communism itself. as a politi- cal objective, a historic goal of the
knce-jerk
as a pout- zoal of the
workers' movement, is now really workers finished, with its partially completed elements beginnin to anraver Should all marxists ape Marxism Today, abandon any socialist preten- sions, and raise a new flag as a refor-
= i retor-
mist current within capitalism?
Nie The very tac: thas some socialists have such a rosy view of the popularity nt apitalism reflects their remoteness from the problems (and political views) of large sections of the working class. With a third of the British population existing at or below the poverty line, an ever-
widening gap between rich and poor. and rampant problems of homeless ness, the idea that the capitalist sys tem is more acceptable now than it was: 100 years ago is a middle class delusion. This is even more the case
ore th
if we consider the plight of workers and peasants super-exploiled by mul- tinational corporations and domestic
Communism as a historic objec live - the struggle to put an end to
capitalists in
world'
myesu
'third
hunger and matenal want, to exploita- tion, lo the threat of war, and to na- tional, racial and sexual oppression,
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK o 23. April 1990
and
perialism.
Expanding the productive forces
Nothing in the recent East European events has questioned the basic marx- ist propusition that "The history of all hitherto exist- ing society is the history of class struggles"
Capitalism developed as the most simplified expres sion of these class strug gles, in which the property- less proletariat, owning nothing other than its Labour power, finds itself exploited by the hour- geoisie, in whose hands are the privately-owned means of production.
Marx and Engels ar gued that such a system
contained huge contradic-
tions - among which is a dynamic which forces the capitalists to continuousiy develop the produc tive forces in pursuit of competitive advantage and super profits. The Communist Manifesto might almost be written about Thatcherism when it
"Constant revolutionising of production, uninterrupted disturbance of all social conditions, everlasting uncertainty and agitation distinguish the bourgenis epoch from all carlier ones. All fixed, fast-frozen relations, with their train of ancient and venerable prejudices and opinions are swept away, all new formed ones he- come antiquated before they can of
"The need of a constantly expand
ing market for its products chases the
bourgeoisie over the whole surface of
the globe. It must nestle everywhere. arle everywler The bourgeorsic has through its exploitation of the world market given a cosmopolitan
character to production and consump
every country. Tn the grear
chagrin of reactionists, it has drawn
from under the foet of industry the na-
tional ground on which it stood. All old-established natinnal industries
have been destroyed or are daily being destroyed. They are dislodged by new industries, whose introduc- tion bocomes a life and death ques- tion for all civilised nations..."
(Communist Manifesto)
As the productive forces advance
and expand, their potential to create
commodities comes into conflict with the guest for profit - the limitations of the market, restrictions of the na-
tion-state and small enterprise. Lenin
weat beyond Mars to develop an analysts of the drive in monopoly. tol
sorb ups
multi-nationar finance. and the dominance of the banks and finance houses: he defined the period since the tum of the century as the histori cal cpoch of imperialism. This would be a period of wars and revolutions
• or markets
vernals
impen "highest stage
and andl
of
capitalism', capitalist relations of production begin to act as a fetter rather than a stimulus to the means of
nosis subjected tn the test of history and pass, Imperialism has generated
«cen inct ot
this prop- history -
"With a third of
the British
population
below the
poverty line, a-widening gap
between rich
and poor, and
rampant
problems of homelessness,
the idea that
the capitalist system is more acceptable now
is a middle class delusion"
Page 15
*The lowest stage of Communism', to employ the term of Marx, begins at that level to which the most advanced capitalism has drawn near..... So long as even a modest 'Ford' remains the privilege of a minority, there survive all the relations and customs proper to a bourgeois society." (Revolution Betrayed)
Page 16
SUPPLEMENT
wars a-plenty: and yet revolution in the USSK and subsequently in China have shown the huge economic ad- vances that can be triggered even in backward economies once the con-
straints of capitalism are removed.
The social overturns of the old, Dankrupt hourgeoise of Eastern Europe also paved the way for the working class to make social gains in terms of jobs, housing, education and welfare provisions that would never have boen conceded under capitalism.
However the contradictory aspoct of this development has been the emergence in the USSR of a parasitic bureaucracy (replicated in subscquent stalinist regimes): this represents the antithesis of a dynamic development of the productive forces. With the working class politically gagged and excluded from control or manage- ment of industry, and power in the hands of a conservative, compt bureaucracy, conditions were created for stagnation.
This, combined with the economic isolation of the Saviet and later stalinist burcaucracies from the technological develop- ments in the west, made it in- evitable that the initially primitive cconomies would fall ever further behind, especially in the area of most rapid technological change - the production of consumer goods.
