UPDATE
As expected the government got its bill allowing up to 225,000 Hong Kong citizens o selle in Britain through the second reading on April 19. The vote was 313 to 216—a majority of 97.
The bill created a split among both Tory MPs and Labour MPs. The former chuirman of the Con- servative Party, Norman Tebbit led the opposition to the bill among Tory MPs on the grounds bill broke the party's
he party s
clection manifesto, which had op
posed any large scale immigra-
tion. On April 19, 44 Tory MPs
voted against the Bill while some abstained
The Labour Party had issued a three line whip for its MPs to
vote against grounds that it was elitist, unprin
cipled and unworkable. About 25 Labour MPs broke the whip by abstaining
the bill on the
Labour MPs broke the whip by
The Labour MPs who broke the party line did it for a variety
of rcasons. Most of them belong
The Labour MPs who broke
and did not want to be part of an unholy alliance with the Tebbit gang by voting against the Bill
Labour criticism of the bill is to a large extent correct. The government's bill will only allow the elite of Hong Kong to get into this country. More than five mil- lion ordinary citizens of Hong Kong would have no chance to get into Britain, if they should want to. The bill is giving
the _ready
ship is giving no clear alternative to the government's bill. Labour wants to avoid being specific on
Dour Party reader
car alten
Roy Hat-
the Labour Party
give passports to
need Labour, that means those Hong Kong citizens who become state-
them. • those
For
state-
less by 1997
China takes over the
British Colony) because
twnen wer the
they * Nevume
Chinese citizens. only amounts to a few thousand.
The Labour Party cor- rectly criticises the government for not intro ucing democracy in tong Kong. But that is also an indirect criticism of former Labour Goverments who did nothing to introduce democratic rights in Hong Kong. Labour's criticism wubid gain some credibilly 11
announced that a Labour government elected before 1997
Vietnamese boat people in Hong Kong: victims of hypocrisy
would
call elections to a General As- sembly and respect the wishes.of the people of Hong Kong.
A lot of hypocrisy is involved from all sides in the Hong Kong debate. The government als want to give a helping hand to the elite of Hong Kong, who (accord- ing to the goverment) could he very useful for the Brush Economy if they should choose to come to Britain.
This is in contrast with the government's altilude to the 40,000 Vietnamese boat people living in inhuman conditions in Hong Kong. Instead of offering these refugees British passports the government wants to send them back to Vietnam by force.
Similarsy, the government (and probably also Tebbit) ac- cepts thar between 50,000 and 1 Полол racist white South Africans have the right to settle down in Britain. Not only that
immigrants" Advisory Service alleges that the Govern-
ment is deliberately courting whites fearing black rule in South Africa as ideal Tory voters. (Guardian 17.4.1990)
The Labour Party's hypocrisy
no less great thar the
immediately introduce
- Hone Kone
government's lf a Labour Govemment comes in power in two years time, this law will be
implemented. counterposing the need for Asian
And Labour is into Britain to letting
and Black
relatives 225,000 Hong Kong citizens into Britain, who have no relations in this country. The argument is that by accepting the 225,000 the queue will be much longer for everyone else. But that argument
is only real if you accept that there should be a limit on im- migration.
what the Labour opposition to the government's bill is really about:
The Labour argument exposes
accommodation to racist altiludes amung the electorate, Labour ac- cepts the argument that a large scale immigration is bad for race relations here in Britain! Labour is opposing the bill bocause it wanis to he seen as not allowing hundreds of thousands of Chinese people into Britain. Of course Labour is not saying that openly. That is where Labour differs But as TebbiL Labour wants lo stop mass im- migration for racist clectoral
TOTRIZTIr" reasons.
Presenting a concrete alternative in tha covarment's bill. Hard
is willing to
That is why Labour is not
Presenting a concrete alternative
to the government's bill. Hard
pressed. admit that only a few thousand Hong Kong citizens should be al lowed into Britain (Newsnight 18.4.1990). That is why Labour is not campaigning to lét the 40,000 Vietnamese Boat peopic in Vietnam come to Britain.
Labour
.... 102e1
Britai:
•NeWsight w... Labour
in vet the Boat people ritain
No wonder that some Labour MPs had difficulties in following the Labour line. But were these MPs righi in not voling against the government's bill? If one can trust the press these MPs mainly
abstamed in the vote because
they did not want to make an al-
liance with Tebbit and because
Labour's alternative vote was ab-
But surely one cannot decide
a vote by looking at who will be
casting the same vote. One has to
judge the bill on its merits-not
on who will vote for or against it.
If it is a bad bill one should vote against it and campaign for a bet-
ter bill.
The Liberal Democrats argued that it is better to let 225,000 Hong Kong citizens into Britain thar: none. The Liberal Democrats have also heen argu- ing that all 3.28 million British Dependent Territories Citizens' in Hong Kong should have the right to come to Britain. (That will exclude the more than 2 mil- Lion non-British Dependent Ter- ritories citizens in Hong Kong from the option of leaving Hong Kong).
But voting for the government's bill the Liberal Democrats missed an opportunity for raising a campaign to let many more Hong Kong citizens into Bntam. A defeat of the government's bill would give the opportunity to debate alternative bills, including a bill which grants universal suffrage to the people of Hong Kong.
By Finn Jensen
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 24, May 1990