Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Something cooking in the Common European Kitchen

· Socialist Outlook no. 22, March 1990 · pp 15-18 · 2,482 words

Women Russia and the USSR

WOMEN'S DAY SUPPLEMENT

AN ME.

FEN

Women demonstrate outside Armargh prison, International Womens Day 1983

cooking

VY

IRENE BRUEGEL reports on the fifth European Socialist Feminist Con- ference Socialist feminists across Europe have been meeting over the last five years in an effort to build an • internationalist

socialist feminism, to develop theoretical understanding and practical, sup- portive links.

One common starting point for West European socialist feminists has been that state ownership of the means of production does not ensure liberation; that the statist economics of the Soviet bloc rest full square on the super-exploitation of women; and that a totally different model of socialism is needed.

It is puzzling then that neither perestroika nor the turmoil in Eastern Europe appears to have generated any such feminist opposition: the voices of women have been absent. Indeed 'leftists" like Boris Kagarlitsky assert

that women's oppression is not an

issue, and that feminism is a bour- geois deviation.

Fortunately a different picture

emerged from the handful of feminists from the Soviet Union, Hungary, Yugoslavia and Poland who were able come to the conference of the European Socialist Feminist Forum in Gothenburg. Sweden in November. While feminism is nowhere a strong and vibrant move- ment, a feminist challenge both to stalinism and to the reform movement

is developing, fragmented, full of contradictions and difficulties and with limited links to working class women. Nevertheless it is there, irespective of the silence in the westem media and the left press.

It is clear that economic reforms are, at best, double edged; that an autonomous feminist movement will have to build an altemative concep tion of women's liberation from that forced down on women through the state and party. These raise central questions for westem socialist feminists, in particular in the analysis of the state, civil society and the fami- ly. What was striking in the European conference was how this implicit questioning of a socialist feminist 'orthodoxy' paralleled some of the is-

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 22, March 1990

sues raised by black women in their

critique of 'white' feminism in thei West.

The theme of this year's Con- ference was "Global Restructuring and Women's Labour'. One single framework can't adequately encom pass what is happening to women workers in the East and West, or the North and South. But certain com- mon themes are clear. Across Europe feminisation of the labour force has not altered the sexual division of labour; it appeared to be developing alongside increasing income dis parities between women and between

the level of women's unemployment

and men's.

In the USSR, where female sec- tors of the economy are being tar- getted for market reform, it seems that given the chance, enterprises would try to avoid flexible/ unstable labour, that is women's labour. Al- though it is in the mines and the steel industry in the USSR and Hungary that the first wave of closures are due, the high level of bureaucratisation put women's work particularly under threat. In one Hungarian uranium

March 8 is

International

Women's Day,

and in 1990

unites new

struggles of

women in

Eastern Euope with their sisters in the west and

in the "third world'. Socialist Outlook presents

a special supplement with

articles on

women in Ireland, on the

fight for an internationalist,

socialist

feminism, and

women's

struggle for rights as the EC

debates its "Social Charter'

Page 13

SUPPLEMENT

- seems unquestionable. In a

situation where there is no

choice of doctor, nor account-

ability or redress, it is perhaps

not so surprising that the East

European feminists fell that

privatisation of the health ser-

vice or at least the development

of medical co-ops, which charge

for services offered a chance of

improving standards.

Soviet health service reforms

are providing some consumer

choice and from now on doc-

tors will be paid according to

how many patients they attract.

Such "choices' are of course

tendentious, as the Swedish

women made clear. In Sweden

there are moves to break the

state's virtual monopoly of

childcare. Under the banner of

*choice' individual subsidies are

being mooted which will foster

private childminding in place of the almost universal public system.

In Poland and Hungary childcare has been privatised largely under the cover of paid maternity leave. Childcare provision at the enterprise elsewhere in Eastem Europe is un- likely to survive local self manage- ment, unless women achieve a great deal more say in economic policy.

