Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Embryology Bill

Socialist Outlook no. 24, May 1990 · p 4 · 1,319 words

Russia and the USSR Women

EDITORIAL/UPDATE

ticularly outraged by the blows to the armed forces struck by the Lithuanian rejection of conscription. They now claim that in some republics less than 50 percent of draftees called up are reporting for military service. Gorbachev knows that the one prop he cannot dis- pense with in his balancing act at the top is the support of the armed forces. He may yet need them to help contain the anger of the workers.

So where should socialists stand? Fully in support of the right of self-determination for the Lithuanian people - up to and including the right to secede: the massive popular support for these policies has been shown in the recent elections. We support calls for international working class solidarity, for solidarity among the socialist and working class organisations springing up in the Soviet Union, and for the most coordinated possible struggle by the peoples of the Baltic states alongside other national minorities in the fight for the most basic democratic right - to determine their own future. We do this in the context of opposing any restoration of capitalism, and rejecting utopian nationalist schemas of sell-sufficiency ('capitalism in a single country"?). New economic and trading relations must be negotiated with the Soviet Union on the basis of equal and sovereign nations.

We must reject the cynical imperialist line of ditching the Lithuanians in order to preserve Gorbachev: not only are the im- perialists supporting him (as the leader most likely to make further concessions at the expense of the working class), but even the 'socialist' case for defending Gorbachev as the embodiment of glas- nost has been thrown into question by his attempts to crush the Lithuanian national movement.

We oppose Gorbachev's attempts to cow the national movement, and call for the withdrawal of Soviet troops and the resumption of nor- mal supplies of goods while longer-term trade relations are negotiated. In the long run, and especially after the momentous chan- ges which Gorbachev himself has helped trigger throughout Eastern Europe and the USSR, the Soviet Union cannot hope to preserve its "unity" by brute force, whether this be economic or military: and any

attempt to do so is a reactionary measure that must be opposed.

This does not mean that socialists would always argue for a full- scale confrontation on this issue, especially where conditions are less than favourable: a serious approach to tactical timing is also important alongside a detence of principle. The evident solid mass support in Lithuania, and even the parallel movements in Estonia and Latvia are not likely to be enough to force Gorbachev to back down in the short term, and some form of temporary compromise may be necessary. it would also be useful it the Baltic republics coordinated their efforts in the push for national independence, and if they made clear that they want support not from the imperialist governments but from the workers of the Soviet Union. Unfortunately the limited political horizons of the nationalist leadership in Lithuania focus on outside as- sistance from the capitalist and imperialist leaders, and do not extend to calls for working class solidarity - or even to working class mobilisation in Lithuania itself. The tentative links that have been made between the new governments in the Baltic states appear to have been at top level only.

The longer-term situation offers more hope of allies for the Lithuanians in their conflict with the Kremlin bureaucracy, showing that there are more choices open than simply between an immediate armed insurrection or a despairing appeal for imperialist support.

Among the first decisions of the new Moscow city council, now taken over by radical oppositionists, was a resolution of sympathy with Lithuania. And as Gorbachev tries to crack the whip over workers in Russia and the other republics, the likelihood will increase of a widen- ing crisis in which new concessions can be won.

As the illusion of Gorbachev promoting a revolution from above" disappears under a tide of increasingly authoritarian moves, the necessity for a genuine political revolution from below becomes ever more obvious. The new socialist currents now emerging in the Soviet workers' movement will need every possible solidarity from socialists in the west as they face up to the important tasks ahead of them.

1967 AC BROKEN

On April 25, anti-abortionists scored the first victory in their long assault on the 1967 Abor- tion Act. MPs voted by 409 to 152 for an amendment to the Embryology Bill reducing the Lime limit on abortion from 28 to 24 weeks, with certain ex- coptions.

It was a defeat for women in the struggle to take control of our

This must

not he obseured by the fact that it could have been much worse.

The ourcome reflects a major

it 1aC......

WORS

shift arounel the question of abor- ton over the last decade. While

the pro-life" organisations have made no headway with their life

21X

187

argument.

they have been very successful at focusing on the question of time

The abortion debate is no longer centred around women but

on foetuses - at what point can they survive outside the womb?

This shift is the result of many

complex factors - the decline of the women's movement; the ax- cendency of the right; and new realism in the labour movement.

This has been mirrored, to some extent, in the campaign in defence

abortion rights. Strategy has often been dictated by parliamentary procedure and political expediency. This, along with a pragmatic rejection of a

woman's right to choose a, led to

the division of the pro-choice for- ces between the issues af abortion

"s Detween ult

Sonor in can

•ake:

"СЛОІС 101 af als.. ior

To write women back into the

equation is the only way to win

back those MPs, particularly in the Labour ranks, who have pre- viously been 28 week stalwarts

but whose convictions have now

The attention given to the abortion issue and the question of

embryo research has obscured

crumbled.

SITMIR" tas'a now

It has moved from the political domain to the scientific.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 24, May 1990

another aspect of the Bill - access

to Di and infertility treatments.

At the third reading in the Lords, the Government inserted a clause specifying that no woman could be given access to Di or infertility treatments "unin» ...it nas been taken of the welfare of the child who may be born as a result of the treatmen As me Lord Chancellor said in introducing this amendment, the intention 1s to prohibit access by unmarried women in a politically acceptable way.

WAmIr cuus- Di .mterti..

WALETE. • inmarried i. autotable

Thas the language and focus is on the welfare of the child rather than explicilly discriminating against lesbians and single women. But the 'wellare of the

The wording of the clause may be vague and open to interpreta-

tion, but then so was Section 28 -

and that has been effective in

arprew-

28

reinforcing sclf-censorship

-censoramp ano

It is vital that socialists migotry. It do not dodge this issuc but ex- pose the ideology behind it and the effects the clause will have.

Both the 'welfare of the child' amendment and the icduction in time limits underline the fact that we must now push for the Bill as

a whole to be rejected. The vote

in favour of embryo research continuing is the only serious defeat suffered by the forces of extreme reaction so far, and the

14 day time limit makes it at hest ambiguous.

It is crucial that the time he- tween now and the final reading of the Bill is spent building for the demonstration on June 2nd. Mass mobilisalems are the only

rading aiding for June 2nd • *he onlv " around.

way to turn this situation around

We must show the right that

public opinion is not on their

side!

By Rebecca Flemming

Page 2

← Editorials · Hong Kong and Hypocrisy →

Something wrong on this page?