Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Labour's classless policies for schools

· Socialist Outlook no. 23, April 1990 · pp 30-31 · 1,907 words

Labour Party

FEATURES

Good Education For All ?

Education is a vote-loser for the Tories.

A recent opinion poll (The Guardian 15-2-90) showed education to be the second most impor tant policy issue, after bealth. 43% said Labour 'had the best education policies", as against 27% for the Tories.

What are these opinions

haved on? Some of the myths popularised by the Tory press did not com-

mand xupport. For example.

Ine the

acent surver par ot express parti-un

ahout teaching

concem …rethods. and pupus het

ahou: the

the other hand, there was wide support for some of the key policies in the 1988 Education Act. According to a recent survey of parents (Times Educational Supple- ment 8.12.801 though onlv just over half had heard of the national curriculum, 9 out of 10 approved. Attainment targets for cach age group were approved by 94 percent.

The overriding reason, in spite of this, for the lack of confidence in Tory education policy lies in the real experiences that parents have had of education under Thatcher - above all, experiences of cuts. Crumbling schools, shortages of books, children sent home be cause there aren't enough teachers, all offer tangible confirmation of the general idea that cducation is not safe in the Tories' hands. whatever the benefits that City Technology Colleges might provide for the few. (Addition- al evidence, again contrary to the popular press, is in another survey published in the TES (5.5.89) which showed a huge gap be- tween public regard for teachers - among the most highly respected groups in society, third only to doctors and the police - and public perception of the govemment's regard for teachers - bottom with 4 percent).

For the Tories, who have invested so much political capital in radical education reform. this is a disaster which will not be tumed around by the turbulent experiences of the im- plementation of the 1988 Act in the couple of years before the next election.

However it does not represent any unc-

there w

Page 28

reducated for the market?

quivocal success for the left. A bedrock of support for comprehensive education, liberal teaching methods and adequate rundin provides the basis for resistance to Tory at- tacks. But it is not enough even to mark out the starting point for a socialist politics of education. This must begin from the under- standing that the working class has an interest in cducation which is fundamentally incom- patible with that of capital.

This hasic conception is entirely absent from the Labour Paity's alternative to Tory education policy. On the coutrary, the central theme of Good education for all? (GEFA), the education section of the Policy Review docu- ment adopted at the 1989 LP conference, is precisely that education for social justice and education for capitalist economic development go hand in hand.

This recalls the rhetoric of the heyday of Labour's educational reformism in the 1960s, when the pools of wasted ability had to be channeled into the 'white heat of the tech- nological revolution. Twenty-five years later. Wilson's vision has been superceded by the challenge of 1992, but the guiding principle remains the same.

As Neil Kinnock put it, replying to Tony Benn during the Labour Party NEC debate on the Policy Review, the market economy was the xystem we lived in, and we had to make it work more efficiently, more fairly, more suc- cessfully in the world market place'. (Cam paign Group News, May 1989)

This aim is the

dominant theme of "EFA The way that Lanour education proposals are govered by the

-ve is illustrated clearly in the sec- sina neaded Th

challenge of millenium. from being

long awaited

socialist millenium, it is the fulure

defined in terms of

in the

changes in

TEm in

lengr Single Market.

There mention of any of

the great issues that move young people today, the environment, disarmament, poverty in the underdeveloped countries, human

rights, issues of gender and race, empowering the powerless. The notion of encation as

aveny Shuasodis incation as

are references tr

-cablishment

• in the aim of houng able

-more democratic sociely, but this is very much a subordinate

HRPArT THUT IPFA Tuan

EnT DEBLI

and token theme in GEFA.

There is no suggestion anywhere in GEFA

that the economic imperative might be in con

tradiction with the quality of people's lives, or

with moral values, or other aspects

socicty's functioning. There is no notion that

there might be even a degree of tension be

tween the demands of industrial and commer-

cial profitability and even the modest aim of a fairer society, let alone that social justice may require pupils to be offered a sel of education- al experiences distinctively different from what exists (that, for example, it may entail a radical rappraisal of school knowledge' and of relationships with leachers and institu- tions). Nowhere is there any suggestion even of a critical approach, let alone one that in based on distinctively socialist, feminist and ecological principles.

It is as though the positive experiences. particularly of antiracist and antisexist teach ing. of the 1980s had never taken place, The document, in the soction headed Multi-racial

and token

There

that the m tradict with society - there migre I

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 23, April 1990

FEATURES

education acknowledges that "discrimins tion, based upon class, sex and race, prevent equal access to educational opportunity. But there are no sections on gender and class.