In Poland only three percent of children under 3 are in childcare; the proportion has been falling since 1981 when paid maternity leave was introduced. However, its value has been systematically croded and it is means-tested. As a result only single parents are effectively eligible; childeare has been privatised not to tothers, who can't afford to give up work, пог necessarily to grandmothers, who also need employment but to retired and redun- dant or low waged men, or to infor- mal childcare at ratios not even ac- ceptable in Britain today. In East Germany, however, the municipality provides a comprehensive system of local child-care, which seems rela- tively secure.

While the right to abortion has been one of the first gains from the Romanian revolution, in Poland the church is actively pushing for restric- tions on abortion provision. Women in factories argue that any referendum on abortion should be for women of childbearing age alone. Solidamose is equivocal. But the Polish women told us how they had organised

demonstration in support of the US

women's abortion struggle; the

Solidarose paper would not touch it, and the only support they had from

Page 14

"Of all European countries, from Ireland to the Urals, it is Hungarian women who are most likely to say that a mother's place is in the home. Years of low status, poorly paid jobs, of high levels of shift work and night work have taken their toll"

mine for example, half the workers were women office staff, and it is they who face unemployment. The situation is contradictory; it is progressive TO get rid of the bureaucrats in the ministries - and yet these were women's jobs; and the safer types of women's jobs at that. These cuts need to be put in context- 40% of women factory workers in Poland, for example, are working in unsafe and unhygienie circumstances.

Although an ideological offensive against the employment of women (especially mothers) is underway across Eastern Europe, it is meeting a mixed, if not positive response from women themselves. Of all European countries, from Ireland to the Urals, it is Hungarian women who are most likely to say that a mother's place is in the home. Years of low status, poorly paid jobs, of high levels of shift work and night work have taken their toll.

It should not really be surprising that women want time for themselves, for their children and indeed for meaningful personal relationships.

Queueing, the lack of household ap- pliances, and men's attitudes, make women's working hours long and hard: whereas the average US married

woman spends 8.5 hours on work, household chores and childcare a day, in the USSR it is 11.5 hours, and in

Czechoslovakia 13.2. At the same time, of course, women need their own incomes more than ever.

The issue of working hours is seen to affect women across Europe. It is

worth noting however that in East

Germany, the slogan was forward to

the 40 hour week, while in Sweden

the debate is around the 6 hour day. Women lost that struggle; the trade unions went for longer holidays in- stead; in Norway, parliament is con- sidering a 6 hour day for working mothers alone, but as the Soviet women pointed out at the conference, that type of demand could easily backfire. They were taking issue with a new proposal giving women the right to part time work. They were adamant that if formulated in this way, it would only serve to bolster in- dustrial patriarchy; they wanted each family to choose how many hours each partner should work outside the home. They acknowledged that it might not affect the outcome since the family is a patriarchal institution, but above all they wanted the state off their backs.

They also opposed the way the state's new interest in the women question was formulated within the traditional "protective" ideology; un- derlying it was the view that women were the problem (even though rape is known to be on the increase) be- cause they didn't care adequately for their children. In contrast the Soviet feminists are looking for a double- sided emancipation; for men, as they put it, to become as multi-functional

as women. A similar refusal to accept male definitions of the issue is evi-

dent in Norway: a royal commission is looking at men's role in society!

When the Soviet and Polish

women talked of the dire state of the health service; of women preferring

back street abortions to those in the

public sector; of a lack of tampons or

even sanitary towels, the need for

economic reform - on women's terms

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 22, March 1990

SUPPLEMENT

men was from Troskyists. At the same time, it is clearly appalling that abor- tion is the only effective means of contraception

We were also reminded of the need to "the proportion

of women take care with our

socialist westem

elected to the

feminist orthodoxy - to

Congress of

avanatic; SUCE WINC for those without hard curren- cy, there is only one phar- macy in Warsaw providing contraceptives.

At the previous year's conference, the Forum had discussed the problems of women attempting to enter and transform the struc- fures of power, specifically whether the experience of quotas was helpful. The problem became clearer as the East European women made us aware of the in- corporation of women's or- ganisation by the state and the distortion of idea of women's liberation by statist ideology.