In analysing the bureaucratisa- tion of the USSR, Leon Trotsky in 1925 wrote his incisive analysis Revolution Betrayed, which today repays fresh atten- tion as an explanation of develop ments in Eastern Europe Reject- ing any idealist attempt to blame the growth of buresucracy simply on had ideas or bad individuals he pointed first and foremost in the material base, the USSR's economic hackwardness and isolation, and the weakness of the Communist cadre as a result of the prolonged wars of in- tervention and civil war. From this he spelled out the inevitability of a resur- gence not only of bureaucracy, but of bourgeois forms, norms and ideology:
"Two years before the Communist Manifesto, young Marx wrote: "A development of the productive forces
js the absolutely necessary practical
premise lof Communism] because
without it want is generalised, and
with want the struggle for necessities begins again, and that means that all ma mu crap must revive Thes
thought Marx never
with
Marx directly devrloped, and for no accidental
reason: he never foresaw a proletarian
revolution in a hackward country. Lenin also never dwelt upon it, and this too was not accidental He did not foresee so prolonged an isolation of the Soviet state. Neverthei».. structure. citation. provides an indispensible theoretical key to the wholly concrete difficulties and sicknesses of the Soviet regime. On the historic basis of destitution, aggravated by the destructions of the imperialist and civil wars, the 'struggle for individual existence not only did not disappear the day after the overthrow of the bourgeoisie, and not only did not abate in the succeeding years, but, on the contrary, assumed at times an un- heard-of ferocity.
(Revolution Betrayed, New Park Edition, pp 56-58)
Trotsky was firm in stressing the huge economic advances that had been made since the revolution, but
pains from capitalist socicty, Law can never be higher than the economic
•utural deven inditioned bu that
thene mmarkanle
Bourge. law m ribution of the ob
jects of consumption assumes of
course, inevitably a bourgeois state.
nourgents mate.
none withnut an ap
we oil rumpelling obser da misTs. ll follows twe are
ling chini that unact tom.
survive for a certain fime, but also even a bourgeois state without the bourgeoisie!"
"Insolar as the state which es: sumes the task of socialist Iransior- mation is compelled to delend ine- quality that 1s, the maleral privileges of a minority - by methods
of compulsion, insofar does it
also remain a 'bourgeois" state.
even though without a bour-
geoisie. These words contain
neither praise nor blame: they
merely name things with their
real names."
manly will hourgooss law
enain time
late without the
with the bourgeors
state, the struggle fos neces-
ad te ineyumitir- stalinism turned back on al-
Alone
sitie-
most every issue - expecially the oppression of women. youth, and national minoritien
to bourgeois ideology: all
this is traced through by
Trotsky in detail.
A false start in
Eastern Europe
As the outcome of a transi-
tional stage of socialist development, in which the supply of useful goods must be not only suffi- cient to eliminate the daily struggle for necessities, but must also nutstrip the cconomic levels possible under
capitalism, communism was always impossible in any single country - let sane an solated. backward
bureaucratised economy-
fought bitterly against the efforts of the stalinists to characterise the 1930s USSR as 'socialist*:
"Is it not monstrous?" - we wrote in March 1932. "The country cannot get out of a famine of goods. There is a stoppage of supplies at every step. Children lack milk. But the official oracles announce "The country has entered into the period of socialism!" Would it he possible more viciously to compromuse the name of socialism?''
Echoing Lenin, Trotsky went fur- ther, and (in words which also have a
bureaucratised economy-
All of the r
analysed in the development of
bureaucracy in the USSR applied
with equal force to the post-war regimes of Eastem Europe, hut with
w-hieme w.
ucn Trotsky
of
:Es
an additional handicap:
contemporary relevance NOnE on Nicardouas brance
NE:
socialist construction
the Bol- berun their mtart
Bor
at bureaucratised Soviet state of the day as a 'bourgeois state' though without a bourgeoisie!
"Marx wrote in 1875: "Bourgeois law. is inevitable in the first phase of the communist socicty, in that form
in which it issues after long labour
genuinely revolutionary party at the
head of a proletarian revolution
with w.y nany al ine
which galvanised mask mobilisation
against the class enemy. In Eastern Europe these elements were almost
Parties"
HCX...
were
wet a most "Crummunisi
hopelessly
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 23, April 1990
SUPPLEMENT
bureaucratised and ponticaliv
"For decades degenerate from the very ourset, and Stalin's Red Army had repressed the spontancour upsurges of the working
argued that class after the fall of Hitler.
political
The new regimes that were im-
revolution is
prosed on la hutter states wern
ruthlessly purged of any clements
the historic task that might display political inde
of the working pendence. In the nationalised but
class but the
fact that the
stalinists have
proved less able
than the
capitalists to
develop the
productive
forces has
rendered their
regimes
vulnerable to
capitalist
restoration"
any nad men
• dispu
nationaliser Par chaotically disorganised oconomies.
arused economi: Stalin had plundered most industrial plant of any value as "reparations". From this grim material starting point there was never any prospect of an advance beyond the limited progress achieved by the USSR.