The only mcarure proposed on gender in the schools in a broad and balanced national curriculum which will provide 'cqual learning upportunities for both boys and girls'. On race, the document says schools must he sen-

sitive to ethnic minonty cultural needs and aspirations, with the implication that this will be sufficient to reduce inequality of achievo- ment An effective challenge to inequality en- tails seeing class, gender and race in terms of social relationships. not indices of disad- vantage, it entails a radical reappraisal of all aspects of schooling, and it entails substantial

The absence of the notion of education for emancipation and the explicit acceptance of the interests of capital as the yardstick of

ale sarastick ~ education policy places tiEFA on ihe same terrain as Tory education thinking. GEFA dis tinguishes itself from Tory cducation policies in claiming to provide better answers than the Tories have to the needs of a modemising

,0n posses

"thun the

dermixing

milenze. nf

capitalism facing

The key contribution that education can make to the task of making British capitalism

int mai

naw Cal

aplatism

etter edt.

regum.

matr meritocracy, reducing the

greater universality of

some egahtarian measures, in order to create a obstacles which prevent some competing on provision: from an expansion of nursery

schools, to wider access to higher education.

abolition of grammar

00...

12

It also means the renovation of 16-19

education and training, based on the model of the most successful capitalist coonomy in Europe, West Germany. And it means some

limited measures to reduce inequality for working-class, black and female pupils and

But because it is an egalitanarism

whor JC egatitan»

that is hamessed to and defined by the inter- ests of carital and not radically emancipatory goals, it will actually have very little effect on incqualities which are the product of social relationships of oppression, mooted precisely in the dominance of those same interests.

An indication of the extent to which Labour shares the Tory agenda was given by a joint press conference held in February by

Education Secretary MacGregor and opposi- tion spokesperson Jack Straw on the issue of citizenship training. It might be thought that this is one issue on which Labour has some- thing distinctive to say. Yet, according to the Guurdun з геров:

"Mr Straw could be seen wielding a red pen over his speech as he listened to Mr Mac- Gregor telling the conference of the need to train pupils to become the good citizens of tomorrow. He needed to change what he had

written because it was so closely in agreement SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 23, April 1990

with the minister.*

The Tories have radi-

ally re shaped how

school education is con

trolled, by a combination of centralisation of pown- to rovernment and devolution of certain powers to govemors and parents, at the expense of LEAs How docs the Labour leadership propose to deal with this issue?

GEFA promises a now partnership with LEAs, largely restoring their previous role. The increased powers that have accrued to the DES under the Tories will ap- parently be largely retained, many of them exercised through a new Education

Standards Council. At school level, GEFA speaks of Parents in partnership. "Parents are a comerstone of a school's success and a pupil's progress'. Labour will give more rights of information and access to parents, more support to parent govemors, and encourage LEAs to establish complaints procedures. GEFA 1 curiously silent on what changes it may make in the Tories' system of Local Management of Schools (LMS).

This is hardly a radical vision of popular democratic involvement in education Under Tory LMS parents have two key roles. As consumers", they can exercise choice in the education market place and thus exert market pressures on the schools, Thugh governing bodies they can directly influence school policy on certain matters.

Labour's alternative may reduce the im-

pact of the education market, and we welcome

that, but it does not replace it with a genuine

extension of direct democratic procedures in

education. Rights of individual information

and invalvement by parents in their schools

are important, hut they need to be comple-

mented by measures that transform governing

bodies under LMS into effective instruments

If you educate your kids right, they could grow up like he did!

e local democracv.

There in a need to rextore certain powers of

planning and provision to Local Edication Authorities, hut they equally need in be democratised, so that processes of consult-

ation and negotiation are institutionalived and

effective. At govemment level we need, not a

government-picked

Council with no popular roots but a powerful

consultative body representative of all the

vanous interest-groups in cducation.

ITTI

Education

Standards

GEFA is notably cautious about money. It simply says that "The Labour Party is com- mitted to increased investment". Yet even the modest reforms it proposes will require a very large increase in spending. For example, GEFA says that more teachers are needed: classes are too big, teachers don't have

enough time to help individual pupils or liaise

with parents, pay is too low. "The result is un- derachievement in the classroom'.

Again, the document says that its aim is that all three and four year olds should have

the right to nursery education'. These are vital aims, but no specific commitments are given in the document as to their calisation Previous experience has repeatediy shown

how Labour's promised reforms have been

undermined by a failure to make the money

available to put them properly into practice,

so laying the ground for a subsequent back-

lash from which the Tories have benefitted.

Discussion of a comprehensive alternative

to Lahour's policy is currently under way in

volved.

Lar

gren

to Lahour's policy is currently under way in

the Socialist Movement's Education Working

Group, in which a number of members of the NUT'= Socialist Teachers' Alliance are in-

naused an = aav-

Notingham and ust Movement itsell. A » ex ako being drafted

for Labour Party Conference.

Richard Hatcher

Page 29

← Reactionaries win Indian state elections · Colleges in crisis →

Something wrong on this page?