Then dand mistie at thin

recognise for example

that paid work is not of itself liberating, rather that it is our best pos- sible means to libera- tion. And to recognise that although the state can support collective provision, and can en- sure greater equality! than voluntary/co-opera- tive systems of reproduction, it can also make. collective provision part of an overall oppression.

Across Europe we

came to understand that

on top of the class diver-

them, are differences of

gences, and linked to

SAVE SAVE

YOUR

HEALTH

IRVICE

The dead weight of the official women's move- ment was still taking its toll on feminism in the USSR. It still has a virtual monopoly on contacts with

the West, so that it isn't just male chauvinism in the media that have kept us in the dark about the develop- ment of feminist thinking. So far, the space for feminists in the East to con- tact cach other has been severely limited. They knew through their limited contacts in the West that there were feminists elsewhere in the USSR and in the Easter bloc, but they don't yet have any organisation- al form of their own. The official movement and its definition of "women's liberation' is a distinct bar- rier.

Yet even in Norway, where 30% of the cabinet are women and where every part of the political system, even conservative parties has a 40% quota and where women are said to be 40% of of board members of private firms, male domination is still rife.

Though the small Worker's Com- munist Party has 50% quotas for all groups, and a woman leader, she in- sists that the party still has to work on unconscious male domination within the party,

to enable it to lead the struggle of the working class as a whole, rather than simply half of it. Struggles of class and sex need to be brought together, but on women's terms.

The limitation of quotas as a sub- stitute for politics is clear from recent

a race and ethnicity be

SERVI Braised the question for!

tween women. "Thisy

the conference of howr

we react to fundamen-

talism, whether of they

Soviet experience. As a result of the abolition of quotas for organisations (of which Soviet Women's Commit- tee is one), the proportion of women elected to the Congress of Deputies fell last year from 30% to 15%. In practice this is no retreat for women, since there was never any effective articulation of women's demands. At the same time obstacles are being placed on feminists attempting to in- volve working class women. One women's factory council, who were in contact with the feminists in Mos- cow, sought to nominate a feminist journalist as their representative and were barred from doing so. In Mos- cow 6% of the candidates for the Congress of Deputies were women, but not one was elected.

The Gothenburg Conference began an important dialogue. The Soviet sisters began to understand that the "socialism' they had ex- perienced and rejected bore resemblance to the socialism we were after. They began by wanting to replace a class analysis with a humanistic analysis, but in the end we were all much clearer about the need for both a class analysis and a feminist analysis: for a socialism 'with a female face that could in their words 'emancipate socialism from hierarchy, uniformity and in- human personal relationships*.

catholic church, the Russian orthodox church or the Mosque. It is clear that the level of debate on the situation of black and migrant women varied! enormously with the different ex- periences and cultures of the feminist movement across Europe. As a step to developing a truly internationalist socialist feminism, the Conference decided to hold the next Forum onl "Feminism and Citizenship'. It is like- ly that this will be in Ljubliana ins November 1990.

Inevitably a socialist feminist)

movement that is independent of any

political party and yet is explicitly political lacks the funding for a mass conference of women from across Europe. Women were able to come, in twos and threes, from 22 differentl countries to the Gothenberg con- ference. And though the range of rep- resentation was necessarily limited, we were able to move towards defin- ing at least the ingredients for an in- temationalist feminist socialism and understanding better the tasks we face.

For further information on the European Forum of Socialist Feminists contact: Claire Crocker, Garden Flat 7, Acol Road London NW6. The Forum publication Entering the Structures: Changing the Structures is available from her, price £1.50

Congress of

Deputies fell

last year from 30% to 15%. In practice this is

no retreat for

women, since there was never

any effective

articulation of

women's

demands"

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 22, March 1990

Page 15

SUPPLEMENT

Andrew Wiard/Report

*In Britain, women today account for 44 percent of the workforce, with that figure predicted to be over 50 percent by the end of the century. There is similar picture across

Europe"

Page 16

← Gorbachev plays Bonaparte · Whose Social Charter? →

Something wrong on this page?