SUPPLEMENT
HELMUT KOHL
her und heute 1 a
• 700 WIll East German workers wear a change of Helmut? Chancellor Kohl campaigning for restorationist CDU in Rostock
Stalinism's terminal crisis
Why communism is
far from finished
The spectre of capitalism hangs
over Lastern Europe, but the spirit
By Harry Sloan
dire example of Poland stares them in the - with is programme.
privatisation and cap in-hand appeals
westem inuustralsts running
alongside growing povelty, starvation
and unemployment for the working
of class struggle is also being
renewed as a new workers move.
ment has sprung to life.
"Communism" is: dead, not only in the exultant right wing press, hut also by the new forces catapulter into power after the col- lapse of stalinist regimes, and by detentist elements on the left includ ing journals like Marxism (which, like the Italian and many
pronounced
class:
Arrogant capitalists sponsor new. immediately corrupt, night wing par- ties and cynically beckon former up-
positionists in East Europe down a mad which could transform their Today countries into dependent sweatshops with the exploited status of under pouties •area Assan. African and Latin
American capitalist states. Against
the pressure for capitalist restoration
there appears linle or no coherent
mass xocialist resistance.
So are the bourgeois idcologists
right? Is communism dead?
In the narrow, superficial sense in
which the mass media use the term -
as a shorthand expression for the
burcaucratised, stalinist regimes of
Easter Europe - then, if not quite
dead, 'connunism' is certainiy on its
nther fommer 'Communist" must now surely have to change its name!)
We ase lectured on all sides on the view that reform has now triumphed over revolution: the "market" over the plan; the individual over the collec- live: yet in Britain all the indicators
popular revulsion against Thatcher and the free market
Bankrupt East Fumpean regimes
'reform" along capitalist lines, even while the
themselves
me
Dun Fas
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 23, April 1990
last legs It survives only through hureaucratic inertia in Cuba North
Tast
aid South Frat Ame
tiny Albania: it required last year's Beijing massacre to keep control in China.
Police regimes
marxists,
however.
"communism" was never synonymous
with the corrupt, grey, bureaucratic with the police regimes established by stooge "Communist Parties" under Stalin's amed might after the defeat of Ger- man imperialism in World War Two.
Though based progressive foundation - nationalised and not private ownership of produc- tion, after the eradication of the rem- nants of the old capitalists and land- owners, and working to a form of centralised planning
rather than linked to a capitalist 'market" - these regimer weir never mom than grotesque deformed parodies of a workers' state. Though the proletariat was notionally the ruling class, and there was a complete break from im-
For
se defeat of Grr
• War Tw
Isoncauv muo of nrnduc
on of ine rem- fiste and land
"For marxists, 'communism'
was never
synonymous
with the corrupt, grey, bureaucratic police regimes
established under Stalin's
armed might
after World
War Two"
Page 13
"When would-be marxists lament the exodus of East Germans to West Germany since the Wall was opened, they should also say whether they want to see the Wall rebuilt, or a revived Honecker-style regime resume its repression of the working class"
Page 14
SUPPLEMENT
military allian- closer to 'socialism" thar those who ule the ther would prefer to ex-
wver al- have fought for worker.
change it for a new proletariat?
With no confidence in the work-
and never ganisation. and those Jeane held more than a tokenistic pretence which have altempted to accor
hands with the most optimistic ele of political power.
the demands of the mass movement.
This kind of political adaptation to
ments of the bourgeoisie, exaggerat-
To equale the political
ing the extent to which a harrage of economic collapse of these regimes stalinism must Incally lead
capitalist propaganda, access 1o glitzy with the defeal of communism is as questioning the pas
working class in Easter Europe.
West Berlin shops and a wild fling of
consumer spending
Poland, the Solidamos govemment
is today leading the hureaucracy's
savings run out) can override the
material circumstances of the work "socialism". It may make handy head- disastrous austenity • lines, but it does little to enlighten the working class: does
ing class and make them cager advo
cates nf their own cx- reader on what is actually
and
inese gimes
ammunim in
ollapse abour government aTingive defeat of make handy head- te to enlighten the
a mally
defeat of the last Labour government in Britain as the definitive defeat of
2. un. sis mean
Wire
MITI
- 1o glitzy wild tling of (until their
happening.
