FEATURES
Tory plans create another fine mess
The Thatcherite plan for higher educa- tion (HE) is in crisis. A scheme seek- ing to serve the short term needs of in- dustry and at same time to attract double the prescut numbers of stu- dents, it is intrinsically riven with con-
The aim is to produce a workforce that is compliant, hardworking, and qualified for the immediate needs of industry: all this without the govemment investing in the longer term needs of education or providing students with financial support.
The Tories themselves are making it impossible to meet their target of 50% in- crease in student numbers in the next 25 yean. They are restricting access and slashing cducational funding at a time when there is a demographic shortfall of 18-24 year olds, which puts a premium on
attracting and offering easier access to HE
for sections who at present make least use
Since 1979 the Tory goverment has
pushed the cost of HE onto students and Architect of chaos: Kenneth Baker
parents — cutting £36 million in benefits
nian ti
pushed the parents rutting 17h munon to students between 1983-86. Now with the loans Bill going through the last parliamentary stages, students face the abolition of the full grant and the introduction of top-up loans, and the loss of housing benefit and income sup- port. This is a loss of around E1,300 per year for many students, and that's before your poll tax bill lands on your doorstep or a top up fee is imposed.
It is ludicrous to claim that this will lead to anything but decreased access, restricting HE to an even narrower group of students than at present.
Even the Times Higher Education Supple- ment stated that "No amount of disengenuous rhetoric about students paying (actually bor- rowing) their way through college can dis- guise the true effect of this Bill, which will be to increase dependence and decrease access".
The removal of housing benefit has further
implications. It means that study in London
becomes virtually impossible — and already
applications to London are static compared to
a sharp increase in applications to northern
colleges. This has led the colleges to a policy
of demanding higher grades for entry which is squeezing out yet more working class
becomes virtually impossible — and already
applications to London are static compared to
in applications
1 the semica-
The contradictions are clear. The Tories want education to be governed hy the market and no state money to assist its long-term
iT COll
on to the wall nr
fail to provide choice of courses and quality
education, then many students, with no finan-
cial support, will vote with their feet, and stay
away.
A recent report by the Institute of Man- power Studies states that a dramatic opening of access to HE is required if student numbers are going to double in the next 25 vears "The number of 18 year olds with 'A" Levels must expand by 50%; a further 50% of work- ing class students must gain "A' Levels, as many women as men must participate and ma- ture students must rise by 50%". It concluded that without a major shift in policy this was unlikely to nocur especially with the introduc- tion of loans.
Thatcher faces further problems with the loans scheme. In the face of students and stu- dent unions taking action and withdrawing their hank accounts the hanks have pulled out of the scheme. And it has been revealed that the scheme won't break even until the year 2050 and will cost £667 million to introduce!
There is another problem. When given a choice, students consistently choose arts and social science courses ratber than engineering. even when enticed by the carrot of financial sponsorship. People go to great lengths to self- fund PhDs in English, courses which even with lack of public funding are oversub- scribed, whereas Phs in engincering, with guaranteed funding. go unfilled.
The Tories consistently fail to understand that the only way to increase participation in HE is to make it accessible to all. In the first instance this means providing a living grant
for all 1619 year olds because the majority of students drop out at thin
stage. Also funding for mature students
sture students
on access courses is vital as is the
restructuring of the archaic "A' Level.
All this plus a non-means tested
grant with travel allowances instead of
our present underfunded scheme is the
only way to radically increase student
numbers and make education available
to all who wish to enter it.
The privatisation of the polytechnics.
is already resulting in money problems.
They are forced to compete and bid for
students as commodities — and quality
has gone out of the window. It has
resulted in taking larger numbers of fee-
paying students, especially overseas stu-
dents paying exhorbitant fees, and cut-
ting resources per student.
A materials levy has been introduced
for most arts students — in other words
a top-up fee. This June the universities
are going down the same path and there
are serious worries aboul academic
standards being maintained. There are
fears of cuts in student representation and the number of courses on offer — also the exploitation of overscas. students.
Japanese art at the School of Oriental and African Studies has already been privatised
— there is no longer access to Japanese art education in this country for ordinary students. Even the hig universities such as Oxford and London are in a financial crisis with London expected to levy a f250 top-up fee to all stu- dents before the end of the year!
The NUS while trying to fight the goverment's proposals is itself in crisis. Its leadership has bowed to the philosophy of new realism and has dragged its foet over stu- dent demands for mass action. It failed to or- ganise nationa action when the student radicalisation first demanded it, and only or- ganised a demo in Glasgow and then London when put under enormous pressure.
Thi• year× NUS elections ser a real danger if the left does not unite to defeat the right. Cosmo, a zionist independent with a fake left face stands a chance of winning the presidency if past form of divisions on the hard left is repeated.
Socialists should vote for the left, and
transfer to NOLS
a leadership committed paign in defence of free the Tor inane: There is re waiting In he won! Louise Holloway
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 23, April 1990