As in the Soviet Union, the failure to end the struggle for necessities led to a revival of the 'old crap". Queues, shortages and stunted economic development lagging way behind the advanced capitalist countries ran alongside grotesque bureaucratic privileges and corruption among the Party elite. The contradictions be- tween such evident inequality and the
'official" marxist idenlogy could only be preserved through intensitied police repression and the imposition of a political monopoly for the "Communist parties. bureaucracy whose stultifying conser varan and stilled incompeten crippled any potential for develop ment of a properly planned economy tumed increasely in dea. with
capitalism as a means to secure access to more modem technology and con- sumer goods.
There was never any prospect that these hidcous replicas of Stalin's bureaucratised TISSR cruld grow ar be peacefully reformed into socialist societies. They were not 'almost' communist regimes, but something qualitatively different, deformed to the extent that a revolutionary over- throw of the bureaucracy was the only way the nationalised means of production could he unleashed to their full potential by the working
pendence. In the nationalised but
And
class.
The bureaucracy not only acts as an impediment to the proper develop meat of the means of production, but in securing its political monopoly on the levers of power, it deforms every aspect of daily life, from the regime in the factories to the narrow restric-
The bureaucracy not only acts as an impediment to the proper develop
roductior hut
tive curricula of schools and univer- sities. The same pressures helped
preserve the backward religious su perstitions that are now resurfacing.
- curric.
preserv perstitions
and bourgeois morality, and fostered
absurd illusions in western capitalism
and bourge absurd illus and bourge the popular backlash against all things
ovaki, a crow to the working class?
seen as 'marxist" and 'communist hy association with the regime.
As an obitacle in the development
the productive forces. the bureaucracy identified itself long ago as a reactionary historic force that had in be removed For decades marxists have argued that this is the historic task of the working class in the process of political revolution: but the fact that the stalinists have proved less able than the capitalists to develop the productive forces has rendered their regimes vulnerable to capitalist restoration. Now we see ele- ments of the old regime openly switching sides, leading the moves for privatisation and restoration, in the hopes of preserving some of their power and privileges.
These developments do not prove the obsolescence of communism so much as the gulf between com- munism and stalinism. Any attempt now by restorationists to drive for- ward a capitalist development in Faster Europe must result in an in tensification of the class struggle, a renewed dnive to explint the working
class and destroy the limited gains it
has secured in the post war years. It will create conditions in which
revolutionaries can put forward a programme of class action to combat the multinationals and defend work- ing class living conditions.
Collapse of the Warsaw
Pact: a blow to the
working class?
Ever since the crisis of stalinist
rule spread beyond Poland it has been
increasingly obvious that the Warsaw Pact is a dead duck. With Czechos- lovakra having negotiated withdrawal of Soviet troops, East
Germany moving swiftly to unifica-
TIOn with a NATO power, ther Romanian regime declaring com-s munism "dead", and the Hungarian stalinist party having largely dis solved itself, there are few if any Moscow loyalists in Easter Europe prepared even to try to deliver the type of support theoretically required of them by the Warsaw Pact.
Worse for Gorhachev, proclaimed
independence Lithuania (and the likelihood similar moves by Estonia and Latvia). coupled with nationalist revolts in ans increasing number of republics within the USSR make the Soviet Union it- self less and less convincing as ar homogenous military "superpower'. Lithuania's lead in rejecting the con- scription of young men into the Soviet armed forcex would certainly be followed by more and more republics in the event of a major warl danger: the revolt of Russian women against Gorbachev sending conscripts to quell the recent Azerbaijan upris- ing made this quite clear.
Does this new situation make communism or the defence of the USSR a hopeless quest? Lenin and Trotsky did not base the defence of the fledgling Soviet workers' state orl the strategy of the new Communists Internationar on grandiose military al-1 liances based on the coercion of al Great Power upon neighbouring sat- telite regimes. They rejected any no tion of exporting revolution on ther points of bayonets, and reengnised that in the last analysis the defence of the Soviet Union depended upon the revolutionarfy mobilisation ofthe in- terational working class. Most im- portant of all was to break theisola- tion of the Russian Revolution bu supporting struggles for the over- throw of capitalism in at least one ad
of of
"it has been
increasingly obvious that the Warsaw Pact is
a dead duck"
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 23, April 1990
Page 17
SUPPLEMENT
marcism" dexpite 40
vanced country. "The notion of
Stamn showed
years of intensive school-
no: comprehension ing. a purely sony military this policy: instead failures East defence of the
proclaim his alter deliver con- USSR was
native, reinforced in the of
developinent the post-war period" while of
the "third world" and ins-
"like a union leader who calls off a strike before negotiations, Gorbachev finds his position weakened in his dealings with the White House by the setbacks of betrayed struggles in Central America"
Page 18
walpainy
4 he bevan to
nationalist
the
of the
European cconomics to
adequate sumer goods or to match
While
.. ceking тo HE CUSTEN
" single country".