Some socialists, however. would disagree, They believe that the working class itself has already suffered a qualita- tive defeat as a result of the crumbling of stalinist rule wuch ther one-sidedly characterise as a victory for imperialism. Such notions prevail in sections of the British left which, since the
days of the Cold War forced
the lahour movement to 'take
sides between the USA and USSR, have leaned towards
Few socialists would
defend the stalinist view that to defend 'socialismi" the masses must be denied democracy and forcibly contained in a "workers" paradise. A socialism im- posed on the masses is not socialism at all. Yet still some on the left are led inexorably Iowards R rude "campist" VIeW. seeing the world divided into just two counterposed
"blocs" - imperialism on the one hand and anti-im-
any weakening of the Demanding democracy in Moscow
of this in 1980-81, in the equivocal or openly hostile
241 Us
Line taken by many on the Labour left, including lett MPx, and by leaders like Scargill in the unions,
towards the struggles of the
worker against the
racy. under the banner of
Polish
1g ers like
Solidarosc.
The problem with this pessimistic, simplistic view or today " East European events is that it effectively writes off any independent rode for the working class, and today flies in th- face of most East Europcan wotkers aspirations. It assumes that these workers will simply do as they are loid by the westem. bourgeoisie, acting ax unwitting dupes, urging on the drive to capitalist restoration.
Such socialists, who draw no en-
couragement from the ousting of the old repressive regimes are forced lo
ignore or play down the decisive role
wow working class action in removing their hated stalinist rulers -
most significantly in East Germany
and Czechoslovakia. They wind up implicitly grang that those
stalinist regimes - or indeed the con-
servative Ligachev wing of the Soviet
bureaucracy - which have maintained
the heaviest repression of the working
class, and made least changes in the
direction of 'glasnost", are somehow
Ligacney
ET - WILI et fentes
851
wrong to support the millions of Polish workers who ten years ago defied repression and fought under the Solidarose hanner to throw off the yoke of burcaucratic rule? Should we tum our heads against some of today's workers" struggles bocause their leaders, too, may later nove to the night?
Obviously all marxists would wish that the mass movements in Eastem Europe were headed by revolutionary socialists: hut it does not follow that because they are not, we should fall into the trap of implicitly prettifying the old stalinist regimes Wher. would be marxists inment the exodus of East Germans to West Germany since the Wall was opened, or corr plain at the pace at which the GDR - stripped of its police-state rigidity - ix collapsing politically into the arms of Helmut Kohl, they should also say whether they want to see the Wall rebuilt, or a revived Honecker-style regime resume its repression of the
Perhaps some working socialists are so disappointed at the ideologically imperfect working class created by four decades of stalinust
class.
decades
stalini.
ploitation.
Few
an land and anti-am-
perialists (including stalinist regimes) on the other.
Jo dumas stalinist bureaucracy - for
From this: stampoint.
the
whatever reason - is sec
as a weakening of the anti-imperialist struggle. This ap proach not only excludes any inde- pendent role for the working class in the west or (especially) the cast, hut also ignores the squalid history of stalinist political sabotage of anti-im- perialist and anti capitalist struggles from the 1930s to the present day.
The logic of such an approach is to reject the Trotskyist position of fighting for a working class-led politi-
cal resolution that would overthrow the bureaucracies and replace them with organs of prolelarian power -
since there have never heen cir-
cumstances in which this cnuld necur
without a profound political upheaval
which could he scen as a weakening
ums.
whateser teasn
inna st
anti-imnenalist camp. and of- fering at least a temporary advantage
( restorationist
clements.
the kov. •workins
and the extent to which struggles mobilise the workers, enabling them
ruseles
to leam politically in mass action.
Such a dynamic threatens not only
st only
nite.
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 23, April 1990
SUPPLEMENT
apitalism: the indecent dste of the has not been superceded West German
mon than the class through unification is motivated at
struggle has come to a halt. least in part by the anxiety to head off any further radicalisation and the pos-
class struggle - and revolu- socialist current emerging among tionary nolitics, remain
valid so long as revolution
remains the only solution
ever to have succeeded in
srip of
im-
bourgeoisie to speed nu se motivated at
anxiety to head -
will pr
German workers.
Rolling backwards?
If we cast aside the hype, and ig nore the respo however, there is still a problem to be answered. It is clear that even though
that aveu th an immediate, full-scale restoration of capitalism is not feasible throughout Eastem Europe, the capitalists are setting their sights on driving much deepe- private texas upto the nationalised economies. They want to exploit a vast pool of well educated yet cheap labour, and to maximise the market for consumer goods. in a more global sense, the imperialist hour- gepixie is also hoping in demolish the Warsaw Pact, leaving NATO powers ascendant in Europe.
Ar "Communist partie. change names, ditch leaders, drop program- mes, lose members hy the thousand and face virtual extinction at the polls, and as yesterday's monolithic 'workers" xtutes' urge in the multina tionals, it certainly does appear that the wheel of history is rolling back- wards, Do these developments sug- gest that