the Poll Tax), offering both a perspective for these struggles and laying the basis for opposition to the policies of a Kinnockite government.
Despite Kinnock's fervent wishes, such opposition will spill over into the Party itself; our task is to ensure it is organised and united around a clear alternative. The groundwork for this can be laid by draw- ing those fighting the Tories now into the Party on a perspective of op- posing the politics of 'new realism".
The clection of a Labour government would most probably lead to an initial demobilisation of struggles, while people waited to sce what it would do. (We only need think of the opposition we would meet in ar- guing for continued resistance to the Poll Tax after a Labour victory.) But we cannot wait, we need to start now if an alternative is to gain credibility.
While it would he wrong to pose the Labour Party Socialists con- ferenice in Sheffield on May 19th/20ch as "the answer" for the left, it can go some way towards preparing the left for the tasks ahead, even at a time when the left is weaker than it has been for years. The setting up of a national, democratic organisation of the Labour Left and campaigns around the Poll Tax and the witch-hunt, and the launching of a left cam- paign for the general election would be a big step forward.
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 24, May 1990