coexisting
with capitalism on
a world scale. Sub
pace
western
capitalist spells out
the Weaklie'
bureaucratic
"planning", the huge scale of poverty and lunger in
of poverty
sequent twists and
tums in Stalin's foreign policy did not change his fun- damental view that any nther revolu- tion had to be subordinate to the "defence of the USSR'. By the mid 1930s the Popular Front policy had enshrined the notion of a political al- Liance with "democratic" sections of the capitalist class, at the expense of discarling any socialist or revolution ary aspiralions of the western Com- munist parties.
In the late 1930s this switched to a
policy of alliance with Hitler, as Stalin attempted militarily to
safeguard and exiend the power of the
USSR by invading caster Poland
and Finland. This notion of a purely
•itary delence of the USSR was
reinforced in the post-war period with
the annexation of the Baltic states, the
carve-up of Poland, the Red Army oc
cupation of the East European "buffer
zone, and the general framework of
the "spheres of influence deals struck with um impenalist powere The
development: of nuclear weapons was met by a parallel Soviet military drive to explode ever-more desilly nuclear bombs and missiles: NATO was countered by press gang ing East European regimes into the Warsaw Pact - but all the lime the disposition of the Kremlin was to op- pose, isolate and limit working class and anti-imperialist struggles,
While the Warsaw Pact and the
vast Soviet armed forces meet the for- mal arqultements of militarily
"defending the USSR" and guarantee-
ing the borders of Eastern
perialist countries as well
as the spread of poverty
1 Poland contin tal a.
restoration of capilaliser
or the market will simip- ey intensify the misery. Those whin doubt the need 16 delend t nationansed cconomies privatiration will soon witness all the evidence they need.
As workers in Eastem Europe flex: their political and trade union muscles for the first time in several genera- tions, beset by confusion arising from the collapse of the old official or thodoxies, the new phase of clas struggle runs alongside the emer- gence of new combalive workers" movements elsewhere. In Brazil | huge trade union movement and the
class struggle Workers Party with a mass base of support have been built;
in South Africa and South Korea
large, dynamic trade union organisa- tions challenging repre- regimes.
Privileged, but not a ruling class: a bureaucrat's limo leaves the Kremlin
spation
i hordere
they are not communism. Marxists defend historic as not only
militarily, but politically: lost in the
wash of stalinist bureaucratic/military
manoeuvies ix the strategic political
defence of the USSR through the fight for socialist revolution.
deten
wannon. to stalin
Brezhnev,
whose Andant.
allabernt
she
isolation of the Nicaraguan revolution and of the fighters of El salvador) Gorbachev inherited a legacy of counter-revolutionary foreign policy. together with an conomic crisis which has compelled him to shift his tactics, He decided that the arms race had to give way to attempts at achiev- ing a negotiated balance of forces with imperialism: spotting this weak- ness, imperialism has dug in to force major concessions. Yet while the su- perpower hype focusses on the top- level talks on warheads and tanks, on the ground the effect of Gorbachev's conciliatory tum has been felt by liberation fighters around the world.
The result has been a predictable each way setback: impenalism has clearly gained the upper hand in the NATO-Warsaw Pact standoff, while, like a union leader who calls off a strike before negotiations, Gorbachev finds his position weakened in his dealings with the White House by the setbacks of betrayed struggles in Central America.
Difficulties and chances
The basic marxist analysis of capitalism and of stalinism has not been refuted but confirmed by recent events.
Regimes portrayed by some as
"state capitalist have shown in the
rapid turnover of leading personnel
that they are controlled not by a new. stable ruling class, but by a privileged bureaucratic caste whose unstable power rests not on ownership of
movement property but on their exercise of political control
Many with stalinist leanings who regarded one or more of the regimes as simply "workers" states" have heen shocked to discover the extent of the corruption at the top and repression at the base, and how wafer thin was the vencer of popular support for
stat i the
against
thie inst the
One positive aspect of the chaotic upheavals in Eastern Europe is that these and other new workers move
ments can develop with much less political pressure from the stalinist movement - making it more likely that revolutionary currents can lie built. There is a new political space opening up for the development nf class struggle politics, amid all the dangers and contradictions of the situation.
mov
The defeats inflicted by the mas ses on stalinism do not autonatically
• 6m: 198
any spontancous mass movement.
The challenge is there for the marxist
r the in particular tive
Trotskyist